All Ireland Senior Hurling (Liam Mccarthy Cup) 2019

marvin80 · 18-08-2019 11:36PM

threeball wrote: »

I think everyone bar KK think it was a sending off and in no way contentious. Everyone on the panel bar Tyrell thought so too.

Tyrell looked like an idiot with his view - it was very satisfying.

Seadin · 18-08-2019 11:36PM

holyhead wrote: »

I would disagree with the sour. We were surprised to find ourselves in the final so in a sense it's been a good year for us. We clearly view the sending off as contentious. Tipp see it otherwise I expect. I expect Sheedy does give a hoot about great teams. He has the honour of being a multiple winning manager and a back to back would elevate his status in Tipp and nationally.

I find it strange that kilkenny fans are surprised to get to a final. They always get there even with less talented teams through the decades. I cant see Cody staying on. He's been highly successful with kilkenny but i think he isn't going to win another All Ireland with Kilkenny. I don't say that as an insult i just dont think he wont get anymore out of this panel of players.

blackcard · 18-08-2019 11:36PM

threeball wrote: »

slegs wrote: »

blackcard wrote: »

Sideline should have been to Kilkenny

Christ I’ve heard it all now

The KK lads should all head up from the hotel, get the keys to croker, let Richie take the sideline and play it out as it should have happened. Right the wrong

I was referring to the Limerick Kilkenny semi final when Paul Murphy went to clear the ball and was blocked by a Limerick player and the sideline was given to Limerick. From the sideline, the ball was deflected by Cillian Buckley and incorrectly waved wide

Comerman · 18-08-2019 11:37PM

slegs wrote: »

Never thought Kilkenny fans were ones for sour grapes but this one obviously has hurt deep

Go back and read other posts, not a sour grape here. Best team won but the first card of the day shouldn't of been a straight red. Well done to Tipp.

holyhead · 18-08-2019 11:37PM

marvin80 wrote: »

Tyrell looked like an idiot with his view - it was very satisfying.

That says more about you than him sadly! One of the most decorated players in the history of hurling.

munsterlegend · 18-08-2019 11:37PM

holyhead wrote: »

Facilitated by a sending off.

Still a hammering. Record books won’t have an asterisk beside the scoreline.

It was also facilitated by poor second half Kilkenny tactics.

holyhead · 18-08-2019 11:38PM

munsterlegend wrote: »

Still a hammering. Record books won’t have an asterisk beside the scoreline.

People have long memories!

holyhead · 18-08-2019 11:39PM

Seadin wrote: »

I find it strange that kilkenny fans are surprised to get to a final. They always get there even with less talented teams through the decades. I cant see Cody staying on. He's been highly successful with kilkenny but i think he isn't going to win another All Ireland with Kilkenny. I don't say that as an insult i just dont think he cant get anymore out of this panel of players.

Your expectations in any year depends on the strength of the panel

Hawkeye9212 · 18-08-2019 11:39PM

Comerman wrote: »

Go back nobby and read other posts, not a sour grape here. Best team won but the first card of the day shouldn't of been a straight red. Well done to Tipp.

It was a straight red.

TheRiverman · 18-08-2019 11:40PM

marvin80 wrote: »

Tyrell looked like an idiot with his view - it was very satisfying.

Henry Shefflin also at half time today.

Mervyn Skidmore · 18-08-2019 11:41PM

Neutral here, anyone who thinks it wasn't a straight red needs their head checked. It's one of the most straight forward red cards you could ever see. Bad weather, the fact that it's an all ireland final etc. do not change the rules of the game.

Comerman · 18-08-2019 11:41PM

Hawkeye9212 wrote: »

It was a straight red.

As I've said and so was the slap into the face.

marvin80 · 18-08-2019 11:41PM

holyhead wrote: »

That says more about you than him sadly! One of the most decorated players in the history of hurling.

So you have a referee, former players, current players, former managers all saying it was a red and Tyrell says it wasn't while getting a few cheap digs in at Tipp and you think he didn't look stupid?

What he's won in the past is irrelevant to him making himself look stupid and naive.

munsterlegend · 18-08-2019 11:43PM

TheRiverman wrote: »

Henry Shefflin also at half time today.

Henry was making no sense. On one hand he was saying by the letter of the law it was a red but because hogan was his ex teammate well he shouldn’t get sent off!

threeball · 18-08-2019 11:43PM

holyhead wrote: »

threeball wrote: »

You wouldn't think it with the amount of moaning going on. It wasn't even a close game. It was a hammering.

Facilitated by a sending off.

Richie Hogan in his prime wasn't worth 12pts never mind the current version. If you think that the game turned to that degree on the sending off you either can't objectively analyse the game or you're deluded.

Seadin · 18-08-2019 11:45PM

Lefty Bicek wrote: »

You have no choice only to accept that ye haven't been good enough to win.

You should also accept that ye haven't been good enough that you can afford to be sniping at anyone else, let alone a county that has won EIGHT :eek: in the meantime.

