Ukranian Airlines Flight PS752 Crash (See mod note/warning in post 270)

Storm 10 · 09-01-2020 04:23PM

GM228 wrote: »

Unverified images that were spread via social media yesterday which no major news organisation has run with....

....there's probably a reason why no one (at least no one reputable) is running with the story

UK Government are going with the missile story its on Sky News

https://news.sky.com/

Mahony0509 · 09-01-2020 04:33PM

https://twitter.com/BNONews/status/1215309657423732737?s=20

Caranica · 09-01-2020 05:00PM

https://twitter.com/CBSNews/status/1215317042603221000?s=19

A slightly more sensational take on it

scotchy · 09-01-2020 05:16PM

Most news sites now reporting the missile hit angle.

https://edition.cnn.com/middleeast/live-news/iran-plane-crash-investigation/index.html

.

Storm 10 · 09-01-2020 05:25PM

If it's a missile it's unforgivable that so many innocent people have died it's making me so angry to think any regime would do it

banie01 · 09-01-2020 05:27PM

Missile hit seems to be the consensus now.
Interesting that the US had Iran under ISTAR surveillance and let the story break, rather than shape the narrative.

Boeing will no doubt be breathing a sigh of relief if the cause is a missile too.

R.I.P to those who've lost their lives and one would hope that whomever gave the release order and those who undertook the launch are afforded a more appropriate justice than those who shot down Iran Air 655.

scotchy · 09-01-2020 05:33PM

Did Iran think they could cover it up?

fritzelly · 09-01-2020 05:35PM

scotchy wrote: »

Did Iran think they could cover it up?

I'm sure there was hardly someone putting their hand up and saying oops

josip · 09-01-2020 05:35PM

scotchy wrote: »

Did Iran think they could cover it up?

No, which is why they didn't try to deny it was a missile from the start.

Unlike the Russians in Ukraine.

cnocbui · 09-01-2020 05:40PM

IE 222 wrote: »

Win??????

176 people lost their lives here.

Yes, and that is why I have been so interested in seeing Iran not get away with it's attempts to absolve itself of responsibility.

CPTM · 09-01-2020 05:41PM

I just dont understand how this happens by mistake. If you're sitting with your finger on a red button waiting to shoot down enemy planes, surely you would have a copy of all scheduled commercial flights due to depart your international airport that day at the very least.

cnocbui · 09-01-2020 05:43PM

CPTM wrote: »

I just dont understand how this happens by mistake. If you're sitting with your finger on a red button waiting to shoot down enemy planes, surely you would have a copy of all scheduled commercial flights due to depart your international airport that day at the very least.

I think you are giving them far more credit than they are due. Besides, it was delayed and 2 hours behind schedule.

wcooba · 09-01-2020 05:46PM

CPTM wrote: »

I just dont understand how this happens by mistake. If you're sitting with your finger on a red button waiting to shoot down enemy planes, surely you would have a copy of all scheduled commercial flights due to depart your international airport that day at the very least.

This flight was delayed by almost an hour.

scotchy · 09-01-2020 05:48PM

CPTM wrote: »

I just dont understand how this happens by mistake. If you're sitting with your finger on a red button waiting to shoot down enemy planes, surely you would have a copy of all scheduled commercial flights due to depart your international airport that day at the very least.

And position your Anti Aircraft missiles at the end of your main international airport runway?

scotchy · 09-01-2020 05:50PM

josip wrote: »

No, which is why they didn't try to deny it was a missile from the start.

Unlike the Russians in Ukraine.

Iran are denying it was hit with a missile.

IE 222 · 09-01-2020 05:53PM

cnocbui wrote: »

Yes, and that is why I have been so interested in seeing Iran not get away with it's attempts to absolve itself of responsibility.

Regardless, I don't think there is anything to be victorious about. This is real live not some quizz game.

Nothing has been proven as of yet. It's only suspicions and good reasons to believe it was shot down.

Letwin_Larry · 09-01-2020 05:54PM

CPTM wrote: »

I just dont understand how this happens by mistake. If you're sitting with your finger on a red button waiting to shoot down enemy planes, surely you would have a copy of all scheduled commercial flights due to depart your international airport that day at the very least.

because you are dealing with a murderous repressive regime, which thinks nothing of gunning their own citizens down.

smurfjed · 09-01-2020 05:56PM

Loss of power, loss of hydraulics and trying to regain control with possibly damaged flight surfaces?

