Sherlock - A game of Werewolf!

Conor WW · 20-09-2018 7:57pm

Brendan doesn't appear to be here. Gabriel I think is lying and I don't trust you either Orla.

Eva WW · 20-09-2018 7:57pm

Gabriel WW wrote: »

He made 4 posts since munch. If he doesnt post again he is modkilled.

So if he posts once he won't be modkilled. Too much of a chance to take for my feeling on him being a wolf.

Changes nothing then for me, it's Steve tonight.

And tbh, I think staying with Steve might work out better for you Gabriel.

Gabriel WW · 20-09-2018 8:00pm

Eva WW wrote: »

So if he posts once he won't be modkilled. Too much of a chance to take for my feeling on him being a wolf.

Changes nothing then for me, it's Steve tonight.

And tbh, I think staying with Steve might work out better for you Gabriel.

It obviously does. And i agree with this post 100%.

Im just worried Conor is seeing wolves everywhere.

Conor there is no more seer powers for the village, you cant verify everyone. You are going to have to trust some of us! I beg you to trust me!!!

Orla WW · 20-09-2018 8:00pm

Conor WW wrote: »

Brendan doesn't appear to be here. Gabriel I think is lying and I don't trust you either Orla.

That's fine, but Eva was also messaged :pac:

I don't expect any trust but when you're looking for opinions and then shutting us down, it's not really that helpful tbh.

Isla WW · 20-09-2018 8:01pm

Can someone link me to the lynch form? Gonna have to vote on phone and haven't done so in this game yet

Eva WW · 20-09-2018 8:01pm

Derry WW wrote: »

I hate when there's a sudden wagon starting to form here.

Would I be right in saying now that we're basically at Steve vs Gabriel?

I put in a thought out post about Steve earlier today. I feel quite strongly that he is a wolf, so if there is a 'wagon' forming on him, I guess that's fine with me.

It's funny, where is the line between 'wagon' and 'village collaborating'?'

Conor WW · 20-09-2018 8:02pm

I haven't shut you down. You haven't posted anything for me to engage with.

Derry WW · 20-09-2018 8:03pm

Gabriel WW wrote: »

For Steve to be modkilled, he would have to not post a single post between now and 9am. I cant see him not posting if he survives the lynch.

So if you want him dead, as i do, dont rely on a modkill.

Eva WW wrote: »

So if he posts once he won't be modkilled. Too much of a chance to take for my feeling on him being a wolf.

Changes nothing then for me, it's Steve tonight.

And tbh, I think staying with Steve might work out better for you Gabriel.

The issue here is if I were a wolf, I'd adore guiding the village onto wasting a lynch on someone who could possibly be mod killed

If Steve is a wolf who only has 4 posts a day, then he's basically not playing at this point......I'd hate to think that was happening.

Gabriel WW · 20-09-2018 8:04pm

Derry WW wrote: »

The issue here is if I were a wolf, I'd adore guiding the village onto wasting a lynch on someone who could possibly be mod killed

If Steve is a wolf who only has 4 posts a day, then he's basically not playing at this point......I'd hate to think that was happening.

Are you kidding me. Why would i bring it up then.

Conor WW · 20-09-2018 8:04pm

Please lynch Gabriel. If I'm wrong, I'm wrong but it might be my last chance to confirm a wolf

Nigel WW · 20-09-2018 8:04pm

Isla WW wrote: »

Can someone link me to the lynch form? Gonna have to vote on phone and haven't done so in this game yet

WerewolfGM wrote: »

Sherlock Lynch Form

https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSdBcGAfLdcO6rQpot74BDOLlfhTc3pspZw1ge0p-Bc5Mqi83Q/viewform

.

Isla WW · 20-09-2018 8:07pm

Thank you helpful wolf

Gabriel WW · 20-09-2018 8:10pm

This is gonna happen again before the next lynch isnt it?

Its gonna keep happening. I dont think there is a way i can win over Conor, and he should be listened to in most things, because he is the priest as far as i can see. Except he shouldnt be listened to here, because im good and we are low on numbers!!

Look ive made my case and i cant do much else. I cant put up a fight like i did last night. I just dont have the energy at the moment

Conor WW · 20-09-2018 8:11pm

I think you're probably safe Gabe.

Gabriel WW · 20-09-2018 8:13pm

Conor WW wrote: »

I think you're probably safe Gabe.

Thats the thing! Id follow you if it werent me up! But the point stands. You convinced im not a wolf? No? Well then see you tomorrow for this dance again!!

Derry WW · 20-09-2018 8:13pm

Gabriel WW wrote: »

This is gonna happen again before the next lynch isnt it?

Its gonna keep happening. I dont think there is a way i can win over Conor, and he should be listened to in most things, because he is the priest as far as i can see. Except he shouldnt be listened to here, because im good and we are low on numbers!!

Look ive made my case and i cant do much else. I cant put up a fight like i did last night. I just dont have the energy at the moment

I'm still inclined not to vote for you.

I just worry bout voting Steve.

Eva WW · 20-09-2018 8:14pm

Derry WW wrote: »

The issue here is if I were a wolf, I'd adore guiding the village onto wasting a lynch on someone who could possibly be mod killed

If Steve is a wolf who only has 4 posts a day, then he's basically not playing at this point......I'd hate to think that was happening.

I'll be honest Derry, I've welcomed your skepticism during the game and will do no different here.

