Werewolf - Winter Is Here - Game of Thrones II Game Thread

Necro · 19-08-2019 10:43pm

Guffy wrote: »

Why was eva not converted this morning btw?

I don't know, maybe she was.

I'm not converted and I'm not either of the original evils

And I have a cool power that is pointless:(

That's all I know right now

Green&Red · 19-08-2019 10:44pm

Once Necro isn’t the NK then I’m happy for him to live, wight or not

Guffy · 19-08-2019 10:46pm

Necro wrote: »

Use the bullet on me, then box me off in my own little corner IF Eva says I'm converted tomorrow.

This is difficult as I'm saying what to do with future potential wolf me as villager me.

I am not the Night King, therefore wasting energy and effort killing me twice is a waste of our resources.

Resolve my ability, then ignore me.

Also this is why it was a terrible move not to use it imo. There's so much shadow, wasted bullets and lost lynches.

Why would you want to revive yourself after being shot if all you were coming back for was to be put in a corner? On what planet there a corner big enough for you

fixXxer · 19-08-2019 10:47pm

Green&Red wrote: »

Once Necro isn’t the NK then I’m happy for him to live, wight or not

Wight or wrong would have worked better

Necro · 19-08-2019 10:48pm

Guffy wrote: »

Also this is why it was a terrible move not to use it imo. There's so much shadow, wasted bullets and lost lynches.

Why would you want to revive yourself after being shot if all you were coming back for was to be put in a corner? On what planet there a corner big enough for you

Well as either alignment I have to tbf, to play in the interest of my team (whichever side) and the game

quickbeam · 19-08-2019 10:48pm

Guffy wrote: »

Also this is why it was a terrible move not to use it imo. There's so much shadow, wasted bullets and lost lynches.

Why would you want to revive yourself after being shot if all you were coming back for was to be put in a corner? On what planet there a corner big enough for you

Were you campaigning for Necro to use the revive? Were you trying hard to convince other people to join the cause? I don't remember seeing these things between 9 and 9.30pm.

Necro · 19-08-2019 10:51pm

My reasoning for not reviving Ted is as follows:

He claimed a prize that had no benefit to the village in Phase 1 and wouldn't reveal the contents.

Choccy pushed him a number of times to reveal his role and he did not.

In those circumstances it was my belief he was a wolf of some description.

Obviously that was wrong but I'm not psychic, I'm working and strapped for time and had to go with my own feelings as not too many were giving their own on thread.

beakerjoe · 19-08-2019 10:52pm

Guffy wrote: »

Also this is why it was a terrible move not to use it imo. There's so much shadow, wasted bullets and lost lynches.

Why would you want to revive yourself after being shot if all you were coming back for was to be put in a corner? On what planet there a corner big enough for you

You said a lot of strange things but thats very senisble.

To answer Necros question for him, selfishness. The answer is selfishness

A man after my own heart is Necro.

We havent bickered yet, feels weird

Guffy · 19-08-2019 10:56pm

Necro wrote: »

My reasoning for not reviving Ted is as follows:

He claimed a prize that had no benefit to the village in Phase 1 and wouldn't reveal the contents.

Choccy pushed him a number of times to reveal his role and he did not.

In those circumstances it was my belief he was a wolf of some description.

Obviously that was wrong but I'm not psychic, I'm working and strapped for time and had to go with my own feelings as not too many were giving their own on thread.

So you believed he wasn't the nk

Necro · 19-08-2019 10:57pm

Guffy wrote: »

So you believed he wasn't the nk

No, he won the prize yesterday and never said boo about it until close to the lynch.

He could have easily been the Night king

Guffy · 19-08-2019 10:59pm

Guffy wrote: »

What if the nk is lynched and the revive him? Seems like a handy tool for the nk to have at his disposal, no?

Sorry qb, i had a very personal issue that needed resolving tonight so i wasn't available at the time. I did get this post in. Didn't realise necro needed hand holding.

Necro · 19-08-2019 10:59pm

How would I know he wasn't the Night King based off him winning a prize?

