Waterford GAA Thread - Mod note post #1

PTH2009 · 20-10-2020 10:38pm

Stephen Bennett the obvs free replacement but Cahill might have other plans

7/10 views from Waterford supporters is Maurice should be in the panel but Cahill has his plan and he doesn't feature ?

Alf Tupper · 20-10-2020 11:08pm

Good luck to Paudie on his retirement, he gave great service. What happened to him against Ballyduff was sheer thuggery.

But to rate Paudie as a big loss is crazy, especially from general play. At his best he always lacked the pace and the cut and thrust of a really top class forward. Great from frees when there was no pressure but questionable from crucial scoreable frees. The one he missed from forty yards against Kilkenny in Thurles was just awful, not an aberration. He followed it up the following year by missing a similar one and five more for Ballygunner in a Munster final. Also, couldn't step up and take a 21 or a penalty like Kelly or Flynn.

I'd love to see his scores per game from play over his years with Waterford compared to the really great Waterford forwards.

He is not a Liam Cahill type of player. He has never worked hard enough in the way Cahill wants his forwards to work. Swanning around hanging loose, swooping around his midfielders or other half forwards looking for hand passes to pop over handy points is not the Cahill way.

Personally, I think he went before he was pushed.

Thanks again for the service Paudie but now there's great chance for a forward to step up.

JeffKenna · 20-10-2020 11:16pm

I dunno, being honest in the last few years I never saw him as a 9/10 free taker. Thinking back to the all Ireland final and one straight in front of the posts he missed when we badly needed it to stay in the game.

Great servant though and was particularly hard done by the year he was injured.

mountgomery burns · 20-10-2020 11:55pm

Alf Tupper wrote: »

Good luck to Paudie on his retirement, he gave great service. What happened to him against Ballyduff was sheer thuggery.

But to rate Paudie as a big loss is crazy, especially from general play. At his best he always lacked the pace and the cut and thrust of a really top class forward. Great from frees when there was no pressure but questionable from crucial scoreable frees. The one he missed from forty yards against Kilkenny in Thurles was just awful, not an aberration. He followed it up the following year by missing a similar one and five more for Ballygunner in a Munster final. Also, couldn't step up and take a 21 or a penalty like Kelly or Flynn.

I'd love to see his scores per game from play over his years with Waterford compared to the really great Waterford forwards.

He is not a Liam Cahill type of player. He has never worked hard enough in the way Cahill wants his forwards to work. Swanning around hanging loose, swooping around his midfielders or other half forwards looking for hand passes to pop over handy points is not the Cahill way.

Personally, I think he went before he was pushed.

Thanks again for the service Paudie but now there's great chance for a real brave forward to step up.

Well, at least you don't have an axe to grind anyway...

Must have stole your bird at some stage

Billy Ocean · 21-10-2020 12:44am

DLS2THECORE wrote: »

Waterford played Wexford late last week
Lineout was as follows

SOK
Shane Fives
Conor Prunty
Shane McNulty
Darragh Fives
Tadhg De Burca
Kevin Moran
Callum Lyons
Jamie Barron
Jack Fagan
Austin Gleeson
Kieran Bennett
Dessie Hutchinson
Stephen Bennett
Pauric Mahony

Wexford won this game. Pauric Mahony forced off with an injury ( not thought to be serious )

No word on the Wexford team by any chance?

Gardner · 21-10-2020 9:05am

Alf Tupper wrote: »

Good luck to Paudie on his retirement, he gave great service. What happened to him against Ballyduff was sheer thuggery.

But to rate Paudie as a big loss is crazy, especially from general play. At his best he always lacked the pace and the cut and thrust of a really top class forward. Great from frees when there was no pressure but questionable from crucial scoreable frees. The one he missed from forty yards against Kilkenny in Thurles was just awful, not an aberration. He followed it up the following year by missing a similar one and five more for Ballygunner in a Munster final. Also, couldn't step up and take a 21 or a penalty like Kelly or Flynn.

I'd love to see his scores per game from play over his years with Waterford compared to the really great Waterford forwards.

He is not a Liam Cahill type of player. He has never worked hard enough in the way Cahill wants his forwards to work. Swanning around hanging loose, swooping around his midfielders or other half forwards looking for hand passes to pop over handy points is not the Cahill way.

Personally, I think he went before he was pushed.

Thanks again for the service Paudie but now there's great chance for a real brave forward to step up.

anyway i think Aussie will start at 11 and be used as a roaming 11. Bennett all day on the frees.

whiteandblue · 21-10-2020 9:08am

Very disappointing for our young minor hurlers & footballers who probably started trials and training almost 12 months ago to have their championship called off at such short notice. Also have to feel for management who have tried to keep the show on the road during all this time. Hopefully it is only a postponement & they will get a chance to represent the county once we are out of Level 5 restrictions.

deisedude · 21-10-2020 9:43am

whiteandblue wrote: »

Very disappointing for our young minor hurlers & footballers who probably started trials and training almost 12 months ago to have their championship called off at such short notice. Also have to feel for management who have tried to keep the show on the road during all this time. Hopefully it is only a postponement & they will get a chance to represent the county once we are out of Level 5 restrictions.

