Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

Garda Reserve to Full-Time (see Moderator note in post#72)

  • 01-01-2012 6:52pm
    #1
    Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 102 ✭✭


    Hi all,

    Not sure if this is the right place to ask, however i've found some great infor from your comments. The question i want to ask is "as being a Garda Reserve, is there anyway of becoming a full-time member? Do you still have to wait to the Garda Recruitment to start?
    Sorry again if its not the right place to post, however all help thank you!!


«13

Comments

  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 272 ✭✭Loopie


    Hi there,

    There's no special way in for Reserves - they'll have to go through exactly the same process as anyone else looking to join up - aptitudes, interview & report writing, med and physical test. Of course being a reserve is something you can use in interview when talking about some experiences but there's no specific route for reserves.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,093 ✭✭✭ZoneAlarm


    Loopie wrote: »
    Hi there,

    There's no special way in for Reserves - they'll have to go through exactly the same process as anyone else looking to join up - aptitudes, interview & report writing, med and physical test. Of course being a reserve is something you can use in interview when talking about some experiences but there's no specific route for reserves.

    mmm. and you know this how ?? might i ask, as at the moment their is no recruitment for the full time, and nobody knows what is going to happen this year, look what has happened in the Uk, the police specials been in house recruited into the full time police force, so who is to say this wont happen here.

    Nothing is impossible !! so never say never.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 272 ✭✭Loopie


    zonealarm - you're absolutely right, that's the way it is now, but I'm not speculating about what may or may not happen.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,093 ✭✭✭ZoneAlarm


    Loopie wrote: »
    zonealarm - you're absolutely right, that's the way it is now, but I'm not speculating about what may or may not happen.

    Must have misinterpreted what you where typing so, as from what i was reading i was taking that reserves will never be in housed recruited.

    By the time recruitment starts again for the full timers some Reserve members would have had maybe 8/9 yrs service, ok they might not be up to speed on the paper work and some other stuff, but it would not take much to train them up, as they would be 100% more advanced than new recruits that's for sure.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,572 ✭✭✭msg11


    Too be honest with me joining the reserves it's for experience. Hopefully I will get into the full time, I know right at this moment in time that joining the reserves with the mind set of getting straight into the full time service, is not a mind set anyone should be in. Should you apply and be declined, it could cause heart break for people.

    So really look at your reasons for joining, for me it is for experience, an inside into the job and really looks like something I will enjoy even if I don't get paid for it. Plus there the added benefit for when I apply for the full time that I can say I have experience. Although I don't see it as a divine right for entry.


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,093 ✭✭✭ZoneAlarm


    Nothing is a divine right, but on the other hand, it would go a long way to knowing you where appreciated for been a member of AGS, dont ya think, nobody is saying that you will just go in, you would still have to do your training to bring you up to speed.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 50 ✭✭ghost86


    I think that if a reserve member where to goin the full time then surely he/she would not have to sit a medical or go through the background checks again as this would be a waste of time and money.
    So reserves would have the upperhand in that respect as opposed to a non reserve person when full time recruitment comes around again.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 15,127 ✭✭✭✭kerry4sam


    Mark37 wrote: »
    Hi all,

    Not sure if this is the right place to ask, however i've found some great infor from your comments. The question i want to ask is "as being a Garda Reserve, is there anyway of becoming a full-time member? Do you still have to wait to the Garda Recruitment to start?
    Sorry again if its not the right place to post, however all help thank you!!

    Hi Mark37,

    This didn't really belong in the thread it was originally posted in and to be fair, I think it deserved a thread of its' own. Let me know if you want the title of the thread changed.

    Thanks,
    kerry4sam


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 51 ✭✭blueforce


    Howdy all,

    Just thought I'd throw in my 2 cents as a serving reserve who wants to go onto join full time. Theres is nearly 1000 ( I think its actually around 974) serving reserves, plus many many more who are going through the stages of recruitment. I cant really speak for the panel and what will happen to them, but when recruitment does come back, I strongly believe that one of the requirements for entry will be that you will have to have been in the reserve. What I personally thing will happen is that recruitment will be done through an apprentice type scheme. As much training as possible done at local level and through your station, cuts out the need for Templemore really.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,093 ✭✭✭ZoneAlarm


    blueforce wrote: »
    Howdy all,

    Just thought I'd throw in my 2 cents as a serving reserve who wants to go onto join full time. Theres is nearly 1000 ( I think its actually around 974) serving reserves, plus many many more who are going through the stages of recruitment. I cant really speak for the panel and what will happen to them, but when recruitment does come back, I strongly believe that one of the requirements for entry will be that you will have to have been in the reserve. What I personally thing will happen is that recruitment will be done through an apprentice type scheme. As much training as possible done at local level and through your station, cuts out the need for Templemore really.

