Pieta House reject fundraising money from hunt

24-12-2016 08:26AM

tomwaterford wrote: »

As someone who has sheep and has no bother killing foxes. ...it's cruel as fcuk....they literally eat the fox alive

Again, no expert...but didn't think the hounds ate the fox at all? I would have thought they'd bite it, and given the relative size and number of hounds to fox it'd be reasonably quick...but the dogs would be trained not to eat the fox?

tomwaterford · 24-12-2016 08:35AM

[Deleted User] wrote: »

Again, no expert...but didn't think the hounds ate the fox at all? I would have thought they'd bite it, and given the relative size and number of hounds to fox it'd be reasonably quick...but the dogs would be trained not to eat the fox?

Nope....they have no kill instinct...like a terrier will choke a fox...but foxhounds won't. ...it's an unspoken about thing....even by those that partake in foxhunting

They literally eat it alive....That's why there is relatively few call to vets etc from kennels where the dogs are kept

A horrible sport,which I am somewhat amazed so many farmers partake in....how could you support doing that to an animal, and go home and look after your own?

24-12-2016 08:44AM

tomwaterford wrote: »

A horrible sport,which I am somewhat amazed so many farmers partake in....how could you support doing that to an animal, and go home and look after your own?

Hands up, don't know anyone who hunts, not a big sport in South Kerry.

Know plenty of farmers, and know 2 fellows who shoot foxes as a job (which afaik racks up far more kills and injuries) and guess they'd shrug their shoulders and say life in the country for animals can be nasty, brutish and short. The socio economic status of the hunter isn't much interest to the fox!

Outlaw Pete · 24-12-2016 08:56AM

Hope the Chistmas dinners they'll be putting on will only contain turkey & ham from non-intensively raised turkeys and pigs.

Socially acceptable animal cruelty is just as abhorrent as the cruelty against the animals it's fashionable to care about.

Merry Christmas!

tomwaterford · 24-12-2016 08:59AM

[Deleted User] wrote: »

Hands up, don't know anyone who hunts, not a big sport in South Kerry.

Know plenty of farmers, and know 2 fellows who shoot foxes as a job (which afaik racks up far more kills and injuries) and guess they'd shrug their shoulders and say life in the country for animals can be nasty, brutish and short. The socio economic status of the hunter isn't much interest to the fox!

I've no problem shooting them (and dogs) to stop them Attacking sheep/killing lambs....but I'll be fcuked if I'll partake in cruelty and would seriously lower my opinion of people who do

PucaMama · 24-12-2016 10:21AM

fatknacker wrote: »

Harriers are hare hunters though, no?

Only greyhounds or lurchers or similar are for hares because of their speed

PucaMama · 24-12-2016 10:22AM

[Deleted User] wrote: »

Again, no expert...but didn't think the hounds ate the fox at all? I would have thought they'd bite it, and given the relative size and number of hounds to fox it'd be reasonably quick...but the dogs would be trained not to eat the fox?

They don't eat it they rip it to pieces.

PucaMama · 24-12-2016 10:23AM

bogwalrus wrote: »

In 2014 the locals did a charity hunt near me. They killed 150 foxes, pups included. They raised 500 for a local hospice. So 150 dead foxes killed for fun = 500 Euro. Let that sink in.

Is it supposed to be acceptable because they donated to charity

1eg0a3xv7b82of · 24-12-2016 10:44AM

If pieta accepted that money they would be aiding in the normalisation of a vicious past time.
There is nothing normal about people on horses getting enjoyment from chasing a Fox to its death.
Harming animals for fun is a proven Sign of a sociopath.

Nekarsulm · 24-12-2016 10:46AM

bogwalrus wrote: »

In 2014 the locals did a charity hunt near me. They killed 150 foxes, pups included. They raised 500 for a local hospice. So 150 dead foxes killed for fun = 500 Euro. Let that sink in.

:rolleyes:
150? I simply don't believe that figure. Five or six would be a serious result. Including cubs? Total nonsense.

I don't suppose you would know the name of the hunt involved?

Nekarsulm · 25-12-2016 02:41AM

bogwalrus wrote: »

In 2014 the locals did a charity hunt near me. They killed 150 foxes, pups included. They raised 500 for a local hospice. So 150 dead foxes killed for fun = 500 Euro. Let that sink in.

Come on Bog, if they are a local hunt to you, you know them, tell us who they are.
Provide proof of the slaughter of 150 foxes on a charity hunt, and I will donate €150 to Pieta House.
If you cannot, you donate €150.
Win Win situation for Pieta.

Ball is in your court.

Irish Guitarist · 25-12-2016 08:30AM

I've often taken a walk by the River Barrow and it really helped my depression. However when the fuckers from the gun clubs (there's at least two of them between Carlow and Athy) are out shooting every animal and bird in sight it depresses me further.

I don't think you can compare suicide prevention to homelessness. If you're hungry you might do anything or take anyones money to survive. If you're suicidal it may well be because of all the misery in the world, and the fact that there are assholes that shoot everything in sight could well be part of that misery. I can see why a suicide charity might have second thoughts about being associated with guns too.

