Ireland Team Talk/Gossip/Rumour Thread VIII - MOD NOTE POST #4781

Burkie1203 · 12-11-2017 12:25AM

MJohnston wrote: »

Kearney was certainly showing plenty of rust, but it must have been immensely helpful for Stockdale and Conway knowing that they had someone reliable behind them for support. I think we saw the inevitable result of that. Rating players purely on their individual impacts is always a losing game.

I cant remember conway or stockdale being turned by SA kicks from deep. We always seemed to have someone in the right position.

Kearney was solid. Nothing more nothing less. But if Conway, Stockdale and Sweetnam were to shine, we needed that. The starting wingers grew into the game so much that Sweetnam replaced RK.

MJohnston · 12-11-2017 12:27AM

prawnsambo wrote: »

Well the kick from the try line to find touch on half way was a peach of a highlight. Completely knocked the stuffing out of Bok pressure. And clearly was picked out by Murray to do exactly that. Maybe some 'fans' don't like him, but his team mates know what he can do.

Yes, that was a great moment, but he can still have those in a rusty enough game. I wouldn't have picked anyone else, given the rest of our backline.

Burkie1203 · 12-11-2017 12:29AM

irishman86 wrote: »

He missed a simple ball has been pointed out, he did nothing going forward of the back three he offered the least for

So he misjudged a bouncing rugby ball. Henshaw dropped a pass under zero pressure. Others had knock ons etc. Your micro analysis is ridiculous. Nobody has said he was brilliant or played a perfect game. But he did exactly what the coach expected of him. He helped set a platform off which others shone. Job done

The Rape of Lucretia · 12-11-2017 12:30AM

The two kicks he caught in the same period somewhere in the middle of the second half where he just strolled to position as if he was just fielding practice kicks in a pre-game warm up, showed his total mastery of positioning and a cool head, suggesting a contemptuous 'lads, is that the best you got ? I could mop these up in my sleep' attitude, that must be so demoralising to the team then kicked them to him. These kind of things have a big impact on the mood and momentum of a game.

12-11-2017 12:41AM

Wasting your time chaps, they won’t accept your viewpoint no matter what you say. They’ll only be happy when RK isn’t at 15 and either SZ or ToH is there in his place end of.

connachta · 12-11-2017 12:45AM

stats might be lies. But look at them. No clean breaks, no tackles made, very few meters gained.
Your only argument is "he did nothing great but nothing bad either".. That's not triggering consequences when the team is dominant, I agree with you all. It will trigger some against better teams

prawnsambo · 12-11-2017 12:49AM

connachta wrote: »

stats might be lies. But look at them. No clean breaks, no tackles made, very few meters gained.
Your only argument is "he did nothing great but nothing bad either".. That's not triggering consequences when the team is dominant, I agree with you all. It will trigger some against better teams

Stats aren't liars. People who use them can be.

Clegg · 12-11-2017 12:50AM

I wish we'd stop nitpicking the performances of players and instead praise them.

I thought Ruddock was excellent when he came on. He's always been a horse in contact, someone who relishes the physical game, but he put a bit of footwork in to beat that South African defender for his try. I thought he was unlucky to not make the starting side and he laid down a marker tonight. We've got players getting better and better before our eyes. It's brilliant.

molloyjh · 12-11-2017 12:54AM

Jesus, we comfortably beat SA with an inexperienced back line, a fair bit of rustiness and having never gotten out of third gear really. And we beat them very convincingly. You’d think people might actually be, I don’t know, happy about that. Why do some people feel the need to moan incessantly in the face of a positive performance and result!?

stephen_n · 12-11-2017 12:57AM

molloyjh wrote: »

Jesus, we comfortably beat SA with an inexperienced back line, a fair bit of rustiness and having never gotten out of third gear really. And we beat them very convincingly. You’d think people might actually be, I don’t know, happy about that. Why do some people feel the need to moan incessantly in the face of a positive performance and result!?

Have you forgotten what country you live in?

The Irish do have a despairing quality of gaiety, but they have also a dour and brooding ghost that rides on their shoulders and peers in on their thoughts. Let them laugh too loudly, it sticks a long finger down their throats. They condemn themselves before they are charged, and this makes them defensive always.
John Steinbeck

prawnsambo · 12-11-2017 12:58AM

molloyjh wrote: »

Jesus, we comfortably beat SA with an inexperienced back line, a fair bit of rustiness and having never gotten out of third gear really. And we beat them very convincingly. You’d think people might actually be, I don’t know, happy about that. Why do some people feel the need to moan incessantly in the face of a positive performance and result!?

