Car insurance - tell us your quotes/renewals

florawest · 05-04-2021 09:26AM

cplwhisper wrote: »

Don’t move to Aviva as you’ll loose - Comp driving other cars, next year when car is 13yrs old they’ll apply an age loading to car.& Axa allow 5 pp on each licence at no additional fees(speed, seatbelt & mobile phone offences it the terms)
Aviva rate has discount of €140 as both drivers have no penalty points(that’s me assuming based on ideal states above) so even if a week after renewal ye get 1st of PP ever then you’ll be loaded on the spot. Fail to disclose would be immed cancellation on their discovery.
Not talking bullsh1t.. I’m ex-Axa staff and have family who are current Aviva staff so best knowledge in this scenario.
Current home/farm rate includes the motor-discount so it’s not that they’ll hike the rate it’s because you choose to remove that rate

Thank you, didn't necessarily mean hike as I am aware of multi policy discounts, thank you for your help, I will give them a ring but more than likely will continue with them as have used their breakdown once ( well my son has a leak in diesel pipe in engine) and found them very helpful.

I was a Aviva customer for probably 20 years before moving to Axa.

This is a great site and thanks again for your valued input.

Dr_Colossus · 05-04-2021 09:55AM

cplwhisper wrote: »

Don’t move to Aviva as you’ll loose - Comp driving other cars, next year when car is 13yrs old they’ll apply an age loading to car.& Axa allow 5 pp on each licence at no additional fees(speed, seatbelt & mobile phone offences it the terms)
Aviva rate has discount of €140 as both drivers have no penalty points(that’s me assuming based on ideal states above) so even if a week after renewal ye get 1st of PP ever then you’ll be loaded on the spot. Fail to disclose would be immed cancellation on their discovery.
Not talking bullsh1t.. I’m ex-Axa staff and have family who are current Aviva staff so best knowledge in this scenario.
Current home/farm rate includes the motor-discount so it’s not that they’ll hike the rate it’s because you choose to remove that rate

Interesting, thanks for posting above.

Aviva won't even quote me for the past few years ever since my car reached the self destructing age of 10 years old which in turn makes a mockery of the yearly NCT requirement. Male, 41, Full license with 10+ years NCB but 3 PP for doing 89 in a 80 section that used to be 100.

Zurich won't quote me either for that matter.

Axa may as well have done the same as insurance quote from them this year was €1,452.43 for TPFT with NCB Protection (€1,423.28 for Comprehensive with NCB Protection) for a 07 Volvo 2.0 litre. What kind of a farce is that with no claims and no convictions, it's over 2 1/2 times as expensive as my renewal quote from 123 which in itself is day light robbery.

Insurance industry needs state intervention at this stage. Perhaps a €300 set fee to cover the legal requirement of basic third party and motorist can thereafter purchase optional extras from existing providers. It might reduce the number of uninsured drivers on the road.

Eggs For Dinner · 05-04-2021 11:52AM

Dr_Colossus wrote: »

Insurance industry needs state intervention at this stage. Perhaps a €300 set fee to cover the legal requirement of basic third party and motorist can thereafter purchase optional extras from existing providers. It might reduce the number of uninsured drivers on the road.

Why do yo think that no Irish government has ever tried to introduce a State backed 3rd party scheme? Because they know they could never cover the cost of running the scheme and pay compensation claims at the current level. It only works in countries where citizens have genetically stronger necks and, in many cases, morals

wonski · 05-04-2021 01:08PM

Given the average payout differences brtween Ireland and the rest of the Europe state funded scheme is out of question. I actually don't know a country in Europe that has something like that.

Looking at the thread lately most people got reasonable quotes tbh anyway (excl young drivers of course).

DAK69 · 07-04-2021 08:25AM

Age: 34 M (3 points), + 33 F
Licence: 10+years ago
NCB: 9 yrs
Car: 141 Toyota verso 1.6d
Location: Donegal
Renewal with Allianz: €770 (up €130 on last yr) even though Iv gone from 6 to 3 points

Got AIG for € 467 . Far more extras included to

CoBo55 · 07-04-2021 08:28AM

DAK69 wrote: »

Age: 34 M (3 points), + 33 F
Licence: 10+years ago
NCB: 9 yrs
Car: 141 Toyota verso 1.6d
Location: Donegal
Renewal with Allianz: €770 (up €130 on last yr) even though Iv gone from 6 to 3 points

Got AIG for € 467 . Far more extras included to

AIG seem to be getting a lot of business hopefully it stays that way.

Dr_Colossus · 07-04-2021 01:08PM

CoBo55 wrote: »

AIG seem to be getting a lot of business hopefully it stays that way.

Not based on the quote I got of them this year of €859 for just TPFT (over 55% more than what I paid) I was insured with them about 5 years ago so they were competitive for me once.

biko · 09-04-2021 10:27AM

biko wrote: »

Renewed now - Liberty quote me €550 for another year.
So it actually went down!

biko wrote: »

Renewal time again
Went with Liberty again, €562
On par or cheaper than others I looked at, around 6 companies or so from the sticky list

biko wrote: »

Liberty again, €496 euros with a promo code (before that was €523)

And again Liberty, this year €469 and with promo ended at €445.

