Newstalk Megathread 22/08/16 to date

Mr Snow · 04-01-2018 06:22PM

Will Jessica Kelly be still on the Pat Kenny show

Tell me how · 04-01-2018 06:27PM

Mr Snow wrote: »

Will Jessica Kelly be still on the Pat Kenny show

I'd imagine so. I suspect that her show will be recorded midweek and broadcast at the weekend.

evolving_doors · 04-01-2018 06:49PM

Guess who's back this Saturday?
https://m.independent.ie/entertainment/radio/george-hook-returns-to-newstalk-with-new-weekend-slot-36459043.html

tototoe · 04-01-2018 06:50PM

evolving_doors wrote: »

Guess who's back this Saturday?
https://m.independent.ie/entertainment/radio/george-hook-returns-to-newstalk-with-new-weekend-slot-36459043.html

Thankfuly at a time I won't ever have to hear him.

ghostdancer · 04-01-2018 11:09PM

good changes there.
Cuddihy deserves a full-time gig, and I've been impressed with Andrea Gilligan when she's been covering recently. Jess Kelly knows her tech stuff well and with the TED radio hour now in the Global Village slot, there's no issues with scrapping the Sunday one.
Hook getting 2hrs with regular travel/music/US politics items should keep the show fairly tight and interesting, rather than the rambling shambles of High Noon.

vince · 05-01-2018 12:51PM

Great to hear George Hook in good form on Redfm just now. Catch it later on neil prenderville pod cast. It will be 30 mins from end aprox.

artvanderlay · 05-01-2018 01:15PM

Is this Ciara Kelly on Newstalk arguing with a vegan on Newstalk??? My god, what a repugnant, toxic, sociopathic c*nt! Go on Sandra give it to the toxic b*tch! How is she a radio presenter...my God. She should be kicked off the show...disgraceful behaviour for a host. She is a nasty piece of work.

Odyssey 2005 · 05-01-2018 01:18PM

Thoroughly dislike Kelly,however I'm in her corner on this one. This vegan is a nutter,threatening to hang up and chickening out when told to.

artvanderlay · 05-01-2018 01:19PM

Well done Sandra Higgins. Not a vegan myself, but that was atrocious smug behaviour by a host. Sandra ran rings around her, and Ciara exposed herself as an ignorant, stupid nasty piece of work. What a bunch of arseholes on Newstalk. They are so paranoid against vegans!

artvanderlay · 05-01-2018 01:24PM

I think she was threatening to hang up because of the snide ridiculous arguments from Kelly. She asked what was the point of bringing her on the show if that's all she was going to do. When she said I'm a psychologist, and Ciara goes "are ya?"....she needs a slap! Jesus, I only listened to Newstalk for an hour today for the first time in a long time...is this really the standard of show? It's like American right wing radio...just sociopathic nutters, that don't want to engage or challenge their own ideas of the world. That's me done with Newstalk again!

ButtersSuki · 05-01-2018 01:27PM

Ah, don’t you know you can’t criticise Dr. Ciara Kelly? She knows everything about everything.

sightband · 05-01-2018 01:28PM

artvanderlay wrote: »

Is this Ciara Kelly on Newstalk arguing with a vegan on Newstalk??? My god, what a repugnant, toxic, sociopathic c*nt! Go on Sandra give it to the toxic b*tch! How is she a radio presenter...my God. She should be kicked off the show...disgraceful behaviour for a host. She is a nasty piece of work.

eh? wouldn't be a big fan of Ciara's but I thought she was a lot more composed, put forth a logical coherent argument for those that eat meat. The vegan on the other hand seemed to just lose the plot and make some pretty ridiculous comparisons. just to add as a by the way, I have no issues with vegans and respect and admire their commitment and compassion towards all animals...I'm just not one of them.

artvanderlay · 05-01-2018 01:29PM

She's a doctor? Good God. Although she is on talk radio, so she's probably a doctor in the same way that Gillian McKeith is a dietician, or Katie Hopkins is a human being!

artvanderlay · 05-01-2018 01:32PM

Sandra tried to stay on point before all these ridiculous interrupting comments from Ciara. I just thought Ciara was very rude. If Sandra was making ridiculous points, then let her talk and then present your own views. Don't keep interrupting and trolling her!

Jamiekelly · 05-01-2018 01:33PM

Love hearing Vegans lose their marbles and act like children. Quality entertainment. Well done Doc.

constitutionus · 05-01-2018 01:43PM

i like cuddihy but got help him going up against marion !

Birneybau · 05-01-2018 02:02PM

artvanderlay wrote: »

She's a doctor? Good God. Although she is on talk radio, so she's probably a doctor in the same way that Gillian McKeith is a dietician, or Katie Hopkins is a human being!

No, she was (until recently) an actual GP. I don't mind her most of the time but fcuk Ian O'Doherty. Rent-a-gob.

ButtersSuki · 05-01-2018 02:36PM

artvanderlay wrote: »

She's a doctor? Good God. Although she is on talk radio, so she's probably a doctor in the same way that Gillian McKeith is a dietician, or Katie Hopkins is a human being!

She used to introduce herself as "DOCTOR Ciara Kelly" all the time with major emphasis on the "DOCTOR". She's a GP - the lowest of the low in the doctor hierarchy. I worked in a very specialist field in pharma for a number of years and you should hear the things hospital consultants say about GPs. The highest level of medical consultant specialists don't refer to themselves or introduce themselves as "Dr." Its use as she used it suggested both a massive superiority and inferiority complex - situation dependent.

