Sherlock - A game of Werewolf!

Brendan WW · 18-09-2018 03:00PM

Desmond WW wrote: »

Katie was lynched yesterday, I don't think she is going to respond to that any time soon.

I assume she means the Katie voters

Barbara WW · 18-09-2018 03:04PM

Desmond WW wrote: »

Katie was lynched yesterday, I don't think she is going to respond to that any time soon.

Can the people who voted Katie last night explain their vote

Derry WW · 18-09-2018 03:05PM

Riona WW wrote: »

Again Derry, I have to be careful cause I got burned last village but you can see how this doesn't look great right ?

Yeah, that's a fair concern.

The answer basically is I couldn't formulate any answers to it, and my style isn't to brute force puzzles.

When I was doing the two puzzles on Day 1, I didn't throw out random answers to a huge extent. I posted my best guess when I had them, and discussed possible ideas of how to get answers. Last night, the few answers I could come up with (and there weren't many, because anything I did come up with didn't fit the entire riddle) had already been guessed.

Once Orla pointed out the possibility the note was a trap, I posted pretty strenuously that I agreed with that assessment. So, in a way, it could be argued that I did post an answer to the riddle, and the answer was "This is a trick" :P

Clodagh WW · 18-09-2018 03:06PM

Riona WW wrote: »

Less then clear about what exactly ? I'm an open Book Clodagh . .

You see ambiguous posts like your can sow seeds of doubt in peoples heads. "oh didn't Clodagh say she thought Riona wasn't clear about something sometime " . "And Riona didn't answer, ooh that's dodgy". .

Well sorry Gabriel but as long as Clodagh is spouting inaccuracy's on me I will correct her.

This is a tactic Trump uses extremely effectively. In essence spew lies and half truths and people don't actually know what lie to focus on . .If people react to these accusations try and make out that they look suspicious because they are trying to clarify things or highlight how ridiculous your comments are.

As far as I can tell the two things people don't like about me where my statement that "Jeff was a wolf" and you making me look like I was suggesting Watson comes out. .

I explained why I said "Jeff was a wolf". I was asked about wendys "mistake". Wendy posted 2 things about her pills. One had jeff as a wolf and the other mentioned the SK. I shorthanded responses with these quotes and only on reflection did my response look like what Desmond said. It actually took me a few mins to get what he was saying . . Take what I said as fact or put it in my dodgy column , theres not much else to debate. Build up other evidence to further show my wolfiness, that's my suggestion because there are plenty of other people who have made mistakes and had dodgy behaviour that also warrants attention. .

So then we have your insistence that I have been pushing for the Vig to come out . . You are insisting I said it . . You quote my posts and respond completely out of context .

You ignore my response like my quoted post :

And then you ignore me showing you my above post .

You see another reason I'm suspicious of you is how insanely defensive you're being. What are you trying to hide?
I felt you weren't being clear and I said you aren't. Now you're trying to make that out as me spreading misinformation?

My biggest issue is that you are advocating the vig to come out after he's used his bullets, despite you not actually knowing whether he just gets one heal or has more. You seem to have a very clear idea on how the vig's powers work.

Riona WW wrote: »

Whether its somebody in hospital or a person killed surely he should reveal himself directly after he has used his last power ? He is an NRV once hes used 2 bullets and a heal . . It means he has also cleared one village . .

Riona WW wrote: »

I mean he comes out at 9.59 so wolves won’t have time to change their chosen victim. Then he immediately heals the person the wolves munched. We know at least that munched person isn’t a wolf and have another confirmed villager in Watson. If wolves try to double bluff it would go bad if Watson hadn’t healed and he is effectively an nrv at that stage so it would be confirming a wolf..

Riona WW wrote: »

Shoot somebody later and heal maybe tomorrows kill and come out at 9.59??

Riona WW wrote: »

Are you saving the Vig shouldn’t come out when they have used all their powers? I’m interested to hear the thought behind that....

I find it very strange that you have such an unshakeable view of how Watson's powers work, despite having no evidence.

At the very least, to me, those posts read as you encouraging the vig to hurry up and use those shots so they can get themselves offed too.

Like I said Clodagh you are either Tunnelling badly or a wolf trying to falsly create an inaccurate narrative of me. This post I am making is for fidelity purposes . .

It's entirely possible I'm tunnelled, but your super defensive reaction doesn't sit right with me.

Barbara WW · 18-09-2018 03:07PM

@derry how come you moved off your ffa for last nights vote?

Riona WW · 18-09-2018 03:07PM

Desmond WW wrote: »

If i was the vig i'd shoot wendy.
if i was the bg, i'd protect derry.
if i was the seer, i'd peek katie.

Good night.

