Irish Comedians: Your Best and worst

barbaraw19

Best
Dylan Moran, Dara O'Brian,Jarlaith Regan, David O'Doherty, Maeve Higgins, Jimmy Carr ( Limerick born so he's are!!)

Worst
Des Bishop ( You seriously needs some new material ) That heating emersion joke is getting old!Ed Byrne, Andrew Maxwell, Tommy Tiernan, Joe Rooney
Brendan Grace, Dave McSavage

Yours thoughts pls!!!

Zaph

I like Tommy Tiernan, but he's been on tv so much you don't need to go to a gig to have seen the whole act. I'd also add Jason Byrneto the best list, although anytime I see him I always get the feeling that he's forgotten to take his medication.

barbaraw19

Oh yeah jason byrne. Forgot about him. Liked the show anonymous. Never seen him live though. I'd imagine he'd be good.

Tommy tiernan: Miss!!! Too many jokes centred around religion. I couldn't listen to that accent for long funny man or not.

damnyanks

Really dislike that american guy who was raised here. He isn't horribly unfunny, but he sure isnt funny. His jokes are all pretty much "I'm american, Ireland..."

timisaprick

Alot of people in your worst section are probely my favorites except Des Bishop + Dave McSavage but I also love Dara O' Brien and ton more just can't remember there names lol

lady_j

Best : Dylan Moran

Worst: DARA O BRIEN and Jason Byrne

Des Bishop isnt irish

Dave Mc Savage is a jumped up busker

and Tommy teirnan used to be funny be he never really developed his act

ClareBear

Best for me would be Tommy Tiernan....and I've gone from thinking Jason Byrne was a big weirdo to thinking he's a really funny big weirdo.

Worst Ed Byrne. I don't think he was ever funny but he's getting worse if that's possible. Surely they could find someone better for the Panel.

AlmightyCushion

Karl Spain for the worst list. The only thing he says is "I've been single now for a bout 3 stone" or whatever. Yeah it was funny the first time I heard it but get some new material. Dylan Moran for the best list for sure the man is completely insane. Black books was absolutely brilliant and his stand up show monster (think that was the name correct me if I'm wrong) was great too.

hoooooooot

dnt like jason byrne, the best are tommy tiernan dara o briain and podge nd rodge if they count!

BeatNikDub

I would recommend people to not judge Jason by his tv shows. Go see him live and you will leave with sore cheeks from the laughter.
The man is mad - MAD!
Oh and dont sit near or at the front.

Tommy Tiernan used to be one of my favourites but i think his act has gone downhill since moving stateside.
He will be back later this year playing gigs though so i will still go and see him back here again.

Dylan Moran has to come out on top for Black Books alone.

And big ups to PJ for going from a support act to Jason Byrne 5 or 6 years agao to having his own show which gets better every season. Jake Stephens - nuff said.

Dont forget the Cat Laughs in Kilkenny! Acts announced 2th April!!!

If Bill Bailey was irish he would be in this list also.

Oh the apres match lads too. Show is hilarious but the chap who does the german character is brilliant "it was outrageous like a malfunction" Have seen this live at a stand up gig and one of the best laughs ive had.

Ginny

Love Neil Delamare and Colin whatshisface from the panel, and obviously Dylan Moran and suprisingly enough Dara O'Briens DVD is very good this year, oh and David O'Doherty.

Hate Hate Tommy Tiernan and Jason Byrne.

Sabre0001

Like: Andrew Maxwell, Neil Delamare, Colin Murphy, Dara O'B, Dylan Moran, David O'Doherty
Dislike: Maeve Higgins, Jason Byrne, Tommy Tiernan, Ed Byrne


Pauline McGlynn (sp?) falls in the middle - great in Fr. Ted, decent on The Panel...don't think she counts as out and out comedian though (hence the middle, otherwise like)

CherieAmour

descry wrote:

Des Bishop isnt irish

Here here!!!!! He proved as much when I saw him in England and he proceeded to slag us off to the British for a full 40 minutes to rapturous applause - famine jokes included - any Irish person would know why this was wrong.

I like Dylan Moran myself, Dave McSavage is an insult to the word 'comedian' and Ed Byrne? Well ?!?!?!?!?!?!?! Deirdre O'Kane doesn't really do anything for me either.

I heard a lot of good things about Jason Byrne but I saw him on the Royal Variety Performance and he didn't go down well at all. Maybe it was nerves or something??