    Panel has well gone by the way side now, time frame for that would have well expired by now.


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 50 ✭✭footprints


    When recruitment does start again I dont believe it will consist solely of reserves and it'll be open to everyone providing you meet educational requirements etc,when reserve numbers reach 1300 it'll be too small a pool to pick from in my opinion.Take away serving reserves who are over age limit now,not many admittedly,those who will be by time recruitment starts again and those who Garda management think wouldnt be suitable for full time role..pool of people to pick from would be less than 1300.
    Reserve numbers could be at 1300 sometime next year but it'll be a good few years before full time force reaches 13,000 so reserves who are in late 20's or early 30's could be over age limit by time numbers drop to 13,000 and thats only maximum.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 51 ✭✭blueforce


    I don't think we'll ever see the sort of recruitment like we had a couple of years ago where there was nearly a new phase going down ever second week!! Id say with the budget cut backs and everything, recruitment will be very slow when it does come back. Maybe 150 going down every 6 months, could be completly wrong but its just what I think. I dont agree with recruiting more reserves as a way of bringing the numbers up either, everyone is getting a raw deal out of it. The public, the full time members and the reserves.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 50 ✭✭footprints


    blueforce wrote: »
    I don't think we'll ever see the sort of recruitment like we had a couple of years ago where there was nearly a new phase going down ever second week!! Id say with the budget cut backs and everything, recruitment will be very slow when it does come back. Maybe 150 going down every 6 months, could be completly wrong but its just what I think. I dont agree with recruiting more reserves as a way of bringing the numbers up either, everyone is getting a raw deal out of it. The public, the full time members and the reserves.

    I agree blueforce reserve or not there's not going to be many opportunities to get into full time,former ESRI economist today said we face ten years of austerity,if thats the case recruitment will be like the dodo!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 51 ✭✭blueforce


    They'll have to recruit at some stage in the future. Are you in the reserves footprints?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,093 ✭✭✭ZoneAlarm


    footprints wrote: »
    When recruitment does start again I dont believe it will consist solely of reserves and it'll be open to everyone providing you meet educational requirements etc,when reserve numbers reach 1300 it'll be too small a pool to pick from in my opinion.Take away serving reserves who are over age limit now,not many admittedly,those who will be by time recruitment starts again and those who Garda management think wouldnt be suitable for full time role..pool of people to pick from would be less than 1300.
    Reserve numbers could be at 1300 sometime next year but it'll be a good few years before full time force reaches 13,000 so reserves who are in late 20's or early 30's could be over age limit by time numbers drop to 13,000 and thats only maximum.

    If they did decide to go that route there is plenty to start them off, and as they are still recruiting for reserves cant see the problem, so if they did move them in to full time training, new reserves would be recruited imo.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 50 ✭✭ghost86


    Congradulations to Reserve Deputy Shervin Lalezary whos traffic stop led to the arrest of a suspect in the Hollywood area arson attacks.
    This story goes to show, in my opinion, that having a reserve police force is not a waste of time and money as some people in Ireland may think.

    http://www.nbclosangeles.com/news/local/Deputy-Arson-Suspect-Arrest-Hollywood-Fires--136587418.html


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,093 ✭✭✭ZoneAlarm


    Just goes to show that Reserves are committed over in the usa as they are in Ireland as member's of AGS.

