Relaxation of Restrictions, Part III - Read OP for Mod Warnings

Nermal · 28-05-2020 08:28AM

bb1234567 wrote: »

Look you really don't seem to understand that it is impossble for their view to be correct in this instance. That is what I take issue with, not who they are, but rather that you won't accept that this intelligent person had an incorrect opinion that has literally been discredited by real world proof.

Do you think that qualified people are never wrong on any issue, ever?

Dying with vs. dying of. Mortality displacement.

https://twitter.com/BitcoinNegan/status/1254614264167440385

road_high · 28-05-2020 08:29AM

[Deleted User] wrote: »

The fact that Leo Varadkar is also a doctor (and his partner) makes this worse as the ONLY lens this has been viewed through is Health . That was fine at the beginning , it’s not fine now. Strong debate is needed fast, the more industry leaders like Michael O Leary who challenge these slow release restrictions the better ! Also Alan Kelly is getting more vocal and Michael Martin , this is good.

Indeed. Harris also with no formal third level education likes to think he’s one of the lads too.

plodder · 28-05-2020 08:32AM

TH is only doing what he is paid to do. What's lacking is any visibility of the government or sense that they are taking other factors into account, as Jim O'Callaghan just pointed out on RTE.

Like when Holohan announced yesterday that he wasn't recommending a change from 2 metres to 1, the media just took that as the decision made because there doesn't appear to be anyone in government making decisions, rather than just rubberstamping what the CMO is saying. We need a new government asap.

Ashleigh1986 · 28-05-2020 08:47AM

A journalist from Denmark was on Newstalk this morning .
Their schools / bars / restaurants are open .
Some for over 6 weeks .
No spike in their numbers .
They haven't allowed large gatherings as in stadiums etc .
We need to get Ireland open .
If we aren't open as the Danes are by the 29th June .... The month of July is so important for so many businesses .

Pitch n Putt · 28-05-2020 08:53AM

Why are we still persisting with giving daily deaths when the data is actually incorrect?

Take yesterday for instance 17 additional deaths reported at the briefing. This is the number people see flashed across the screen along with the total number of cases.

The reality is 7 of those deaths are from March and only being reported now for some strange reason and 3 from Monday and 4 from Tuesday. The 24 thousand odd cases are a total since the beginning with most fully recovered.

If we could report the proper way it might alleviate some of the unnecessary fear factor that’s been created around this thing.

If it read as

3 deaths yesterday and additional 73 cases with x amount of cases currently active whatever that is roughly 4 thousand.

Why do these people and the media insist on sensationalist reporting.

With regards Dr Tony someone definitely questioned his opinion and he came across badly yesterday evening with his ignorant bully boy tactics

“How dare you plebs question me “

paw patrol · 28-05-2020 08:53AM

road_high wrote: »

Yes he gets extremely dismissive and combative at the hint of anyone with the audacity to question his tack and advice.
Varadkar and Harris are still relatively young and reckon they’re just not able for this lad. It may take a Michael Oleary or other seasoned business men and politicians to get him brushed aside, they’ve no fear of anyone.
Major national mistake appointing someone like this to this role- it’s not as if the efforts to control virus he’s overseen are anything to crow about.
Now is the time for some pragmatic flexibility. Holohan is just stuck in school principal mode, a role no one ever appointed him to be

I mentioned this in a rant I had (prob a 100 page back at this stage) I get it Harris and Leo are inexperienced and lack the life experience to handle this but is there no wise elder in FG that can take them aside and say "hold up , this Dr Tony is Fc8k1n Dr. Evil. FG need to come out of this looking good"

somebody like Enda or Noonan or even some behind the scenes fella we don't know exists.

Professor Moriarty · 28-05-2020 08:55AM

Tony Holohan is Doctor Evil. I love the internet.

is_that_so · 28-05-2020 08:56AM

Ashleigh1986 wrote: »

A journalist from Denmark was on Newstalk this morning .
Their schools / bars / restaurants are open .
Some for over 6 weeks .
No spike in their numbers .
They haven't allowed large gatherings as in stadiums etc .
We need to get Ireland open .
If we aren't open as the Danes are by the 29th June .... The month of July is so important for so many businesses .

