upc users

Shammy

Mods i am posting this here as it has to do with online gaming .

For those who are with upc i need to ask a favour .

My broadband provider is a small company with about 5,000 customers , the quality of their broadband is top notch (anyone who has been in my room will agree). The one problem is if you are with upc you will only have 1.2 bars to me as you go to the States before you come back to me. My provider has written many e-mails asking upc to peer with them but so far upc have failed to comply.

The favour i'm asking is that you a upc customer , e-mail a complaint to upc asking them why they wont peer to bbnet (munster broadband) as it is effecting your online gaming .

Thanks.

see http://www.boards.ie/vbulletin/showthread.php?t=2056099653

Leeg17

I don't have UPC but if I get it I'll sent them a mail.

everlast75

Good luck with that Shammy!

My experience with ISPs has been nothing but hearbreak... I've only one choice and that's Errorcom. They'll be prising the controller out of my cold, dead hand before I get to see NGB.

Balfie

I done what ya said, on the other thread, tested my speed test with the Limerick server and this is what I got.



Compared to Dublin



*Note, my ping isn't normally at 75, its normally at around 25-35 I'm currently loading a youtube video.. but to get 225 to the Limerick Server is disgusting.

Shammy

Balfie wrote: »

I done what ya said, on the other thread, tested my speed test with the Limerick server and this is what I got.



Compared to Dublin



*Note, my ping isn't normally at 75, its normally at around 25-35 I'm currently loading a youtube video.. but to get 225 to the Limerick Server is disgusting.

Its disgraceful , i'm hoping if upc get a good few e-mail complaints then they will agree to peer.

Balfie

This is what I got off the Cork Server



And Galway



I'm afraid to try any more to be honest... Haha

Balfie

141_Oscar_Mike wrote: »

Dubland.

You got the 100meg BB??? Well Jealous!!!

Balfie

141_Oscar_Mike wrote: »

I wish! Thats definitely an error. :P

More like this

Haha I was looking into getting the 100meg, 85 euro a month, I'd love that if I could get it.. Downloads youtube videos in less than a second.. haha

docdolittle

Wow, that sucks...

Jet Black

Hey, have you tried contacting the UPC rep on boards? Might get a better response. No harm in trying. UPC:JASON

Shammy

Jet Black wrote: »

Hey, have you tried contacting the UPC rep on boards? Might get a better response. No harm in trying. UPC:JASON

The best option is sending a complaint in by e-mail , the more complaints they receive the more chance something can be done.

Jet Black

Aright. I've sent a complaint nyway and there was a survey on the site when I logged in so I said the same again. Good luck.

matt-dublin

Can you give me an ip address on your network and I will check the routing?

It would be highly unlikely that UPC would route to us then back.

Who is your broadband provider pairing with?

Shammy

See the link in the first post , follow that thread , there are tracert results on it.
Also you will see the peering matrix and see how little upc have peered with other companies.

sierra117x

Sent an email there tonight . No response although it's late on a Friday so expected

tommy_irish23

sent an email also last night

gimli2112

I have eircom ngb which generally works fine. Was playing on my bros' console this weekend and he has UPC. The lag was awful in comparison imo. Maybe cos I was getting picked as host but there was a noticeable difference.

matt-dublin

I would say thats the ip flood detection. Had a huge impact on mine. Also make sure he's not using bittorrent at the same time as that destroys cod!

Enigma IE

The problem is basically down to UPC's strict peering policy, they don't peer with single-homed ISP's, which MunsterBB are.

Shammy

They have their wires crossed here. BBnet don't want to provide them transit to the Internet, nor do they want to get internet access from them. If anything bbnet just want to exchange routes so that bbnet customers and upc customers can get a better service.
What has a dual homed internet connection requirement go to do with that. They don't know what they are talking about.

sierra117x

has anyone gotten any sort of reply from this ? i didnt even get the usual response of email recieved going to blah blah blah to be looked by blah blah

matt-dublin

I would suggest BBNET log a call with inex.

from the letter above UPC are willing to prepare via inex but not directly.

the inex matrix shows that BBNET is a member of inex and so us upc but they're nor pairing, this could be due to advertisements on either network (stated at the bottom of the inex matrix page (https://www.inex.ie/technical/peeringmatrix)

it also suggest that because both providers are members of inex the capability is there to peer but could be something like a BGP password sharing issue or general fault.

I think due to the fact that you're residential customers and MBB/BBNET are residential only that the end user will have a hard time convincing them to change.

My suggestion here would be if anyone has a large corporate account with UPC to log a call stating that shammy is a home business user and is experiencing extremem latency issues due to the routing tables due to a peering fault at inex whereby subnets are not being directly advertised between network.

I've sent a mail to my SPs to see if there's any contacts they might have that might be able to assist in escelating this problem but again i don't expect to get anywhere.

This problem really is between MBB/BBNET and UPC so its up to them to fight it out. All we can really do is to make noise.

Enigma IE

Shammy wrote: »

They have their wires crossed here. BBnet don't want to provide them transit to the Internet, nor do they want to get internet access from them. If anything bbnet just want to exchange routes so that bbnet customers and upc customers can get a better service.
What has a dual homed internet connection requirement go to do with that. They don't know what they are talking about.

