Sherlock - A game of Werewolf!

I really want to hear more from Gertrude and anyone below her. Holly and Liam have made inroads on that today, but the rest of you please. Thoughts??

Gabriel WW 298
Orla WW 271
Riona WW 147
Clodagh WW 139
Derry WW 128
Desmond WW 125
Conor WW 97
Abigail WW 88
Barbara WW 84
Nigel WW 83
Winifred WW 82
Eva WW 81
Brendan WW 76
Doris WW 59
Gertrude WW 57
Steve WW 57
Katie WW 56
Tegan WW 52
Liam WW 50
Mary WW 48
Isla WW 47
Holly WW 44
Wendy WW 40
WerewolfGM 22
Frank WW 12
Pter 5
Loughc 1
Oisin WW 1

Eva WW wrote: »

Apologies Holly, that was when you had barely made much contribution today. I didn't get a great vibe off that, but you are contributing a whole lot more since I saw that.

I will say though, it seems like you have a decision made on Gabriel, so don't maybe don't get boxed into that now that you've decided.

Since someone mentioned you started on Doris yesterday, since I opined today that we might have lynched a wolf in Doris, what was it that made you go for Doris?

This is just for my own recollection and interest btw, and not to put you under a spotlight.

No worries, I understand how it is with low posters


I'm never fully set one way or the other without hard proof, trying not to tunnel him but he don't make it easy. Pretty sure he's a wolf but won't leave him beyond redemption.


I only properly followed today and D0, D1 and D2 were primarily speedreading so I didn't get too deep a focus on anyone, its why my FFA on Nidge was poor, it's just a feeling I got from reading. Doris was the same, nearly everyone has a handful of posts I could spotlight and say "this is helpful and sincere villager chat" but I didn't spot any at all from Doris, everything seemed to be fluff or struck me as insincere. She's one of the few I had no villager reads on.

Gabriel, was it you who early on floated the possibility/probability of a wolf being in the top 2 votes on night one? Do you still think that theory is viable?

Derry WW wrote:

Gabriel, was it you who early on floated the possibility/probability of a wolf being in the top 2 votes on night one? Do you still think that theory is viable?

Might be. They usually try hide in the crowd on d1 in my experience. One of them at least. But it might not fly in this game since the vote was so spread out.

Derry: I really worry his strong early work on the riddles has seen him coast by without anyone really looking at him too much but he does not strike me as a wolf and I tend (not always to agree with his reads). Really hope hes not a wolf, cos he will get away with it

Conor: Good with the clues like Derry but never seemed to get as cleared in peoples minds as him. Perhaps because Derry was more active. Still contributes to the conversation a good bit without raising flags. Could be god wolf play but im not leaning that way at the moment

Gabby: Rallied harder than most against the Wini situation which will bring eyes on her. I actually have a slight village lean on her despite this thinking that maybe she is just tunneling / finding it hard not to respond to stuff or put things to one side so as not to derail the village (kinda similar to Orla) but still im not going to be voting here i'd think

Nigel: I feel I should have more on Nigel, Derry didn't trust him based off day 0/1 interaction, while (cant think who) showed he was actively involved in trying to solve riddles etc. Hasn't done much of note despite us being a few days in so could be the quiet wolf except hes not been that quiet in terms of post tally

Steve: weird when talking about hospitalisation, I see mention of him and Holly starting the Doris wagon of votes. Very hard to read despite being a few days in now also so could be a quiet wolf but that could be said of a few as mentioned with Nigel


Isla: has not been all day, so obviously a low enough post count although did have a post saying that there post count wasn't important and that they should be on more the next day. Seemed to be after Des & and Doris "pinged her wolfdar" before that seemed to spend a lot of time talking about hospital


Liam: Was iirc the first to suggest ignoring the wini4 to focus on a list of uncertains for FFAs etc, this list includes himself, one of the lowest posters but much more active since the Wini reveal, Gabby called him a wolf on thread, seemed to be tunneling me for a day 0 post nobody else found worthy of discussion despite it getting me top of his 2 FFAs... and now 3 despite saying he thinks someone he doesn't list is a wolf!


Holly: tunneling Nigel - lowest post count thats even padded by Magic the gathering talk, riddle guesses, hospitalization talk and a youtube video and asking others opinions instead of giving her own. Very little to read into tbh



#FFA3

1.Liam
2.Steve
3.Isla

all potential quiet wolves but then again when you take out wini's 4 and lean good on Derry from early actions you very quickly get down away from the potential talkative wolves

Hey guys

Isla WW wrote: »

Hey guys

Long time no see. Are you up to date with whats going on? If so what do you think about the days happenings? who do you think is Wolfie? Think you will get an FFA in? The village could do with hearing more from Isla even if I always associate that account with being a headwreck from past games.