    Keep up the good work lads / lassies


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 9 hobby bobby


    Speaking as a member of the Garda reserve for the past couple of years I just want to share my view. Recruitment to the full time should be through the Garda Reserves no exceptions. To suggest that Reserve members are too old or unsuitable for whatever reason is a nonsense. Every Garda reserve reading this knows exactly how tough it is to endure the process of recruiting, to training as a reserve and most of all walking through that door to the public office at the start of a shift and meet your unit. Regular members don't realise that you have already spent 8 hours at your normal job and are ready to step into line for whatever duties await. I am lucky that the majority of my experience with the units has been good. Although you have to know your place and looking for more powers is not my priority. My priority as a reserve is to support the full time members in whatever capacity I can. I joined the Garda reserve while under the age limit and now risk being too old to become a full member. I have had many correspondance with the Minister for Justice trying to unpick his views on the age and recruitment with little success. all I will say to any reserve member is don't lose heart at your age I believe that this will not be an issue by the time recruitment opens. One last thing to all reserves reading this post. When you do become full members, please remember when a reserve walks into the station to make them feel as welcome as possible. The reserve is here to stay people and its going to be the way forward to get into full time policing.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,778 ✭✭✭WilcoOut


    im with ya on that hobby bobby

    recruitment in the future for the fulltime should be exclusivly from the reserve ranks

    reserve members who show commitment, dedication and a good clean workin record should be brought into the college before anyone else

    i feel that giving up your free time to do such a tough job, and doing it well, should prove to managment that a reserve member is dedicated to the uniform and by going that bit extra he/she should earn the right to wear it fulltime


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 9 hobby bobby


    Your view wilc0out is one of many i am sure. There is no better probation for a job than doing that job and doing it for free. It shows commitment on your behalf and gives hands on experience. Most importantly management can see if you are suitable or not. How many full time garda regret going in to the job but are stuck now and feel like they have no option but to stay because they don't know what else to do? Logically, taking reserve police to fill gaps for full time positions is a no brainer and I will eat my hat if this is not the case when the time comes. When full time positions are created in the future and all positions are filled by reserve members it will help for many reasons. Firstly the reserve will be more accepted in the station as every member will know that being a reserve is a means to getting full time and I am sure this is the view of many members at present. Secondly when the public see the Reserve as the only means to get recruited there will be a flood of applications for the reserve. Thirdly the GRA will accept the reserve for its true purpose as a "filter for full time membership" If Public jobs advertised 150 garda positions in the morning they would probably get about 400,000 applications for those few jobs. can you imagine the waste of money, time and resources, filtering down 400,000 applications to 150 suitable canditates. Yet right now we still can't get 1300 reserve members due to lack of interest for the 5-6 years the reserve has been born. To all reserve members with any concerns or questions - let the minister for justice know you are there. Alan Shatter is an excellent Minister who is doing all he can right now in a very difficult position. Send him an email to remind him that you are a reserve member and he has your support and you are waiting for the call up.


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 50 ✭✭footprints


    im a medical away from becoming a reserve and my main aim is to join full time shock horror!but its important not to put all your eggs in one basket as above poster said you'll have 400,000 for 150 positions-my best mate is a reserve the only reason she's still there is to join full time,imo its a pity because if she doesnt get in she'll be heartbroken.
    I believe,my gut feeling, that in the future you will have to be reserve to join full time but that will only apply to future generations of reserves.comparing reserves to specials in uk is light and day they have been around decades and can patrol on their own with more powers afaik..that day will have to come for Reserves before in-house recruitment is considered.also just because UK went down that route doesnt mean we will..I mean we dont copy everything they do- voting system,currency etc.
    We might as well compare our police system to that of Canada as much as UK,just because UK is one of our nearest geographical police forces doesnt mean we will imitate their police recruitment policies.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,572 ✭✭✭msg11


    footprints wrote: »
    My best mate is a reserve the only reason she's still there is to join full time,imo its a pity because if she doesnt get in she'll be heartbroken.

    Most are joining too get into the full time, just most people are forgetting that you could be refused.

    As a matter of interest, if she or anyone who is a reserve is refused for the full time service. Would they just call it a day ? What there plan ?

    In house recruitment, is the policy in the company I am in. It works well because if you want to be a manager you have to start at the bottom and move up. There are Regional Area Managers that started out pushing trolleys.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 50 ✭✭footprints


    msg11 wrote: »
    Most are joining too get into the full time, just most people are forgetting that you could be refused.

    As a matter of interest, if she or anyone who is a reserve is refused for the full time service. Would they just call it a day ? What there plan ?