Then why did both the radios and transponder fail? They are designed to be powered by the aircraft batteries as a last resort.

I can understand their reluctance to send the FDR to the NTSB or even an European agency, but what about sending it to someplace like Singapore?

josip · 09-01-2020 05:58PM

Letwin_Larry wrote: »

because you are dealing with a murderous repressive regime, which thinks nothing of gunning their own citizens down.

I think only the extreme conspiracy theorists thought that Iran deliberately shot it down.
But it was obvious to most others that it was highly likely Iran shot it down by mistake, bearing in mind everything else that was happening that night.

Tenzor07 · 09-01-2020 05:58PM

banie01 wrote: »

Boeing will no doubt be breathing a sigh of relief if the cause is a missile too..

No one is relieved that 176 people lost their lives no matter what!

smurfjed · 09-01-2020 05:59PM

And position your Anti Aircraft missiles at the end of your main international airport runway?

That happens a lot in this part of the world, in Damascus you would find tanks buried with just their turrets above the ground and that was before all this recent mayhem.

Van.Bosch · 09-01-2020 06:02PM

Tenzor07 wrote: »

No one is relieved that 167 people lost their lives no matter what!

While I would like to agree it’s not hard to imagine that someone in Boeing is relieved a bit, given all they have going on.

IE 222 · 09-01-2020 06:03PM

It would of had a call sign and civil are clearly identified on radar. I find it very strange the military wouldn't have both primary and secondary radar at it disposal to easily identify the aircraft.

I wonder what the plane passing above it was. There was reports of the investigation team questioning a crew of a plane passing above it. It doesn't seem to appear on flight radar and maybe it played a part in this with someone mistaking PS752 for it as descending for an attack.

Discodog · 09-01-2020 06:04PM

scotchy wrote: »

And position your Anti Aircraft missiles at the end of your main international airport runway?

Very likely. Your airport is a potential target.

scotchy · 09-01-2020 06:04PM

BBC and Sky leading with Megan and Harry FFS

scotchy · 09-01-2020 06:06PM

Discodog wrote: »

Very likely. Your airport is a potential target.

Absolutly, but the point Im trying to make is, if you position missiles there, you'd better be damn sure your not firing at a 737.

Discodog · 09-01-2020 06:11PM

scotchy wrote: »

Absolutly, but the point Im trying to make is, if you position missiles there, you'd better be damn sure your not firing at a 737.

Imagine the consequences if an American Bomber flies overhead & you don't shoot at it. We aren't talking about a highly trained, calm operator.

banie01 · 09-01-2020 06:15PM

smurfjed wrote: »

Then why did both the radios and transponder fail? They are designed to be powered by the aircraft batteries as a last resort.

I can understand their reluctance to send the FDR to the NTSB or even an European agency, but what about sending it to someplace like Singapore?

I have no clue and honestly couldn't hazard a guess other than catastrophic failure.

Of all the people on boards tho, I'd be certain that you more than most would agree that Comms were at the back of the flight crews mind during their brief time trying to save the airframe?
Aviate, navigate and communicate.

The Black Box, can also totally understand the reluctance to engage with NTSB given the sanctions regime and anti-american sentiment.

Agree that one of the Euro or Asian agencies with appropriate experience and equipment should be used.

If memory serves the Ethiopians did the same after their MAX crash? (Could have been the Malaysian's but 1 of them definitely did.).

Larbre34 · 09-01-2020 06:16PM

By a bizarre coincidence, Sky Atlantic today showed an old West Wing episode in which a crisis arose when Iran shot down a British airline's 737 which strayed off its flightpath, mistaking it for a US RC-135 recon aircraft.

Looking at the grainy footage I am reminded only of the Concorde crash. Something external impacted that 737 after it took off to cause that fire and with design tech changes I don't think it was a fragment of debris from the runway.

smurfjed · 09-01-2020 06:27PM

newsweek are reporting that it was shot down by missiles according to “sources”

Ukranian Airlines Flight PS752 Crash (See mod note/warning in post 270)

Comments