Can Liam Gallagher do a Johnny Rotten (ie PIL)??

ArtSmart

on later with jools. possible

Karl Stein

Where's the 'I want to knock the teeth out of Liam Gallagher's head' option?

WoollyRedHat

I.e Pil does not make any sense to me. Sir, what is it that you mean, speak clearly and plainly, lest I behead you for speaking in riddles.

buyer95

no

WoollyRedHat wrote: »

I.e Pil does not make any sense to me. Sir, what is it that you mean, speak clearly and plainly, lest I behead you for speaking in riddles.

Public Image Ltd

stefan idiot jones

Liam will not find a Jah Wobble though.

Too much of a dick.

DetectivFoxtrot

why is this in after hours?

Cathal Cloch wrote: »

Where's the 'I want to knock the teeth out of Liam Gallagher's head' option?

Did you see him on Jools the other night - d1ckhead!

Karl Stein

DetectivFoxtrot wrote: »

Did you see him on Jools the other night - d1ckhead!

I didn't but I can't stand the prick. He head butted a fan a couple of years back. I think someone punched him in the mouth and he lost a couple of teeth some time ago too.

He's a scumbag who stumbled into success by way of his Brother's talent.

Wattle

DetectivFoxtrot wrote: »

Did you see him on Jools the other night - d1ckhead!

What did he do?

DetectivFoxtrot

why is this in after hours?

Wattle wrote: »

What did he do?

just being a dope when interviewed. the (BeadyEye) song was ****e also

Hilly Bill

i can't imagine anything less interesting

Apart from 2 or 3 songs, PIL were brutal. Beady eye are just as bad and wont trouble the top of the charts any time soon.

Wattle

DetectivFoxtrot wrote: »

just being a dope when interviewed. the (BeadyEye) song was ****e also

Par for the course. I've kind of warmed to Noel a little bit but Liam is a talenteless charlatan and a complete dickhead.

longshanks

He's a fucking parody of his younger self, and the younger him was an over rated little maggot.

DEFTLEFTHAND

no

ARE YA MAD FER IT??

He's mellowed out a bit these days, he's in his 40s now and by all accounts I've heard he's a very good father. One of his sons is actually called Lennon.

thebaz

Hilly Bill wrote: »

Apart from 2 or 3 songs, PIL were brutal.

Public Image are class , not sure of their new stuff - but they have a great backcatalog -

dd972

i can't imagine anything less interesting

They're both musical spent forces, I can just envisage a big Slane Oasis reunion gig in 2020, just so Noel can buy a Chateau because the kids have grown up and Liam can proffer some of his witless soundbites that'll end up on Yahoo.com.

The gig of course will be a total shambles.

dd972

i can't imagine anything less interesting

thebaz wrote: »

Public Image are class , not sure of their new stuff - but they have a great backcatalog -

Although Lydon's a dick now compared to his 20's and 30's, PIL and Metal Box are masterpieces.

vicwatson

Don't be bloody ridiculous

Smidge

Went to Oasis concert in Pairc Ui Caoimhe in the 90's at the height of Oasis career.

WORST. CONCERT. EVER.

The support was the Prodigy and they were great.
Then comes along the Eyebrowed Idiots and it all went to muck.

They spent the whole time arguing(and they were genuinely fighting, not just for show)through the whole gig.
It was a shambles, only one of them on stage at once, drinking tea and bitching.

Waste of ticket money and a journey:mad:

buyer95

no

dd972 wrote: »

They're both musical spent forces, I can just envisage a big Slane Oasis reunion gig in 2020, just so Noel can buy a Chateau because the kids have grown up and Liam can proffer some of his witless soundbites that'll end up on Yahoo.com.

The gig of course will be a total shambles.

Noel solo album was as good as any of the early Oasis albums imo. " If I had a Gun... " is up there with Don't Look Back in Anger, Supersonic, and Live Forever. It was No.1 in UK and Ireland, Liam a spent force? Hell yeah, but not Noel. I was at the concert in Marlay Park with him and Kasabian(epic concert) both sounded great live.

Diabhal Beag

Noel is far more annoying than Liam these days but they're both worthless.

pabloh999

Oasis were great in their day

MadYaker

In the 90s Liam was one of the greatest male vocalists ever, he sounded like a cross between Lennon and Johnny Rotten from the sex pistols. But his voice kinda went to **** over the years.

Mint Sauce

Beady Eye is basically Oasis without Noel, or what Oasis were before Noel came along and fixed them.

Whats the Story Morning Glory and Definitely Maybe were two of the best albums from the 90's as far as Brit Pop was concerned. Turned on the end of 'Later' last night when Beady Eye was doing their closing song, was not impressed.

