South Park WW ROLE MADNESS - Game Thread

Henry WW · 22-10-2019 11:22am

Winifred WW wrote: »

Oh Henry you've got me right in your pocket there with your replica of my FFA you nasty boy

I figure you're self-resolving Wini old pal, so you're on my buddies list for today!

Kisses.

Barbara WW · 22-10-2019 11:22am

Regans adventures posting outside the WW forum must have broken her!

Tegan WW · 22-10-2019 11:23am

Henry WW wrote: »

Whoever asked for votes:

Sorry, I can't table.

Senan Gabriel Holly Brendan Wendy
Gabriel Oisin Fiona
Liam Ewan Phil
Eva Isla
Regan Frank Orla Clodagh Derry Vernon Angus Barbara Senan
Ewan Winifred
Frank Conor Patrick
Vernon Henry Doris Eva
Angus Emily
Doris Abigail
Derry Regan =Tegan
Fiona Lucy

No Lynch Liam

Didn't vote: Mary

Assuming the wolves knew they were going to pull a manipulator, they could be anywhere so not sure what we can get from this, e.g. Derry was on Regan when he knew it wouldn't matter.

Not sure if relevant but Senan changed his vote to me at last minute too

Patrick WW · 22-10-2019 11:23am

Im going for a stroll through Derrys posts, don't think there was too many so I'll see what I can find.

Lucy goes from clear back to unknown for me now

Tegan WW · 22-10-2019 11:23am

Barbara WW wrote: »

Regans adventures posting outside the WW forum must have broken her!

That'll teach me

I'm never venturing outside again

Senan WW · 22-10-2019 11:24am

Abigail WW
Angus WW
Barbara WW
Brendan WW
Clodagh WW
Conor WW
Derry WW
Desmond WW
Doris WW
Emily WW
Eva WW
Ewan WW
Fiona WW
Frank WW
Gabriel WW
Gertrude WW
Henry WW
Holly WW
Isla WW
Liam WW
Lucy WW
Mary WW
Oisin WW
Orla WW
Patrick WW
Phil WW
Regan WW
Senan WW
Steve WW
Vernon WW
Wendy WW
Winifred WW

I thought things were going very badly but theres a load of us left, looking at that list though Phil, Mary, Clodagh and Angus - I don't remember one thing about them

Mary WW · 22-10-2019 11:24am

Barbara WW · 22-10-2019 11:24am

Winifred WW wrote: »

Either way, the point is still the same. We can't trust that Lucy is Good or Bad, so she's to go back on the board as completely unknown.

I agree with this

Patrick WW · 22-10-2019 11:24am

Derry voted Regan

Regan voted Derry

The time of the votes there are important too

Winifred WW · 22-10-2019 11:25am

Tegan WW wrote: »

Not sure if relevant but Senan changed his vote to me at last minute too

Very relevant, and we shouldn't forget that as a group

Tegan WW · 22-10-2019 11:26am

Patrick WW wrote: »

Derry voted Regan

Regan voted Derry

The time of the votes there are important too

True also look that I had been saying I didnt trust him Iasked him and liam about being poisoned at 1854 and he voted for me at 1909. This I posted about previously

Tegan WW · 22-10-2019 11:27am

Might I also say I nearly voted for someone else but Derry was niggling at me. I wanst fussed about him voting for me as a bunch had already so what was one more, so it wasnt a revenge vote

Eva WW · 22-10-2019 11:28am

Think I have everyone marked off here who is dead.

Night One
No lynch - Barbara / Regan / Ewan / Oisin / Conor / Phil / Liam / Lucy
Lucy - Wendy / Winifred / Orla / Vernon / Henry
Steve - Emily / Gertrude / Patrick
Regan - Eva / Doris / Clodagh
Eva - Senan
Ewan - Steve
Liam - Isla
Wendy - Desmond
Phil - Brendan

Didn't vote: Abigail, Angus, Derry, Fiona, Frank, Gabriel, Holly, Mary

Night Two
Senan Gabriel/Holly/Brendan/Wendy
Gabriel Oisin/Fiona
Liam Ewan/Phil
Eva Isla
Regan Frank /Orla/Clodagh/Derry/Vernon/Angus/Barbara/Senan
Ewan Winifred
Frank Conor/Patrick
Vernon Henry/Doris/Eva
Angus Emily
Doris Abigail
Derry Regan
Fiona Lucy

No Lynch Liam

Didn't vote: Mary

Never massively tried wagonomics before but let's try.