As for the bolded part, it has happened. In the past, I have seen them as a villager and as a wolf, it happens.

So while your skepticism is healthy, 'hate to think that would happen' doesn't make it the case unfortunately. Conversation for another place, but non-engaging wolves happen.

Seriously, we need a wolf tonight and I really believe Steve is one. I'll take the absolute scathing from the village if Conor tells us different post 9pm.

I've considered the consequences of my actions if I'm wrong for both me and the village losing another villager.

Conor WW · 20-09-2018 8:16pm

If Steve is a wolf I reckon he's a sacrificial one. We lynch him and he *can't* post again. Handy that isn't it?

Gabriel WW · 20-09-2018 8:17pm

Riona please finish your pasta and get back here.

Riona WW · 20-09-2018 8:20pm

Gabriel WW wrote: »

Riona please finish your pasta and get back here.

I’m genuinely sorry Gab I don’t have a lot of time until kids are in bed...

I’ve tried to skim through Conor’s quotes but I don’t know what he’s getting at....

Should we not kill Steve and sort out gab later?

Nigel WW · 20-09-2018 8:20pm

I do think that there's at least one deep hidden wolf, and it could be Gabriel.

However, the very thing that had me sus of him yesterday - his going hard at Wini's claim when I thought there was a good chance that Wini was on the up, is sort of the thing that makes me want to give him a pass today. Yet that's the very thing that Conor is using as evidence for him being a wolf today.

I'd normally follow the confirmed villagers, and I'd still love to know who Barbara and Riona are voting for. But at the moment I'm highly reluctant to move to Gabriel just on one confirmed villager's say so.

Derry WW · 20-09-2018 8:21pm

Nigel WW wrote: »

I'd normally follow the confirmed villagers, and I'd still love to know who Barbara and Riona are voting for.

Nigel, I think we need to break some bad news to you.

Eva WW · 20-09-2018 8:22pm

Conor WW wrote: »

If Steve is a wolf I reckon he's a sacrificial one. We lynch him and he *can't* post again. Handy that isn't it?

I don't understand that Conor. Could you elaborate.

And btw, just saw your pleas about Gabriel. I just need the time to look back into what you think you've seen and I don't have the time to do that before lynch. He isn't a good lean for me, however Steve is so much worse for me.

Conor WW · 20-09-2018 8:22pm

Nigel WW wrote: »

I do think that there's at least one deep hidden wolf, and it could be Gabriel.

However, the very thing that had me sus of him yesterday - his going hard at Wini's claim when I thought there was a good chance that Wini was on the up, is sort of the thing that makes me want to give him a pass today. Yet that's the very thing that Conor is using as evidence for him being a wolf today.

I'd normally follow the confirmed villagers, and I'd still love to know who Barbara and Riona are voting for. But at the moment I'm highly reluctant to move to Gabriel just on one confirmed villager's say so.

Ok. Well Barbara is dead. Riona isn't confirmed. And it's not based on him going hard at Wini over her claim, it's their early interactions that is making me think that they were working together.

Nigel WW · 20-09-2018 8:23pm

Derry WW wrote: »

Nigel, I think we need to break some bad news to you.

Sorry, Brendan of course.

Conor WW · 20-09-2018 8:24pm

Eva WW wrote: »

I don't understand that Conor. Could you elaborate.

If Steve is a wolf, he's drawn a lot of heat today and it would be handy for wolves to stick him in their FFAs and when he shows as a wolf go "Oh, look I voted Steve, and he's a wolf, look how good I am"

Bussing basically. Also, if he's a not really showing up wolf, even better.

Conor WW · 20-09-2018 8:27pm

Nigel WW wrote: »

I do think that there's at least one deep hidden wolf, and it could be Gabriel.

However, the very thing that had me sus of him yesterday - his going hard at Wini's claim when I thought there was a good chance that Wini was on the up, is sort of the thing that makes me want to give him a pass today. Yet that's the very thing that Conor is using as evidence for him being a wolf today.

I'd normally follow the confirmed villagers, and I'd still love to know who Barbara and Riona are voting for. But at the moment I'm highly reluctant to move to Gabriel just on one confirmed villager's say so.

Also, I'm pretty sure that Brendan went for Isla. Finally, if I'm right and Gabriel *already* knew who Winnie was, of course he goes all out attacking her. It gains him village cred points.

Gabriel WW · 20-09-2018 8:27pm

Conor WW wrote: »

If Steve is a wolf, he's drawn a lot of heat today and it would be handy for wolves to stick him in their FFAs and when he shows as a wolf go "Oh, look I voted Steve, and he's a wolf, look how good I am"

Bussing basically. Also, if he's a not really showing up wolf, even better.

So who had him on their lists before today?

Eva WW · 20-09-2018 8:28pm

Derry WW wrote: »

I'm still inclined not to vote for you.

I just worry bout voting Steve.

So what road should the village go tonight then Derry? That's a very fence-sitting type of post.

Derry WW · 20-09-2018 8:29pm

Conor WW wrote: »

Also, I'm pretty sure that Brendan went for Isla. Finally, if I'm right and Gabriel *already* knew who Winnie was, of course he goes all out attacking her. It gains him village cred points.

Is it not more likely that the reason he'd go in hard on Winnie is because he doubted the story?

Sherlock - A game of Werewolf!

Comments