Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie

Fight Time From 4am-McGregor vs Mayweather**MOD Warning in 1st Post**

1105106108110111220

Comments

  • Closed Accounts Posts: 890 ✭✭✭Sweet Science


    Conor on points
    GerryDerpy wrote: »
    Of course, there are too many Ifs and Buts.


    If and buts to what ?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 761 ✭✭✭GerryDerpy


    Conor via DQ
    If and buts to what ?

    To building the picture of why walshb should re-evaluate his opinion on McGregor as a boxer. I agree he would have to base that evaluation on facts of the fight, rather than listing out caveats.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 890 ✭✭✭Sweet Science


    Conor on points
    GerryDerpy wrote: »
    To building the picture of why walshb should re-evaluate his opinion on McGregor as a boxer. I agree he would have to base that evaluation on facts of the fight, rather than listing out caveats.

    True . In fairness though , it is perfectly normal right now to have his view until proved wrong.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 761 ✭✭✭GerryDerpy


    Conor via DQ
    True . In fairness though , it is perfectly normal right now to have his view until proved wrong.

    I agree with you on that.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 890 ✭✭✭Sweet Science


    Conor on points
    GerryDerpy wrote: »
    I agree with you on that.

    So what are we all disagreeing on


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 58,499 ✭✭✭✭walshb


    Floyd via KO-TKO
    If Conor scores the KO and ends this, but pre KO he looks very very ordinary, what evaluation do we do?

    There are scenarios here....

    The scenario above is nothing really. Very very average and happened to land the big shot...

    Are we meant to proclaim him some sort of worthy pro boxer?

    Now, let's say for some bonkers reason that he looks slick, sharp, in control and looking like a fluid boxer who is controlling the fight and holding his own-winning against a Mayweather who is not some crock of sh1t hobbling around the ring....I guess we can only evaluate that as him being a freak who was hiding his talents from the world.....

    Then I think we all wake up!


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 890 ✭✭✭Sweet Science


    Conor on points
    If he gets battered and KOs Floyd i will give him all the credit he deserves tbh


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 58,499 ✭✭✭✭walshb


    Floyd via KO-TKO
    If he gets battered and KOs Floyd i will give him all the credit he deserves tbh

    Yes, but as a pro boxer how do you assess him?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 890 ✭✭✭Sweet Science


    Conor on points
    walshb wrote: »
    Yes, but as a pro boxer how do you assess him?

    Yeah i know the point you are making but i will forget about this as soon as its done . Wouldnt bother assessing him as he will be straight back to the UFC after


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 761 ✭✭✭GerryDerpy


    Conor via DQ
    walshb wrote: »
    If Conor scores the KO and ends this, but pre KO he looks very very ordinary, what evaluation do we do?

    There are scenarios here....

    The scenario above is nothing really. Very very average and happened to land the big shot...

    Are we meant to proclaim him some sort of worthy pro boxer?

    Now, let's say for some bonkers reason that he looks slick, sharp, in control and looking like a fluid boxer who is controlling the fight and holding his own-winning against a Mayweather who is not some crock of sh1t hobbling around the ring....I guess we can only evaluate that as him being a freak who was hiding his talents from the world.....

    Then I think we all wake up!

    He won't look like a slick boxer in my opinion. He will look like a martial artist that is only throwing punches. If that works for him (KO) and no other freak event happens (Floyd slips on a banana etc) then McGregor is a genius and one of the Worlds greatest sportsman ever.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,380 ✭✭✭The Reservoir Dubs Anchorman


    Floyd via DQ
    Yeah i know the point you are making but i will forget about this as soon as its done . Wouldnt bother assessing him as he will be straight back to the UFC after

    I wonder. Why would he bother going back? €75million in the bank. He'd have to fight 20 times in the UFC to even come close to that amount.

    He's got his health and his wits about him. Would be madness to go back really.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 890 ✭✭✭Sweet Science


    Conor on points
    GerryDerpy wrote: »
    He won't look like a slick boxer in my opinion. He will look like a martial artist that is only throwing punches. If that works for him (KO) and no other freak event happens (Floyd slips on a banana etc) then McGregor is a genius and one of the Worlds greatest sportsman ever.