When she started her own show the "DOCTOR" was dropped. I posted on this at the time that I suspect she was encouraged/forced to drop it by Newstalk as she was coming across as very aloof. She comes across as an incredibly smug know it all. To paraphrase Ben Stiller in Dodgeball "I'm better than you, and I know it" could be her catchphrase such is her own lofty opinion of herself - at least this is how she comes across.

No matter what the topic she seems to know more about it than her guest, which begs the question as to why have any guests on at all.

JPCN1 · 05-01-2018 02:40PM

Tell me how wrote: »

Chris O'Donoghue cannot catch a break.

Announced last week he was leaving Newstalk to join Simon Coveney and now this Francis Fitzgerald mess is blowing up.

He'll remember 2017 for a while.

He doesn't deserve one.

Tell me how · 05-01-2018 02:42PM

ButtersSuki wrote:

She's a GP - the lowest of the low in the doctor hierarchy. I worked in a very specialist field in pharma for a number of years and you should hear the things hospital consultants say about GPs.

The lowest of the low.... SMH.

ButtersSuki · 05-01-2018 04:46PM

Tell me how wrote: »

The lowest of the low.... SMH.

What are you shaking your head at? I qualified the statement by further adding “within the Doctor hierarchy”, which it is - or are you going to try and state otherwise? I did not say she is the lowest of the low as it appears you’re trying to imply.

Cop on.

DEFTLEFTHAND · 05-01-2018 05:27PM

How does she find time to host a 5 day a week radio show and fulfill her GP commitments.

Most GPs I know are run off their feet.

ButtersSuki · 05-01-2018 05:29PM

DEFTLEFTHAND wrote: »

How does she find time to host a 5 day a week radio show and fulfill her GP commitments.

Most GPs I know are run off their feet.

She's not practicing anymore since her media career took off, or at least she's significantly reduced her hours. She has a locum in covering her hours.

ghostdancer · 06-01-2018 10:13AM

Hook's show seems to be pre-recorded.

webcam turned off on the website, no reference to who the 9am newsreader was, or a thanks after (and the webcam was on for them), and for some reason after George said that the first half was over (at 8:55am) and they'd take news and sport, Imagine Dragon's song "Believer" played for a few minutes before going to the news, which seems like they finished up recording a few minutes early and had to fill some time, so a producer plonked a song in there to take them up to 9am.

jimmyw · 06-01-2018 12:48PM

George used to have a show similar to this before.

It could well be pre recorded, maybe the "snowflakes" that are newstalk are afraid that Georgey boy might say something deemed not PC enough for them and they can delete it.

You notice no texts on the show? I would have preferred the interaction between Micky Graham and Georgy, instead of him being allowed to say his piece uncombured.

By the way, I wonder did new Georgys slot make Ciaras weekend show to be scrapped I wonder?

Vorenus400 · 06-01-2018 03:45PM

jimmyw wrote: »

George used to have a show similar to this before.

It could well be pre recorded, maybe the "snowflakes" that are newstalk are afraid that Georgey boy might say something deemed not PC enough for them and they can delete it.

You notice no texts on the show? I would have preferred the interaction between Micky Graham and Georgy, instead of him being allowed to say his piece uncombured.

By the way, I wonder did new Georgys slot make Ciaras weekend show to be scrapped I wonder?

I couldnt see George getting up at the weekend to do an early show. It seems like everyone kicked off the weekeday shows is given an early weekend slot till they move on

sightband · 06-01-2018 05:54PM

ghostdancer wrote: »

Hook's show seems to be pre-recorded.

webcam turned off on the website, no reference to who the 9am newsreader was, or a thanks after (and the webcam was on for them), and for some reason after George said that the first half was over (at 8:55am) and they'd take news and sport, Imagine Dragon's song "Believer" played for a few minutes before going to the news, which seems like they finished up recording a few minutes early and had to fill some time, so a producer plonked a song in there to take them up to 9am.

is there not an obligation on a broadcaster to let listeners know that a show is pre recorded according to BAI standards? you hear it quite often that they mention it is pre recorded and not to text, even if it was prerecorded and hook never mentioned the text number you would still get a fair few people texting assuming it was live and that would be totally unethical.

I’m just surmising and being honest, i have absolutely no interest in reading the BAI code of conduct and standards to find out.

ghostdancer · 23-01-2018 10:09AM

very impressed with Kieran Cuddihy's show the last two Sundays. good mix of topics, and presented very well.
hopefully he'll get a full-time weekday gig soon.

Tell me how · 23-01-2018 10:19AM

ghostdancer wrote:

very impressed with Kieran Cuddihy's show the last two Sundays. good mix of topics, and presented very well. hopefully he'll get a full-time weekday gig soon.

He was that good when presenting before the recent shakeup.
I don't see room for him on the current daily schedule, not sure how suitable he would be for breakfast...
Himself and Shane Coleman would be too similar if working together I think.

Jess Kelly show had interesting guest in VP of Ticketmaster on Sunday. She's well able host as well as contribute.

ghostdancer · 23-01-2018 06:24PM

I missed her this Sunday gone, but caught the first half of the previous week, and agree, she had no problems hosting her own show. she was always very good as a contributor to the other shows.

Newstalk Megathread 22/08/16 to date

Comments