Not just minors. U20 Championship gone now too

https://www.otbsports.com/sport/reports-senior-inter-county-can-proceed-level-5-not-underage-1093958?fbclid=IwAR3XI3p5K0u9NAmo81q_l8jdDfNW0x7ozV5wPjDVoJLxst5vqY64r-23nIE

Mastermcgrath · 21-10-2020 10:37am

upthedeise16 wrote: »

Curran may not start, Stephen Bennett may be more likely?

If only there was another experienced forward in the county to lead from the front with the frees etc.. (cough cough Maurice)

Pogue eile · 21-10-2020 1:40pm

Mastermcgrath wrote: »

If only there was another experienced forward in the county to lead from the front with the frees etc.. (cough cough Maurice)

It's a hell of a long time since Maurice did anything on the intercounty scene to justify his place, amazing they way lads in every sport seem to get better and better the longer they don't play!

Bennett will 100% take the frees and he is a far better free taker that Maurice or the O'Mahony of the last few seasons.

Pogue eile · 21-10-2020 1:40pm

Mastermcgrath wrote: »

If only there was another experienced forward in the county to lead from the front with the frees etc.. (cough cough Maurice)

It's a hell of a long time since Maurice did anything on the intercounty scene to justify his place, amazing they way lads in every sport seem to get better and better the longer they don't play!

Bennett will 100% take the frees and he is a far better free taker that Maurice or the O'Mahony of the last few seasons.

Mastermcgrath · 21-10-2020 5:20pm

Pogue eile wrote: »

It's a hell of a long time since Maurice did anything on the intercounty scene to justify his place, amazing they way lads in every sport seem to get better and better the longer they don't play!

Bennett will 100% take the frees and he is a far better free taker that Maurice or the O'Mahony of the last few seasons.

A couple of things here 1) name one Waterford forward that did play well the last 2 years 2) you cannot ignore Maurice’s club form, aside from Dessi Hutchison he was the best in the club championship this year. It’s not like we’re talking about yesterday’s man he’s clearly on top of his game this year. Just saying now would be an I deal time for Cahill to swallow whatever it was that he couldn’t get past and bring Maurice in

JeffKenna · 21-10-2020 5:37pm

Mastermcgrath wrote: »

A couple of things here 1) name one Waterford forward that did play well the last 2 years 2) you cannot ignore Maurice’s club form, aside from Dessi Hutchison he was the best in the club championship this year. It’s not like we’re talking about yesterday’s man he’s clearly on top of his game this year. Just saying now would be an I deal time for Cahill to swallow whatever it was that he couldn’t get past and bring Maurice in

Maurice's ability has nothing to do with him not being on the panel. It's all his temperament. How many times has he been sent off?

Tiger Roll · 21-10-2020 5:38pm

Maurice has all the ability and talent and should have been one of our best ever but for whatever reason he simply doesn't have the discipline at intercounty level and became a laibilty the last few times he played . It's hard for a new manager to look beyond that although everyone deserves a second chance too.

Pogue eile · 21-10-2020 5:39pm

Mastermcgrath wrote: »

A couple of things here 1) name one Waterford forward that did play well the last 2 years 2) you cannot ignore Maurice’s club form, aside from Dessi Hutchison he was the best in the club championship this year. It’s not like we’re talking about yesterday’s man he’s clearly on top of his game this year. Just saying now would be an I deal time for Cahill to swallow whatever it was that he couldn’t get past and bring Maurice in

One forward who played well or who played better than Shanahan, because the latter is a long list!

Yes he is yesterdays man from an intercounty perspective, 2015 was the last time you could say he excelled. He has always shone for his club to be fair to him, different kettle of fish altogether. He is not needed for frees and I'm not sure what else he brings to the table at 30 years of age. Cahill has a long term plan, this will not be a quick fix job and he obviously doesn't see the long term benefit in Shanahan.

You are suggesting that the decision wasn't hurling based which unless you have evidence to back it up is quite an accusation to be making.

deisedude · 21-10-2020 8:19pm

A quick refresher lesson on why Maurice Shanahan isn't on the panel despite his undeniable ability

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.sportsjoe.ie/amp/gaa/maurice-shanahan-definitely-broke-record-shortest-stint-ever-field-154309

Mastermcgrath · 21-10-2020 10:13pm

Pogue eile wrote: »

One forward who played well or who played better than Shanahan, because the latter is a long list!