It's a scorpion and frog thing.

irishman86 · 12-11-2017 12:59AM

Burkie1203 wrote: »

So he misjudged a bouncing rugby ball. Henshaw dropped a pass under zero pressure. Others had knock ons etc. Your micro analysis is ridiculous. Nobody has said he was brilliant or played a perfect game. But he did exactly what the coach expected of him. He helped set a platform off which others shone. Job done

Actually the original comment i quoted said that, in he was one of the best players. I agree with what your saying. Job done exactly

Burkie1203 · 12-11-2017 01:00AM

connachta wrote: »

stats might be lies. But look at them. No clean breaks, no tackles made, very few meters gained.
Your only argument is "he did nothing great but nothing bad either".. That's not triggering consequences when the team is dominant, I agree with you all. It will trigger some against better teams

My argument is he did exactly what his coach wanted him to do. He executed the gameplan. The gameplan led to a 38-3 win over South Africa. We gave SA nothing. Our back 3 were never caught out of position that i can remember. If you cant see that value and are only interested in negativity then your clearly just being negative for the sake of it

Stats have context too which you will conveniently ignore.

bilston · 12-11-2017 01:01AM

Burkie1203 wrote: »

irishman86 wrote: »

He really wasnt buddy, he looked rusty
Made a few stupid mistakes defo not one of the better performances.
He was possibly the least effective back, lets not hyperbole a performance.
He did his job of adding experience to the back three,
I dont rate Kearney but since Zebo has been kicked to the curb, he was the obvious choice to start

Kearney got pinged for one penalty for holding on and had a few other mistakes .

To be fair to Kearney that looked like it was down to a poor clear out from SOB.

Kearney ran it back a lot tonight. I kept thinking he was going to run into his own players though, but I think that was down to the jerseys.

irishman86 · 12-11-2017 01:01AM

molloyjh wrote: »

Jesus, we comfortably beat SA with an inexperienced back line, a fair bit of rustiness and having never gotten out of third gear really. And we beat them very convincingly. You’d think people might actually be, I don’t know, happy about that. Why do some people feel the need to moan incessantly in the face of a positive performance and result!?

I personally blame sitting through the Denmark game afterwards for my negativity and i apologise but i feel a little dead inside

Hastentoadd · 12-11-2017 01:02AM

Clegg wrote: »

I wish we'd stop nitpicking the performances of players and instead praise them.

I thought Ruddock was excellent when he came on. He's always been a horse in contact, someone who relishes the physical game, but he put a bit of footwork in to beat that South African defender for his try. I thought he was unlucky to not make the starting side and he laid down a marker tonight. We've got players getting better and better before our eyes. It's brilliant.

Agreed Ruddock had a fine game. He has being playing very well for a while now. As for comments on Kearney, he did what Rob does, he played well if not terribly exciting. It was a leap for Joe to start Stockdale and Conway. Now that he has seen what dynamic wingers can do against (arguably poor) Tier 1 opposition maybe he can the benefit of a more attacking back 3 than he is has selected in the past. This was a very good day for Irish rugby. We moved a step in the right direction at last

Burkie1203 · 12-11-2017 01:06AM

bilston wrote: »

To be fair to Kearney that looked like it was down to a poor clear out from SOB.

Kearney ran it back a lot tonight. I kept thinking he was going to run into his own players though, but I think that was down to the jerseys.

Yh there was a poor clearout but it was Louw I think who got a great position over the ball. It happens

thomond2006 · 12-11-2017 01:22AM

connachta wrote: »

stats might be lies. But look at them. No clean breaks, no tackles made, very few meters gained.
Your only argument is "he did nothing great but nothing bad either".. That's not triggering consequences when the team is dominant, I agree with you all. It will trigger some against better teams

At this stage I miss the days Connacht were irrelevant. Reading your never ending whining has made me post this.

The Rape of Lucretia · 12-11-2017 01:40AM

thomond2006 wrote: »

At this stage I miss the days Connacht were irrelevant. Reading your never ending whining has made me post this.