That was a class kk team in those 8 years. Fantastic achievement but thats history now. Today is Tipps day and they are also a super team.

Pigeon Chaser · 18-08-2019 11:46PM

Kilkenny poster here.

Can all kilkenny people on this thread please take a deep breath, review what you are posting before hitting submit and try not to embarrass ourselves.

We were beaten by a better team today. At the match, in real time I thought Hogan was hard done by. Looking at the replays it was the correct decision.

Well done Tipp. Ye were tuned in today and handled your numerical advantage to perfection. Even 15 v 15 you would have had our measure as we were carrying about 5 or 6 passengers who didn't perform.

It's difficult to be beaten so comprehensively. However, it is important to be gracious in defeat as I like to think we are in victory. Despite how it ended the year has been a success.

Still bloody hate Tipp though...

Comerman · 18-08-2019 11:46PM

threeball wrote: »

Richie Hogan in his prime wasn't worth 12pts never mind the current version. If you think that the game turned to that degree on the sending off you either can't objectively analyse the game or you're deluded.

My Jazus, some players don't need to score to have an impact on a game.

Lefty Bicek · 18-08-2019 11:46PM

Seadin wrote: »

That was a class kk team in those 8 years. Fantastic achievement but thats history now. Today is Tipps day and they are also a super team.

Indeed they are.

munsterlegend · 18-08-2019 11:47PM

threeball wrote: »

Richie Hogan in his prime wasn't worth 12pts never mind the current version. If you think that the game turned to that degree on the sending off you either can't objectively analyse the game or you're deluded.

I think Tipp would have won but sending off did make it easier and Kilkenny weren’t able to adapt their game plan in second half. Never retained possession through the lines but pucking Hail Marys into a Tipp defence with extra men.

Lefty Bicek · 18-08-2019 11:48PM

Richie Hogan’s red card was the wrong call and it ruined the All Ireland Hurling final.

https://www.thesun.ie/sport/4455075/babs-keating-richie-hogan-red-card-all-ireland/

Babs Keating, take a bow !

shanboghted · 18-08-2019 11:48PM

If that's a red then technically there's 3/4 reds a game touching playere in the head ! Barrett knew well what he was at

TheRiverman · 18-08-2019 11:50PM

Mervyn Skidmore wrote: »

Neutral here, anyone who thinks it wasn't a straight red needs their head checked. It's one of the most straight forward red cards you could ever see. Bad weather, the fact that it's an all ireland final etc. do not change the rules of the game.

As an Offaly man I am disappointed that Micheal Duignan mentioned the weather in relation to the sending off.

Mervyn Skidmore · 18-08-2019 11:50PM

Lefty Bicek wrote: »

https://www.thesun.ie/sport/4455075/babs-keating-richie-hogan-red-card-all-ireland/

Babs Keating, take a bow !

Tipperary scoring all them goals and points also ruined the game, shame on them.

Seadin · 18-08-2019 11:51PM

Why did kk keep hitting high ball down on the Tipp backs. That clearly wasnt working but they kept doing it. Surprised Cody didnt do something about that.

RMAOK · 18-08-2019 11:53PM

Mervyn Skidmore wrote: »

Tipperary scoring all them goals and points also ruined the game, shame on them.

threeball · 18-08-2019 11:55PM

Comerman wrote: »

threeball wrote: »

Richie Hogan in his prime wasn't worth 12pts never mind the current version. If you think that the game turned to that degree on the sending off you either can't objectively analyse the game or you're deluded.

My Jazus, some players don't need to score to have an impact on a game.

I didn't say score 12pts. No one player is going to change a game from a hammering to a close run thing. Just accept your beating. My own county were completely flat last year, ended up losing by a point and we did 10 times less bitching than I've seen on this thread so far. Take your beating and give tipp their due.

Lefty Bicek · 18-08-2019 11:58PM

Mervyn Skidmore wrote: »

Tipperary scoring all them goals and points also ruined the game, shame on them.

True. You clearly know more about hurling than the average Sligo man.

But did you know, and this is what tickled me - Babs is a Tipperary legend, and former manager.

Mervyn Skidmore · 19-08-2019 12:00AM

Lefty Bicek wrote: »

True. You clearly know more about hurling than the average Sligo man.

But did you know, and this is what tickled me - Babs is a Tipperary legend, and former manager.

I knew, it was a joke obviously. I never understood this "ruining the game" talk though.

Comerman · 19-08-2019 12:01AM

threeball wrote: »

I didn't say score 12pts. No one player is going to change a game from a hammering to a close run thing. Just accept your beating. My own county were completely flat last year, ended up losing by a point and we did 10 times less bitching than I've seen on this thread so far. Take your beating and give tipp their due.

Go back and read three balls, I accepted the better team won from the start. And as I said WELL DONE TIPP.

All Ireland Senior Hurling (Liam Mccarthy Cup) 2019

Comments