Sherlock - A game of Werewolf!

Isla WW · 19-09-2018 06:28PM

I do think holly is a wolf. No vote day1, voted on Nigel which was off wagon on day2. Not sure if they brought anything to the table today but there was nothing brought yesterday.

Gabriel has been one of my strongest villager leans all game. His posting has sensational flow that for me would be pretty impossible to fake as a wolf. He's just posting exactly as he's thinking. A lot like I'm doing.

Nigel still hiding as a wolf lean for me. Again not read anything today but someone pointed out the helpful tables above me here but helpful tables are a good place for a wolf to hide. He's been one of my constant reads since the start.

Few people I'm not so sure about. Riona for one. Didn't like her vote history day 1 & 2. Derry and Gabriel. Whatever about Derry but Gabriel seemed a very strange *cough* Wolfy choice to me.

I'll start skimming the thread. Brendan was an early wolf read of mine day 1&2. I'll look into him too as well as everyone else.

Eva WW · 19-09-2018 06:30PM

Gabriel WW wrote: »

Wagoneers hooooo

.

So Orla who is now another person who raises valid concerns with you, and instead address her points you deflect with a bs response like that.

It's this kind of shít Gabriel which has people worried about you.

Orla WW · 19-09-2018 06:33PM

Gabriel WW wrote: »

I didn't think lynching wini was even an option. Low posters ftw imo.

Let's see what FFA results bring. 8 in which is half +1 so enough to run with for the night if people wish to do so.

Holly WW · 19-09-2018 06:34PM

Abi - Village lean, she seemed to be doing decent work D1 and D2, haven't seen much from her today but seems vil to me.
Conor - Village lean, explains his suspicions and asks the right questions imo, consistently read Conor as good.
Derry - As said already, seems too good to be true, consistently reading Derry as a villager, makes a lot of good observations and asks questions, I've gotten very few wolf reads off Derry
Gabriel - Wolf lean, thought he had a good D1 at the time but I'm not so sure now, today has been dismissive and for want of a better word, victimized. Very wolfy day from Gabs imo.
Gertrude - Literally no opinion on Gertrude, will need to iso
Holly - Poor D1 and D2 but seems to be trying to help now
Isla - Slight village read, hasn't posted much to get a read off
Liam – Slight wolf lean, had a stronger wolf lean until today, has been posting more and coming alive so I'm unsure, probably my weakest wolf lean.
Nigel -Wolf lean, Today has been Nigels villageriest day, explaining his absense D1 followed by adding little but lists and tables until earlier today had him setting off wolf bells big time.
Steve - Slight village lean, hasn't posted much from what I recall but given his questioning I feel he may be village.

That's my reads on the unknowns as it stands, will be voting either Gabs or Nigel atm

Isla WW · 19-09-2018 06:34PM

Low posting is just a busy real life. I'd give anything to be able to park myself at the PC and just post and poast and poooast

Gabriel WW · 19-09-2018 06:36PM

Eva WW wrote:

So Orla who is now another person who raises valid concerns with you, and instead address her points you deflect with a bs response like that.

Oh stop being so serious. We are allowed have fun with the game. I've posted enough and asked enough questions that I can have some fun too.

Read my opus from this morning if you wanna learn more about last night. And my posting style being aggressive or flippant? Maybe it is. So what. That make me a wolf? No.

As i said before Eva, bring something new to your accusation or stop bringing it back to me. You are repeating the same accusation over an over again.

Maybe I do need to take a page out of orlas book in fairness and stop making so much noise. Let me try that.

Orla WW · 19-09-2018 06:36PM

Holly WW wrote: »

Abi - Village lean, she seemed to be doing decent work D1 and D2, haven't seen much from her today but seems vil to me.
Conor - Village lean, explains his suspicions and asks the right questions imo, consistently read Conor as good.
Derry - As said already, seems too good to be true, consistently reading Derry as a villager, makes a lot of good observations and asks questions, I've gotten very few wolf reads off Derry
Gabriel - Wolf lean, thought he had a good D1 at the time but I'm not so sure now, today has been dismissive and for want of a better word, victimized. Very wolfy day from Gabs imo.
Gertrude - Literally no opinion on Gertrude, will need to iso
Holly - Poor D1 and D2 but seems to be trying to help now
Isla - Slight village read, hasn't posted much to get a read off
Liam – Slight wolf lean, had a stronger wolf lean until today, has been posting more and coming alive so I'm unsure, probably my weakest wolf lean.
Nigel -Wolf lean, Today has been Nigels villageriest day, explaining his absense D1 followed by adding little but lists and tables until earlier today had him setting off wolf bells big time.
Steve - Slight village lean, hasn't posted much from what I recall but given his questioning I feel he may be village.