My understanding of the situation is this:

• MunsterBB have a single-homed connection to the internet via wholesale provider Cogentco. Cogentco dictate the routing over their circuit.
• MunsterBB are part of BBNet, this allows them to piggyback on any peering arrangements BBnet have through INEX.
• Although both BBnet & UPC are members of INEX, but they do not peer with each other.
• Feedback from INEX tells me that UPC have a very strict peering policy, they only peer with providers who have dual-homed link to the internet, this is what UPC say in the letter.
• BBnet peer with Digiweb & Eircom (among others), through INEX, but UPC refuse to peer with them unless they take out a second internet circuit through another provider.

Where to from here? I'm not sure how much more us end-users can do unfortunately.

Enigma IE

matt-dublin wrote: »

I would suggest BBNET log a call with inex.

from the letter above UPC are willing to prepare via inex but not directly.

the inex matrix shows that BBNET is a member of inex and so us upc but they're nor pairing, this could be due to advertisements on either network (stated at the bottom of the inex matrix page (https://www.inex.ie/technical/peeringmatrix)

it also suggest that because both providers are members of inex the capability is there to peer but could be something like a BGP password sharing issue or general fault.

I think due to the fact that you're residential customers and MBB/BBNET are residential only that the end user will have a hard time convincing them to change.

My suggestion here would be if anyone has a large corporate account with UPC to log a call stating that shammy is a home business user and is experiencing extremem latency issues due to the routing tables due to a peering fault at inex whereby subnets are not being directly advertised between network.

I've sent a mail to my SPs to see if there's any contacts they might have that might be able to assist in escelating this problem but again i don't expect to get anywhere.

This problem really is between MBB/BBNET and UPC so its up to them to fight it out. All we can really do is to make noise.

INEX can't tell UPC what do to, they simply facilitate peering for companies who want to do it, UPC's peering policy means they won't peer with MunsterBB.

matt-dublin

no but they may be able to initiate discussion between the two.

the ins and outs of what UPCs answr is that they're saying 'these boys aren't big enough to play in our playground'

Shammy

Enigma IE wrote: »

Where to from here? I'm not sure how much more us end-users can do unfortunately.

I think your right , you have done all in your power and basically upc has a strict peering policy. Like i said before bbnet is made up of 3 companies with a customer base of 5,000 , which is growing. In an online gaming sense as you know yourself , if upc users are in a lobby with a bbnet customer then the chance of a upc host is rare, meaning like the other night upc customers have a huge latenacy problem.

matt-dublin wrote: »

the ins and outs of what UPCs answr is that they're saying 'these boys aren't big enough to play in our playground'

Pretty much sums it up .

Enigma IE

matt-dublin wrote: »

the ins and outs of what UPCs answr is that they're saying 'these boys aren't big enough to play in our playground'

Shammy wrote: »

Pretty much sums it up .

There is nothing in it for UPC unless MunsterBB buy one of their circuits. The commercial reality unfortunately.

Shammy

Enigma IE wrote: »

There is nothing in it for UPC unless MunsterBB buy one of their circuits. The commercial reality unfortunately.

Or the flip side of the coin , danger is switching from upc for munster broadband

hightower1

Shammy wrote: »

if upc users are in a lobby with a bbnet customer then the chance of a upc host is rare .

Thats not really the case. If a lobby is made up of 10 people - 1 from BBnet and 1 from UPC and the game will look at who has the best connection to everyonelse. For theroies sake say the game only has a choice of the bbnet user or the UPC user then it wont care if they dont have a good connection to each other as thats only 1 out of a possible 8 to test.

If the upc user has a better connection to the other 8 folks than the bbnet user then it will pick him as host and then bump the bbnet user off to another lobby. The situation would happen vice versa if the bbnet user had a better average connection to the remaining 8 but in fairness with the size of bbnet vs UPC in all reality the UPC user would have a better connection most of the time.

The only realistic time where a bbnet user would be picked as host over a UPC user is when the majority of the lobby had better ping to bbnet than upc network , based on the sheer size of networks alone then it looks like bbnet users are fresh out of luck?

Enigma IE

Shammy wrote: »

Or the flip side of the coin , danger is switching from upc for munster broadband

Do they do TV and landline also? If so, I'm there !

Shammy

hightower1 wrote: »

Thats not really the case. If a lobby is made up of 10 people - 1 from BBnet and 1 from UPC and the game will look at who has the best connection to everyonelse. For theroies sake say the game only has a choice of the bbnet user or the UPC user then it wont care if they dont have a good connection to each other as thats only 1 out of a possible 8 to test.

If the upc user has a better connection to the other 8 folks than the bbnet user then it will pick him as host and then bump the bbnet user off to another lobby. The situation would happen vice versa if the bbnet user had a better average connection to the remaining 8 but in fairness with the size of bbnet vs UPC in all reality the UPC user would have a better connection most of the time.

The only realistic time where a bbnet user would be picked as host over a UPC user is when the majority of the lobby had better ping to bbnet than upc network , based on the sheer size of networks alone then it looks like bbnet users are fresh out of luck?

Actually your wrong , bbnet users have a better quality broadband , lower ping rates and a much better connection to other providers , with the exception of upc , (see peering matrix).
Like the other night with a party of 6 , 4 of whom were upc customers but yet i was host . And the same goes for any other upc customers that i've played with , they dont get to host.