10 Player Secret Role

Clarabel · 09-10-2019 3:36pm

MrKingsley wrote: »

Nope not at all. Ive said consistently who is on my wolf list since yesterday. I have old Spooky number 1 and you made your way into my uncertain pile this more. I hadn't really looked at your posts probably before.

It is a nice little story isnt it?

Are you telling me that there is no truth to it whatsoever??

Mr K, this is what I had based that on, I neglected to include everything, that's why I said I thought I had it - always open for correction. I missed your vote on Khal yesterday in my table too. I corrected it straight away after your last post

quickbeam · 09-10-2019 3:41pm

Quoting that exchange above from shortly after the game opened made me realise that sK probably was trying to draw the munch, and I trampled all over it

I had decided in advance that if I was NRV I'd make a hard claim and never really thought about anyone else's strategies. So, sorry sK

quickbeam · 09-10-2019 3:53pm

Look how quiet it is. Wolves don't care who's lynched so long as it's not them. They're sitting back happy that it's looking like me. I don't know if it's a wolf that orchestrated it, or just if they're happy leaning on other people's (misguided) work, but they're only delighted that I'm for the chop. Believe me, I'm not a wolf guys!

Baggly · 09-10-2019 3:57pm

Agh! Why would two people vote at 3pm when lynch is at 9!!

Fixxxer still clear in my book, but Spooks jumped right on! Why not wait!!!???

Ok im gonna do my Clara reread now.

fixXxer · 09-10-2019 3:58pm

Sorry, not gonna be here for Lynch and for better or worse QB is my read at the moment.

Clarabel · 09-10-2019 4:00pm

quickbeam wrote: »

Look how quiet it is. Wolves don't care who's lynched so long as it's not them. They're sitting back happy that it's looking like me. I don't know if it's a wolf that orchestrated it, or just if they're happy leaning on other people's (misguided) work, but they're only delighted that I'm for the chop. Believe me, I'm not a wolf guys!

Who is it?????

Gahhh

quickbeam · 09-10-2019 4:05pm

Clarabel wrote: »

Who is it?????

Gahhh

You? :eek:

Clarabel · 09-10-2019 4:06pm

made stated
QB Fix, Spook Clara, Bags, Mr K
Spook Clara Mr K
Clara Bags
Mr K QB
Bag QB

Clarabel · 09-10-2019 4:07pm

quickbeam wrote: »

You? :eek:

it's not. It's really not. I will fight kicking and screaming

quickbeam · 09-10-2019 4:13pm

As I've not caught a wolf, I'm gonna vote for self preservation tonight if there's a chance of me surviving as I'm the only one I can trust 100%.

However, I think my best wolf lean is King and that'd probably be where my vote will go if I were free to choose.

So you can update your table if you like, with that, Clara.

Baggly · 09-10-2019 4:21pm

Claras posting.

17 posts before BH died. Lots more since. 17 is actually respectible for a D1 tally. Ok so ill revise that opinion.

Definitely following the game. Spotted someone left me off a list at some stage. So watching closely and spotted that. Thats ok though.

Im surprised the level of flak she got for the silencing thing. I understand that as a mod punishment and it seemed fairly straight forward it was for not voting.

Ok so one thing im not happy with in regards Clara is that she is very flip floppy. Ive been in and out of her 'core' a couple of times i think. Im not sure how easy people go in and out of this core or if its more of a stream of consciousness thing.

Helpful player in making that mini table with who is on whom etc. I like this, but it can be someone playing helpful villager.

Claras Voting.

Voted Khal last night.
Didnt vote the night before. Thats a real onion in the ointment tbh.

If Clara was a wolf, would she have killed who she killed.

Would Clara have killed GNR? She had decent cover in that GNR dismissed her. So yeah, maybe.
Would Clara have killed sKeith? Another onion in the ointment here. No real interactions with sKeith up until he died, because she couldnt comm with the thread. He was on her a bit leading up to munch to see where she voted and called her wordless. She queried his attempted role claim on d1. Maybe she banked on him actually being the role and not QB? Thats actually a solid reason tbh.

Ok so Clara, you will be glad to know im withdrawing my accusation that you increased activity after BH died. But im actually more suss of you than QB right now.

Im mulling it over but my vote is going to one of those. It could be both tbh. Im still guessing this is a 2 wolf game, but there is an off chance the two of them are.

Im leaning QB, ill be honest. I think she is too clever by half not to kill GNR after he semi clears her based on vote analysis. Then all she has to do is get king and or me and or Clara killed and she wins.