Guffy · 19-08-2019 11:00pm

Necro wrote: »

No, he won the prize yesterday and never said boo about it until close to the lynch.

He could have easily been the Night king

Your reason for not reviving him was he had a prize that could be used in phase 2. You literally said it 5 minutes ago

Necro · 19-08-2019 11:02pm

Guffy wrote: »

Your reason for not reviving him was he had a prize that could be used in phase 2. You literally said it 5 minutes ago

Yeah, he said that, but gave no details. It was close to lynch.

Would you believe him?

I've a new name for you now though

Eva WW · 19-08-2019 11:03pm

Everyone plays the game differently. There is no correct way to play.

Reading back on the thread, he was in the firing line and revealed to try & save himself. Didn't work in the end for him.

Plenty of games have late reveals.

Anyway, is your prize gone now, Necro or can it still potentially be used if you survive the morning.

Necro · 19-08-2019 11:04pm

Eva WW wrote: »

Everyone plays the game differently. There is no correct way to play.

Reading back on the thread, he was in the firing line and revealed to try & save himself. Didn't work in the end for him.

Plenty of games have late reveals.

Anyway, is your prize gone now, Necro or can it still potentially be used if you survive the morning.

No time limit that I've been informed of. I wish it was gone

Guffy · 19-08-2019 11:04pm

Necro wrote: »

Yeah, he said that, but gave no details. It was close to lynch.

Would you believe him?

I've a new name for you now though

My first post was at 9.25 pointing that the revive was a major benefit to the nk. No hindsight in that.

Eva WW · 19-08-2019 11:06pm

Necro wrote: »

No time limit that I've been informed of. I wish it was gone

The joys of WW decisions, damned if you do, damned if you don't.

Anyhoo, I am off for the night. matchsticks in the eyes will not a good look when in work in the morning.

Necro · 19-08-2019 11:08pm

Yep, I'd have an arbitrary mob out for me had I revived Ted as well.

I'm off too, there's nothing left to discuss tbh. Don't focus on me I guess

quickbeam · 19-08-2019 11:09pm

Guffy wrote: »

My first post was at 9.25 pointing that the revive was a major benefit to the nk. No hindsight in that.

What if Necro had revived and Ted turned out to be the NK? Wouldn’t Necro have looked silly for reviving our worst enemy? You’d be here saying what a crap move it was.

19-08-2019 11:09pm

Green&Red wrote: »

Once Necro isn’t the NK then I’m happy for him to live, wight or not

Just since you've mentioned that a few times now, it has got my attention and I can't ignore it - That's all well and good once you are not the NK yourself trying to protect this morning's convert or original wight follower (Necro).

Maybe if you were the NK though, you wouldn't be so vocal about 'Meh to killing converts' as it could raise too many suspicions.

I dunno, but I do know that whoever said it earlier (might have been sKeith) is right - Ignoring the converts and trying to get the NK might be grand for now, but could seriously hurt us in end game.

Converts, NK or any original NK follower there might be - I don't mind who once we get one of them. I'm eager to reach the politicking/House allegiances part of the game.

Necro · 19-08-2019 11:13pm

quickbeam wrote: »

What if Necro had revived and Ted turned out to be the NK? Wouldn’t Necro have looked silly for reviving our worst enemy? You’d be here saying what a crap move it was.

Here's the thing: A character claim is resolveable. A prize claim that doesn't help us in this Phase is not.

Had he claimed Tyrion I'd have revived him.

Guffy · 19-08-2019 11:16pm

quickbeam wrote: »

What if Necro had revived and Ted turned out to be the NK? Wouldn’t Necro have looked silly for reviving our worst enemy? You’d be here saying what a crap move it was.

No i wouldn't. It was the best move possible given 4 people voted for ted and worst case we could lynch him the following day. We still save a lynch/bullet that we would otherwise have to use on necro anyway.

