Dublin GAA Discussion Thread MOD WARNING POST #2944

Saint Sonner

What way do club transfers work in Dublin? I would be transferring from Tyrone to Dublin - can it be done any time of the year?

TouchingVirus

There doesn't seem to be a cut-off for intercounty club transfers, though your name will appear here when you transfer

DoctaDee

Yeah I think the application is handled thru Central Council rather than county/provincial boards

salmocab

Saint Sonner wrote: »

What way do club transfers work in Dublin? I would be transferring from Tyrone to Dublin - can it be done any time of the year?

c'mon what club you going to?

Saint Sonner

salmocab wrote: »

c'mon what club you going to?

LOL - I'm not saying it until its done - don't want to jinx it. It'll be all over the papers anyway I would imagine!

:rolleyes::rolleyes:

Past30Now

DoctaDee wrote: »

Just hearing that Pats Donabate blew a 6 point ht lead to lose in IFC to Judes. Huge surprise imo and opens the door to any number of teams but I think Fingallians and Castleknock will be licking their chops

Saw Castleknock's match against Scoil Ui Chonaill. Cracking game. Castleknock built up an 11 point lead in the first half. Scoil came back strongly. Level with a minute to go. Penalty put Castleknock 3 clear at 60 mins. Another penalty equalised for Scoil in injury time. Castleknock pulled away in extra time to win by 5.:)

They'll (we'll) be hard to beat. So will Fingallians.

DoctaDee

Past30Now wrote: »

Saw Castleknock's match against Scoil Ui Chonaill. Cracking game. Castleknock built up an 11 point lead in the first half. Scoil came back strongly. Level with a minute to go. Penalty put Castleknock 3 clear at 60 mins. Another penalty equalised for Scoil in injury time. Castleknock pulled away in extra time to win by 5.:)

They'll (we'll) be hard to beat. So will Fingallians.

Yeah I find it hard to get a true read on the IFC - saw Olafs two years ago go down tamely to Pats Donabate only to win it last year. Likewise I would've assumed Pats this year would be looking to a semi at the least. Fingallians turned round a 3 point HT deficit last week and like yerselves showed a bit of resilience.

I was talkin with a lad at the weekend who told me that Judes gave Ballyboughal an awful caning in the 1st round, coupled with their win last time out against Pats - I'd have to assume they'll have a lot to say this season. Then again much like Pats this year they were handing the championship to Finians Swords last year (I think they were 13-0 in AFL 3 at the time) only to fall to Good Counsel (I think AFL 5).

Most of the talk around the IFC is that yer lads are a very good football team (even without CK) and are rightly considered the favourites - there's the kiss of death for ya

Past30Now

DoctaDee wrote: »

Most of the talk around the IFC is that yer lads are a very good football team (even without CK) and are rightly considered the favourites - there's the kiss of death for ya

Thanks for that. Hopefully CK will be back in time for the next round (sometime after S Cluxton lifts Sam)

windy shepard henderson

i know it was against ye but there was a masive ellement of this ^^^^



but i doubt there were many people engaging in casual sex on the back of it espicaly after watching donegals trype today ( or eoin mulligans hair cut on the sunday game for that matter)

DoctaDee

I can smell the beer off that post ... kudos for embedding 2 youtube clips tho

keane2097

Did Mulligan not foul the ball twice there?

Dubliner28

keane2097 wrote: »

Did Mulligan not foul the ball twice there?

How?

windy shepard henderson

DoctaDee wrote: »

I can smell the beer off that post ... kudos for embedding 2 youtube clips tho

yes i stand by my drunkiness although there was never any intention to rub it in .........i just couldnt find a tyrone page at 4 o clock this morning :pac:

keane2097 wrote: »

Did Mulligan not foul the ball twice there?

i taught at the time that he did too but the fake hand pass was legit

keane2097

Dubliner28 wrote: »

How?

You can't switch hands on the ball.

windy shepard henderson wrote: »

i taught at the time that he did too but the fake hand pass was legit

Any chance you could explain what exactly is and isn't allowed in that regard? I'm not 100% sure myself.

bren2001

keane2097 wrote: »

You can't switch hands on the ball.



Any chance you could explain what exactly is and isn't allowed in that regard? I'm not 100% sure myself.

Taken from a copy of the rules

changed from one hand to the other once, with the original holding hand maintaining contact until the change is completed

i.e. you can switch hands once per play (between each hop/solo) but cannot throw it between hands. You must go from one hand to both hands on the ball then off to one hand. Muligan did nothing wrong.

keane2097

bren2001 wrote: »

Taken from a copy of the rules



i.e. you can switch hands once per play (between each hop/solo) but cannot throw it between hands. You must go from one hand to both hands on the ball then off to one hand. Muligan did nothing wrong.

Surprised we don't see more of it in that case, super-effective move.

DoctaDee

windy shepard henderson wrote: »

yes i stand by my drunkiness although there was never any intention to rub it in .........i just couldnt find a tyrone page at 4 o clock this morning :pac:




i taught at the time that he did too but the fake hand pass was legit

You did well to turn on a computer at that hour :P... no bad feelings about that match at all

DoctaDee

A lively training session last week by all accounts.....

