GW8 Match Day Thread.

Sooner or Later

90 mins of dreadful football to top off a dreadful week.
Thought my 27 last week was bad but hit 26 this week.

Scorpion Sting

manual_man wrote: »

Pfff that's very late for the bonus to be changing

They can change up to 1 hour after the final whistle.

manual_man

Scorpion Sting wrote: »

They can change up to 1 hour after the final whistle.

And they did lol

iroced

Clyne: 3
Bailly: 2
Lovren, Matip, De Gea, Valencia: 1


--

Horrible game (was kinda expected with Mourinho after United 3 consecutive defeats) that turned out pretty good for me and could have been fantastic if Firmino had a bit more gas in the tank for his Valencia-denied 1 on 1 with DDG (and if he scored it of course ).

12 from 3 tonight though so more than happy with it.

How Soon Is Now

That bonus point system ****ing joke!

How Karius gets same as Herrera I don't know!!

FHFC

37 assuming bonus is final.

Down to 160k from 100k at the start of the week. Still only one green arrow all season.

km79

hit was
Valencia baines out for bellerin and Adam smith
amat would have played if I had not done transfers as kone out too
so down 2 points but team in better shape
of course the other hit I had planned was ibra and Antonio or bolasie out for Costa/Wilson and Walcott so

iroced

How Soon Is Now wrote: »

That bonus point system ****ing joke!

How Karius gets same as Herrera I don't know!!

I said it many times over the last couple of years but I don't agree. We have to bear in mind the bonus points system is not the real game bonus points system but the fantasy game bonus points system. When the bonus points system was decided by a panel of "pundits", it was much worse. There was no consistency at all and controversy every single GW (dare I say every game ). Sometimes, you could really suspect subjectivity in some choices, some players seemed guaranteed some bonuses whatever their performance (Charlie "hero" Adams ).

So, as much as it can hurt us football lovers (and if you'd ask me, Merlin Silva would be the new Charlie Adams with an automatic 3 BPs for each one of his games ), we must remember that the rules are different there and Karius and his CS is more valuable than Herrera who did not much FPL-wise.

So 5 defs and a goalie for the 6 BPs distributed tonight with another def & goalie + Herrera just shy of them is to be expected IMO. Nothing nonsensical to me.

FHFC

iroced wrote: »

I said it many times over the last couple of years but I don't agree. We have to bear in mind the bonus points system is not the real game bonus points system but teh fantasy game bonus points system. When the bonus points system was decided by a panel of "pundits", it was much worse. There was no consistency at all and controversy every single GW (dare I say every game ). Sometimes, you could really suspect subjectivity in some choices, some players seemed guaranteed some bonuses whatever their performance (Charlie "hero" Adams ).

So, as much as it can hurt us football lovers (and if you'd ask me, Merlin Silva would be the new Charlie Adams with an automatic 3 BPs for each one of his games ), we must remember that the rules are different there and Karius and his CS is more valuable than Herrera who did not much FPL-wise.

So 5 defs and a goalie for the 6 BPs distributed tonight with another def & goalie + Herrera just shy of them is to be expected IMO. Nothing nonsensical to me.

I usually agree, but Bailly with a yellow outdoing 7 other defs who also got cs and DDG with 3 saves is a bit off.

Rikand

20 (-4)

Heaton and Lovren on the bench

Cheers

iroced

FHFC wrote: »

I usually agree, but Bailly with a yellow outdoing 7 other defs who also got cs and DDG with 3 saves is a bit off.

Yeah I was expecting him to go down after the update but I remember him doing a couple of key clearances that probably counter-balanced his YC. It's the problem of the stats-oriented system. A key clearance on the edge of the penalty area is the "same" than one that prevents a goal. It's statistically consistent. Then for us, people, DDG opposite hand save is miles ahead any clearance.