25-12-2016 08:51AM

Irish Guitarist wrote: »

I've often taken a walk by the River Barrow and it really helped my depression. However when the fuckers from the gun clubs (there's at least two of them between Carlow and Athy) are out shooting every animal and bird in sight it depresses me further.

I don't think you can compare suicide prevention to homelessness. If you're hungry you might do anything or take anyones money to survive. If you're suicidal it may well be because of all the misery in the world, and the fact that there are assholes that shoot everything in sight could well be part of that misery. I can see why a suicide charity might have second thoughts about being associated with guns too.

Um, they don't shoot on horseback, this isn't the Wild West!

It's a hunt, horses, hounds, jackets, crops...

As for the suicide link, that's tenuous to the point of ridiculous.

25-12-2016 08:53AM

Ember Scarce Mind wrote: »

If pieta accepted that money they would be aiding in the normalisation of a vicious past time.
There is nothing normal about people on horses getting enjoyment from chasing a Fox to its death.
Harming animals for fun is a proven Sign of a sociopath.

I won't challenge your expertise in psychology, know a few who hunt in Cork and Limerick...and they are not sociopaths. Do you have any references, studies etc.?

Junkyard Tom · 25-12-2016 09:38AM

Describing these sausage-supper eating animal shooters as 'hunters' does a disservice to creatures who actually have to stalk and kill their prey to survive.

Irish Guitarist · 25-12-2016 10:41AM

Deleted User wrote: »

Um, they don't shoot on horseback, this isn't the Wild West!

It's a hunt, horses, hounds, jackets, crops...

Where did I mention shooting on horseback?

Deleted User wrote: »

As for the suicide link, that's tenuous to the point of ridiculous.

Going for a walk and having the peace and quiet disturbed by a bunch of morons from a gun club is depressing. I don't see what's so ridiculous about suggesting that people need peace and quiet to improve their quality of life.

bogwalrus · 25-12-2016 11:53AM

Nekarsulm wrote: »

Come on Bog, if they are a local hunt to you, you know them, tell us who they are.
Provide proof of the slaughter of 150 foxes on a charity hunt, and I will donate €150 to Pieta House.
If you cannot, you donate €150.
Win Win situation for Pieta.

Ball is in your court.

The area in question is macroom. I believe the proof is in one of the issues of the Lee valley outlook where it mentions 150 foxes killed. I am not sure what year or month exactly. My guess is 2013. It will take me some time to go through the online archive but I will do my best.

It was my neighbour that said it to me but I do remember reading it in the magazine. There was loads of people and dogs involved in the hunt that covered a very large area. That is why such a high number of foxes killed.

They are mad for hunting in my area. Almost every Sunday you hear the dogs running through the fields. You hear guns often as well.

HandsomeDan · 25-12-2016 11:57AM

Hunters are scum. Fair play to Pieta for telling the knackers to shove it.

byhookorbycrook · 25-12-2016 12:01PM

bogwalrus wrote: »

In 2014 the locals did a charity hunt near me. They killed 150 foxes, pups included. They raised 500 for a local hospice. So 150 dead foxes killed for fun = 500 Euro. Let that sink in.

If there are 150 foxes in such a small area that's amazing. Foxes have cubs by the way, not pups. Which hunt pack was this?? Looking forward to actual proof .
Hounds do not " eat foxes alive" or "rip them to pieces " - they kill like other hounds, biting the prey in the neck - instant death.

25-12-2016 12:06PM

Irish Guitarist wrote: »

Where did I mention shooting on horseback?.

This thread is about a hunt. You introduced shooting and gun clubs. It's not relevant.

Irish Guitarist wrote: »

Going for a walk and having the peace and quiet disturbed by a bunch of morons from a gun club is depressing. I don't see what's so ridiculous about suggesting that people need peace and quiet to improve their quality of life.

Shooting is also a hobby, it helps people mix, in fresh air. They are positives.

The idea that it contributes to suicide is a very glib analysis of suicide, wholly unsupported by anything except your imagination.

1eg0a3xv7b82of · 25-12-2016 12:22PM

[Deleted User] wrote: »

I won't challenge your expertise in psychology, know a few who hunt in Cork and Limerick...and they are not sociopaths. Do you have any references, studies etc.?

Are u a Donald?
These people you know hunt a defenceless animal with dogs that eventually tear it to pieces. this is done for fun.
The experts all agree hunting animals for fun is a mental illness an addiction to extreme violence..
Google it and you will find all the studies you require.

25-12-2016 12:25PM

Ember Scarce Mind wrote: »

Are u a Donald?
...
The experts all agree hunting animals for fun is a mental illness an addiction to extreme violence...

Not sure what the first sentence even means. What were you trying to say?

As for your "the experts all agree that this who hunt are sociopaths", utter nonsense and completely made up by you.