Clarabel · 09-10-2019 4:26pm

Baggly wrote: »

Im not sure how easy people go in and out of this core or if its more of a stream of consciousness thing.

you've played with me before!

Baggly · 09-10-2019 4:27pm

Its different when its MS Paint.

Clarabel · 09-10-2019 4:28pm

Baggly wrote: »

Its different when its MS Paint.

I meant WW, i'm a stream of conscious player.

Clarabel · 09-10-2019 4:29pm

*ness

Baggly · 09-10-2019 4:34pm

I know Clara - but at a certain stage flip flopping isnt helpful at all. And you seem immune to vote and post analysis for the most part. The flip flopping and the would you have killed GNR and sK is what looks wolfy to me.

quickbeam · 09-10-2019 4:39pm

Okay, Bag's post brings up another thing I hadn't thought of before. If Clara was barred from posting here for not voting, would she also have been barred from putting in a kill order if she was a wolf. In a 2-wolf team, she would have been the last wolf available to put in a kill order. Unless Tusk accepted a placeholder from Bounty.

A lot of parameters there about mod decisions though.

Clarabel · 09-10-2019 4:43pm

quickbeam wrote: »

Okay, Bag's post brings up another thing I hadn't thought of before. If Clara was barred from posting here for not voting, would she also have been barred from putting in a kill order if she was a wolf. In a 2-wolf team, she would have been the last wolf available to put in a kill order. Unless Tusk accepted a placeholder from Bounty.

A lot of parameters there about mod decisions though.

This is definitely a waste of time to think about. That didn't happen.

Baggly · 09-10-2019 4:46pm

I dont think Tusk bars her from placing an order tbh. Even if she is barred from posting on thread.

Clarabel · 09-10-2019 4:47pm

Baggly wrote: »

I know Clara - but at a certain stage flip flopping isnt helpful at all. And you seem immune to vote and post analysis for the most part. The flip flopping and the would you have killed GNR and sK is what looks wolfy to me.

I get it. If you hadn't stated how sick you were you'd still be on on suspect list.

I think until then you've always been suspect but the flipflop is more how high up that list you are. I think that's fairly normal.

I didn't think GnR would get munched to be honest.
I'm bullying I didn't get a dig in at sK over his...use your words comments. Which referenced an offline chat.

Baggly · 09-10-2019 4:48pm

Why did you think GNR wouldnt be munched?

tusk · 09-10-2019 4:51pm

If a Majority is reached pre-lynch time, the lynch will take place then.

Munch may be brought forward if this is the case. We shall wait and see.

Clarabel · 09-10-2019 4:52pm

Baggly wrote: »

Why did you think GNR wouldnt be munched?

I said it already, I thought that spooks had led a trail that had created sufficient doubt about GnR and Fixxxer being a wolf team.

Clarabel · 09-10-2019 4:53pm

tusk wrote: »

If a Majority is reached pre-lynch time, the lynch will take place then.

Munch may be brought forward if this is the case. We shall wait and see.

You hate majority voting!

quickbeam · 09-10-2019 4:54pm

Please nobody else vote until close to 9pm. Majority lynch only helps wolves.

tusk · 09-10-2019 4:55pm

Clarabel wrote: »

You hate majority voting!

I'm happy going ahead with this, as there are no takesbacksies, so the result cannot change.

Spook_ie · 09-10-2019 4:55pm

quickbeam wrote: »

Okay, Bag's post brings up another thing I hadn't thought of before. If Clara was barred from posting here for not voting, would she also have been barred from putting in a kill order if she was a wolf. In a 2-wolf team, she would have been the last wolf available to put in a kill order. Unless Tusk accepted a placeholder from Bounty.

A lot of parameters there about mod decisions though.

That was the reasoning behind my asking was murderized the same as munched, if murderized wasn't the same then I'd have gone with Clarabelle as a wolf and someone else in a village role using a gun or other weapon

Baggly · 09-10-2019 4:56pm

Im not going to vote, but that change has permutations in terms of how many wolves, doesnt it?

If it was a 3 wolf game, 2 wolves could have hopped on QB, right? So either QB is a wolf or its a 2 wolf game.....

Baggly · 09-10-2019 4:57pm

OMG if QB flips village and we dont lose the game, Spooks is cleared i think.

Spook_ie · 09-10-2019 4:58pm

Clarabel wrote: »

I said it already, I thought that spooks had led a trail that had created sufficient doubt about GnR and Fixxxer being a wolf team.

Well considering I reckoned that 2 of the 3 Fixxer,QB and GnR were my suspects I wonder why you think that idea

10 Player Secret Role

Comments