I'm filling my nights with the Ladies Dublin Club Championships, it's my methadone until 8th June

Ed Winchester

DoctaDee wrote: »

A lively training session last week by all accounts.....

Do go on!

PM if necessary :-)

dubliner 2

DoctaDee wrote: »

A lively training session last week by all accounts.....

I'm filling my nights with the Ladies Dublin Club Championships, it's my methadone until 8th June

Philly McMahon gone off the panel.

Did he walk or was he pushed?

Dublinfan

Heard rumors myself that McMahons gone it was building up there was another incident a month or two ago between him and Connolly during a club match , Sadly while he is a good player hes always been too rough and ready to pick a fight imo Connolly's no saint but he seems to have calmed abit

Stoner

I saw that game alright, McMahon lost the head when he was sent off just after Connelly was sent off. It might have been unfair but he was lucky to have been on the pitch at that stage anyway as he had enough yellow card offences built up. It was all just verbal though.

He'll be missed imo, thought he was the second best number 3 on display. All the more reason to keep O'Carroll fit. I'd hate to see George, Brady, Cooper, O'Brien thrown in there during a championship game.

DoctaDee

..... I like Philly - I'd rather have him with me than against me and he's also a far better footballer than a lot of people would give him credit for.

BUT .. he's a liability. He has cultured the image and it's being played out for all to see at club and IC level. It's just the mentality he has - reminds me a lot of Johnny/Eddie & Keith Barr. Philly was the man that coined the A v B games as the Killer B's when he was on the road back, he'll hopefully have his road to Damascus moment and come back with all the intensity he brings to the jersey - but leave the other messing alone (the Gooch incident last year being one)

copacetic

That's the same stuff a lot of people were saying about Ger 3 years ago and he turned a corner and showed how key a role a player used to playing on the edge can provide. Philly has done that this year in the league for me and relatively well controlled himself, just has the continued focus from referees. He will be key for Dublin in next 2 or 3 years in my opinion as Ger has lost a lot of the pace he had.

My understanding is there was a minor bust up and he was asked to take a couple of weeks away from the panel, but is back with them. Fuss about nothing.

Slattsy

I think he'll be a big loss. Well a loss anyway.

I'd imaging lads absolutely hated playing against him, and you always want a defender that can put lads off their game the way he does. Occasionaly he can over-step the mark though.

Past30Now

Slattsy wrote: »

I think he'll be a big loss. Well a loss anyway.

I'd imaging lads absolutely hated playing against him, and you always want a defender that can put lads off their game the way he does. Occasionaly he can over-step the mark though.

I agree. He'll be missed. I hope we don't regret his absence.

Who'll get his spot on the team. Darren Daly had a good start to the season. Mick Fitz would probably be the favourite. What about one of the half backs (Deveraux, Nolan, Lowndes, Jack?). It's probably too early for Sean George. Only five days before we find out.

My guess at the team for next weekend.

Cluxton, Daly,O'Carroll, Cooper, McCaffrey, Nolan, McCarthy, MDMA, O'Sullivan, Flynn, Brogan (A), Connolly, Brogan B, O'Gara, Costello.

Past30Now

copacetic wrote: »

That's the same stuff a lot of people were saying about Ger 3 years ago and he turned a corner and showed how key a role a player used to playing on the edge can provide. Philly has done that this year in the league for me and relatively well controlled himself, just has the continued focus from referees. He will be key for Dublin in next 2 or 3 years in my opinion as Ger has lost a lot of the pace he had.

My understanding is there was a minor bust up and he was asked to take a couple of weeks away from the panel, but is back with them. Fuss about nothing.

I missed this when I was posting my team above. I hope he's back. If so, he'd be in my team ahead of Daly.

Dublinfan

Whats everyones team predictions for Sunday? i think it will be the same team that started against Derry except Jack mc Back in Nolan out and Im still not sure about full forwards will Mannion start now hes back or O,Gara i think its between these two unless Andrews Dosent start and they have both on

ProudDUB

Think that barring injury, BB, Alan, O'Gara, Flynn and Connolly are nailed on starters up front. The 6th spot is up for grabs. I don't think that it automatically goes to Andrews. He had a so so Spring & there are others that need game time under their belt. I honestly don't know who else will start, it could be any one of him, Costello, Mannion, Rock, or Kev Mc. Then again, if we have a decent lead by half time, I can see half the starting forwards being taken off and other lads being given a decent run out. So who starts or doesn't start won't really matter.

Deffo want to see Jack Flash starting and I think he will. Would be great to see Ger B get some game time too. We sorely missed him at times during the league.

CurryFlavoured

It's a pity. This league season and the end of last years AI I think he's really stepped it up, he was one of our better players in the league. But if he can't keep his head then something had to be done, and it's easier to replace Philly than Connolly (not saying Jim sided with Diarmuid but I'd say he was no angel either). I'm still confident Philly will come back though.

It's very annoying that we looked like having a solid settled FB line (Philly - ROC - Cooper) for the first time in a while and this happens. Now we'll have to bring in a corner back who's probably played feck all county football this season. I've always been a fan of Daly but he got barely any time in the league, I like Mick Fitz as well but he's looked rusty since all his injuries last season. George has looked out of his depth in the blue shirt so far. Nolan in the corner anybody? Probably a bit late to start experimenting but he's a quality defender.