Sherlock - A game of Werewolf!

Nigel WW · 20-09-2018 03:47PM

First thing was that I had my placeholder on Riona but the above sounds like a confused villager more than a wolf. If she was genuinely confused, she'd have her team in a backroom telling her to STFU, I reckon. So, as I voted for Steve the last two nights, I think I'm going to go back to him. My gut has been telling me there's something off about him, as an under-the-radar wolf.

Abigail WW · 20-09-2018 03:49PM

Riona WW wrote: »

Also . . Are we all agreed that Jeff cant have a power tomorrow ?

Wini and Brendan both claimed that Jeff gave them some pill or poison and it failed . . So there should only be one wolf kill tomorrow . .

Last time Jeff failed, it was claimed he would not have his pills the next day and seemingly that was the case so one would assume that would hold true this time too.

Nigel WW · 20-09-2018 03:50PM

Secondly, I was asking Gabriel about his table. I was wondering why we three made the table when he admitted later on that there were others he had down as more wolfy, so was wondering why he didn't include them too. Then, I was explaining why I didn't ask Wini for the note yesterday - it happened quickly, between Wini asking who to send and Gabriel saying pick him. In that time, I was discussing with Holly who had started the Doris train. If I'd seen Wini's offer on time I would have offered to be picked. Not that it seemingly matters. I think Wini's power never included her dying if the person was a wolf, so it'd not have confirmed me anyway.

Gabriel WW · 20-09-2018 03:52PM

Nigel WW wrote: »

Secondly, I was asking Gabriel about his table. I was wondering why we three made the table when he admitted later on that there were others he had down as more wolfy, so was wondering why he didn't include them too. Then, I was explaining why I didn't ask Wini for the note yesterday - it happened quickly, between Wini asking who to send and Gabriel saying pick him. In that time, I was discussing with Holly who had started the Doris train. If I'd seen Wini's offer on time I would have offered to be picked. Not that it seemingly matters. I think Wini's power never included her dying if the person was a wolf, so it'd not have confirmed me anyway.

Sorry.....explain that again....

Nigel WW · 20-09-2018 03:52PM

Then, I was asking a bit about Wini. She certainly lied because she said she was Janine Hawkins. If she Team Village then why did her death notice not say that. And if she was Team Village then why would she say she was Janine Hawkins? If she was Team Wolf, then the only wolf (that we know of anyway) that comes up NRV is Irene. But if she was Team Wolf why did she not continue with her pocketing villagers story instead of changing it to a finding wolves story. She has me baffled, and tbh, I don't think we're likely to get to the bottom of this as it probably only makes sense once all the mods' secrets are revealed.

Eva WW · 20-09-2018 03:53PM

Gabriel WW wrote: »

I dont necessarily agree with your reasoning, but i had him in as my target anyway.

Your point essentially boils down to him targeting Doris with his analysis?

No Gabriel, there's more in there. After writing that long post, please don't make me repeat points from it.

Plus if you're going to make a piss poor effort at summing it up, at least mention "because he targeted Doris and Liam", two villagers confirmed by our Priest. Why did you leave out Liam?

So you don't think that interaction with me last night was shady and the reasoning why? Forget about me, what about those random comments from him? In other games, that shít would at least draw a jovial "You mean to post that in you BR?" joke, but not in this game. A low poster, on the night of a day when you wanted to hang one, shows up with those random posts and no one passes any remarks. That doesn't make sense.

This comment...

Steve wrote:

That's done now Eva. Will report back in the morning.

What's done now? What will he report back to me?? Just doesn't make sense.

Plus, you don't feel he is skimming by? Another day without him today while we could do with another voice in here.

I know I was missing earlier, but I explained that before I logged off last night after a really long WW session. Sure, Steve is working or RL or something, but so are all of us. Why the hell sign-up for a game if one can't interact despite work? He's a low lying wolf.

Nigel WW · 20-09-2018 03:54PM

Lastly, I was asking did anyone think it was odd about Holly getting munched today, nobody has seemed to question the choice so far. It was about that time that I lost the post so didn't get to finish the point, which I was going to make which is that it sounded almost like a Mycroft mechanic where a different player was targeted. But that's not possible if Mycroft died when Conor said he did, so I'm baffled again.

Nigel WW · 20-09-2018 03:59PM

Gabriel WW wrote: »

Sorry.....explain that again....