And what if necro is the nk? Its very convenient to leave him in a corner isn't it? The only way not reviving ted makes sense is if your saving it for nk imo

Green&Red · 19-08-2019 11:16pm

FWIW some posters, myself included, agreed he shouldn’t revive Ted, the no reveal was the clincher

Green&Red · 19-08-2019 11:24pm

[Deleted User] wrote: »

Just since you've mentioned that a few times now, it has got my attention and I can't ignore it - That's all well and good once you are not the NK yourself trying to protect this morning's convert or original wight follower (Necro).

Maybe if you were the NK though, you wouldn't be so vocal about 'Meh to killing converts' as it could raise too many suspicions.

I dunno, but I do know that whoever said it earlier (might have been sKeith) is right - Ignoring the converts and trying to get the NK might be grand for now, but could seriously hurt us in end game.

Converts, NK or any original NK follower there might be - I don't mind who once we get one of them. I'm eager to reach the politicking/House allegiances part of the game.

I did write that before I thought of Tandy being able to tell if Necro is converted or not

I stand by my point though, if we’re confident someone is a convert then I say leave them, were only after the NK. Converts are of no use and a wasted lynch is a day closer to the NK winning

Green&Red · 19-08-2019 11:25pm

And since you mentioned it - even if I was the NK it’s still a solid strategy

I’m not though

beakerjoe · 19-08-2019 11:31pm

Green&Red wrote: »

And since you mentioned it - even if I was the NK it’s still a solid strategy

I’m not though

Whos your fav to be the nightking?

Right now Im leaning on Fixxxer based on his 902pm post. It seemed Disenguinous to me, esp now that his vote was placed at 835pm. Cant shake it that hes bad since then

beakerjoe · 19-08-2019 11:40pm

duffman13 wrote: »

Whose demise would you like to see this evening? Who are you? Timestamp Total
Ted_YNWA tritium 8/19/2019 19:47:49 1
sKeith 8/19/2019 20:55:42 1
Necro 8/19/2019 20:58:08 1
Choc chip 8/19/2019 19:54:02 1
Ted_YNWA Total 4
Hello 2D Person Below DublinAndy2 8/19/2019 20:43:40 1
Tusk 8/19/2019 18:40:39 1
Ted_YNWA 8/19/2019 20:03:10 1
Hello 2D Person Below Total 3
Tusk fixxxer 8/19/2019 20:35:31 1
Stu Redman 8/19/2019 18:22:12 1
Tusk Total 2
Guffy Quickbeam 8/19/2019 16:34:52 1
Bounty Hunter 8/19/2019 16:41:42 1
Guffy Total 2
Bounty Hunter Beakerjoe 8/19/2019 10:31:26 1
Guffy 8/19/2019 19:05:14 1
Bounty Hunter Total 2
sKeith Micksjaguar 8/19/2019 19:25:55 1
Lord TSC 8/19/2019 19:41:38 1
sKeith Total 2
Lord TSC gnr 8/19/2019 14:57:42 1
Drumpot 8/19/2019 20:35:55 1
Lord TSC Total 2
Choc Chip Hello 2D Person Below 8/19/2019 10:32:56 1
Choc Chip Total 1
Necro Ladyskunk 8/19/2019 17:30:02 1
Necro Total 1
Beakerjoe Ectoplasm 8/19/2019 18:30:37 1
Beakerjoe Total 1

Necro and skeith with very late votes on Ted there.

Worth noting. The latest of any votes there.

If they did lump on Ted as wolves, who was it to save.... 2D was the other lad close to the chop. Others had 2 votes but didnt seem to be close to being lynched

Green&Red · 19-08-2019 11:42pm

beakerjoe wrote: »

Whos your fav to be the nightking?

Right now Im leaning on Fixxxer based on his 902pm post. It seemed Disenguinous to me, esp now that his vote was placed at 835pm. Cant shake it that hes bad since then

I’ve no idea. I find the start of games very tough, my radar is usually miles off.
I FFA’d Lord TSC and BH but that was on feel

19-08-2019 11:45pm

Hell hath no fury like a Lady scorned.

2/3 that voted for me are gone.

Werewolf - Winter Is Here - Game of Thrones II Game Thread

Comments