    I do not believe there is any chance at all of it happening . But if it did i agree with you as i've said many times


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 890 ✭✭✭Sweet Science


    Conor on points
    I wonder. Why would he bother going back? €75million in the bank. He'd have to fight 20 times in the UFC to even come close to that amount.

    He's got his health and his wits about him. Would be madness to go back really.

    He is contracted to the UFC so he cant even if he wanted to . Plus there is no other boxing fight that would come close to this commercially


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 761 ✭✭✭GerryDerpy


    Conor via DQ
    I do not believe there is any chance at all of it happening . But if it did i agree with you as i've said many times

    And that is all good in my book. We disagree on only the probability of the event happening (maybe I am wrong), but once we agree on the effect that outcome has then I am happy.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,380 ✭✭✭The Reservoir Dubs Anchorman


    Floyd via DQ
    He is contracted to the UFC so he cant even if he wanted to . Plus there is no other boxing fight that would come close to this commercially

    he could just retire. I'm not talking about him boxing. I'm talking about just hanging up the gloves and mouthguard. Why would he bother to fight?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 761 ✭✭✭GerryDerpy


    Conor via DQ
    I wonder. Why would he bother going back? €75million in the bank. He'd have to fight 20 times in the UFC to even come close to that amount.

    He's got his health and his wits about him. Would be madness to go back really.

    That is assuming he only makes what he previously made for UFC fights. There is a possibility his UFC fights be promoted in association with McGregor sports and entertainment so his cut grows significantly.

    Edit to add: 20 times? He supposedly cleared 15 mill from his last fight.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 4,719 ✭✭✭JaMarcusHustle


    Floyd via KO-TKO
    I wonder. Why would he bother going back?

    Maybe he enjoys it? Maybe he likes having fights to train for, having lots of attention, and competing in a sport that he undoubtedly loves.

    It's easy for fans to say people should retire now that they've made enough money, or if they're past it and in danger of tainting their legacy - maybe they just want to keep playing the sport they enjoy playing.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,380 ✭✭✭The Reservoir Dubs Anchorman


    Floyd via DQ
    Maybe he enjoys it? Maybe he likes having fights to train for, having lots of attention, and competing in a sport that he undoubtedly loves.

    It's easy for fans to say people should retire now that they've made enough money, or if they're past it and in danger of tainting their legacy - maybe they just want to keep playing the sport they enjoy playing.

    Maybe it will be interesting to see what happens. Its a lot of money for a guy who likes to live it large, we'll see how motivated he is afterwards.

    With regard his previous earnings I don't know the figures so I cant argue on that I just seen something McGregor said himself about earning $3million to become a double world champ and was getting 20 times that to fight some retired bum.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,634 ✭✭✭ThinkProgress


    Floyd via DQ
    walshb wrote: »
    Pete IMO is and has been playing two sides of the fence here. He is more than just hoping Conor wins, he believes that he can, and in selling this he is kind of dismissing and insulting the science that is pro boxing, and the scientist that is Floyd Mayweather.

    I think this because of the way Pete reacts when certain points are rightfully shot to bits.....

    He is either deliberately dismissing the skill/science of pro boxing or ignorantly dismissing it.

    Either way Pete is well wide of the mark.

    I think he is ignorantly dismissing it... I've read enough from the fight strategy he was proposing Conor use on the night, to learn enough about his boxing knowledge (or lack thereof).

    He strikes me as one of those boxing haters / MMA snobs... there is a fair few of them around since Conor has become successful.

    (Most of them conveniently forgetting, that Boxing is arguably the most important skill within MMA - if not the most important, then certainly on a par with any other skills) :rolleyes:

    You do have to wonder about the mentality of certain people, when they are afraid to publish their true feelings on something. It really doesn't say much for that person's character tbh...

    If you consider Conor to have a good chance in this fight, then just be brave enough to stand behind that viewpoint... you might get ridiculed for your flawed logic... but at least you won't come accross as being completely dishonest. :)
    So, lets get to the meat of it: after the above opener then video then jumps on to critiquing how Conor keeps his right hand down while throwing a straight left, how he often fights upright and stiff and also how he sometimes has a static head position................... but to highlight these aspects of how Conor fights as somehow being flaws.... is as laughable as it gets as these fighting positions are very much deliberate for many mma fighters given that all of these things are used as part of their guard.

