Silence of the Wolves - A Game of Werewolf GAME THREAD

Ectoplasm

Strawberry Milkshake wrote: »

Undeclared - skunk, duffman, crosstownk

Is that right?

I think so. The relative silence on thread has me a bit concerned. Either we've nailed the wolves in Kolido and Fixxxer or we have 2 more villagers up for the noose.

tusk

tusk wrote: »

Thanks for that Strawbert!

Can anyone collate or create a pros cons list for the top three suspects flipping green/red?

Give it a whirl, tusk

tusk

Madness should start any minute now....

tusk

Strawberry Milkshake wrote: »

Give it a whirl, tusk

Making dindins for the boss rn

Green&Red

quickbeam wrote: »

Thinking of changing my vote to Triceratops. On, only to argue with GnR about whether she did or didn't vote for Duffers before or after her FFA. No real game play. If a few people pile on her, she might come talking again. If a wolf, she might let something slip in her defending herself. If she's a Villager she might just step up to the plate and find something useful for us and we can change our vote, or otherwise she's not great loss (sorry TB!).

Do you think you could get enough of ur Digi5 buddies to hop over?
As someone said it’s very quiet, not necessarily a good thing.

Kolido

tusk wrote: »

Madness should start any minute now....

LadySkunk

Just reading the vote list and laughed thinking would Green vote for himself if the Digi4 did :pac:

On a serious note though I’m looking back into G&R, Fixxxer and Clarabel.

G&R so I can decide on what I think of him and finally put it to bed.

Fixxxer as a few people are on him and want to see how I feel about him too.

Clarabel because there’s something about her posts that are poking at me but don’t know what it is.

That’s not an FFA just wanted to put out where my heads at from keeping up the last couple of days but nothing concrete as haven’t done a proper read back. Will update when I do and also chip in on discussions during.

Something else I’ve been thinking and said already. I don’t think people who are lock clear villagers to themselves should go with what the Digi4 chooses just because we got Digi.

I can’t get it out of my head that there might be a wolf in one of us but at the moment I don’t have suspicions on any of the others. Just feel like it’s too easy for the wolves to manipulate if there is one in there, still is even if there’s not. A couple of people have said they’d vote with us and that’s making me a bit uneasy. Also feel uneasy as it’ll just be another big pile on like it was with SK and we learn nothing.

I think people should be voting who they strongly feel is a wolf, state their reasons and by all means if you’re voting because you have the same reasons as one of us then do but just say that in your own words. It gives us more to work with after.

Necro

Blah missed it. Post count limit lifted

LadySkunk

This new mobile site is doing my head in, can’t quote your post properly Green.

Will you stop with the team buddies stuff. You’re coming on way too strong, at least buy us dinner first! :P

LadySkunk

Dying laughing, read that as “our buddies”. Thought I was gas

Green&Red

TheSkunk wrote: »

Just reading the vote list and laughed thinking would Green vote for himself if the Digi4 did :pac:

On a serious note though I’m looking back into G&R, Fixxxer and Clarabel.

G&R so I can decide on what I think of him and finally put it to bed.

Fixxxer as a few people are on him and want to see how I feel about him too.

Clarabel because there’s something about her posts that are poking at me but don’t know what it is.

That’s not an FFA just wanted to put out where my heads at from keeping up the last couple of days but nothing concrete as haven’t done a proper read back. Will update when I do and also chip in on discussions during.

Something else I’ve been thinking and said already. I don’t think people who are lock clear villagers to themselves should go with what the Digi4 chooses just because we got Digi.

I can’t get it out of my head that there might be a wolf in one of us but at the moment I don’t have suspicions on any of the others. Just feel like it’s too easy for the wolves to manipulate if there is one in there, still is even if there’s not. A couple of people have said they’d vote with us and that’s making me a bit uneasy. Also feel uneasy as it’ll just be another big pile on like it was with SK and we learn nothing.

I think people should be voting who they strongly feel is a wolf, state their reasons and by all means if you’re voting because you have the same reasons as one of us then do but just say that in your own words. It gives us more to work with after.

I buy this post about a big pile on.

In my head I’m flipping between four
Kolido
TB
Clarabel
Strawbs

The most panic was when it was on Strawbs so I think I might go back to her

Vote placed

quickbeam

Green&Red wrote: »

Do you think you could get enough of ur Digi5 buddies to hop over?
As someone said it’s very quiet, not necessarily a good thing.

You’d need to ask them tbh. I’m really not sure of anyone anymore though so would be willing to switch. My main aim in naming her earlier was to get her to talk which worked, somewhat anyway.

Ectoplasm

I'll be sticking with fixxxer, even if you guys vote elsewhere. You may all be team village but I'm the only one I can be 100% sure of so I'm trusting myself.
I've already outlined my reasons but basically if he flips red or green I think we learn something. The fact that he didnt FFA the first 2 days was the final nail for me.
With Kolido I'm not so sure what we learn either way and nobody has taken me up on/been able to answer this question.

Green&Red

I’m probably signing my own death warrant by flipping but there you go

quickbeam

Green&Red wrote: »

Kolido
TB
Clarabel
Strawbs

Swap Strawbs for Fixxxer and that’d be my list. I’d quite happily vote for any of them.