Sorry first time I typed it out, when it was lost, it was probably better phrased. I didn't have the energy to be as careful the second time. I was wondering why Steve, Isla and myself made that table, when below you said that there were others (eg, Orla) that you were even more suspicious of.

Gabriel WW wrote: »

Don't think I'd FFA Nigel.

Would go Orla over nigel.

Gabriel WW · 20-09-2018 03:59PM

Eva WW wrote: »

No Gabriel, there's more in there. After writing that long post, please don't make me repeat points from it.

Plus if you're going to make a piss poor effort at summing it up, at least mention "because he targeted Doris and Liam", two villagers confirmed by our Priest. Why did you leave out Liam?

So you don't think that interaction with me last night was shady and the reasoning why? Forget about me, what about those random comments from him? In other games, that shít would at least draw a jovial "You mean to post that in you BR?" joke, but not in this game. A low poster, on the night of a day when you wanted to hang one, shows up with those random posts and no one passes any remarks. That doesn't make sense.

This comment...

What's done now? What will he report back to me?? Just doesn't make sense.

Plus, you don't feel he is skimming by? Another day without him today while we could do with another voice in here.

I know I was missing earlier, but I explained that before I logged off last night after a really long WW session. Sure, Steve is working or RL or something, but so are all of us. Why the hell sign-up for a game if one can't interact despite work? He's a low lying wolf.

Thank for for elaborating more. I get your reasoning. Apologies for leaving Liam out - wasnt my intention but yeah i focused on the Doris stuff.

Those posts from around midnight from Steve would seem to implicate both him and yourself. It does look like misplaced backroom chat.....i dont know why he would be calling you Eva in any backroom though, so i dont know the significance of those posts.

As i said, im happy to vote for him, and will be interested in his explanation of those posts.

Eva WW · 20-09-2018 04:00PM

Abigail WW wrote: »

adds feul to the fire. Don't like piggy backing on someone elses work but him drawing lots of attention on people who turn out to be actual NRVs (considering I believe Wini was Irene) does add to the reasons I was suspicious of him (he was second on my FFA yesterday, although that was not focusing on the 4 messaged people). I would imagine the throwing shade bit would stand out to you far more than anyone else though considering it happened to you.

Don't worry about piggy-backing - That is easy to spot either in real-time or searching back.

Focus on the messaged people, oh god focus on the messaged people and that mess, but on Day 4 now we can't ignore the low lying wolf either. And I'm fairly sure there is one.

Gabriel WW · 20-09-2018 04:00PM

Gabriel WW wrote: »

Just FYI, the basis of my analysis were the people who would have benefitted from being 'cleared' by Winis message last night that didnt ask to do so. Holly was in the list too but she ded.

So not me randomly doing an analysis of who i suspect. Me analysing people based on an event.

The Orla and Abi reads by me just now were all gut however.

I also said this Nidge, about 2 posts under where i said id go for Orla or Abi.

Nigel WW · 20-09-2018 04:05PM

Derry WW wrote: »

This goes out to a specific someone.

If you're given a choice soon....don't.

(I'll see about expanding in a while. I'm hoping I've read something right and that the relevant person will understand).

Has this comment been explained satisfactorily?

Eva WW · 20-09-2018 04:09PM

Gabriel WW wrote: »

Thank for for elaborating more. I get your reasoning. Apologies for leaving Liam out - wasnt my intention but yeah i focused on the Doris stuff.

Those posts from around midnight from Steve would seem to implicate both him and yourself. It does look like misplaced backroom chat.....i dont know why he would be calling you Eva in any backroom though, so i dont know the significance of those posts.

As i said, im happy to vote for him, and will be interested in his explanation of those posts.

Yeah they certainly would implicate me too, but I don't care.

I am honestly a villager trying to find the wolves. I've already been 'dead', I have nothing to lose here. I know that Steve didn't mean to send me that in a backroom as I am not in one with him, so it's just a bit baffling.

If it is BR chat, could it be just missing a word? Like 'on' or something...

Steve wrote:

That's done now "on" Eva. Will report back in the morning.

Steve's follow up post just saying 'Well' signifies that he wasn't in the most grammatically-minded mood.

I dunno, really don't, but I feel I've put a bit into that long post on Steve to give the village a bit of thought.

