Werewolf XVI - Star Trek

The_Valeyard · 04-09-2017 06:13PM

What if the Borg Assimilate Q?

Barney92 · 04-09-2017 06:13PM

My FFA for what it's worth

#FFA1
MicksJaguar - sided with my plan early. I did think that wolves might be the ones to jump on the plan, and Mick seemed to go quite after being questioned on this point. Now he seem to be moving towards arguing for a complete no lynch. By that I mean no lynch and no phasering.

Partyjungle - I don't think they are q but they might be the recruiter. If they last long enough they are doing well and can convert someone. I think pj could be a good choice to peek. If they are good then they are not the recruiter.

Necro (for old times sake). But really it's yosser. As with mick they are going for no lynch. They are going for a different reason than Mick, but nonetheless I don't really like it.

I understand that for two of the above I am suspecting them for partially siding with a plan I came up with.

Necro · 04-09-2017 06:16PM

The_Valeyard wrote: »

What if the Borg Assimilate Q?

He becomes a Borg and loses his own side game. It's actually a decent result for the village if that were to happen

Necro · 04-09-2017 06:17PM

Barney92 wrote: »

My FFA for what it's worth

#FFA1
MicksJaguar - sided with my plan early. I did think that wolves might be the ones to jump on the plan, and Mick seemed to go quite after being questioned on this point. Now he seem to be moving towards arguing for a complete no lynch. By that I mean no lynch and no phasering.

Partyjungle - I don't think they are q but they might be the recruiter. If they last long enough they are doing well and can convert someone. I think pj could be a good choice to peek. If they are good then they are not the recruiter.

Necro (for old times sake). But really it's yosser. As with mick they are going for no lynch. They are going for a different reason than Mick, but nonetheless I don't really like it.

I understand that for two of the above I am suspecting them for partially siding with a plan I came up with.

I got really mad there for like a couple of seconds until I read the rest:o:o:o:o:o:o

Drumpot · 04-09-2017 06:18PM

Guys, I have voted "No Lynch" just for the moment because I am not sure who I suspect and got in real trouble before, in my dreams, when I missed a vote in an imaginary universe. Would rather accidently vote for no lynch, then miss a vote.

But I intend on choosing a target closer to the vote. .

quickbeam · 04-09-2017 06:18PM

Necrominus wrote: »

He becomes a Borg and loses his own side game. It's actually a decent result for the village if that were to happen

Except that the wolves become 6. But if somebody has to be recruited, Q would be better for us than otherwise.

quickbeam · 04-09-2017 06:20PM

#FFA1

PJ - initially took his "I am Q" as a joke, but his subsequent posts have been weird, eg, his reply to Keith about being the only one to comment about it (post 314) - like, what was he hoping to achieve by the claim? And his saying he'll vote for himself (post 681). He also may have outed a potentially roled player, which at the very least is a silly move.

Trit - because it's about time he was a baddie!!!

Plus his good list seemed a bit contrived, especially for the inclusion of some people that I'd have as neutral at best at this early stage. On the other hand, he's been quite vocal about voting for lynch instead of no-lynch which would edge him slightly back to the good side.

Mick - jumped on Barney's (IMO horrible idea) of a no-vote, and is one of the most prominent advocates of it still even after Barney has rejected the idea.

Currently leaning towards Mick out of the three.

Necro · 04-09-2017 06:20PM

quickbeam wrote: »

Except that the wolves become 6. But if somebody has to be recruited, Q would be better for us than otherwise.

Yeah, but at least it's not a negative number on the village side. Hopefully we can find the recruiter though.

I agree yoss would be a decent shout for a peek tbh. I'd also advocate peeking PJ or Vale right now.

sKeith · 04-09-2017 06:21PM

#ffa1

mick - mick is usually good with numbers and his no lynch agenda does not make sense. if we have 10 shots at killing a wolf 6 lynches and 4 bullets, why waste a shot.

Necro · 04-09-2017 06:21PM

Necrominus wrote: »

Yeah, but at least it's not a negative number on the village side. Hopefully we can find the recruiter though.

I agree yoss would be a decent shout for a peek tbh. I'd also advocate peeking PJ or Vale right now.

That should read - PJ being the good choice for a peek. Then Yosser or Vale

sKeith · 04-09-2017 06:22PM

well the start of it anyway. pfft..

The_Valeyard · 04-09-2017 06:24PM

Necrominus wrote: »

Yeah, but at least it's not a negative number on the village side. Hopefully we can find the recruiter though.

I agree yoss would be a decent shout for a peek tbh. I'd also advocate peeking PJ or Vale right now.

Peek at me, but dont reveal this early in game who the seer is.

The_Valeyard · 04-09-2017 06:25PM

Also Necro happy memeng and very active play has me mildly suspecious at present. But there are one or two others I am currently Sussing out first.

Kolido · 04-09-2017 06:25PM

Necrominus wrote: »

That should read - PJ being the good choice for a peek. Then Yosser or Vale

I'm thinking vale is q, but those are decent shouts for a peak.

Necro · 04-09-2017 06:25PM

The_Valeyard wrote: »

Peek at me, but dont reveal this early in game who the seer is.

Agreed. Although if the recruiter is pinged it MIGHT be worth the sacrifice. We should still get one night more night out of them if the BG is on point.