    Thats a good point some reserves do forget that they may well be refused and most will be refused because of the lack of recruitment..Yes,if my friend was told she wouldnt get into the full time she'd quit straight away whereas I know of reserves,not personally who aren't far off age limit or above age limit but they will remain in reserves regardless.
    Obviously,I dont know till I start,if I pass medical,but Id like to think that id remain in reserves because its helping the community even if I dont get into full time but I could end up having same attitude as my friend.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,093 ✭✭✭ZoneAlarm


    There is nothing in the rule book to say a Reserve Garda cannot be promoted to Garda, no different from been promoted from Garda to Sgt, it’s not in any legislation at the end of the day to say they can’t do that, it’s just the same as any big employer promoting from within the Company structure, and where best to start than someone that has experience of the job, and has been doing it for maybe the last 3 to 6 yrs, I know if I was picking someone best suited it would be in house.

    There is nothing also to get the age restriction changed, remember there is no rule that says age is a barrier in promotion from Reserve to Garda from Garda to Sgt, and with the pension structure set to change so might age, also is the retirement age not been pushed up to 70, as people are living longer and are more fitter as well.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 50 ✭✭footprints


    ZoneAlarm wrote: »
    There is nothing in the rule book to say a Reserve Garda cannot be promoted to Garda, no different from been promoted from Garda to Sgt, it’s not in any legislation at the end of the day to say they can’t do that, it’s just the same as any big employer promoting from within the Company structure, and where best to start than someone that has experience of the job, and has been doing it for maybe the last 3 to 6 yrs, I know if I was picking someone best suited it would be in house.

    There is nothing also to get the age restriction changed, remember there is no rule that says age is a barrier in promotion from Reserve to Garda from Garda to Sgt, and with the pension structure set to change so might age, also is the retirement age not been pushed up to 70, as people are living longer and are more fitter as well.

    I never said there was anything in rule book to say Reserve garda cant be 'promoted' to full time :confused:,as it stands there is an age barrier for reserve to become full timer along with everyone else -35.

    Retirement age isnt been pushed to 70--
    http://www.kildarestreet.com/wrans/?id=2011-09-21.1039.0&s=garda+retirement+age#g1040.0.q


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,093 ✭✭✭ZoneAlarm


    footprints wrote: »
    I never said there was anything in rule book to say Reserve garda cant be 'promoted' to full time :confused:,as it stands there is an age barrier for reserve to become full timer along with everyone else -35.

    Retirement age isnt been pushed to 70--
    http://www.kildarestreet.com/wrans/?id=2011-09-21.1039.0&s=garda+retirement+age#g1040.0.q

    Yes i know about the age restriction, that would not apply to internal promotion, that is what im trying to point out, the age restriction is 55 i think for reserves to join, so promoting within the ranks there is no age restriction that i know of.

    I was also speaking about the age limit outside the Garda remit to 70.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 50 ✭✭footprints


    ZoneAlarm wrote: »
    Yes i know about the age restriction, that would not apply to internal promotion, that is what im trying to point out

    Yes,it would still apply because you cant join full time if your over the age of 35...where did you hear or read that if your a Reserve and over age of 35 you can still gain entry to full time?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,093 ✭✭✭ZoneAlarm


    Thats not what i posted is it ?? what i posted is there is nothing written that says people who are Reserve members of AGS cannot be promoted within the rank structure, you show me anywhere where it says a person who is already a member of AGS is subject to age restriction to be promoted within.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 50 ✭✭footprints


    The bottom line is a reserve becoming a garda is not regarded as a promotion because he/she will have to apply for the job of Garda Trainee the same as a non garda reserve...if it was in house recruitment it would be regarded as promotion.I have rang Garda HQ in the past and age restriction applies to garda reserve as well,If you dont believe me ring yourself and let us know if you hear different


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,093 ✭✭✭ZoneAlarm


    footprints wrote: »
    The bottom line is a reserve becoming a garda is not regarded as a promotion because he/she will have to apply for the job of Garda Trainee the same as a non garda reserve...if it was in house recruitment it would be regarded as promotion.I have rang Garda HQ in the past and age restriction applies to garda reserve as well,If you dont believe me ring yourself

    Nobody knows what will change with this government, they are out to make a savings and cutting corners no matter what, if they can do in-house recruitment in the uk from specials to Constables, they can do it here no matter what Hq tell you or me, decisions are taken much higher up the food chain.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 50 ✭✭footprints


    ZoneAlarm wrote: »
    Nobody knows what will change with this government, they are out to make a savings and cutting corners no matter what, if they can do in-house recruitment in the uk from specials to Constables, they can do it here no matter what Hq tell you or me, decisions are taken much higher up the food chain.