    I think they are pointing to the fact, that they will very much be flaws if he brings them into a boxing ring... against a very clever counter puncher.

    (and there is every chance he will do this, particularly when his energy levels start to dip)

    So, they are correct to highlight this imo... as it certainly could be relevant.
    For example, if an mma fighter fought with their hands raised and elbows tight (like boxers) their whole body would then be wide open to attack from either kicks, knees or a take down attempts. If you watch the second Diaz fight you'll see that Nate often kicked Conor right after Conor threw a left...... and that right hand being down low helped McGregor guard his body from the kicks doing damage. Same goes for some of Nates take down attempts. Had Conor's right hand not being low and ready to defend against them, Nate would quite easily have taken him down in that fight............ but if I remember correctly, Conor prevented Nate taking him down for the whole five rounds of that fight (well, until the dying seconds of it at least).

    Right... but if Conor slips back into any of these habits, on purpose or by mistake, he will be ruthlessly punished for it.

    This is not MMA... and now you are starting to get to the meat and bones, of why it takes years of specific training AS A BOXER, in order to avoid making such elemental errors!
    Same goes for the remarks about his body being upright and stiff and his head position being static. These are all just examples of certain aspects of specific body stances which make it easier to defend against attempted take downs. The guy in this video absurdly compares Floyd's Matrix-Neo-esque defense skills in boxing bouts to what he sees as Conor's rigidity during MMA fights but if any fighter in MMA tried to use the defensive postures of Floyd mayweather in an MMA fiight........ they'd be taken down in mere seconds. Bend backwards and tilt your body to avoid a punch and fighters like Nate Diaz would have you choked out in no time at all.

    Right... so are you suggesting that Conor intentionally eats shots in MMA fights... as part of his fight strategy??

    Because he certainly DOES get hit a fair bit in many of his fights.

    If opponents can land punches reasonably easily against him in the octagon... why would Floyd have any issues landing on him pretty much at his leisure in a boxing ring??

    Conor is very good at landing his power shots on the counter... but he also eats a fair amount of leather too. He is not actually particularly good at defending himself... he is very rigid, his head movement is fairly terrible.

    Again, I think they are correct to point out these weaknesses in Conor's defensive abilities. If that trend continues against Mayweather, he is in for a very long night. I don't think they are exclusive to an MMA fight.
    Last 'point' made in the video was with regards to clinches........... and well the same really applies again. The chap shows footage of Floyd bobbing and weaving, throwing some great shots and then cuts to Conor doing some bobbing and weaving of his own, but clearly nowhere near as eye catching (in his eyes) and also with Conor not getting off as many shots in the clinch as Floyd did............... but again this misses the point by a country mile, and that is that the fight in question was an MMA fight, not a boxing one and Conor didn't bob, weave or get off as many shots as this clown thinks he should of being able to as he was kinda busy trying to make sure Nate didn't take him to the ground and rnc him again. The sheer determination and strength Conor showed in those final clinches of that last round (in the second fight) was fcuking incredible..... but yet this guy just looks at McGregor in those clinches and all he sees is an inability to box.

    He was fighting a very average journeyman fighter, in fairness... he really should not have been struggling as much as he was.

    If he gasses out that much on Aug 26th... Floyd will have far better ability to finish him in a stand-up fight, than Diaz had.

    Diaz knew he simply did not have the tools to finish Conor standing up... so he was desperate to get him on the ground. Mayweather won't have any such problems in a boxing match!! ;)
    So in short, whoever made that video, doesn't have a damn clue what the hell they are talking about. They are comparing apples and oranges. Conor won't be fighting in a boxing ring the way he does in the octagon (with regards to positioning and stances anyway) for the simple reason that he won't have to. His right hand won't need to be kept low and he won't have to keep his upper body and head readied for attempts to take him down. In clinches he'll be free to fire off shots in ways he simply wasn't when fighting the likes of Nate Diaz.

    I think he'll be even worse at defending himself, in a boxing ring, than he is in the octagon...

