November Series (non-Ireland)

sydthebeat

sydthebeat wrote: »

No.

The kick 'chaser' runs ahead of hooper immediately after the kick. Kirobete I think.

When Kirobete is ahead of hooper, hooper is onside... And I argue that this was immediately after the kick.

Kerevi doesn't come into the equation at all, which was my initial point.
The officials only looked at hooper in relation to the kicker, never the chaser....

Interesting. So a chaser puts puts everyone else on side? Makes perfect sense actually. I just never thought of it.

Bridge93

The head on replay clearly hits the line

bilston

It's a 50/50 call. It definitely did not clearly hit the line. It may have done but it wasn't clear and obvious.

Bridge93

Interesting after all of Wales whinging at France in the 6N around the scrum, they now go to uncontested scrums at the end to Georgia due to injury. Not suspicious at all.

They've been getting annihilated there

bilston

Bridge93 wrote: »

The head on replay clearly hits the line

I honestly don't think there was anything clear about it at all. Toss of the coin for me.

corny

bilston wrote: »

It's a 50/50 call. It definitely did not clearly hit the line. It may have done but it wasn't clear and obvious.

Agreed. Home side will always get that call.

MadYaker

Hard to say if that touched the line or not..... try awarded anyway.

blackcard

50/50 call for me.

LuckyGent88

It nearly deserved to be a try anyway due to Beale going to sleep.

All down to Kurindrani dropping that offload. Could and should have been 7 the other way

Kiith

Beale ha been atrocious today.

sydthebeat

Kiith wrote: »

Beale ha been atrocious today.

Having a mare!

MadYaker

Jesus that was an atrocius "tackle" by Phillips. Late with no arms and no card?

tooManyChoices

Bridge93 wrote: »

Interesting after all of Wales whinging at France in the 6N around the scrum, they now go to uncontested scrums at the end to Georgia due to injury. Not suspicious at all.

They've been getting annihilated there

There has to be some kind of fuss kicked up about this.

*Georgia 7 points behind
*Georgia have scrum on wales 5m line with the wales sub tight-head in the bin.
*Georgia go for scrum but wales say their props on the bench are all injured (props were subbed off uninjured because they were getting annihilated in the scrums)
*Ref says "fine, uncontested scrums but you have to leave an extra player off the pitch (ie. 15v13)
*wales say "oh look, we do have a front row"
*somehow they end up playing 15v14 with uncontested scrums...

If that isn't cheating, I don't know what is

Kiwi_knock

England are lucky not to have a man in the bin yet.

MadYaker

He needs to shave that moustache

pickarooney

I think Oz butchered that

LuckyGent88

That has to have touched the ground. Australia have totally dominated this game. Don't deserve to be behind

SlickRic

The amount of decisions England's way in this is mental.
Ridiculous.
Nonsense.
Pathetic.

Even Barnes is confused.

Kiith

That was grounded.

Stheno

No try

Sephiral

Australia should be ahead by double points here. Atrocious by the reffing team.

Dick phelan

Has to be a try surely

MadYaker

Looks like a try to me, even the english commentators think its a try

SlickRic

Kiith wrote: »

That was grounded.

No issue. The ref called obstruction.

Spudmonkey

The Aussies have been ridden raw with decisions today.

Dick phelan

Very poor call England very lucky to be winning this game

sydthebeat

So moore stopped robshaw from making the tackle.... But robshaw makes the tackle anyway....

Hummmm

Ah that was blatant obstruction

vienne86

That's shocking. England are VERY lucky.

LuckyGent88

Can't wait till Cheikas press conference.