That's my reads on the unknowns as it stands, will be voting either Gabs or Nigel atm

Am I taking your wolf leans as your FFA?

Isla WW · 19-09-2018 06:38PM

Lol holly. Love the read on yourself

"Seems to be trying to help now"

Holly WW · 19-09-2018 06:38PM

Orla WW wrote: »

Am I taking your wolf leans as your FFA?

Yeah sorry, Gabs, Liam, Nigel #FFA3

Abigail WW · 19-09-2018 06:40PM

Isla WW wrote: »

Lol holly. Love the read on yourself

"Seems to be trying to help now"

seems to be...can't even fully convince herself. nice spot De Tective

Eva WW · 19-09-2018 06:48PM

Gabriel WW wrote: »

Oh stop being so serious. We are allowed have fun with the game. I've posted enough and asked enough questions that I can have some fun too.

Read my opus from this morning if you wanna learn more about last night. And my posting style being aggressive or flippant? Maybe it is. So what. That make me a wolf? No.

As i said before Eva, bring something new to your accusation or stop bringing it back to me. You are repeating the same accusation over an over again.

Maybe I do need to take a page out of orlas book in fairness and stop making so much noise. Let me try that.

You really do, and I'll certainly not stop you by persisting. You say I'm not bring anything new, my whole day has been realising new things about you. Plus, I offered that on Doris, I've more than a few times drawn attention to people who were missing too much from the game, I was the one who reminded the village that Jeff Hope could still be around and we might be due a visit today, I've explored possibilities about Wini. Don't tell me I'm just repeating the same accusation over and over. There are many things unanswered about you which IMO need answering.

But look, we are getting into that point now where you're gonna have to respond. Leave it, you don't, we're at odds at the moment and maybe we need to take a break Ross. Yes, that makes me Rachel and that's just the way it is.

Gabriel WW · 19-09-2018 06:50PM

Eva WW wrote:

But look, we are getting into that point now where you're gonna have to respond. Leave it, you don't, we're at odds at the moment and maybe we need to take a break Ross. Yes, that makes me Rachel and that's just the way it is.

I WAS RIGHT

Gabriel WW · 19-09-2018 06:52PM

Oh man it's I FELL ASLEEP isn't it. Anyway point taken Eva.

Orla WW · 19-09-2018 06:52PM

Eva WW wrote: »

You really do, and I'll certainly not stop you by persisting. You say I'm not bring anything new, my whole day has been realising new things about you. Plus, I offered that on Doris, I've more than a few times drawn attention to people who were missing too much from the game, I was the one who reminded the village that Jeff Hope could still be around and we might be due a visit today, I've explored possibilities about Wini. Don't tell me I'm just repeating the same accusation over and over. There are many things unanswered about you which IMO need answering.

But look, we are getting into that point now where you're gonna have to respond. Leave it, you don't, we're at odds at the moment and maybe we need to take a break Ross. Yes, that makes me Rachel and that's just the way it is.

Gabriel WW wrote: »

I WAS RIGHT

Nigel WW · 19-09-2018 06:54PM

Okay, so seriously, this is starting to piss me off. Since when has posting of lists been a wolf trait?

Orla WW wrote: »

Nigel - Still suspicious of his 'had to vote for someone' spiel on Monday night. He's upped the post count but aside from pretty tables and lists, until today nothing really of substance.

Holly WW wrote: »

Nigel -Wolf lean, Today has been Nigels villageriest day, explaining his absense D1 followed by adding little but lists and tables until earlier today had him setting off wolf bells big time.

If it is a wolf trait, then I present to you three more wolves (from a random page search) in Liam, Clodagh and Orla. Seriously, do an ISO on my posts and you'll see a lot more than just posting of the odd table which (a) I've posted on the request of others and (b) I personally find helpful to gather my own thoughts. If you've any real concerns about me that doesn't include fiddlstick tables, then I'll happily address them!