Desmond WW wrote: »

mistake there, not wendy, winifred..
If i was the vig i'd shoot winifred.
sorry wendy, mixed up names.

full correction.

If i was the vig i'd shoot winifred.
if i was the bg, i'd protect derry.
if i was the seer, i'd peek katie.

Desmond WW wrote: »

#FFA1

Slot CYAN:
I see that there may be a wolf in here, but only 1 wolf, if any.
Gabriel WW - not w/w with clodagh
Clodagh WW - not w/w with gabs.

Slot MAGENTA
Doris WW - misinformation about Moriarty

Slot LILAC
Katie WW - where's our credit?

My slots are not numbered and should not be read with any preference to order.

Desmond WW wrote: »

If i was the vig i'd shoot Winifred.
if i was the bg, i'd protect Wendy.
if i was the seer, i'd peek Liam.

All this and he votes Clodagh . Clear as mud Dessie . .

Orla WW · 18-09-2018 03:09PM

Barbara WW wrote: »

@derry how come you moved off your ffa for last nights vote?

IIRC Derry was pushing pretty hard for Katie late on last night.

Barbara WW · 18-09-2018 03:10PM

Orla WW wrote: »

IIRC Derry was pushing pretty hard for Katie late on last night.

Ok, let me check back.

Orla WW · 18-09-2018 03:11PM

So, 2 FFAs/readslists so far. It's now 10 past 3

Gabriel WW · 18-09-2018 03:12PM

Orla WW wrote:

So, 2 FFAs/readslists so far. It's now 10 past 3

I don't know about you but I'm finding the current chat on thead very useful.

6pm deadline.

Desmond WW · 18-09-2018 03:13PM

Riona WW wrote: »

All this and he votes Clodagh . Clear as mud Dessie . .

Clodagh was my best guess at wolf. I think it still is.

Riona WW · 18-09-2018 03:14PM

Clodagh WW wrote: »

1. You see another reason I'm suspicious of you is how insanely defensive you're being. What are you trying to hide?
I felt you weren't being clear and I said you aren't. Now you're trying to make that out as me spreading misinformation?

2. My biggest issue is that you are advocating the vig to come out after he's used his bullets, despite you not actually knowing whether he just gets one heal or has more. You seem to have a very clear idea on how the vig's powers work.

3. I find it very strange that you have such an unshakeable view of how Watson's powers work, despite having no evidence.

4. At the very least, to me, those posts read as you encouraging the vig to hurry up and use those shots so they can get themselves offed too.

It's entirely possible I'm tunnelled, but your super defensive reaction doesn't sit right with me.

1. Ive answered all your questions . . What am I hiding ? You are making ridiculously vague accusations all of which I have extensively responded to . . I don't speak Trump so actually haven't a clue what you are going on about here. .

2. You even quoted my own post that clarifies it explicitly

Riona WW wrote: »

Whether its somebody in hospital or a person killed surely he should reveal himself directly after he has used his last power ? He is an NRV once hes used 2 bullets and a heal . . It means he has also cleared one village . .

I don't know what powers he has but I clearly say "after he has used his last power"

3. See above, where did I presume to know Watsons powers ?

4. See above . . WTF are you on about ? How am I looking for Watson to be offed ? I said come out when he has used ALL his powers at which stage he is effetivey an NRV but a cleared NRV for the village . .

I cant wrap my head around your thinking on this and I cant respond specifically to your points any clearer . . Why do you call it defensive ? You are using this as a motive to cast shade on me, what do you think I should do ? Say nothing and let your narrative play out ?

Gabriel WW · 18-09-2018 03:14PM

Desmond WW wrote:

Clodagh was my best guess at wolf. I think it still is.

Spoiler; I'm inclined to agree.

Desmond WW · 18-09-2018 03:14PM

Also, I clearly named clodagh in the CYAN slot of my #FFA1

Riona WW · 18-09-2018 03:15PM

Desmond WW wrote: »

Clodagh was my best guess at wolf. I think it still is.

Maybe Dessie . . Maybe . .

Barbara WW · 18-09-2018 03:17PM

Ok, this is Derrys sequence. Looks fairly legit tbh. Nigel tag is fluffy but it is first lynch. Apart from that there’s a pretty consistent path to his vote and after

Derry WW wrote: »

I think the priority should be the lynch, and people firing off clues secondly, not trying to take away from discussions of lynches. Even if just for the next hour or two, till we get the lynch half-sorted.

Tentative #FFA1

1. Wendy - I can buy the notion the bottles would be named, and that she could work out the names were chosen by the wolf in question. I really worry about the fact she was "told" the wolves can't use that power again cause she survived though. That feels a bit off.