For once that I could see the game (again free on French Channel 23, they seem to like 'Pool, last free game was Chelsea-'Pool), I have to say I couldn't find any outstanding player bar maybe DDG for his 2 wonder saves. United were good defensively but Mourinho parked the bus. I found Valencia very good. Very sharp, great late tackle on Firmino (unfortunately for me). Coutinho finished very well and lallana made a great sub-appearance. Bar that/them...

km79

Should still see a small rise of about 10/15k and my defense is in better shape
Prob take another hit next week

FHFC

iroced wrote: »

Yeah I was expecting him to go down after the update but I remember him doing a couple of key clearances that probably counter-balanced his YC. It's the problem of the stats-oriented system. A key clearance on the edge of the penalty area is the "same" than one that prevents a goal. It's statistically consistent. Then for us, people, DDG opposite hand save is miles ahead any clearance.

For once that I could see the game (again free on French Channel 23, they seem to like 'Pool, last free game was Chelsea-'Pool), I have to say I couldn't find any outstanding player bar maybe DDG for his 2 wonder saves. United were good defensively but Mourinho parked the bus. I found Valencia very good. Very sharp, great late tackle on Firmino (unfortunately for me). Coutinho finished very well and lallana made a great sub-appearance. Bar that/them...

Yeah just seen Valencia wonderful goal saving tackle which makes it even worse!!!

Iused2likebusts

67(-8) great week for me as I got a good score and sorted my team out once and for all.

MarkSRFC21

Despite the aguero(c) horror show, a respectable 55 sees me get a decent rise up to around 120k. Holebas and Lovren really saved me this week though after a horror show on Saturday, but both wild carded in the week before so can't complain. Onwards we go!

IsMiseMyself

28(-4). Just gonna pretend the last two weeks never happened tbh.

Shanotheslayer

A respectable 40.

mcgettigan16

54 points. Another solid week. Overall rank of 41k.

iroced

65 pts. 87k GW rank. Up 170k to 91k. Back in top 100k for the first time after my GW4 apocalypse. Wasn't expecting it after not going with Walcott (C). But Holebas-Lovren unexpected combined 22 pts made up for it.

After 3 GWs, my GW6 WC is a success (3 green arrows from 445k to 91k). I'm not fully happy with my team though. But this season is quite unpredictable so everything can change so quickly...

wrestlemaniac

45 for the week and at 218k at the moment. Had dropped to 500k after the games Saturday!!

Scorpion Sting

41 (-4)

Fell 93k places to 371k. I'm still rueing my captaincy switch from Costa to Sanchez but at least I didn't give it to Aguero. A couple of key decisions to make with regard to transfers now ahead of GW9. I think I'm definitely going to take another -4 and possibly -8.

ScummyMan

48(-4) I'll take it and run after that horror show Saturday.

F1ngers

31(-4).
GW rank - 2.9 million.
OR - 1.5 million.

Calvin

31(-4) as well. Sitting OR at 1.7m

wonski

Calvin Leong wrote: »

31(-4) as well. Sitting OR at 1.7m

28(-8)

Sitting OR at 2.5m

Brought Benteke in for -4.

I was laughing when City missed theirs until Benteke's penalty

KevIRL

Finished the week on 34K OR. Highest of the season so far.

tailgunner

32 (-8). Last night's game turned an absolutely disastrous week into merely a very bad week. Dropped from 293k to 629k overall.

Think I've sorted out the major problems in my team now though, so hopefully will start to climb back up over the next few weeks.

2nd Row Donkey

Avg is 39 and I finished on 38.

First time below avg this season.

Aguero(c) and Benteke with -3 between is a freak of nature that I'm just going to take on the chin and move on.

1ft , may roll it but if Son plays in the CL tonight I may bring in Alli for the weekend.

km79

48(-4) actually ended up getting me a red arrow of 4k
still when. your strikers score a combined total of minus 1 ...........

Neoulous

40 pts. Horror run continues .

Was 58k for GW3. Played WC in GW4. 5 red arrows later (187k, 232k, 299k, 655k) I'm at 685k. Made all the wrong decisions. Ibra killed me. Snodgrass/Capoue was a huge mistake since it allowed a dearer defense that never worked so far.

Time for a change now. No pts hits limit. This is WC week without the WC.