Knowing Derry is now bad.....he chose not to vote on Night One. Didn't receive any votes on night one either. Would multiple wolves have chosen not to vote on night one?

Night two gives us more info. Derry votes Regan, Regan votes Derry. Would two wolves trade votes like that? Would multiple wolves have lumped on Regan?

Patrick WW · 22-10-2019 11:28am

Tegan WW wrote: »

True also look that I had been saying I didnt trust him Iasked him and liam about being poisoned at 1854 and he voted for me at 1909. This I posted about previously

Regan now Tegan appears to be a good puppy based on wagonomics anyway

Senan WW · 22-10-2019 11:28am

Winifred WW wrote: »

Very relevant, and we shouldn't forget that as a group

Why is it relevant?

I gave my reasons, IF Regan was a wolf then they could have had a CFD and I was the closest to get to, we've seen it done before.
I KNOW i'm good, the only one I know for definite, why wouldn't I vote to protect myself?

As it turns out they didn't CFD they used vote manipulation instead. So you think I made the obvious move of jumping vote AND knew about the voting manipulation?

Do you think these theories through?

Mary WW · 22-10-2019 11:28am

Winifred WW wrote: »

Is that really hard to understand?

Derry was bad. He was gifted a peek to use. We as a group asked that he peek Lucy. He said Lucy was Good.

we have no way of knowing if lucy is good or bad because Derry can't be trusted.

He could have:
peeked lucy and she's good

peeked someone else looking for the joker, said his wolf buddy lucy was good

peeked someone else looking for the joker and knowing lucy is good, say she's good.

[/QUOTE

I was following most of yesterdays action. Derry imo could only have peeked lucy, according to how des told him to write it, therefore didnt peek anyone esle.

Lucy could be good, no doubt, but there will always be a doubt about her for the rest of the game

I'd be looking at who put forward the suggestion to pick derry or liam. Good idea at the time, yes, but also could have been a scheme planned by the wolves.

Henry WW · 22-10-2019 11:29am

before I forget - i'm leaning village on liam as I don't see wolves poisoning two of their own (even if they could cure them again). It seems high risk if something were to happen to your curer.

Senan WW · 22-10-2019 11:30am

Henry WW wrote: »

before I forget - i'm leaning village on liam as I don't see wolves poisoning two of their own (even if they could cure them again). It seems high risk if something were to happen to your curer.

I posted earlier that I didn't think the poisoner was an evil role

Winifred WW · 22-10-2019 11:31am

Senan WW wrote: »

Why is it relevant?

I gave my reasons, IF Regan was a wolf then they could have had a CFD and I was the closest to get to, we've seen it done before.
I KNOW i'm good, the only one I know for definite, why wouldn't I vote to protect myself?

As it turns out they didn't CFD they used vote manipulation instead. So you think I made the obvious move of jumping vote AND knew about the voting manipulation?

Do you think these theories through?

I don't have any theories. I'm just saying that changing votes last minute can be a red flag, and we shouldn't forget it.

Tegan WW · 22-10-2019 11:31am

Senan WW wrote: »

Why is it relevant?

I gave my reasons, IF Regan was a wolf then they could have had a CFD and I was the closest to get to, we've seen it done before.
I KNOW i'm good, the only one I know for definite, why wouldn't I vote to protect myself?

As it turns out they didn't CFD they used vote manipulation instead. So you think I made the obvious move of jumping vote AND knew about the voting manipulation?

Do you think these theories through?

At that stage you had 4 votes I had 8 no need to jump

Winifred WW · 22-10-2019 11:32am

Mary WW wrote: »

Winifred WW wrote: »

Is that really hard to understand?

