Yulewolf - A Werewolf Christmas Carol Game Thread

Barbara WW · 17-12-2018 11:12AM

Wasn't this a wolf kill?

Holly WW wrote: »

Gertie also put in a staunch defence of Oisin. Question is was this a wolf play to protect a member (Fiona or Oisin) or just wolves choosing what looked like a good player?

Isla WW · 17-12-2018 11:12AM

Right so Gertie is dead. Probably worth looking back at her posts to see what (if anything) piqued the wolves interest.

In other news, we have a Marley. Now, do we think that Marley always knew he was Marley and had been in a BR with Scrooge yesterday or was Marley a sleeper wolf who was only activated this morning? Or infected by Scrooge? If he's newly changed to team wolf he could be posting differently today. Something to look out for.

"Scrooge & the evil spirits have an alpha and a power blocker, and may be able to increase their numbers or risk their numbers being decreased, either by design or by accident.
Update: Scrooge (Alpha) - Will peek as good if peeked by the seer
Update: Marley (Power Blocker) - Can block the powers of a player each night. Very evil and tricky spirit!"

Brendan WW · 17-12-2018 11:14AM

Peek as good in the OP also answers how peeks will be shown - looks like good/bad as opposed to full role.

Holly WW · 17-12-2018 11:15AM

Barbara WW wrote: »

Wasn't this a wolf kill?

Yeh but if Oisin was a wolve , would killing Gertie (who defended him) potentially throw shade on Fiona and off Oisin?

Holly WW · 17-12-2018 11:16AM

Is it normal for no SK kill on day 1?

Brendan WW · 17-12-2018 11:17AM

Holly WW wrote: »

Is it normal for no SK kill on day 1?

It might have been an SK kill, it's not definitive which evil team killed Gertie

Vernon WW · 17-12-2018 11:17AM

Gertrude WW wrote: »

Picks Oisin as his main target for nothing that I can see as different from anyone else.

Shows a bit of .. WTF.. at Fionas targetting.

More Oisin targetting, sure, I think someone else at this stage went to Oisin, just laugh it off.

Lets leave Oisin for a while, let that ferment with others....

Let's talk about scrooge, then..
probably zero point on speculating at this stage IMO, focus on what's in front of us
Discusting advise.
Dont speculate??

What else do we do with a game with shag all to go on?

Back to scrooge again. I'll note the fixation on the wolf team and move on.

Okay, ending the not so helpful dies hard xmas stuff is probably villagery.

But, back to Oisin.

Okay, I have seen a certain player before targetting another for zero reasons before, just for both to survive the munch, so this is possible.

The most horrible stuff out of Fiona is don't speculate.

I'll forgive the Oisin targetting, but if Fiona is wolf, that does not let Oisin off as wolf.

Now, my earlier note, mentioning scrooge and focusing on the wolves, could mean we have a sk here.

If one sk know the id of another, maybe they do some distancing on d0, the way Fiona has been doing to Oisin?

Well, thats my ramble for now.

Fiona possibley still vallagery just picking fight with Oisin so both survive the munch.

If thats the case, Oisin is the innocent victum in Fionas villagers ruse.

Gertys main contribution

Isla WW · 17-12-2018 11:18AM

Holly WW wrote: »

Is it normal for no SK kill on day 1?

Normal enough. Bit harsh to kill off 2 players on Day 1 when they might not have even posted.
There was probably a backroom competition for who gets the kill or else the SK just have kills on alternate nights so Monday is their first kill.

Did we ever get an answer to when the SK kills? Maybe it's at lynchtime?

Riona WW · 17-12-2018 11:22AM

I say, MrsFlushdraw. Your notice of Gertrude’s demise was positively ugsome.

Steve WW · 17-12-2018 11:26AM

What I take from this, quote " marley orocured a new bidy to inhabit" sounds like a convert.

This morning was a munch, its in the op. Have to assume it was a wolf kill.

Riona WW · 17-12-2018 11:28AM

So we have a wolf team containing Scrooge (alpha), Marley (power blocker) and the 3 ghosts.

Along with 2 SKs that makes 7 evils vs 16 good?

If someone could be so kind to explain this part to me - unless absolutely necessary?

3) The Serial Killers
The serial killers work as a pair, unless absolutely necessary, and choose their kills each night. They appear as normal people most of the time, so will peek as good every second cycle.

Brendan WW · 17-12-2018 11:28AM

Steve WW wrote: »

What I take from this, quote " marley orocured a new bidy to inhabit" sounds like a convert.

This morning was a munch, its in the op. Have to assume it was a wolf kill.

Just says first munch, it's not definitive as being wolf munch. Likely, but also possible Scrooge got his convert and the SKs got a munch.

Rule nothing out

Mary WW · 17-12-2018 11:32AM

Gertrude WW wrote: »

Maybe the task is to misread the post.

Gertrude WW wrote: »

Gertrude WW wrote: »

Do you think there is a shared wolves and serial killers comms room where they can all chat together?