    His rigidity, his poor head movement, his propensity to throw shots while leaving himself open to counters... these things will all be more ruthlessly exposed in a boxing ring!!
    walshb wrote: »
    Not a bit. It would however damage Mayweather a hell of a lot losing to a complete novice

    Put it this way, if it was Canelo or GGG or Spence or Thurman etc, Conor would not get past a single rd.....

    Forget even the WWs, Lomachenko and Frampton would be far too good for Conor....

    Forget even the lower weights,

    Irish amateur internationals would be far too good for Conor

    And on and on...

    Micky Conlon would take him to school in a boxing match!

    That's what is actually so frustrating about this "fight"... Conor is getting a chance to test himself against one of the best, with no real boxing record... when guys like Conlon (an actual highly talented olympic caliber boxer) would never get such an opportunity... because he's not famous enough!!

    When people talk about the sport of boxing being a mess... it's stuff like this, that makes me nod my head in total agreement with those people! (And generally I'm more of an optimist about the future of boxing).


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 14,339 ✭✭✭✭StringerBell


    Floyd via DQ
    GerryDerpy wrote: »
    I dunno man.

    If Conor says he is going to knock him out inside four rounds, goes in and does it, you need to re-evaluate your opinion of him as a boxer.

    Conor said he was gonna take Siver out in 1 round, he went in there.......and didn't,did it make you re-evaluate your opinion on him as a FW contender?

    Of course it didn't, that would be absurd.

    For the same reason certain people give Conor a chance (citing MW is old, smaller, slower, poor power, brittle hands etc) would surely accept that the likes of Canelo/GGG/Bradley/Thurman and so on and so on would not have any of these issues and would be an even further reach for McGregor following their own logic?

    Conor has more of a chance at coming through this fight with less lasting damage then he does against anybody else I have listed, he knows that too. That the chances of winning only improve by about .0001% v Mayweather is irrelevant, he isn't in it to win he is in it to make the most money possible following his mantra, get in,get rich, get out, taking as little damage as possible.

    Nothing wrong with that if you can get paid for it, nothing wrong with it at all. The fault doesn't lie with him for this circus act.

    "People say ‘go with the flow’ but do you know what goes with the flow? Dead fish."



  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 58,499 ✭✭✭✭walshb


    Floyd via KO-TKO
    GerryDerpy wrote: »
    He won't look like a slick boxer in my opinion. He will look like a martial artist that is only throwing punches. If that works for him (KO) and no other freak event happens (Floyd slips on a banana etc) then McGregor is a genius and one of the Worlds greatest sportsman ever.

    I really don't care what happens but this one of the world's greatest ever sportsmen is just nonsense.

    He's not even top 10 ever in MMA- UFC terms...


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,634 ✭✭✭ThinkProgress


    Floyd via DQ
    Conor said he was gonna take Siver out in 1 round, he went in there.......and didn't,did it make you re-evaluate your opinion on him as a FW contender?

    Of course it didn't, that would be absurd.

    For the same reason certain people give Conor a chance (citing MW is old, smaller, slower, poor power, brittle hands etc) would surely accept that the likes of Canelo/GGG/Bradley/Thurman and so on and so on would not have any of these issues and would be an even further reach for McGregor following their own logic?

    Conor has more of a chance at coming through this fight with less lasting damage then he does against anybody else I have listed, he knows that too. That the chances of winning only improve by about .0001% v Mayweather is irrelevant, he isn't in it to win he is in it to make the most money possible following his mantra, get in,get rich, get out, taking as little damage as possible.

    Nothing wrong with that if you can get paid for it, nothing wrong with it at all. The fault doesn't lie with him for this circus act.

    Great post... totally agree with everything said there.

    He also predicted the easy dismantling of Nate Diaz... those fights could not have been much more different from his predictions. Yet so many people say all his predictions come true? How so..? He has predicted a few right... credit to him... but he has gotten a few wrong as well tbf. (but the fanboys like to ignore those ones - they don't count, apparently) :pac:


    If this great sport was better run and better organised... this fight wouldn't even be possible. I don't blame the fighters trying to make their money... the sport needs to clean it's house up - big time!!