    At present there is an age limit for reserves of 35 and you suggested in previous post there wasnt because you regarded it as 'promotion' which it clearly isnt,we'll agree to disagree.
    As a future reserve I'd love it to be solely in-house recruitment because your competing with about 1000 people instead of couple of hundred thousand but I'm not a person who just believes what he wants to believe.If your a reserve you'll argue all day for in house recruitment,if your a non reserve you'll argue all day for an open competition,that's simply it.In house recruitment if it ever happens is a long way off imo.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,093 ✭✭✭ZoneAlarm


    footprints wrote: »
    At present there is an age limit for reserves of 35 and you suggested in previous post there wasnt because you regarded it as 'promotion' which it clearly isnt,we'll agree to disagree.
    As a future reserve I'd love it to be solely in-house recruitment because your competing with about 1000 people instead of couple of hundred thousand but I'm not a person who just believes what he wants to believe.If your a reserve you'll argue all day for in house recruitment,if your a non reserve you'll argue all day for an open competition,that's simply it.In house recruitment if it ever happens is a long way off imo.

    There is no age restriction on Reserve garda joining only full time members.

    Conditions for Entry to the Garda Reserve

    Members of the Garda Reserve will serve on a voluntary unpaid basis and not as employees.

    Entry to the Garda Reserve is governed by the Garda Síochána (Reserve Members) Regulations, 2006.
    The Garda Commissioner may not recruit a person for admission as a reserve trainee unless the following requirements are met:
    (1) the Garda Commissioner is satisfied that the person is of good character;
    (2) the person, for the purposes of paragraph (3), supplies to a registered medical practitioner nominated by the Garda Commissioner a medical certificate in such form as that practitioner may determine, detailing the person’s medical history for the previous 5 years;
    (3) the person is certified by that registered medical practitioner to be in good health, of sound constitution and fitted physically and mentally to perform the duties of a reserve member;
    (4) the person is not less than 18, but under 60, years of age when commencing the prescribed training;


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 62 ✭✭P.C.Plod


    There is no age restrictions for reserves. Well its different to full time. As alarmzone stated above. I have friends that joined and where too old for full time. They wanted the experience and love it. Regret everyday they didn't apply for full time


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 50 ✭✭footprints


    ZoneAlarm wrote: »
    There is no age restriction on Reserve garda joining only full time members.

    Conditions for Entry to the Garda Reserve

    Members of the Garda Reserve will serve on a voluntary unpaid basis and not as employees.

    Entry to the Garda Reserve is governed by the Garda Síochána (Reserve Members) Regulations, 2006.
    The Garda Commissioner may not recruit a person for admission as a reserve trainee unless the following requirements are met:
    (1) the Garda Commissioner is satisfied that the person is of good character;
    (2) the person, for the purposes of paragraph (3), supplies to a registered medical practitioner nominated by the Garda Commissioner a medical certificate in such form as that practitioner may determine, detailing the person’s medical history for the previous 5 years;
    (3) the person is certified by that registered medical practitioner to be in good health, of sound constitution and fitted physically and mentally to perform the duties of a reserve member;
    (4) the person is not less than 18, but under 60, years of age when commencing the prescribed training;

    What's your point??
    Thats conditions for entry to Garda Reserve,our debate was whether or not age limit of 35 applies to reserves applying for full time.Age limit of 35 still applies to everybody applying for full time.I told you to ring Garda HQ if you wanted verification of that fact but you ignored it.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 62 ✭✭P.C.Plod


    footprints wrote: »
    What's your point??
    Thats conditions for entry to Garda Reserve,our debate was whether or not age limit of 35 applies to reserves applying for full time.Age limit of 35 still applies to everybody applying for full time.I told you to ring Garda HQ if you wanted verification of that fact but you ignored it.