Gertrude WW wrote: »

Make sure to make a few of these to hang on your tree. Very festive xmas tree decoration.

Gertrude WW wrote: »

Gertrude WW wrote: »

If its obvious then any chance you can spell it out for us?

Gertrude WW wrote: »

I'd treat pinnapple on a pizza the same way as I would sweetcorn on a pizza. I have no issues with them being on pizzas, but I'll be ripping them off my slice before eating it.

Gertrude WW wrote: »

Tried to check out xmas forum, not allowed entry.

Boards.ie Message Gertrude WW, you do not have permission to access this page. This could be due to one of several reasons:
Your user account may not have sufficient privileges to access this page. Are you trying to edit someone else's post, access administrative features or some other privileged system?

If you are trying to post, the administrator may have disabled your account, or it may be awaiting activation.

Gertrude WW wrote: »

Picks Oisin as his main target for nothing that I can see as different from anyone else.

Shows a bit of .. WTF.. at Fionas targetting.

More Oisin targetting, sure, I think someone else at this stage went to Oisin, just laugh it off.

Lets leave Oisin for a while, let that ferment with others....

Let's talk about scrooge, then..
probably zero point on speculating at this stage IMO, focus on what's in front of us
Discusting advise.
Dont speculate??

What else do we do with a game with shag all to go on?

Back to scrooge again. I'll note the fixation on the wolf team and move on.

Okay, ending the not so helpful dies hard xmas stuff is probably villagery.

But, back to Oisin.

Okay, I have seen a certain player before targetting another for zero reasons before, just for both to survive the munch, so this is possible.

The most horrible stuff out of Fiona is don't speculate.

I'll forgive the Oisin targetting, but if Fiona is wolf, that does not let Oisin off as wolf.

Now, my earlier note, mentioning scrooge and focusing on the wolves, could mean we have a sk here.

If one sk know the id of another, maybe they do some distancing on d0, the way Fiona has been doing to Oisin?

Well, thats my ramble for now.

Fiona possibley still vallagery just picking fight with Oisin so both survive the munch.

If thats the case, Oisin is the innocent victum in Fionas villagers ruse.

Gertrude WW wrote: »

In summary, Die Hard is an xmas movie.

But there no santas in it, boo hoo, so what. There was a santa hat, an xmas party , its xmas time, it an xmas movie.

Where is santa in its a wonderful life?

Xmas soundtrack, tick.

Listed as xmas movie in almost every xmas movie list, tick.

Get over it, its an xmas movie.

mic drop.

All of Gertie's posts. There is really only one in that list of particular substance which suggests that the first port of call is Fiona and Oisin for discussion. Both could be good.

Aside from the death, we now have more info which is always good for us.

The wolf team might be five members - Scrooge, Marlay and the 3 spirits.
I am just not sure what the increase/decrease parts of the OP would relate to. The increase possibly is Scrooge getting Marlay to his team? But the bold part says Marlay visited Scrooge, which seems odd to me?

I think Tiny Tim might have some bullets (shotgun walking stick) which is always good.

Steve WW · 17-12-2018 11:32AM

Brendan WW wrote: »

Just says first munch, it's not definitive as being wolf munch. Likely, but also possible Scrooge got his convert and the SKs got a munch.

Rule nothing out

SK kills are not referred to as munches though, thats my reasoning. Not ruling anything out of course

Fiona WW · 17-12-2018 11:32AM

Gertie a surprising choice for munch. I'd have thought they would be hunting Tiny Tim. Thankfully we are dealing with stupid wolves!

Someone asked me why Oisin, purely style of posting pushes me to make me think hes a wolf trying to row through. The Gertie kill as speculated may be to put heat on me but sure we'll see. Pretty stupid move if it was

Barbara WW · 17-12-2018 11:35AM

Brendan WW wrote: »

Just says first munch, it's not definitive as being wolf munch. Likely, but also possible Scrooge got his convert and the SKs got a munch.

Rule nothing out

Think terminology-wise "munch" has always been wolves, and Serial Killers kill. But I suppose we can't be too careful

Henry WW · 17-12-2018 11:35AM

Fiona WW wrote: »

Gertie a surprising choice for munch. I'd have thought they would be hunting Tiny Tim. Thankfully we are dealing with stupid wolves!

Someone asked me why Oisin, purely style of posting pushes me to make me think hes a wolf trying to row through. The Gertie kill as speculated may be to put heat on me but sure we'll see. Pretty stupid move if it was

Did we even know of Tiny Tim prior to munch? Why would they be hunting for someone not in the OP?

Fiona WW · 17-12-2018 11:38AM

Henry WW wrote: »

Did we even know of Tiny Tim prior to munch? Why would they be hunting for someone not in the OP?

No, it was speculated yesterday, Tiny Tim can turn scrooge good IMO, thats my thoughts and if the wolves had any sense they'd be thinking that too.

Barbara WW · 17-12-2018 11:39AM

Original OP: "The village have a priest, interrogator, seer, vigilante and maybe some other roles as well."