    The wrong people, with the wrong motives, have always had too much power and influence in the boxing world. Sad, but true!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 12,930 ✭✭✭✭Frank Bullitt


    Floyd via DQ
    Conor said he was gonna take Siver out in 1 round, he went in there.......and didn't,did it make you re-evaluate your opinion on him as a FW contender?

    Of course it didn't, that would be absurd.

    For the same reason certain people give Conor a chance (citing MW is old, smaller, slower, poor power, brittle hands etc) would surely accept that the likes of Canelo/GGG/Bradley/Thurman and so on and so on would not have any of these issues and would be an even further reach for McGregor following their own logic?

    Conor has more of a chance at coming through this fight with less lasting damage then he does against anybody else I have listed, he knows that too. That the chances of winning only improve by about .0001% v Mayweather is irrelevant, he isn't in it to win he is in it to make the most money possible following his mantra, get in,get rich, get out, taking as little damage as possible.

    Nothing wrong with that if you can get paid for it, nothing wrong with it at all. The fault doesn't lie with him for this circus act.

    He also said this before his first fight with Diaz.
    "His soft body and his lack of preparation, he will not be able to handle the ferocity. End of the first I feel he will be put away,"

    His crystal ball can tell porkies sometimes.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 761 ✭✭✭GerryDerpy


    Conor via DQ
    Ahhhh, so frustrating. Forget I said anything about the prediction, it is not important. If he KOs FM with skill and or unique gameplay then yee need to take notice. Forget the bloody prediction thing.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,380 ✭✭✭The Reservoir Dubs Anchorman


    Floyd via DQ
    GerryDerpy wrote: »
    Ahhhh, so frustrating. Forget I said anything about the prediction, it is not important. If he KOs FM with skill and or unique gameplay then yee need to take notice. Forget the bloody prediction thing.

    And if he gets hammered? Beaten up, humiliated .... what will your assessment of him be?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 761 ✭✭✭GerryDerpy


    Conor via DQ
    walshb wrote: »
    I really don't care what happens but this one of the world's greatest ever sportsmen is just nonsense.

    He's not even top 10 ever in MMA- UFC terms...

    Humm. Not sure now Walshey. Do you genuinely follow MMA? Not sure how you can put him outside the top 10 if so.

    Well if a sportsman can overcome a 0.001% probability in one of the biggest sporting events ever then I put him up there. I know we differ on that which is fine.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 761 ✭✭✭GerryDerpy


    Conor via DQ
    And if he gets hammered? Beaten up, humiliated .... what will your assessment of him be?

    That he is useless in a boxing ring. Stick to the day job.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 21,044 ✭✭✭✭everlast75


    Floyd via DQ
    And if he gets hammered? Beaten up, humiliated .... what will your assessment of him be?

    That he managed to manoeuvre his way into the biggest pay day of his life into a completely different sport, despite those "in the real world" thinking it would never happen? Fair play is what I think.

    Look - he has nothing to lose. Those in the boxing fraternity will not be surprised if he gets beaten up. Those in MMA will never have the chance to emulate what he's done so they can take a pop at him and he'll just reply - you try it.

    Tip of the cap to him.. even more so if he manages to do the impossible

    Elect a clown... Expect a circus



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,380 ✭✭✭The Reservoir Dubs Anchorman


    Floyd via DQ
    everlast75 wrote: »
    That he managed to manoeuvre his way into the biggest pay day of his life into a completely different sport, despite those "in the real world" thinking it would never happen? Fair play is what I think.

    Look - he has nothing to lose. Those in the boxing fraternity will not be surprised if he gets beaten up. Those in MMA will never have the chance to emulate what he's done so they can take a pop at him and he'll just reply - you try it.

    Tip of the cap to him.. even more so if he manages to do the impossible

    And if he gets battered and gets hurt?


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 58,499 ✭✭✭✭walshb


    Floyd via KO-TKO
    GerryDerpy wrote: »
    Humm. Not sure now Walshey. Do you genuinely follow MMA? Not sure how you can put him outside the top 10 if so.

    Well if a sportsman can overcome a 0.001% probability in one of the biggest sporting events ever then I put him up there. I know we differ on that which is fine.

    I know enough about MMA to not put him in the top ten ever in UFC...

    He could become a contender if he does more in the Octagon...


Advertisement