2Mad2BeMad · 12-04-2021 10:35PM

Your Age: 27
Car type and engine: Auris 1.2t
years driving: 6
any claims: none
Price and provider AXA was 830e last year. Renewal 984e???
Checked several other places
Went with AA for 597 (excess is abit high though 750e) still much better value.

beertons · 14-04-2021 02:00PM

Renewal time. Last year, got it reduced from 660 to 600. This year, they specified on the letter that it would stay the same as last year, 660. I rang. Down to 575. Took it.

florawest · 17-04-2021 06:21PM

florawest wrote: »

Vw polo 1.4 diesel 09
F 50's + named driver son 25
Full licence 30 +6 years.
Have few extras, fully protected no claim bonus, comprehensive driving of other cars, breakdown assist, key cover and open driven insurance.
Axa current provider renewal €670, down to €600
Aviva €540

Rang Axa to say got lower quote but they wouldn't budge, I have house and farm insurance with them too policy worth €750, will ring week before renewal April 23rd to see if they will go bit lower or match Aviva, just think if I move they will hike up my other policy come August (renewal).

Rang Axa again during week 14-04 and they dropped it to €570 didn't match Aviva but feel getting bit more comprehensively driving other cars, plus had them for breakdown on motorway once ( leak in diesel pipe crack in pipe) and was impressed with their service.

AnSliabhCorcra · 18-04-2021 03:27PM

32 year old
Male
Cork
Seat Leon 211 (1.0)
Liberty - 380 for 1 year, fully comprehensive.
4 years no claims bonus.
No penalty points.
1 named driver on policy (with no penalty points, driving 20+ years)

Was very pleased with the quote. Renewal coincided with purchase of new car (the one above), previous car was a 182 SEAT (1.0) and was coming in at 440.

ShadowHearth · 20-04-2021 06:09PM

Age: 35
License: 16 years
NCB: 10+++
No accidents
Car: 2017 Seat Ibiza Cupra 1.8

Last Year: 1k Axa ( 1k every year since I got it)

Renewal came from AXA for 1k, but broker got from FBD 782eu. This is the first in 5 years I am paying less then 1k eu. Very happy.

tippej9 · 20-04-2021 06:47PM

Male
Provisional license.
no lessons declared.
no previous driving experience.
21.
1800 with AXA on 1.4i sport Ej9 civic

IrishGrimReaper · 20-04-2021 07:43PM

33 year old Male
Monaghan - Public Road
2012 Honda Civic EX GT 1.8 Petrol
Liberty - Renewal €464.23 TPFT
4 Year NCB - No penalty points/previous claims.
1 named driver on policy (with no penalty points, driving 20+ years)

Put through the same details on their site as a new quote - €425.73 comprehensive + driving other cars. :pac:

They've always been the cheapest by a long shot so won't shop around.

Galwayguy35 · 20-04-2021 08:14PM

2019 Golf diesel €488 comp with 123

richieffff · 20-04-2021 08:25PM

Galwayguy35 wrote: »

2019 Golf diesel €488 comp with 123

In case you missed it, here's a code "So simply start a quote online and don’t forget to enter 404040 in the promo code box for your €40 off."

Should still be working

cplwhisper · 21-04-2021 10:55AM

florawest wrote: »

Rang Axa again during week 14-04 and they dropped it to €570 didn't match Aviva but feel getting bit more comprehensively driving other cars, plus had them for breakdown on motorway once ( leak in diesel pipe crack in pipe) and was impressed with their service.

ALSO - based on Zero penalty points (pp)
Axa allow 3 pp on each driver licence at no additional cost.
The Aviva rate would have included 26% pp discount to get down to €540 thus 729 originally.
So 3 pp by any driver , even a week after renewal is €190 on the spot....fail to disclose them has excess clause of €2000+ on top of the standard €300.
Axa best by far in your scenario

CoBo55 · 21-04-2021 12:51PM

cplwhisper wrote: »

ALSO - based on Zero penalty points (pp)
Axa allow 3 pp on each driver licence at no additional cost.
The Aviva rate would have included 26% pp discount to get down to €540 thus 729 originally.
So 3 pp by any driver , even a week after renewal is €190 on the spot....fail to disclose them has excess clause of €2000+ on top of the standard €300.
Axa best by far in your scenario

Where did you get those figures? The pp ones I mean.

Warbeastrior · 21-04-2021 05:08PM

AnSliabhCorcra wrote:

32 year old Male Cork Seat Leon 211 (1.0) Liberty - 380 for 1 year, fully comprehensive. 4 years no claims bonus. No penalty points. 1 named driver on policy (with no penalty points, driving 20+ years)

Im 27 year old
Male
Donegal
Nissan Pixo 10 (1.0)
6 years no claims bonus.
No penalty points
I named driver on policy (with no penalty points, driving 30 years)

Liberty quoted me â‚¬570

How on earth have I been charged â‚¬190 extra than yourself I wonder!