Assuming Cross and Duff are modkilled, how many mislynches are there? I think someone worked it out as four. Is that four we can absorb or four till we lose?

quickbeam

Ectoplasm wrote: »

I'll be sticking with fixxxer, even if you guys vote elsewhere. You may all be team village but I'm the only one I can be 100% sure of so I'm trusting myself.
I've already outlined my reasons but basically if he flips red or green I think we learn something. The fact that he didnt FFA the first 2 days was the final nail for me.
With Kolido I'm not so sure what we learn either way and nobody has taken me up on/been able to answer this question.

In black and white so we’re clear, what do we learn if he’s good? What do we learn if he’s bad?

quickbeam

Green&Red wrote: »

So if we have two modkills tonite we have four mislynches


13v2 Currently
Mislynch1 - 12v2
Modkill x2 - 10v2
munch - 9v2
mislynch2 - 8v2
munch - 7v2
mislynch3 - 6v2
munch - 5v2
mislynch4 - 4v2
Munch - 3v2


My stag is on Friday, Clare Island will need some good coverage

Oh, ‘twas yourself. So, four we can absorb.

Ectoplasm

quickbeam wrote: »

Swap Strawbs for Fixxxer and that’d be my list. I’d quite happily vote for any of them.

Assuming Cross and Duff are modkilled, how many mislynches are there? I think someone worked it out as four. Is that four we can absorb or four till we lose?

You'd be better at the maths than me QB.

Is there any value to the 4 remaining Digi voters NOT declaring their vote? If all of you are in the clear then the wolf's know that. By declaring where you're voting it gives them a place to hide and an excuse to do it.
If there is a wolf (or 2) in that 4, it limits the damage that can be done by village following a semi-confirmed majority.
I know it risks not having a clear majority but are there other downsides that I'm not seeing?

LadySkunk

Ectoplasm wrote: »

You'd be better at the maths than me QB.

Is there any value to the 4 remaining Digi voters NOT declaring their vote? If all of you are in the clear then the wolf's know that. By declaring where you're voting it gives them a place to hide and an excuse to do it.
If there is a wolf (or 2) in that 4, it limits the damage that can be done by village following a semi-confirmed majority.
I know it risks not having a clear majority but are there other downsides that I'm not seeing?

Ohh I actually really like this idea! We could FFA 3 people so they have a chance to defend themselves. Vote and not tell everyone who we go for and then at twilight we can post our reasons for the person we voted??

Kolido

quickbeam wrote: »

Oh, ‘twas yourself. So, four we can absorb.

Missed that post earlier. That was assuming both duffers and cross are town, worst case for us.

OT, have a great stag G

quickbeam

I said a few days ago that none of us should be declaring our votes but was shot down by Keith and Pter.

tusk

TheSkunk wrote: »

Ohh I actually really like this idea! We could FFA 3 people so they have a chance to defend themselves. Vote and not tell everyone who we go for and then at twilight we can post our reasons for the person we voted??

I'm in but I don't get the upside really

LadySkunk

quickbeam wrote: »

I said a few days ago that none of us should be declaring our votes but was shot down by Keith and Pter.

Sorry Quickbeam, you're not getting any of the credit for your ideas this game are you

I'm down for it, think it will ruffle any feathers? Any downside?

Kolido

Not a bad idea Ecto. Only downside now is that most have mentioned who they are voting for so they won't stray too far but going forward I like that idea.

LadySkunk

tusk wrote: »

I'm in but I don't get the upside really

Wolves can't pile on and hide behind us

tusk

TheSkunk wrote: »

Wolves can't pile on and hide behind us

Interested to see where this goes...

Ectoplasm

quickbeam wrote: »

In black and white so we’re clear, what do we learn if he’s good? What do we learn if he’s bad?

If he is good I think we learn a bit less than if he is bad but I think we learn quite a bit from who was putting him forward repeatedly. If he's good it will look crap for me but I can live with that.

IMO he has been a serious candidate for lynch twice and people have been nudged off him. If he flips wolf I think we have clues to his partner.

fixXxer

Just checking in. Been sick as a dog all day with migraine, hardly been keeping up. Vote on Kolido but probably not going to be back on tonight.

LadySkunk

Couple of things I noticed going back over Fixxxer...

He hasn't really given full on thoughts on all players, like we've all done a read list at some point. Can't seem to find anything where he gives a lot of thought on everyone. Has only really called out people who have been a tad controversial to begin with. Kind of echoing what others have said. Makes me think that's why nothing stood out to me as a lot of what he was saying was what I was thinking. Also him not ISOing me when I requested it and then ignoring when I questioned the choice. Could it be because there's something I was onto about a potential wolf buddy that he didn't want to highlight? If he flips red at any point and I'm dead, that's something to look into.

Now onto the next. Think I'll do it like this where I write my thoughts on three players and then pick one to vote for at the end and give reasoning after twilight.

tusk

fixxxer wrote: »

Just checking in. Been sick as a dog all day with migraine, hardly been keeping up. Vote on Kolido but probably not going to be back on tonight.

Hope you feel better man. Migraines are the devil's work.