While it is a good public interest story in "How are countries doing it?" it fast becomes "Why aren't we doing that?". I think this very antsy phase was also anticipated but it's likely to be at least next week or some time into phase 2 before we see any real shifting in position. Our incoming government may give things a new focus.

ednwireland · 28-05-2020 08:56AM

road_high wrote: »

Indeed. Disgraceful answering at this stage in the game, ranks of dismissive arrogance. “I know best so I don’t need to justify myself”. I’d love to see him taken down now

thats pretty much holohans public career in a nutshell isnt it ? i have no idea what he has done apart from being assistant CMO and CMO as his CV seems very sparse.

we shouldnt forget his part in the cervical smear scandal.

28-05-2020 08:57AM

Oh god.....Luke O’Neill coming up on pat kenny again. More fearmongering coming up....

is_that_so · 28-05-2020 08:57AM

Professor Moriarty wrote: »

Tony Holohan is Doctor Evil. I love the internet.

It's the equivalent of a six-year-old blaming you for their unfair life because you won't buy them an ice cream!

paw patrol · 28-05-2020 08:59AM

is_that_so wrote: »

It's the equivalent of a six-year-old blaming you for their unfair life because you won't buy them an ice cream!

you've hurt my feelings :pac:

is_that_so · 28-05-2020 08:59AM

Deleted User wrote: »

Oh god.....Luke O’Neill coming up on pat kenny again. More fearmongering coming up....

He's a mix of the grim and the cheerful. Tries to be positive and tends to give opinions that the CMO wouldn't be seen near!

pjohnson · 28-05-2020 08:59AM

Professor Moriarty wrote: »

Tony Holohan is Doctor Evil. I love the internet.

These threads just keep giving :pac:

KerryConnor · 28-05-2020 09:00AM

Ryanair cheap Dublin-North Italy routes in early 2020 are why it spread so quickly in Dublin. I live in NW Dublin and the few I know who had it in early days had all been skiing in N Italy . We locked down at same time as Denmark for example but it got much deeper hold here. I am really hope life gets back to normal soon, all shops, businesses open, schools start with full classes in September..... But cheap travel witb no kind of quarentine is what ll jeopordise this. If we get hit by Covid as hard as London or new York, that ll wreck economy just as much as lockdown.

Also much as I loved weekends to Barcelona n Lisbon I don't think that kind of travel is sustainable long term given how bad airplanes are for climate change .

polesheep · 28-05-2020 09:03AM

is_that_so wrote: »

While it is a good public interest story in "How are countries doing it?" fast becomes "Why aren't we doing that?". I think this very antsy phase was also anticipated but it's likely to be at least next week or some time into phase 2 before we see any real shifting in position. Our incoming government may give things a new focus.

Honestly, it's difficult to believe that anything has been 'anticipated'. It seems much more of a case of make it up as you go along, plus react and deflect.

Sadly, we're a nation without a government at a critical time in our history.

28-05-2020 09:03AM

is_that_so wrote: »

He's a mix of the grim and the cheerful. Tries to be positive and tends to give opinions that the CMO wouldn't be seen near!

Maybe I’m getting confused with that UCD professor who wants to lock down forever

Penfailed · 28-05-2020 09:04AM

Idbatterim wrote: »

The initial lockdown was to be expected in a hyper cautious conservative country. That good and fortunate initial circumstance, is now our Achilles heel

Hyper cautious conservative country? You don't get marriage equality and abortion in one of those countries.

is_that_so · 28-05-2020 09:04AM

Deleted User wrote: »

Maybe I’m getting confused with that UCD professor who wants to lock down forever

You mean Gerry Killeen from UCC? Think O'Neill is TCD.

is_that_so · 28-05-2020 09:05AM

polesheep wrote: »

Honestly, it's difficult to believe that anything has been 'anticipated'. It seems much more of a case of make it up as you go along, plus react and deflect.

Sadly, we're a nation without a government at a critical time in our history.

I think some of the behavioural stuff like this was easier to forecast.

KaneToad · 28-05-2020 09:06AM

CruelSummer wrote: »

Michael O'Leary was slow to come out and criticise the government but I'm glad he did, I wish others would take a stand against them and NPHET also. He has highlighted that our 'leaders' are completely at odds with international recommendations on a number of fronts, the ECDC and others.

Michael O'Leary is a fine businessman who is out to maximise the profits of RyanAir for its shareholders. He has no training in epidemiology or medicine (to the best of my knowledge). In his radio interview he was stating things, about facemasks, that have no evidence to back them up.

the kelt · 28-05-2020 09:07AM

pjohnson wrote: »

Michael O'Leary for President, Taoiseach and CMO!

We shouldn't have medical experts deciding health policies.

