Will Joe be Gone Til November like Wyclef Jean? Liveline: 17/09/2019 to date

sligojoek

Katie
Article about suicide in Irish Times.

Violent downs syndrome guy from yesterday.

Dog on restricted list might be taken to the pound.

Children being shouted at at sports.

Should pupils be penalised for not attending religion classes?

Odyssey 2005

sligojoek wrote: »

Katie
Article about suicide in Irish Times.

Violent downs syndrome guy from yesterday.

Dog on restricted list might be taken to the pound.

Children being shouted at at sports.

Should pupils be penalised for not attending religion classes?

So..none of these will be discussed today :)

Thanks Jeremy for the thread title

Keeping up the musical theme

Previous thread here
https://www.boards.ie/vbulletin/showthread.php?t=2057997497

Uncharted

Joe won't be gone till November but you can be sure he will have at least 2 breaks in between.

A little ditty to celebrate the new thread title


Every time I make a run
Dee she turn around and cry,
I ax myself why-o-why

See you must understand, I can’t work a 9 to 5.
So I’ll be gone, til November,

Said I’ll be gone til November I’ll be gone til November,
Yo tell Katie I’ll be gone til November,
Alicante in Summer, Bordeaux in September
I’ll be gone til November I’ll be gone til November
Praise be to Allah I’ll be gone til November
Working class hero on millionaire pay,
I see you cryin’ I get off on dismay,
I'll be gone til November I'll be gone til November
Any death? How’s your mother?









Is that my coat on the lawn?

Dan Jaman

More cheery chit.

2smiggy

a good old suicide to make this lovely warm sunny day even better :rolleyes:

SEPT 23 1989

they should be putting Prozac into the water instead of fluoride in Montrose

daveorourke77

I feel like kiling myself listening to this

Ally Dick

I hope they give Damien O'Reilly a go before Joe gets back. Time to get rid of Katie. Too boring

SEPT 23 1989

2smiggy wrote: »

a good old suicide to make this lovely warm sunny day even better :rolleyes:

there are no windows in the radio centre bunker

sligojoek

She can only be as good as the subjects they throw at her.

Dan Jaman

Tshasm!

daveorourke77

I've said this before but I feel the need to say it again.

I do not and never will understand why people draw attention to things they disapprove of.

I would never have bothered with this article but now my curiosity has been stoked.

BPKS

160 road traffic collisions a year?

Roger_007

There's a bizarre contrast between this item on suicide and the one one they did last week where callers were claiming the right to commit suicide.
Are we to judge between those who should have the right to take their own lives and those who shouldn't?

Dan Jaman

sligojoek wrote: »

She can only be as good as the subjects they throw at her.

Joe left a list, to keep de punters on de boil, an dat.


Sooyesoide

Mentul elf
Depreshun
Gravey yards
Dead childers

Odyssey 2005

SEPT 23 1989 wrote: »

there are no windows in the radio centre bunker

Put Duffy, tubbers and Darcy into it and seal it up so

daveorourke77

Roger_007 wrote: »

There's a bizarre contrast between this item on suicide and the one one they did last week where callers were claiming the right to commit suicide.
Are we to judge between those who should have the right to take their own lives and those who shouldn't?

How can you grant someone the right to commit suicide?

It's impossible. Someone can end their own life at anytime and will most likely lt do it alone. That can't be stopped.

Assisted suicide is a different matter entirely.

Dan Jaman

Roger_007 wrote: »

There's a bizarre contrast between this item on suicide and the one one they did last week where callers were claiming the right to commit suicide.
Are we to judge between those who should have the right to take their own lives and those who shouldn't?

I'm glad it's not illegal any more.
I mean, I'd be really pissed off if I tried to top mesel' and got arrested for it. Feckin' cheek, when you think of it.

daveorourke77

Dan Jaman wrote: »

Joe left a list, to keep de punters on de boil, an dat.


Sooyesoide

Mentul elf
Depreshun
Gravey yards
Dead childers

Mar dhea and dat per se

Odyssey 2005

daveorourke77 wrote: »

Mar dhea and dat per se

T
Y
4
Y
S

daveorourke77

Who makes a hero out of a person that ends their own life?

Roger_007

Dan Jaman wrote: »

I'm glad it's not illegal any more.
I mean, I'd be really pissed off if I tried to top mesel' and got arrested for it. Feckin' cheek, when you think of it.

Would it be worse or better if you got hanged for attempted suicide?

2smiggy

Courage in suicide ?!?!?!? That's what we are listening to on RTE now

daveorourke77

I kind of agree that it takes courage in a sense.

The logic may seem perverse but I know what she's getting at

Odyssey 2005

Clusters ok.