Quiz Q : who and when was the last genuine Connacht player (and lets not get into it, but no, Henchie doesnt count) to be a regular starter for Ireland ?

Clegg · 12-11-2017 01:47AM

When it comes to controlling a game Murray and Sexton are the best in the world. Smith and Barrett may have a slight attacking edge, but if you're looking to exploit an opposition's weakness I'd take our lads every time. We're so lucky the careers of these two overlapped.

MJohnston · 12-11-2017 01:49AM

The Rape of Lucretia wrote: »

Quiz Q : who and when was the last genuine Connacht player (and lets not get into it, but no, Henchie doesnt count) to be a regular starter for Ireland ?

Henshaw counts, don't be such a bore.

Bazzo · 12-11-2017 09:03AM

Can I just point out to everyone that there's no need to have a pop at Connacht just because they disagree with a Connacht supporter? It happens very frequently and it's incredibly juvenile.

connachta · 12-11-2017 11:18AM

The Rape of Lucretia wrote: »

thomond2006 wrote: »

At this stage I miss the days Connacht were irrelevant. Reading your never ending whining has made me post this.

Quiz Q : who and when was the last genuine Connacht player (and lets not get into it, but no, Henchie doesnt count) to be a regular starter for Ireland ?

Henshaw counts. He was Connacht and starter

its_phil · 12-11-2017 12:11PM

thomond2006 wrote: »

At this stage I miss the days Connacht were irrelevant. Reading your never ending whining has made me post this.

Stay classy Thomond.

Like any of the other provinces around here don’t have posters that drag the forum down.

its_phil · 12-11-2017 12:14PM

The Rape of Lucretia wrote: »

Quiz Q : who and when was the last genuine Connacht player (and lets not get into it, but no, Henchie doesnt count) to be a regular starter for Ireland ?

Same number of letters in Henshaw as there is in ‘Henchie’.

Ugh

Buer · 12-11-2017 12:15PM

its_phil wrote:

Same number of letters in Henshaw as there is in â€˜Henchieâ€™.

Good spot, Philster.

irishbucsfan · 12-11-2017 12:17PM

I can't believe it Buernard

Former Former · 12-11-2017 12:21PM

Bazzo wrote: »

Can I just point out to everyone that there's no need to have a pop at Connacht just because they disagree with a Connacht supporter? It happens very frequently and it's incredibly juvenile.

It's not genuine anti - Connacht sentiment, it's just frustration at one particular poster.

If I was on here yesterday saying Aki was rubbish, we should have picked Rory O'Loughlin, would everyone have said, "fair enough" or "that's mental"? And if I kept saying it over and over...

Wegians89 · 12-11-2017 12:48PM

Anyways.......

Great win yesterday and you'd think the next two matches should be won too. I'd like to see a few new combinations tired out over the next two game. Henderson and Ryan starting in second row together is one another would be stockdale and Byrne on the wings, that'd be interesting attaching wise. Don't think we'll see henshaw and bundee together again this series with mccloskary and Farrell swaying in and out. Hope there isn't 15 changes next week I'd be looking for half the team from yesterday to start next week and the other half to start against Argentina .I'd also like to see Carbery and Murray start together and sexton and marmion to start against Argentina. I really do think these next two games is a chance to give Carbery, marmion and McGrath a good bit of game time. We need quality strength in depth in these positions.

connachta · 12-11-2017 12:51PM

Wegians89 wrote: »

Anyways.......

Great win yesterday and you'd think the next two matches should be won too. I'd like to see a few new combinations tired out over the next two game. Henderson and Ryan starting in second row together is one another would be stockdale and Byrne on the wings, that'd be interesting attaching wise. Don't think we'll see henshaw and bundee together again this series with mccloskary and Farrell swaying in and out. Hope there isn't 15 changes next week I'd be looking for half the team from yesterday to start next week and the other half to start against Argentina .I'd also like to see Carbery and Murray start together and sexton and marmion to start against Argentina. I really do think these next two games is a chance to give Carbery, marmion and McGrath a good bit of game time. We need quality strength in depth in these positions.

Argentina, though limited, didn't look bad against a powerful England. We will need our main team, i.e Aki and Murray IMO.

Ireland Team Talk/Gossip/Rumour Thread VIII - ** MOD NOTE POST #4781 **

Comments

Ireland Team Talk/Gossip/Rumour Thread VIII - MOD NOTE POST #4781