Experts all agree that those who pluck nonsense out of thin air should be laughed at.

ebbsy · 25-12-2016 12:29PM

Ember Scarce Mind wrote: »

[Deleted User] wrote: »

I won't challenge your expertise in psychology, know a few who hunt in Cork and Limerick...and they are not sociopaths. Do you have any references, studies etc.?

Are u a Donald?
These people you know hunt a defenceless animal with dogs that eventually tear it to pieces. this is done for fun.
The experts all agree hunting animals for fun is a mental illness an addiction to extreme violence..
Google it and you will find all the studies you require.

Yawn.

Nekarsulm · 25-12-2016 12:51PM

bogwalrus wrote: »

The area in question is macroom. I believe the proof is in one of the issues of the Lee valley outlook where it mentions 150 foxes killed. I am not sure what year or month exactly. My guess is 2013. It will take me some time to go through the online archive but I will do my best.

It was my neighbour that said it to me but I do remember reading it in the magazine. There was loads of people and dogs involved in the hunt that covered a very large area. That is why such a high number of foxes killed.

They are mad for hunting in my area. Almost every Sunday you hear the dogs running through the fields. You hear guns often as well.

That's great.
Your neighbour told you.
Show me proof of a Charity Hunt that killed 150 foxes.
Not over the course of a year, but on a Charity hunt day.
I will donate €150 to Pieta House. Simple as that.

bogwalrus · 25-12-2016 01:00PM

byhookorbycrook wrote: »

If there are 150 foxes in such a small area that's amazing. Foxes have cubs by the way, not pups. Which hunt pack was this?? Looking forward to actual proof .
Hounds do not " eat foxes alive" or "rip them to pieces " - they kill like other hounds, biting the prey in the neck - instant death.

Google macroom hunting festival. It is held annually in Jan that lasts a week and all over macroom. So that is a whole week of hunting. It is the 2014 one that was the one that killed 150 foxes. I found a photo of that meet and they had loads of people on horseback.

I'll get back to you regarding the 150 number but with a hunt that lasts a week and called a festival it is very possible 150 killed would you not agree?

bogwalrus · 25-12-2016 01:05PM

Nekarsulm wrote: »

That's great.
Your neighbour told you.
Show me proof of a Charity Hunt that killed 150 foxes.
Not over the course of a year, but on a Charity hunt day.
I will donate €150 to Pieta House. Simple as that.

If you were on a hunt that killed that many foxes most of the statistics would come from word of mouth. We are rural Ireland. Not everyone uses the internet. The one magazine is the Lee valley that mentions the hunt and has a photo but does not say the 150 number.

This number comes from those that were involved. So the evidence I will bring to the table will be from someone that was involved in the hunt. Somehow I don't think that will be enough evidence for you?

Nekarsulm · 25-12-2016 01:11PM

bogwalrus wrote: »

If you were on a hunt that killed that many foxes most of the statistics would come from word of mouth. We are rural Ireland. Not everyone uses the internet. The one magazine is the Lee valley that mentions the hunt and has a photo but does not say the 150 number.

This number comes from those that were involved. So the evidence I will bring to the table will be from someone that was involved in the hunt. Somehow I don't think that will be enough evidence for you?

Bring it on and we will see.
Master of Foxhounds, Abbeyfeal Harriers, would be a good place to start.

bogwalrus · 25-12-2016 01:30PM

Nekarsulm wrote: »

Bring it on and we will see.
Master of Foxhounds, Abbeyfeal Harriers, would be a good place to start.

So you provisionally agree that a week long hunting festival can kill 150 foxes? I am not going to be contacting individuals about hunting statistics over Xmas so I will come back here with some proof at a later date.

I never like being accused of offering misinformation. My initial post was to mention the charity affiliation with a local charity and that a high number of foxes were killed in one particular event. The 150 number is well known in the area and the number communicated to me by my neighbour who would have no reason to lie.

Of course individuals that took part in the event would like to brag about the success of the event so maybe 150 is inflated. I can see also why publications would not want the actual figure to be promoted as that would reflect poorly on the charity and magazine. Most mentions I discovered are about how successful it was. No mention of how success is measured I.e number of foxes killed, turn out.....

So in due course we will find out how they measured success and hopefully I will have a number for you in the next few days. Merry Xmas!=)

Nekarsulm · 25-12-2016 01:44PM

Super! Look forward to your proof.
Already you are modifying your original statement, no longer was it "a local charity hunt" day, but a week long event , with multiple hunts involved.
However!
Show proof from the organisers, here on this thread, of 150 foxes killed, and I will show proof of my donation to Pieta House of 150 euro.
By this day week?
OK?

25-12-2016 01:51PM

bogwalrus wrote: »

In 2014 the locals did a charity hunt near me. They killed 150 foxes, pups included. They raised 500 for a local hospice. So 150 dead foxes killed for fun = 500 Euro. Let that sink in.

bogwalrus wrote: »

Google macroom hunting festival. It is held annually in Jan that lasts a week and all over macroom. So that is a whole week of hunting.

Ah.

The first post suggests a hunt, you've amended it to a week of hunting at a festival.

Do you think it was a little misleading?

Pieta House reject fundraising money from hunt

Comments