Clusterfuk of a show

daveorourke77

2smiggy wrote: »

Courage in suicide ?!?!?!? That's what we are listening to on RTE now

Yes. I understand exactly what she's getting at.

McDermotX

Just turned on the radio.......sounds like your one is giving tips around sewercide.

Ally Dick

I would never commit suicide. I'd rather shoot everyone who is annoying me

ShamNNspace

How is this conversation helping anyone?
I wonder could saying "it takes tremendous courage to take your own life" have ticked a box for someone listening and edged them nearer to the rope or to the river

SEPT 23 1989

they wont feel any better after listening to Liveline

Odyssey 2005

Katie,like Duffy is not capable or qualified to talk about this subject.

BPKS

Will Joe be back for his annual jaunt to the Ploughing Championship?

sligojoek

I heard the discussion but I didn't read the article.

daveorourke77

Ally Dick wrote: »

I would never commit suicide. I'd rather shoot everyone who is annoying me

How do you know that? Anyone could becom suicidal. Most won't but its possible

Odyssey 2005

If you've thought about sewerside it should be compulsory to attend ???

I might have to turn this off.



If I wasn't entirely depressed before this came on, I'll definitely be after it.

BPKS

ShamNNspace wrote: »

How is this conversation helping anyone?
I wonder could saying "it takes tremendous courage to take your own life" have ticked a box for someone listening

I agree - thought it was a very dangerous assertion to let go more or less unchallenged by the host.

sligojoek

BPKS wrote: »

Will Joe be back for his annual jaunt to the Ploughing Championship?

Yes. On Thursday

daveorourke77

daveorourke77 wrote: »

I do not and never will understand why people draw attention to things they disapprove of.

To call it out?

It'd be different if this were some Facebook post or a tweet by someone with ten followers, but McGarry wrote this in a national broadsheet.

I don't think suicide is selfish but I can see why someone would say that. However what really got my convinced that McGarry was talking shïte was the insertion of the word "thoughtless". That's worse than selfishness, where you put your needs above others, that's actually not even considering the effect on others, or not thinking of any consequences at all.

That's an obviously stupid statement, a crass generalisation.

Hector Savage

ah jaysus ... out of here...

Roger_007

Odyssey 2005 wrote: »

If you've thought about sewerside it should be compulsory to attend ???

That would be a mighty big crowd!

BPKS

Deleted User wrote: »

I might have to turn this off.



If I wasn't entirely depressed before this came on, I'll definitely be after it.

I'm suffering from post All Ireland final loss mood and I think I need to turn off this and get something upbeat on Spotify:eek:

daveorourke77

ShamNNspace wrote: »

How is this conversation helping anyone?
I wonder could saying "it takes tremendous courage to take your own life" have ticked a box for someone listening and edged them nearer to the rope or to the river

Is writing an article calling tham thoughtless and selfish going to stop them?

Odyssey 2005

Odyssey 2005 wrote: »

Katie,like Duffy is not capable or qualified to talk about this subject.

Completely agree.



Are there no head shops Katie can get shut? Thats more her area.

ShamNNspace

BPKS wrote: »

ShamNNspace wrote: »

How is this conversation helping anyone?
I wonder could saying "it takes tremendous courage to take your own life" have ticked a box for someone listening

I agree - thought it was a very dangerous assertion to let go more or less unchallenged by the host.

I edited my comment later

I forsee very few comments in this thread today.

daveorourke77

A Tyrant Named Miltiades! wrote: »

To call it out?

It'd be different if this were some Facebook post or a tweet by someone with ten followers, but McGarry wrote this in a national broadsheet.

I don't think suicide is selfish but I can see why someone would say that. However what really got my convinced that McGarry was talking shïte was the insertion of the word "thoughtless". That's worse than selfishness, where you put your needs above others, that's actually not even considering the effect on others, or not thinking of any consequences at all.

That's an obviously stupid statement, a crass generalisation.

What I meant originally was that if it needs to be called out is it worth reading in the first place.

Roger_007

A Tyrant Named Miltiades! wrote: »

To call it out?

It'd be different if this were some Facebook post or a tweet by someone with ten followers, but McGarry wrote this in a national broadsheet.

I don't think suicide is selfish but I can see why someone would say that. However what really got my convinced that McGarry was talking shïte was the insertion of the word "thoughtless". That's worse than selfishness, where you put your needs above others, that's actually not even considering the effect on others, or not thinking of any consequences at all.

That's an obviously stupid statement, a crass generalisation.

I knew a young lad, 23yo, who committed suicide. When I spoke to his mother the first thing she said was "How could he do this to us?".
I was disgusted!

Dan Jaman

Ah; this is bollocks.
I'm off.
I leave the rope to someone else.