I know my car is 11 years older but surely that shouldn't be that big a gap. A
Also, I have two extra years no claims bonus.

I've heard people saying us in Donegal get hit worse due to rally narrative.

Odyssey 2005 · 21-04-2021 06:40PM

Warbeastrior wrote: »

Im 27 year old
Male
Donegal
Nissan Pixo 10 (1.0)
6 years no claims bonus.
No penalty points
I named driver on policy (with no penalty points, driving 30 years)

Liberty quoted me â‚¬570

How on earth have I been charged â‚¬190 extra than yourself I wonder!

I know my car is 11 years older but surely that shouldn't be that big a gap. A
Also, I have two extra years no claims bonus.

I've heard people saying us in Donegal get hit worse due to rally narrative.

I think you've answered your own question.

chancer12 · 22-04-2021 09:29AM

Got a great quote from the AA yesterday for insurance but they don't do breakdown assist, you have to take separate membership for that. when the membership guy called me to negotiate a price on that he told me that I can't have my daughter on the membership as she doesn't live at my address. She uses the car occasionally and I want to keep her insured on it as much for a convenience for me as for her. I live in the suburbs (Dublin) and she's in the city. It is highly unlikely she would have the car overnight. I just want to ensure she's covered in case she's on a day trip somewhere and something happens. Do any of the experts on here know if that is the norm and more importantly is that going to cause a problem with having her insured on the policy?

For what it's worth the details of the insurance are:
Driver 64, Female, Dublin based
Car: Renault Clio, 182, 11 cc
Full no claims bonus protection
Comprehensive with one additional driver, 26, both full licence and no penalty points, convictions etc
EURO 332.28 plus AA membership EURO 60 reduced down from 120

dinneenp · 22-04-2021 09:53AM

wife, 44, no points, Nissan X Trail 161, looking for fully comp
Currently with Marsh.

Renewal €408, on phone without me prompting they reduced to €368
Liberty- €391
An Post- €427
123.ie- €422

So sticking with Marsh.

lalababa · 22-04-2021 10:04AM

Spursyiddo wrote: »

My axa renewal is €1,600 on a 02 polo 1.4 with a learner permit, I done a quick quote on 123.ie, a 08 note 1.4 and I'm getting €1,066. would I be better sticking with the polo or invest in a newer car. Any advise would be great

I have been finding lately that newer cars (even for comprehensive!) are slightly cheaper to insure. E.g. a 142 to a 04 cost extra 100euros..Mad sh#t Ted!

The Continental Op · 22-04-2021 10:16AM

chancer12 wrote: »

Got a great quote from the AA yesterday for insurance but they don't do breakdown assist, you have to take separate membership for that. when the membership guy called me to negotiate a price on that he told me that I can't have my daughter on the membership as she doesn't live at my address. She uses the car occasionally and I want to keep her insured on it as much for a convenience for me as for her. I live in the suburbs (Dublin) and she's in the city. It is highly unlikely she would have the car overnight. I just want to ensure she's covered in case she's on a day trip somewhere and something happens. Do any of the experts on here know if that is the norm and more importantly is that going to cause a problem with having her insured on the policy?

For what it's worth the details of the insurance are:
Driver 64, Female, Dublin based
Car: Renault Clio, 182, 11 cc
Full no claims bonus protection
Comprehensive with one additional driver, 26, both full licence and no penalty points, convictions etc
EURO 332.28 plus AA membership EURO 60 reduced down from 120

See what quote AXA will do. They provide a decent tow service with most of their policies. Its very useful. Used it twice to get a car to a mechanic.

chancer12 · 22-04-2021 11:13AM

The Continental Op wrote: »

See what quote AXA will do. They provide a decent tow service with most of their policies. Its very useful. Used it twice to get a car to a mechanic.

Unfortunately AXA were off the richter - 590

corsav6 · 22-04-2021 11:36AM

142 Zafira tourer 2.0cdti 130bhp.

Renewal for myself and the wife is €380 with 123.ie
Got that down to €345 just doing a new quote online.

I'm going to price around tomorrow and see the difference between them all.

The Continental Op · 22-04-2021 11:39AM

corsav6 wrote: »

142 Zafira tourer 2.0cdti 130bhp.

Renewal for myself and the wife is €380 with 123.ie
Got that down to €345 just doing a new quote online.

I'm going to price around tomorrow and see the difference between them all.

At that price I wouldn't be wasting too much time looking for a better quote :eek:

naughtysmurf · 22-04-2021 12:28PM

Male 54
141 Civic 1.4l
Aviva
Full ncb
€360.37
Fully comp, ncb protected ,

corsav6 · 22-04-2021 01:11PM

The Continental Op wrote: »

At that price I wouldn't be wasting too much time looking for a better quote :eek:

It's not fully protected so it'll go up slightly if I add that.
Just got a quote from FBD for €424 which is excellent considering they were always above €1000. I'll try liberty next since they were always miles above the rest previous years too.

Car insurance - tell us your quotes/renewals

Comments