Liam WW wrote: »

User Name| Posts
Orla WW |78
Mary WW |48
Derry WW |35
Katie WW |33
Riona WW |31
Nigel WW |31
Conor WW| 27
Winifred WW |22
Clodagh WW| 22
Abigail WW |20
Brendan WW| 20
Doris WW| 18
Gabriel WW |16
Desmond WW| 16
Tegan WW |16
Wendy WW| 11
Steve WW |10
Frank WW| 9
Liam WW |6
Barbara WW| 5
Eva WW |1
Holly WW |1

So by my counting we've yet to hear from Gertrude, Isla and Ois

Clodagh WW wrote: »

User Name| | |
Winifred WW |Orla|Desmond|Gabriel
Gabriel WW |Tegan|Winifred|
Barbara WW |Desmond|Winifred| Liam
Tegan WW |Clodagh|Orla|Winifred
Desmond WW |Gabriel/Clodagh|Doris|Katie
Conor WW |Wendy|Liam|Tegan
Clodagh WW| Wendy|Derry|Abigail
Derry WW |Wendy|Nigel|

#1 - Wendy and Winifred - 3 votes each
#2 - Orla and Desmond and Liam- 2 votes each
#3 - Gabriel and Clodagh - 1 and a half votes? (Desmond pegs one or the other to be a wolf. but not both)

Orla also gave us her run down of every player here:

THose who didn't post FFAs:
Abigail WW
Barbara WW
Brendan WW
Doris WW
Eva WW
Frank WW
Gertrude WW
Holly WW
Isla WW
Katie WW
Liam WW
Mary WW
Nigel WW
OisWW
Riona WW
Steve WW
Wendy WW

If I got anything wrong, feel free to correct me

Orla WW wrote: »

Orla WW 214
Gabriel WW 196
Desmond WW 123
Riona WW 108
Derry WW 83
Clodagh WW 75
Conor WW 74
Barbara WW 71
Abigail WW 63
Winifred WW 51
Doris WW 50
Nigel WW 46
Brendan WW 42
Wendy WW 40
Isla WW 37
Gertrude WW 22
Steve WW 21
Eva WW 21
Holly WW 21
Liam WW 17

75 posts to the thread, treble what the bottom 3 posters have done.

You said earlier - we'll catch out the high posters eventually.

And now you're backtracking on that.

I just want to know why tbh.

Orla WW · 19-09-2018 07:00PM

Ok, posting what I have now.

Orla WW · 19-09-2018 07:00PM

FFAs Day 3:

Player Name Choice 1 Choice 2 Choice 3
Winifred WW Derry Gabriel Liam
Liam WW Abigail Holly Steve
Gabriel WW Holly Liam Steve
Brendan WW Isla Nigel Liam
Nigel WW Gabriel Holly Steve
Abigail WW Liam Steve Isla
Orla WW Liam Nigel Gabriel
Conor WW Isla Steve Riona
Holly WW Gabriel Liam Nigel

Results:

Liam WW 6
Steve WW 5
Gabriel WW 4
Holly WW 3
Isla WW 3
Nigel WW 3
Derry WW 1
Abigail WW 1
Riona WW 1

Derry WW · 19-09-2018 07:01PM

Nigel WW wrote: »

Okay, so seriously, this is starting to piss me off. Since when has posting of lists been a wolf trait?

List posting, collating FFAs, etc....its a handy way to appear as if you're contributing without actually contributing, hence why it can appear as wolfy.

Eva WW · 19-09-2018 07:05PM

I won't persist Gabriel, but of course I have to submit an FFA. It should be no surprise to you that you are on it...

#2 FFA;

Gabriel - That will be obvious that he's going on mine. I'm not trying to convince you with my FFA, just point out that I've put in that reasoning for anyone who wants to look back today. I'm sure many have seen my posts already. The day didn't start this way, but Gabriel is on my FFA tonight.

Steve/Isla - Isla is at least here contributing. Her and Steve are two whose absence have concerned me though. At this point on Day 3, it is time to start considering the prospect of a low-lying wolf coasting by.

I do not feel Steve/Isla are my strongest leads there though, or at least barely deserve to be differentiated from some others. I have mild concerns about Holly and Abigail too for instance. It's just, it's been a very taxing day with trying to keep up with some revelations - revelations which probably aren't going to mean the revealers are lynched tonight. So attention has been taken by them, but what do we do in the mean-time tonight?