Necro · 04-09-2017 06:28PM

The_Valeyard wrote: »

Also Necro happy memeng and very active play has me mildly suspecious at present. But there are one or two others I am currently Sussing out first.

Welcome to the 'I hate Necro' club, buddy. Sit down, take a seat. This is a growing phenomenon in the world of WW apparently:D:D:D

You can even be President although you might have to fight PatrickSTARR for that honour right now

sKeith · 04-09-2017 06:30PM

#ffa1.2

kollido - moving more back into netural position than the leaning wolf that I had him earlier

grumpy - wolves don't need to read the thread to play, villagers will reread the whole thread 3 or 4 times before the game is over.

Jayop · 04-09-2017 06:31PM

The problem with no lynch voting is that if it doesn't have the numbers to pass then it'll hurt the village. The Wolves all vote for people and its pretty much a free kill for them.

Lord TSC · 04-09-2017 06:32PM

Right, I'm keeping my FFA at two for now. Both of whom I've mentioned over the day but they are...

FFA

PJ - Claimed Q, has avoided answering why all day, and also another reason that I'd rather not draw attention to at this moment....

Mick - Seemed eager when barney suggested the no vote option, vanished the second (literally) he was called out on it, returned today to push a decision that, to me, does little but give wolves a two kill head start instead of one. Has vanished again when the heat is on.

I'd be leaning more towards Mick as Q; his disappearing act makes me feel he wants some heat but not too much.

Necro · 04-09-2017 06:34PM

Anyone collaborating the FFAs? How we looking?? Also there's a few to do them yet...

Guffy · 04-09-2017 06:35PM

I think not lynching is a no go. Its been said before but how do we kill wolves if we dont lynch?

I think we need to stop getting hung up on Q. Imo we should look at it as a 1A/1B prize. If we lynch q tonight ya he wins but who cares. Its still us v the wolves to the end.

Ffa

PJ- not only has he not allieviated my concerns over the maha issue he hasn't even addressed them.

Mick- constantly pushing the no vote. I had cooled on him earlier as i thought i saw something in his posts but tbh the only ones a no vote serves are the wolves.

Grumpy- im struggling to get a nailed on third tbf. Grumpy's only post i can see to date is essentially hi, not arsed reading back bye. What use are you then?

y0ssar1an22 · 04-09-2017 06:35PM

Jayop wrote: »

The problem with no lynch voting is that if it doesn't have the numbers to pass then it'll hurt the village. The Wolves all vote for people and its pretty much a free kill for them.

that could potentially give more data for some post vote data analysis

Necro · 04-09-2017 06:36PM

Jayop wrote: »

The problem with no lynch voting is that if it doesn't have the numbers to pass then it'll hurt the village. The Wolves all vote for people and its pretty much a free kill for them.

Looks like we'll be voting to lynch someone alright. Any further thoughts or suspicions to add yourself??

Digital Solitude · 04-09-2017 06:41PM

beakerjoe wrote: »

I don't like posters putting other posters in a "probably good pile". It can affect others judgment while you have no reason to think so many or good on day 1.

If you are a wolf, its can be a few things

1. You are a wolf trying to keep another wolf clear of suspicion.

2. Your a wolf trying to cosy up to other village posters using the "I think your good, so therefore I am good" approach."

Your reasoning for voting for me is weak. I curious. I like to see others theories and elaborate on them and discuss them. Reactions to said posts can be fasinating and tell you a lot about a poster and where I may think their alligence lie.

Now your not the only one to do this, but I find it odd at day 1 to assume some are good.

I'm not assuming anyone as good, I'm giving my reads so far. That was why I chose misinterpreting. I have no

Its N1, no one has much to go on.

I take your point about following up to see reactions, I'm trying to do the same.

The_Valeyard · 04-09-2017 06:42PM

Lord TSC wrote: »

Right, I'm keeping my FFA at two for now. Both of whom I've mentioned over the day but they are...

FFA

PJ - Claimed Q, has avoided answering why all day, and also another reason that I'd rather not draw attention to at this moment....

Mick - Seemed eager when barney suggested the no vote option, vanished the second (literally) he was called out on it, returned today to push a decision that, to me, does little but give wolves a two kill head start instead of one. Has vanished again when the heat is on.

I'd be leaning more towards Mick as Q; his disappearing act makes me feel he wants some heat but not too much.

Disappearing act? Very Q like.

quickbeam · 04-09-2017 06:43PM

Guffy wrote: »

PJ- not only has he not allieviated my concerns over the maha issue he hasn't even addressed them.

What's the Maha issue again? Sorry if already explained.

sullivlo · 04-09-2017 06:43PM

FFA

Mick
Pj
Necro

Mick because he's trying to stop the village lynching. PJ because he claimed Q. Necro because I'm finding it hard to keep up with this thread and it might be nice for you to keep Robyn company in the dead room.

Lord TSC · 04-09-2017 06:44PM

The_Valeyard wrote: »

Disappearing act? Very Q like.

Necro · 04-09-2017 06:44PM

quickbeam wrote: »

What's the Maha issue again? Sorry if already explained.

PJ saw Mahama as suss but then rolled back on it when he appeared on her good list. That's the crux of it anywho

The_Valeyard · 04-09-2017 06:45PM

Lord TSC wrote: »

You are improving.

I must promote you to Commander.

Werewolf XVI - Star Trek

Comments