Well we have a Minister for Health who a few weeks ago spoke about not finding a vaccine for the 18 other corona virus that came before Covid 19 so in that respect anything goes!

manniot2 · 28-05-2020 09:11AM

Headline in the Irish times "2m, summer camps and golf discussed by ministers" - the country facing collapse and these lads are worried about ****ing golf!

average_runner · 28-05-2020 09:14AM

The numbers are under a 100 a day now, they need to move into phase 2 this weekend.

Need to relax two meters to 1 meter.

I was all for lockdown and did what it meant to do, but now time to move on

is_that_so · 28-05-2020 09:14AM

manniot2 wrote: »

Headline in the Irish times "2m, summer camps and golf discussed by ministers" - the country facing collapse and these lads are worried about ****ing golf!

Leave them to it, it's likely to be one of their last meetings. School's nearly out and they are all a bit giddy. I will say I reckon the 2m guidance is just going to get more and more flak.

is_that_so · 28-05-2020 09:16AM

average_runner wrote: »

The numbers are under a 100 a day now, they need to move into phase 2 this weekend.

Need to relax two meters to 1 meter.

I was all for lockdown and did what it meant to do, but now time to move on

It's only 5 working days to phase 2, let it finish. For all the challenges in this pandemic getting out of it seems to be turning into the biggest one of all.

stephenjmcd · 28-05-2020 09:18AM

average_runner wrote: »

The numbers are under a 100 a day now, they need to move into phase 2 this weekend.

Need to relax two meters to 1 meter.

I was all for lockdown and did what it meant to do, but now time to move on

Yup agree, we were told at the start what we needed to do, we as a public did it, we bought the HSE and the government time to get whatever was needed in place. We flattened the curve , took the economic and social hits, some of us haven't seen family in months but now is the time to move on. Starting with phase 2 on the 8th and more businesses and services to be brought into that phase and for the love of god just scrap the 5k or 20k rules, it's just stupid.

paw patrol · 28-05-2020 09:20AM

average_runner wrote: »

The numbers are under a 100 a day now, they need to move into phase 2 this weekend.

Need to relax two meters to 1 meter.

I was all for lockdown and did what it meant to do, but now time to move on

from the journal today

Meanwhile, Health Minister Simon Harris has highlighted that 22,089 people have recovered from Covid-19, 1,083 are still sick, and 1,631 people have sadly died.

our lives are being messed about cos 1000 people are sick out of 4.5million.
that's insane

hopefully the next announcement will contain better news

the kelt · 28-05-2020 09:22AM

Arghus wrote: »

He also said things are under constant review. It all depends what happens in the future.

17 deaths and 73 new cases today. He couldn't lift restrictions today with those numbers.

Pitch n Putt wrote: »

Why are we still persisting with giving daily deaths when the data is actually incorrect?

Take yesterday for instance 17 additional deaths reported at the briefing. This is the number people see flashed across the screen along with the total number of cases.

The reality is 7 of those deaths are from March and only being reported now for some strange reason and 3 from Monday and 4 from Tuesday. The 24 thousand odd cases are a total since the beginning with most fully recovered.

If we could report the proper way it might alleviate some of the unnecessary fear factor that’s been created around this thing.

If it read as

3 deaths yesterday and additional 73 cases with x amount of cases currently active whatever that is roughly 4 thousand.

Why do these people and the media insist on sensationalist reporting.

With regards Dr Tony someone definitely questioned his opinion and he came across badly yesterday evening with his ignorant bully boy tactics

“How dare you plebs question me “

Simply put reading it out how you put it doesnt convey enough fear in people and get the reaction he wants.

What he wants is the reaction in the post above, headline number jumps out and immediate response is, cant be easing restrictions now.

People by their very nature have a short attention span, feed them bullet points and headline figures and they gobble them up without looking at the finer details. It plays to the simple masses to get a message across rather than the facts.

Yep and your're right, we were told on here about how informative these press conferences are and how Tony once told a joke, haa haa haa yet i sense now that pressure is starting to come on we are returning to "im going to threaten ordinary people, Mr Cevical Check Scandal Tony"

Ginger n Lemon · 28-05-2020 09:24AM

average_runner wrote: »

The numbers are under a 100 a day now, they need to move into phase 2 this weekend.

Need to relax two meters to 1 meter.

I was all for lockdown and did what it meant to do, but now time to move on

Fully agreed. Very happy to see you change your mind and lean towards re opening of the country quicker.

Relaxation of Restrictions, Part III - **Read OP for Mod Warnings**

Comments

Relaxation of Restrictions, Part III - Read OP for Mod Warnings