Nigel WW · 20-09-2018 04:09PM

Gabriel WW wrote: »

I also said this Nidge, about 2 posts under where i said id go for Orla or Abi.

Okay but if it was purely about who would benefit from Wini clearing them by sending them a note (which we now know is bogus, but admittedly didn't know at the time), then what has "In top 2 voted for D2/D3", you in their FFA, voted for you or Liam, got to do with that?

Do you accept that the request for Wini's note and decision made happened quickly and though I was online I was responding to another player at the time?

Gabriel WW · 20-09-2018 04:14PM

Nigel WW wrote: »

Okay but if it was purely about who would benefit from Wini clearing them by sending them a note (which we now know is bogus, but admittedly didn't know at the time), then what has "In top 2 voted for D2/D3", you in their FFA, voted for you or Liam, got to do with that?

Do you accept that the request for Wini's note and decision made happened quickly and though I was online I was responding to another player at the time?

The event happened and created a sub group of the village to analyse. Now that i have the headers ill apply it to everyone. But that was a start.

doesnt matter if it happened quickly or not. It was only a starting point. The other headings i have put in there mean that im not overly reliant on the wini note thing. Thats only 2 headings out of all the headings.

Why are you trying to discredit the table and the wini note thing. You come out of the analysis in the best condition......

Nigel WW · 20-09-2018 04:21PM

Gabriel WW wrote: »

The event happened and created a sub group of the village to analyse. Now that i have the headers ill apply it to everyone. But that was a start.

doesnt matter if it happened quickly or not. It was only a starting point. The other headings i have put in there mean that im not overly reliant on the wini note thing. Thats only 2 headings out of all the headings.

Why are you trying to discredit the table and the wini note thing. You come out of the analysis in the best condition......

Not discredit it. Just understand it. Above makes most sense. Those three only, but with all those headings made no sense. If you're planning on adding more it, that makes more sense.

Yeah, I did hesitate to ask as I was "winning" but I thought I'd rather know and understand rather then not have a clue.

Brendan WW · 20-09-2018 04:21PM

Riona WW wrote: »

Also . . Are we all agreed that Jeff cant have a power tomorrow ?

Wini and Brendan both claimed that Jeff gave them some pill or poison and it failed . . So there should only be one wolf kill tomorrow . .

I can confirm that the PM said if I chose the right pill he has to wait an extra day before he can kill again.

Riona WW · 20-09-2018 04:25PM

Abigail WW wrote: »

Last time Jeff failed, it was claimed he would not have his pills the next day and seemingly that was the case so one would assume that would hold true this time too.

Wendy got a note

Wendy WW wrote: »

Sorry, I'm back. Jeff Hope just tried to kill me.

I got a message that I had to pick between two bottles he sent me. One would kill me instantly and one would let me live.

I chose the right bottle so here I am. Bonus for us is he has to wait an extra day before he can use his pills again.

Wendy WW wrote: »

I was told specifically that
wrong pick = instant death
Right pick = life, and Jeff can't use his pills for one day.

Wendy WW wrote: »

I am not allowed to copy and paste the PM I got, but that was information contained in it. I don't know why the massage contained the info it did but I'm telling the village everything I know.

Again, I don't know why I was told Jeff wouldn't get to use his pills for one day. Maybe a way to verify I am telling the truth? It would make sense as a balance against the wolves getting a 50/50 kill every day.

Brendan what sort of information did you get ? Did you confirm that Jeff wont get a 24 hour kill ? I cant see where you confirmed this to the village which would be handy to know . .

Gabriel WW · 20-09-2018 04:25PM

Eva WW wrote: »

Yeah they certainly would implicate me too, but I don't care.

I am honestly a villager trying to find the wolves. I've already been 'dead', I have nothing to lose here. I know that Steve didn't mean to send me that in a backroom as I am not in one with him, so it's just a bit baffling.

If it is BR chat, could it be just missing a word? Like 'on' or something...

Steve's follow up post just saying 'Well' signifies that he wasn't in the most grammatically-minded mood.

I dunno, really don't, but I feel I've put a bit into that long post on Steve to give the village a bit of thought.

Why are there no links to the posts you quote?

Riona WW · 20-09-2018 04:26PM

Brendan WW wrote: »

I can confirm that the PM said if I chose the right pill he has to wait an extra day before he can kill again.