Derry was bad. He was gifted a peek to use. We as a group asked that he peek Lucy. He said Lucy was Good.

we have no way of knowing if lucy is good or bad because Derry can't be trusted.

He could have:
peeked lucy and she's good

peeked someone else looking for the joker, said his wolf buddy lucy was good

peeked someone else looking for the joker and knowing lucy is good, say she's good.

[/QUOTE

I was following most of yesterdays action. Derry imo could only have peeked lucy, according to how des told him to write it, therefore didnt peek anyone esle.

Lucy could be good, no doubt, but there will always be a doubt about her for the rest of the game

I'd be looking at who put forward the suggestion to pick derry or liam. Good idea at the time, yes, but also could have been a scheme planned by the wolves.

Yeah, somebody reminded me about the on-thread peek, I've reverted on that.

Henry was the one with the initial poisonee peeker idea. I think it was a good idea whether derry is bad or not.

Abigail WW · 22-10-2019 11:33am

Barbara WW wrote: »

Derry being bad doesn't necessarily imply that Lucy is also bad. He could habe double bluffed, knowing there was a 50% chance of death anyway and figured we would disbelieve his claim, turning heat on Lucy when she's actually not a wolf. Not saying Lucy is off hook, just tgat it's possible.

Abi, why did you vote for Doris previous lynch? And shoukd we be looking closer at Doris now that you've been a munch target?

To be honest it was just to get a vote in yesterday. I wasn't sure about the whole Lucy/Wendy business and with the jester in the game I wanted to stay away from them. I also wanted to stay away from the poisoned people, so just took a punt on Doris.

Winifred WW · 22-10-2019 11:34am

Senan WW wrote: »

I posted earlier that I didn't think the poisoner was an evil role

Fair point. We can't know for sure though. Until Ewan gives us some more information....

Ewan? You wanna help your villager buddies out? Or are you still stuck in your backroom panicking?

Clodagh WW · 22-10-2019 11:34am

Tegan WW wrote: »

That'll teach me I'm never venturing outside again

Is Tegan actually Regan or a completely new player/role or not, in which case whats your role now you're passed the munch and why shouldnt i switch my no lynch back to regan/tegan?

Winifred WW · 22-10-2019 11:35am

Clodagh WW wrote: »

Is Tegan actually Regan or a completely new player/role or not, in which case whats your role now you're passed the munch and why shouldnt i switch my no lynch back to regan/tegan?

It's the same player/character/role, they've just had to use a new account for tech issues.

Patrick WW · 22-10-2019 11:35am

Abigail WW wrote: »

To be honest it was just to get a vote in yesterday. I wasn't sure about the whole Lucy/Wendy business and with the jester in the game I wanted to stay away from them. I also wanted to stay away from the poisoned people, so just took a punt on Doris.

Was there some sort of reasoning for it though?

Henry WW · 22-10-2019 11:36am

Mary WW wrote: »

I'd be looking at who put forward the suggestion to pick derry or liam. Good idea at the time, yes, but also could have been a scheme planned by the wolves.

It was my idea. I'm more interested in who cured Derry/Liam and why.

Mary WW · 22-10-2019 11:38am

Henry WW wrote: »

It was my idea. I'm more interested in who cured Derry/Liam and why.

I thought dery died from the poison, how did he die?

Henry WW · 22-10-2019 11:38am

Senan WW wrote: »

I posted earlier that I didn't think the poisoner was an evil role

i thought that initially, but changed my mind. Since ewan has reacted so strongly to being called poisoner, i'm becoming more convinced it's an evil role.

Necro · 22-10-2019 11:39am

Clodagh WW wrote: »

Is Tegan actually Regan or a completely new player/role or not, in which case whats your role now you're passed the munch and why shouldnt i switch my no lynch back to regan/tegan?

Game Mod: Tegan is Regan. Regan is Tegan. Only thing that has changed is the account name

South Park WW ROLE MADNESS - Game Thread

Comments