2. Nigel - As outlined today, my initial reads when I went back over yesterday was that Nigel's contributions were suspicious. I outlined those thoughts earlier.

3.

I'm bouncing on a few names; Katie for playing the "me not paying full attention" card, Wini just railroading for a Desmond lynch....I'm not sure on the third yet.

We know the SK feels the urge to brag about his kill though, right? Has anyone "targeted" Frank today?

Derry WW wrote: »

I've not voted yet. I really don't know what way to go.
Anyone wanna make a final pitch to me.

Derry WW wrote: »

I've voted Katie in the end.

Their behaviour has been really weird tonight. All over the place.

It's not a strong accusation, but it's them or Wendy right now, and I'm not sure enough about the holes in Wendy's story.

Derry WW wrote: »

On this.

My FFA had two names as 1 and 2, and for my 3, I gave two more names. Katie was one of those names. I went with her cause after my FFA, her behaviour was erratic. But I'm fairly certain I did reference her at the time of my FFA

Oh Matron

Eva WW · 18-09-2018 03:24PM

Morning all.

Bit more free today so will have an actual FFA with reasoning on the way soon.

Barbara WW · 18-09-2018 03:29PM

Desmond WW wrote: »

Clodagh was my best guess at wolf. I think it still is.

Why?

What stood out about her to pair her with gab last night?

What if anything has influenced you since your ffa?

Desmond WW · 18-09-2018 03:34PM

Barbara WW wrote: »

Why?

What stood out about her to pair her with gab last night?

What if anything has influenced you since your ffa?

anti-paired, not paired.

Gabriel WW · 18-09-2018 03:34PM

Barbara WW wrote:

What stood out about her to pair her with gab last night?

Why are you not reading the thread properly?

Brendan WW · 18-09-2018 03:35PM

FFA:

Eva - currently on 11 posts which on day 2 is near the bare minimum required, seems to be trying to coast through with little effort

Doris - even though she has a good few posts they are all very short and have no substance. Also the way she asked if Frank was ok and then he dies - strange that out of the four of us in hospital she chooses to check on the one who subsequently dies?

Wini - she seems to be all over the place, could be a ploy to have people just dismiss her and focus elsewhere.

Barbara WW · 18-09-2018 03:36PM

Desmond WW wrote: »

anti-paired, not paired.

Whichever

Why?

Barbara WW · 18-09-2018 03:37PM

Gabriel WW wrote: »

Why are you not reading the thread properly?

I am reading the thread properly. But I’m not seeing what you’re seeing. Wagonomics says clodagh shouldn’t be a wolf

Barbara WW · 18-09-2018 03:39PM

Barbara WW wrote: »

I am reading the thread properly. But I’m not seeing what you’re seeing. Wagonomics says clodagh shouldn’t be a wolf

Assuming vig shot right, tegans a wolf who voted for clodagh in a chaotic lynch. Tegan was so wishy washy that I think she had to be a wolf. If she is that vote makes no sense

Desmond WW · 18-09-2018 03:42PM

Barbara WW wrote: »

Whichever

Definitely anit-paired.
And to expand on that, "In my opinion, its unlikely that gabriel & clodagh are on the same team.

Why?

Why not? What is your opinions on the pair of them?

Desmond WW · 18-09-2018 03:45PM

Barbara WW wrote: »

I am reading the thread properly. But I’m not seeing what you’re seeing. Wagonomics says clodagh shouldn’t be a wolf

Heh, Can you expand on that for us morons who don't understand how you are getting to there.

Riona WW · 18-09-2018 03:45PM

Barbara WW wrote: »

I am reading the thread properly. But I’m not seeing what you’re seeing. Wagonomics says clodagh shouldn’t be a wolf

If I was frantic Phil I would jump all over Clodagh . . . .

I would hate if the wolves thought I was going to be their go to wrecking ball . . :pac:

That's just me wearing my tin foil hat Dessie . .

Riona WW · 18-09-2018 03:46PM

Desmond WW wrote: »

Heh, Can you expand on that for us morons who don't understand how you are getting to there.

I don't get that either, was just dieing to use that Gif for you Dessie . .

Orla WW · 18-09-2018 03:48PM

Riona WW wrote: »

If I was frantic Phil I would jump all over Clodagh . . . .

I would hate if the wolves thought I was going to be their go to wrecking ball . . :pac:

That's just me wearing my tin foil hat Dessie . .

Abigail WW · 18-09-2018 03:48PM

Eva WW wrote: »

Morning all.

Bit more free today so will have an actual FFA with reasoning on the way soon.

late night? after 3pm isn't Morning Eva, but your probably not here anyway

hope you do post an FFA though we def need more of them today

Sherlock - A game of Werewolf!

Comments