Forget my post just after yours . . I was typing it up when you responded .

Derry WW · 20-09-2018 04:28PM

Upside, I was starting to doubt my trust in Gabriel, but if hes a wolf, then he deserves to win on that trophy :P

Riona WW · 20-09-2018 04:29PM

Brendan WW wrote: »

I can confirm that the PM said if I chose the right pill he has to wait an extra day before he can kill again.

Did you have to make a choice and wait to see if you didn't die before announcing on thread ? That is, if you chose the wrong pill you don't get to say anything on thread and we all have to assume you were jeffed?

Gabriel WW · 20-09-2018 04:32PM

Derry WW wrote: »

Upside, I was starting to doubt my trust in Gabriel, but if hes a wolf, then he deserves to win on that trophy :P

510slit-yourgold-so-justins-dating-hailey

Are you gonna give an FFA or read list today Derry?

Gabriel WW · 20-09-2018 04:32PM

Actually - everyone.....its half 4. Where are your FFAs?

7pm deadline again today?

Nigel WW · 20-09-2018 04:36PM

Eva / Steve thing now with links to quotes.

Eva WW wrote: »

Guys I'm awake 32+ hours now. Not your fault I know, but a reality which means me going to bed now and hopefully sleeping for at least 12 hours.

When I eventually rise tomorrow, I really need to get some RL stuff done which has fallen badly by the wayside since Andy Mourinho PMed me on Monday to call me up to the WW first 11.

This is fun and intense, but I need to draw a line. So I will likely not be around this side of RL lunch-time tomorrow. If I survive any and all surprises this game has to throw in the meantime, I will be back with contributions.

Good night, you absolute crazy ****s

Steve WW wrote: »

I feel like you're trying to pocket the whole village.

Steve WW wrote: »

That's done now Eva. Will report back in the morning.

Steve WW wrote: »

Well

Nigel WW · 20-09-2018 04:38PM

Just reading back over that exchange Eva, and yes it is very strange. It does sorta implicate you, but if you were a wolf, why highlight it at all when seemingly we'd all skirted by it, so I'm gonna give you a pass on it. High suss of Steve though. Has he been on at all today? I'd love to hear what he has to say about it.

Riona WW · 20-09-2018 04:38PM

Nigel WW wrote: »

Has this comment been explained satisfactorily?

Apparently that was a message to John not the SK .

Its an explanation, whether its satisfactory to the village is up to them . .

Maybe its been explained in more detail somewhere to actually give context to what is a very cryptic post from somebody whose kneck on the SK chopping block, but I am sure Derry will be happy to clear up his own motives on that .

Gabriel WW · 20-09-2018 04:40PM

#ffa4

Steve - see the table
Orla - disappearing act today (might be RL in fairness, but we need more from you man). Its a significant drop off in posting from someone who was saying they were off work this week. And you are still around to follow stuff. Has been under heat and has gotten at others this week, especially the D1 and D2 (Eva) stuff.......your play is erratic and that worries me.
Isla - see the table

Special mention to Derry who was as skeptical of the Wini plan as i was. Now im stream of consciousness guy - im posting what im thinking, but Derry is more measured. Despite that, he had a super cautious yet disbelieving set of objections to the Wini plan, pretty much as soon as she posted. This might implicate me a bit, but i dont care about that......

Also a special mention to Eva. You seem to have gotten off the hook since you almost swung, and your upturn in posting yesterday was great, even if it almost got me killed, but your flip flop on wini has been pointed out as looking a bit staged once Wini slipped. How do you respond to that?

Brendan WW · 20-09-2018 04:41PM

Riona WW wrote: »

Did you have to make a choice and wait to see if you didn't die before announcing on thread ? That is, if you chose the wrong pill you don't get to say anything on thread and we all have to assume you were jeffed?

Correct - I couldn’t post on thread again unless I was successful

Nigel WW · 20-09-2018 04:41PM

Nigel WW wrote: »

Just reading back over that exchange Eva, and yes it is very strange. It does sorta implicate you, but if you were a wolf, why highlight it at all when seemingly we'd all skirted by it, so I'm gonna give you a pass on it. High suss of Steve though. Has he been on at all today? I'd love to hear what he has to say about it.

Last message was his "Well" message this morning (last night really) at 00.09.

Sherlock - A game of Werewolf!

Comments