Orla WW · 19-09-2018 07:06PM

God dammit Eva :pac: Okay I'll add those results

Orla WW · 19-09-2018 07:09PM

Updated FFA Results Day 3:

Player Name Choice 1 Choice 2 Choice 3
Winifred WW Derry Gabriel Liam
Liam WW Abigail Holly Steve
Gabriel WW Holly Liam Steve
Brendan WW Isla Nigel Liam
Nigel WW Gabriel Holly Steve
Abigail WW Liam Steve Isla
Orla WW Liam Nigel Gabriel
Conor WW Isla Steve Riona
Holly WW Gabriel Liam Nigel
Eva WW Gabriel Steve Isla

Results:

Liam WW 6
Steve WW 6
Gabriel WW 5
Isla WW 4
Holly WW 3
Nigel WW 3
Derry WW 1
Abigail WW 1
Riona WW 1

Gertrude WW · 19-09-2018 07:09PM

Got the short straw and late break tonight. Starting my read back now will post an ffa by 8

Nigel WW · 19-09-2018 07:10PM

Derry WW wrote: »

List posting, collating FFAs, etc....its a handy way to appear as if you're contributing without actually contributing, hence why it can appear as wolfy.

So, you agree Orla, Liam and Clodagh are wolves too?

It can be a handy way to contribute as a wolf, I agree. But, I reiterate, I have done more than that if you look back at my ISO.

Nigel WW · 19-09-2018 07:13PM

Nigel WW wrote: »

So, you agree Orla, Liam and Clodagh are wolves too?

It can be a handy way to contribute as a wolf, I agree. But, I reiterate, I have done more than that if you look back at my ISO.

And (last I'll say on the subject), it can also just be a helpful way to gather information. IIRC, the one collating the FFAs last game was the first to be munched, by the wolves, for being too helpful.

Eva WW · 19-09-2018 07:13PM

Sorry Orla, I had to have the 'What do you want me to get us for dinner?' conversation with the OH on the phone in the middle of writing my FFA.

That conversation can almost be as enduring as some of the stuff I've experienced in here the last two days :pac:

Derry WW · 19-09-2018 07:15PM

Nigel WW wrote: »

So, you agree Orla, Liam and Clodagh are wolves too?

It can be a handy way to contribute as a wolf, I agree. But, I reiterate, I have done more than that if you look back at my ISO.

Out of curiosity, if you had to sum up your contributions to the village thus far, how would you?

Eva WW · 19-09-2018 07:23PM

Right, in the same vein as Isla and Steve whose absence have concerned me, I guess I could include Liam in that. It's just Liam piped up today and started contributing. Still, as far as I'm concerned, no one for me is confirmed in any way except my fellow messengers until Wini's next result is revealed. That thing is parked for now.

So, low posters it seems to be, but we have to be careful there - As well as a low lying wolf, there could be a RV in there.

The low posters, who has seemed the fluffiest? Barely getting by, just summising events and repeating other peoples opinion in one line? I don't know right now, but I don't think a low lying RV will be doing that. As well as conceal themselves, they will at least try to be helpful to the village with what they do contribute.

Derry WW · 19-09-2018 07:24PM

Eva WW wrote: »

Right, in the same vein as Isla and Steve whose absence have concerned me, I guess I could include Liam in that. It's just Liam piped up today and started contributing. Still, as far as I'm concerned, no one for me is confirmed in any way except my fellow messengers until Wini's next result is revealed. That thing is parked for now.

So, low posters it seems to be, but we have to be careful there - As well as a low lying wolf, there could be a RV in there.

The low posters, who has seemed the fluffiest? Barely getting by, just summising events and repeating other peoples opinion in one line? I don't know right now, but I don't think a low lying RV will be doing that. As well as conceal themselves, they will at least try to be helpful to the village with what they do contribute.

Isla, Steve and Liam, I have no read on.

Holly and Nigel, I feel as trying to look like they are contributing, but I'm no really convinced by their contributions.

Nigel WW · 19-09-2018 07:33PM

Derry WW wrote: »

Out of curiosity, if you had to sum up your contributions to the village thus far, how would you?

Sunday, doing my best to solve the riddles, asking for the village to work together to solve them.
Monday (especially) and Tuesday hardly any contribution at all as struggling to just catch up and make informed lynch choices.
Tuesday evening onwards, questioning of role claims, trying to get to the bottom of players' motivations, doing my best to vote for a wolf, and defend anyone I see as villager.

Gertrude WW · 19-09-2018 07:34PM

Steve WW wrote: »

I will pull together a lean list later.

For a quick summary of where I am at
Liam wolf
Orla and Gabe on opposing teams with a lean towards Orla being bad
Holly wolf

I don't keep notes so this only has ones that have particularly peeked my interest. For the rest I need to properly investigate contributions thus far

May have been asked and answered but you lean holly wolf. What are your opinions on Wini, riona and Eva then?

Sherlock - A game of Werewolf!

Comments