Hownowcow

Can Liam Gallagher influence music the way that Johnny Rotten and the Pistols did? No.

Nodin

i can't imagine anything less interesting

...I'd say theres more talent in the beady eye of me flute, tbh.

AllGunsBlazing

Liam's voice is shot. His singing has become so nasal that he sounds like zippy from rainbow.

mikom

Cathal Cloch wrote: »

Where's the 'I want to knock the teeth out of Liam Gallagher's head' option?

This is not a love song.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9BGi8u8BtaA

old hippy

Hilly Bill wrote: »

Apart from 2 or 3 songs, PIL were brutal. Beady eye are just as bad and wont trouble the top of the charts any time soon.

PIL in their heyday - First Issue & Metal Box - were essential. Jah Wobble's bass is unmistakeable and the influence of krautrock is impossible to ignore.

I reckon PIL's last good album was, er, "Album". You gotta love the lineup - Steve Vai, Bill Laswell, Ryuichi Sakamoto and Ginger Baker. And I'm sure when they appeared on TotP Don Lett's was larking about with them...

Welsh Megaman

When it comes to experimenting and exploring different styles of music, Liam is far more narrow-minded than Lydon.

Pil mix krautrock, dub, reggae and roots, punk and folk.

Liam likes Beatles derpa derp!

Now sit back and enjoy this magnificent record...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zN-GGeNPQEg

mikom

I heard Liam and Beady eye are set to appear on the x factor.
Edgy..........

Nodin

i can't imagine anything less interesting

mikom wrote: »

I heard Liam and Beady eye are set to appear on the x factor.
Edgy..........

Well, that sinus condition doesn't pay for itself....

--Kaiser--

Hownowcow wrote: »

Can Liam Gallagher influence music the way that Johnny Rotten and the Pistols did? No.

'Sex Pistols' and 'music' in the same sentence....snigger

Sir Gallagher

Liam Gallagher is the greatest cnut of all time.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4QR6u_9m5lY

gramar

why is this in after hours?

Beady eye are rubbish and Liam is a prick. I wish them all the worst and I won't be wasting anymore time on the subject.

Rented Mule

ArtSmart wrote: »

on later with jools. possible

Would love to see what would happen if he got Steve Vai to play guitar on the album.

Rented Mule

--Kaiser-- wrote: »

'Sex Pistols' and 'music' in the same sentence....snigger

Say what you want. They helped save rock and roll.

Flimbos

Had to laugh at Liam slagging off Daft Punk last week. He has form for this kind of rubbish, but this was a new low for him, piggybacking on someone else's success...

He made the headlines because of it though. Oh and wait, what a coincidence, it just so happens his band are releasing a new album next week :rolleyes:

Reamer Fanny

What's a PIL?

phelixoflaherty

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ylOCIP54PIQ

Nodin

i can't imagine anything less interesting

justryan wrote: »

What's a PIL?

It's not the beatles.

inmyday

Sir Gallagher wrote: »

Liam Gallagher is the greatest cnut of all time.
]

You seem lovely yourself Mr. Gallagher

anncoates

A derivative thick like Liam Gallagher could only dream of creating some of PIL's best work.

--Kaiser--

Rented Mule wrote: »

Say what you want. They helped save rock and roll.

By creating such abominable noise that real, talented musicians were motivated to make actual music?

JD DABA

--Kaiser-- wrote: »

By creating such abominable noise that real, talented musicians were motivated to make actual music?

OooOOooOh ... get 'er

Rented Mule

--Kaiser-- wrote: »

By creating such abominable noise that real, talented musicians were motivated to make actual music?

Taking it back to the basics.

Anything more than three chords and you're showing off.

SEPT 23 1989

Two great Irishmen

old hippy

--Kaiser-- wrote: »

By creating such abominable noise that real, talented musicians were motivated to make actual music?

Beauty is in the eye of the beholder and the Pistols were a beautiful and furious noise. I don't know if they "saved" rock and roll but they certainly re-wrote the rules.

--Kaiser--

old hippy wrote: »

Beauty is in the eye of the beholder and the Pistols were a beautiful and furious noise. I don't know if they "saved" rock and roll but they certainly re-wrote the rules.

Did they bollox. If they weren't controversial and didn't swear in interviews no one would ever have heard of them

mikom

--Kaiser-- wrote: »

Did they bollox. If they weren't controversial and didn't swear in interviews no one would ever have heard of them

Yeah.......... Oliver Reed was a shit actor..........

Rothko

i can't imagine anything less interesting

Rented Mule wrote: »

Say what you want. They helped save rock and roll.

No, they didn't. Rock and roll didn't saving.

Clemenza

Beady Eye are woeful

Noel is best shot of the lot of them