    I misread, thought you were saying you cant join reserves if you are over 35.
    Age limit of 35 applies to everyone applying to full time position. Being a reserve as it stands makes you no different to anybody else.
    Same rules and same process applies to everyone that wants to join


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 50 ✭✭footprints


    Exactly PCPlod,this debate started when ZA said there was no age restriction for the 'promotion' of reserve to full timer but as you said also there is.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 383 ✭✭bluetop


    footprints wrote: »
    At present there is an age limit for reserves of 35 and you suggested in previous post there wasnt because you regarded it as 'promotion' which it clearly isnt,we'll agree to disagree.

    My take on your post would be that you are saying there is an age limit for reserves clearly this is not true from other posts above


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 9 hobby bobby


    I can see the point Zonealarm is making Garda Reserve is the lowest rank of AGS - but garda reserve is a rank in AGS structure so technically all reserve members are looking for promotion in rank, even though a reserve may still have to win this promotion through open competition via public jobs the reserve is a member of AGS. Any reserve member under 35 years when joining AGS and now over 35 I think would have a good argument with regards to still being able to apply for full time. I have asked this question to the minister and he won't confirm or deny this issue.. what he did say was that in 2006 legislation was introduced to allow public appointments to give favour to any reserve member with satisfactory service done. It's a bit vague but it's hope.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,778 ✭✭✭WilcoOut



    what he did say was that in 2006 legislation was introduced to allow public appointments to give favour to any reserve member with satisfactory service done. It's a bit vague but it's hope.

    its a step in the right direction

    Reserve Gardai have earned the right to become a fulltime member more than anyone

    and they should be rewarded in the future


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 50 ✭✭footprints


    bluetop wrote: »
    My take on your post would be that you are saying there is an age limit for reserves clearly this is not true from other posts above


    Yes,but if you look back at previous page ZA said there was no age barrier for Reserve becoming full timer and I replied there clearly is.That post of mine that you quoted does appear incorrect but in context of that debate is correct.Its old news now anyway..time to move on from it,worn out at this stage.


  • Advertisement
  • Posts: 18,749 ✭✭✭✭ [Deleted User]


    i dont believe for one minute that future recruits to An Garda Siochana should come only from the Garda Reserve!
    to exclude hundreds of thousands of people just because they were not/ could not be a member of the reserve is crazy!!

    everyone, ordinary civilians and reserves should go through the same application procedure, obviously the fact that someone had served in the reserve would be a major advantage to them. i dont believe that just because someone could not be a member of the reserve should stand in their way, in any way, to applying for a full time position.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,778 ✭✭✭WilcoOut


    thats why you will hve to become a reserve member to become a fulltime member

    you will have to give up your time voluntary to assist the fultimers for a period and earn the right to wear that uniform, just like reserves have done already

    i think it will attract a better candidate


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 9 hobby bobby


    I must strongly disagree with you bubbly pop but welcome to this discussion. Garda Reserve program is a ready made filter process for pending full time selection and every Garda Reserve "in my opinion" has won the right to be considered ahead of any other. The quality of Garda reserve recruit has " in my opinion " also got stronger due to the quality of applicants who now see the reserve role as the best route forward. What i mean by this is that initially older people would have joined the reserve with no chance of full time option But the age of recruit now is probably average mid 20s. Prior to the set up of the Garda Reserve I would strongly agree with you but not anymore. But you may be right who knows


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 383 ✭✭bluetop


    bubblypop wrote: »
    i dont believe for one minute that future recruits to An Garda Siochana should come only from the Garda Reserve!
    to exclude hundreds of thousands of people just because they were not/ could not be a member of the reserve is crazy!!

    everyone, ordinary civilians and reserves should go through the same application procedure, obviously the fact that someone had served in the reserve would be a major advantage to them. i dont believe that just because someone could not be a member of the reserve should stand in their way, in any way, to applying for a full time position.

    And what is stopping you and the others that are on the panel from getting of there rear end and joining, people that have joined the reserves to me have taken the initiative and actually done something, and have not sat on there behinds doing nothing, so i would also be of the opinion that they should have the first crack of the whip.