Abigail WW wrote:

Long time no see. Are you up to date with whats going on? If so what do you think about the days happenings? who do you think is Wolfie? Think you will get an FFA in? The village could do with hearing more from Isla even if I always associate that account with being a headwreck from past games.

Yeah Isla. Put your detective skills to work.

Gabriel WW wrote: »

How many times do I have to tell you I was genuinely impressed you did the Doris research. Give me back the star please.

It wasn't just about the 'gold star' or you being impressed, i'm keeping the gold star anyway :mad:

It was more that you didn't even weigh in on those thoughts, despite requesting more work from me today.

.....................................

All respect to RL, work, kids, everything outside of WW, but when possible I'd like to hear more from Steve and Isla. One of them is going on my FFA. Steve in fairness pursued someone who I'm leaning on as wolf, Doris. Isla has not been on my radar. At this point, that's more of a bad thing.

Ok, fwiw here's my #FFA3:

Liam - inactive basically until today, aside from the bare minimum. Has improved today, and I'm grateful for that but then he WTFs and calls Gabriel a wolf but leaves him off his FFA.... it's all a bit too 'stay under the radar' for me.

Nigel - Still suspicious of his 'had to vote for someone' spiel on Monday night. He's upped the post count but aside from pretty tables and lists, until today nothing really of substance.

And while it pains me to do this, I think I have to

Gabriel - His vote flip-flop parade last night raised my eyebrows, along with his hand in outing Clodagh (granted, more than him involved, and I had a very bad day yesterday too if Eva turns out to be good). But today he's rather aggressive, rattled almost by Wini and her claims. At first he was shouting her down and talking about rocket cars in relation to it, then he was mentioning priests, then stating we could afford a mislynch on him. Arguing with Eva, Liam and Holly - grand, but some of it is quite dismissive of their points.

Gabriel WW wrote: »

Orla your post rate has plummeted. How come?

RL stuff this afternoon, also minor exhaustion tbh.

Orla WW wrote:

Gabriel - His vote flip-flop parade last night raised my eyebrows, along with his hand in outing Clodagh (granted, more than him involved, and I had a very bad day yesterday too if Eva turns out to be good). But today he's rather aggressive, rattled almost by Wini and her claims. At first he was shouting her down and talking about rocket cars in relation to it, then he was mentioning priests, then stating we could afford a mislynch on him. Arguing with Eva, Liam and Holly - grand, but some of it is quite dismissive of their points.

Wagoneers hooooo

Orla WW wrote:

RL stuff this afternoon, also minor exhaustion tbh.

You ok to collate? I can prob do it if you are stuck.

Orla WW wrote: »

RL stuff this afternoon, also minor exhaustion tbh.

Know how you feel. I have been awake since 2pm yesterday and playing WW for much of that time since then...in a week where I didn't even envision a game of WW.

I am starting to see weird shapes here in the room, my eyes are sore and heavy, and I really need to take off soon and get some rest.

I'd like to at least hang around and see what our strategy is for this evening though. Are we lynching Wini or are we sparing her until at least her next result? Are we aiming in to the low posters again?

I'm wrecked here, but as well as enjoying the game, it's not an ideal time to take off. If I was one of the posters who have cruised by under the radar for 3 days now, I guess I could do that.

^^ No idea why the above says was posted by WerewolfGM. In reply to Orla, in case anyone needs to know.

Ok..going to be offline for a bit

Abi: Leaning good on her
Derry: Leaning good on him
Nigel: Leaning good but less so, could be helpful wolf
Brendan: BG: Team village
Gabriel: Skeptical about Wini...which makes me slightly lean town but not sure
Gertie: Very neutral, could go either way
Liam: Could be sneaky wolf but has posted today so getting benefit of doubt. If he goes silent again will worry
Holly: Low poster but missed a vote N1 which sways me towards just not paying attention.
Wini/Eva/Orla: No idea. I find the reveal too hard to believe but trying not to get trapped by this.

#FFA3

Isla: I've been suspicious of Isla since yesterday and the low posting hasn't given me anything to change my mind

Steve: Low lying wolf or fairly useless villager

Riona: I can't shake my feelings about Wini's reveal and Riona is the one I suspect most from that group.

Think that's everyone. I probably won't be back on until after 8