PJ Gallagher gets my number 1 vote!

I do find that the people doing stand up in the Ha'penny Bridge Inn are more likely to reduce me to tears (in a good sense) rather than those who seem to have managed to make a name for themselves as 'comedians'...there are often really funny people hidden away at open mics and the like...pity, those who deserve to be up there aren't.

daiixi

Best would have to be Jimeoin! He so funneh.

SuperSean11

Worst has to be Ed Byrne I like Jimmy Carr and Andrew Maxwel but he needs new material

AnonoBoy

Nobody in the world likes Dave McSavage.

Remember a few years back his Ma tried to have him killed. Now *that* I laughed at.

G'wan Mrs. McSavage!

Karl Hungus

I have to say, Kevin McAleer is an absolute genius of a comedian. Quite possibly one of the finest Ireland has to offer, and he just doesn't get any of the recognition he deserves.

I'd seriously recommend everyone to see his stand-up, it's just brilliant in the kind of wandering story / surreal absurdity kinda way.

Des Bishop is easily the worst.

lady_j

Karl Hungus wrote:

I have to say, Kevin McAleer is an absolute genius of a comedian. Quite possibly one of the finest Ireland has to offer, and he just doesn't get any of the recognition he deserves.

Yeah I went to see him last week, by chance (won tickets) and he was hilarious. Highly reccomend

grahamo

I saw Dara O'Brian stand up show. Really funny! Ardal O'Hanlon was V. good too.
Worst is probably Tommy Tiernan. He's only got one joke, Slagging off the church............its not funny anymore!

Ladilia

Best: Tommy Tiernan (surprised alot of people don't like him..), Ardal O Hanlon, PJ Gallagher, Jason Byrne, Neil Delamare, Dylan Moran (legend!!) Dara O' Briain, Deirdre O Kane, David O Doherty.

Worst: Ed Byrne (the definition of s**t), Des Bishop (even though he isn't irish but i hate him anyway) Brendan Grace.

pikachucheeks

I'd definitely agree that Dylan Moran is the best.
He's hilarious,and Black Books with Bill Bailey is brilliant.
I know Bill Bailey isn't Irish,but he's my favourite comedian right now.
As for Des Bishop?-I never thought he was funny,same goes for Brendan Grace.
I've seen a bit of Tommy Tiernan on tv ; Some of the material was funny but I don't like the way he has to resort to shouting and swearing to make a joke.

He's an up-and-comer, but Paddy Courtney gets my vote. He did the intro for Podge & Rodge at Vicar Street, very funny.

Dark Artist

Tommy Tiernan and Neil Delamere (or hower u spell it) are my top picks at the moment.

The worst has to be Ed Byrne. That guy makes me cringe every time.... literally pianfull to watch, sorry mate.

I think Des Bishop is quite funny actually. He's no Tommy but he's definitely no Ed.

ambasite

Kevin McAleer, the best by far, his slots on Nighthawks(?) were fantastic.

OPENROAD

barbaraw19 wrote:

Best
Dylan Moran, Dara O'Brian,Jarlaith Regan, David O'Doherty, Maeve Higgins, Jimmy Carr ( Limerick born so he's are!!)

Worst
Des Bishop ( You seriously needs some new material ) That heating emersion joke is getting old!Ed Byrne, Andrew Maxwell, Tommy Tiernan, Joe Rooney
Brendan Grace, Dave McSavage

Yours thoughts pls!!!

Des Bishop is American.

Dylan Moran - you haven't seen anything until you've seen him live in person.

Worst, for me, is Ed Byrne and Tommy Tiernan. Hate his jokes.

SlinkyToo

Worst - Any Comedian who releases a DVD for Xmas. A little tip, if you are going to publicise a DVD, at least show clips with jokes in it.

Prime example - PJ Gallagher talking about dating... it was funny when Bob Monkhouse did it in the 50s.

View Profile

Best: Jimmy Carr
Worst: Ed Byrne

SlinkyToo

Jimmy Carr is a comedian?

fullstop

Best- David O' Doherty, Tommy Tiernan, Dara O' Briain, Jimmy carr

Worst - Neil Delamere, Neil delamere and Neil Delamere

SlinkyToo

Interesting how Jimmy Carr is liked over here... he is universally hated in the UK.

He would appear at the opening of a paperbag just to get his face on telly.