    It works out at 4 measly hrs a week, are you telling me you and the rest of them sitting on their hands cant commit to this, load of bull, i do hope people in the know are reading this ask these people the same question, and i also think that the people on the panel that are sitting on their arses reading this do get left behind in place of the serving reserves, that are doing a great job out their, that are doing the walk and not the talk they are doing in here.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 50 ✭✭footprints


    When there is a recruitment campaign in a few years and say they look for 300 people,they aren't going to take in 300 Reserves put them through the full time course and at same time recruit 300 reserves to replace ones that entered full time.Some reserves will be successful as will non reserves.
    The Govt. or AGS have never even suggested in house recruitment,some reserves on boards point to the UK for their hope of in house recruitment but choose to forget specials have been in existence there for decades,have more powers,can patrol on their own.If we are going to be same as UK should reserves not be around for decades and have more powers?Reserves have only been here a few years.
    Im joining reserves as I hope it will help me join full time but it wont be a reserve only competition.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 383 ✭✭bluetop


    Ok first off how long does it take to train a Reserve, and how long does it take to train a full timer, so yes they could take 300 in from the reserves, remember some of these have some training under their belt some with up to 6 yrs on the job training, now take a new guy no training whatsoever, no on the job training who is going to take longer to train.

    So they could easily take 300 in from reserves, and still manage to train 300 more on weekends like they are doing now, by the time they are trained the first lot of 300 will only be in their first year, the new reserves will be on the street in on the job training so to speak, so its so so simple, it was done before the moratorium, with no problems and could recommence in the morning should they so wish

    Regardless of whether it has been suggested is that an obstacle for them nope its not, and because something in the Uk has been there for years or not means nothing, as for more powers, that is in the pipe line for this year, so changes are a foot, so nothing is written in stone, anything can happen between now and the start of recruitment in prob early 2015


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 50 ✭✭footprints


    The duration of the new training course and expense will be the same whether you are a reserve or not...I cant see financially how they will have the funding at the same time for the training of 300 reserves to replace the 300 former reserves in the college now training for full time,that's just my opinion.
    Also,I cant see new powers for reserves this year because when I was onto garda reserve office I asked that very same question..they weren't aware of any new powers(not ruling it out or in) but said training course for this year would be the same.Surely,if new powers were to be introduced this year training course would change to reflect that.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 18 ais2012


    footprints wrote: »
    The duration of the new training course and expense will be the same whether you are a reserve or not...I cant see financially how they will have the funding at the same time for the training of 300 reserves to replace the 300 former reserves in the college now training for full time,that's just my opinion.
    Also,I cant see new powers for reserves this year because when I was onto garda reserve office I asked that very same question..they weren't aware of any new powers(not ruling it out or in) but said training course for this year would be the same.Surely,if new powers were to be introduced this year training course would change to reflect that.

    Hi!!!
    Im a reserve. The word down in templemore is we are getting powers under the public order act, iv a friend that was down a few weeks ago and he was told by the training officer.
    Problem is we have no powers at the minute for public order which is ridiculous as most of us work when its busy (e.g. Saturday nights!!) if something goes wrong we can only arrest under sec.4 of criminal justice act which is basically a citizens arrest!!!! useless! so they've no choice really.
    Also.... they've started doing phase2 over a 2week period. so your basically in the college for two weeks straight. Thank god that wasn't in when i was training because i work full time.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 50 ✭✭footprints


    ais2012 wrote: »
    Hi!!!
    Im a reserve. The word down in templemore is we are getting powers under the public order act, iv a friend that was down a few weeks ago and he was told by the training officer.
    Problem is we have no powers at the minute for public order which is ridiculous as most of us work when its busy (e.g. Saturday nights!!) if something goes wrong we can only arrest under sec.4 of criminal justice act which is basically a citizens arrest!!!! useless! so they've no choice really.
    Also.... they've started doing phase2 over a 2week period. so your basically in the college for two weeks straight. Thank god that wasn't in when i was training because i work full time.


    Thanks for that info,hope Reserves do get powers!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 51 ✭✭blueforce


    Recruitment opens back up to everyone. First question from the interviewers mouth is,

    "Did you join the Reserve?" Yes..........great, how did you handle this, this and this.

    "Did you join the Reserve?"No........ "Why?".........................................

    Can anyone who hopes to join full time and is not in the reserve answer fill in the blank above. Better to do it here then sitting infront of a Super and a civil servant.

    ais2012, are you sure they are doing phase 2 over a 2 week period? The cost to the college would be huge seeing as they'll have to feed everyone and also I dont think anyone would be willing to go down for that long if they have a full time job.


  • Advertisement
Advertisement