Updated OP: "The village have a priest, interrogator, seer, vigilante and maybe some other roles as well.
Update: Tiny Tim (Vigilante) - Has a gun and will receive a bullet each day."

So they'd've known there was a vig just not the rules and that he was called Tiny Tim

Fiona WW · 17-12-2018 11:39AM

Fiona WW wrote: »

No, it was speculated yesterday, Tiny Tim can turn scrooge good IMO, thats my thoughts and if the wolves had any sense they'd be thinking that too.

However I'm completely wrong now following the update

Brendan WW · 17-12-2018 11:40AM

Fiona WW wrote: »

No, it was speculated yesterday, Tiny Tim can turn scrooge good IMO, thats my thoughts and if the wolves had any sense they'd be thinking that too.

Well your thinking is wrong as per the updated OP :cool:

Fiona WW · 17-12-2018 11:41AM

Brendan WW wrote: »

Well your thinking is wrong as per the updated OP :cool:

I like your sunnys, never seeing a wolf wearing sunnys.

I jest of course.

Riona WW · 17-12-2018 11:43AM

It is quite probable that one or more wolves have posted after the munch. I am suggesting that the following be investigated further today.

Brendan
Holly
Barbara
Vernon
Henry
Isla
Riona
Steve
Mary
Fiona

My gut says there are more than one baddun in the above.

MrsFlushdraw · 17-12-2018 11:44AM

Riona WW wrote: »

I say, MrsFlushdraw. Your notice of Gertrude’s demise was positively ugsome.

Maybe it was Pter or LoughC who wrote that? I was asked to post it up, makes me look bad though :eek:

Brendan WW · 17-12-2018 11:45AM

Riona WW wrote: »

It is quite probable that one or more wolves have posted after the munch. I am suggesting that the following be investigated further today.

Brendan
Holly
Barbara
Vernon
Henry
Isla
Riona
Steve
Mary
Fiona

My gut says there are more than one baddun in the above.

:pac::pac::pac:

Love the inclusion of your own name. How do you propose we whittle down this large amount of names?

And why are you discounting everyone else....

Mary WW · 17-12-2018 11:46AM

Steve WW wrote: »

What I take from this, quote " marley orocured a new bidy to inhabit" sounds like a convert.

This morning was a munch, its in the op. Have to assume it was a wolf kill.

On this, if Marlay was a convert this morning it throws open a few things to consider.

Did wolves get a choice between convert or kill?
Or was the convert destined to happen anyway, like the appearance of Tiny Tim.
The OP says no tasks in the game thread, but in other stories there's been tasks in backrooms so I wonder did the bad teams need to compete for the kill. Has happened before.

Munch sounds like a wolf kill as opposed to SK kill. I'm a bit torn between taking flavour as flavour and not discounting anything. The kill notice is a clear sign of this - it talks of Tim's gun, and I've just noticed the updated OP where Tim has a gun so flavour is definitely more than flavour.

Clodagh WW · 17-12-2018 11:46AM

Mary WW wrote: »

All of Gertie's posts. There is really only one in that list of particular substance which suggests that the first port of call is Fiona and Oisin for discussion. Both could be good.

Aside from the death, we now have more info which is always good for us.

The wolf team might be five members - Scrooge, Marlay and the 3 spirits.
I am just not sure what the increase/decrease parts of the OP would relate to. The increase possibly is Scrooge getting Marlay to his team? But the bold part says Marlay visited Scrooge, which seems odd to me?

I think Tiny Tim might have some bullets (shotgun walking stick) which is always good.

I think Fiona and Oisín would be a good starting point.

Fiona - you say his posting style is wolfie, what is it about him that makes him wolfy, when there was nothing of substance in day 0?

And Oisín - Fiona has thrown shade on you a few times. But you haven’t really given a response beyond the usual “trying to get involved”. I’m not pointing one way or another, just trying to start somewhere.

Brendan WW · 17-12-2018 11:47AM

MrsFlushdraw wrote: »

Maybe it was Pter or LoughC who wrote that? I was asked to post it up, makes me look bad though :eek:

The mutilation of poor old Gertie's genitals leads me to believe you are responsble :pac:

Riona WW · 17-12-2018 11:49AM

Brendan WW wrote: »

:pac::pac::pac:

Love the inclusion of your own name. How do you propose we whittle down this large amount of names?

And why are you discounting everyone else....

I am not discounting anybody, sir! I simply feel that one should look at all of the above first. Isn’t a list of 10 better than a list of 22?

And I am not above suspicion.

Brendan WW · 17-12-2018 11:50AM

Riona WW wrote: »

I am not discounting anybody, sir! I simply feel that one should look at all of the above first. Isn’t a list of 10 better than a list of 22?

And I am not above suspicion.

I'm just a bit confused as to why target the 'after/before' munch posters. We had a wolf cub do that in the last game to throw around a bit of confusion so it makes me wary of someone doing the exact same thing in this one.

Yulewolf - A Werewolf Christmas Carol Game Thread

Comments