Yes he is yesterdays man from an intercounty perspective, 2015 was the last time you could say he excelled. He has always shone for his club to be fair to him, different kettle of fish altogether. He is not needed for frees and I'm not sure what else he brings to the table at 30 years of age. Cahill has a long term plan, this will not be a quick fix job and he obviously doesn't see the long term benefit in Shanahan.

You are suggesting that the decision wasn't hurling based which unless you have evidence to back it up is quite an accusation to be making.

A provisional panel of 50 was drawn up shortly after Maurice got the call from Cahill to say he wasn’t wanted. are you telling me after his scoring exploits for Lismore this year that Maurice is not in the top 50 hurlers only the county? It’s abundantly clear the decision wasn’t hurling based.

And if we’re talking about lack of discipline and players being sent off regularly then Aussie Gleeson shouldn’t be next or near an intercounty panel.

I’m not saying Cahill is not within his right to pick whoever he wants but based on Maurice club form (Cahill said he would monitor) and the fact that Paudie now injured, surely you’d look to a hungry Maurice with a point to prove, which us when he’s at his best

thesultan · 21-10-2020 10:49pm

Maurice legs are gone at intercounty..

Giveitfong · 22-10-2020 1:28am

I don't think Stephen Bennett is a particularly reliable freetaker. Certainly not in Mahony's league. Jack Fagan is an alternative. Look out also for Dessie Hutchinson, who filled in very effectively whenever Mahony was off the field during the club championship. I only realised he was left-handed when he stepped up to his first free. Good sign of a two-sided player.

Mastermcgrath · 22-10-2020 5:37am

Giveitfong wrote: »

I don't think Stephen Bennett is a particularly reliable freetaker. Certainly not in Mahony's league. Jack Fagan is an alternative. Look out also for Dessie Hutchinson, who filled in very effectively whenever Mahony was off the field during the club championship. I only realised he was left-handed when he stepped up to his first free. Good sign of a two-sided player.

Bennett is far from reliable free taker, he’s got a very unorthodox style for me. If you wanted consistency from frees in Mahony a absence I’d be looking at fitting Curran into the forward line somewhere

KevIRL · 22-10-2020 8:42am

Antrim given a walkover by waterford football team for final league game at the weeknd

Jjjjjjjjbarry · 22-10-2020 2:33pm

Giveitfong wrote: »

I don't think Stephen Bennett is a particularly reliable freetaker. Certainly not in Mahony's league. Jack Fagan is an alternative. Look out also for Dessie Hutchinson, who filled in very effectively whenever Mahony was off the field during the club championship. I only realised he was left-handed when he stepped up to his first free. Good sign of a two-sided player.

I'd agree on Bennett. His free taking seems to fluctuate anywhere from 10/10 to 4/10. You can stick him on them though and at least know he won't bottle it. The eye might just be off on that day. I'd say mainly due to his technique not being the best and as easily repeatable as the great free takers?

Jjjjjjjjbarry · 22-10-2020 2:37pm

Mastermcgrath wrote: »

Bennett is far from reliable free taker, he’s got a very unorthodox style for me. If you wanted consistency from frees in Mahony a absence I’d be looking at fitting Curran into the forward line somewhere

He's not been that reliable either on frees since his underage days and not done much from play at all in my opinion. There's the odd bit of flash now and then but overall not worth a starting place in my opinion. It's a shame that he didn't push on but not everyone's curve continues to rise. Wouldn't rule him out completely yet though!

mickotallow · 22-10-2020 6:46pm

Great credit is due to the Waterford footballers for taking the right decision and not traveling to Antrim. The two reasons given are a lesson to our county board and Croke Park. 1. Family heath and 2. Work related concerns where they would have had to isolate for 10 days once they return.
It’s a pity the county board are not as proactive with regards to Covid. All they have done is just forward emails from Croke Park out to clubs. And more importantly they missed the opportunity to send out a strong message with the Dungarvan incident. 3 to 4 weeks later and all we’ve had is two statements. One from the CCC to say they recommended the county board to look into it and one a day later from the CB to say they would look into it with no further comment. Bureaucracy gone mad. When DLS erected a canopy in Fraher field emblazoned with Opel the CB came out with a statement immediately to say this could not be done.
These are tough times and clubs need leadership and direction and to know there are repercussions if Covid rules are not adhered to.

upthedeise16 · 22-10-2020 9:50pm

https://twitter.com/aontroimgaa/status/1319378294526119961?s=21

Antrim have offered to move the match

Billy Ocean · 22-10-2020 9:57pm

upthedeise16 wrote: »

https://twitter.com/aontroimgaa/status/1319378294526119961?s=21

Antrim have offered to move the match

Calling Waterford's bluff perhaps..

killbillvol2 · 22-10-2020 11:23pm

Billy Ocean wrote: »

Calling Waterford's bluff perhaps..

Decent thing to do but the GAA should have made the decision for them and for all the games involving long trips. This is going to turn into a PR disaster for the GAA when an intercounty player brings Covid to home/workplave and their decision to proceed with meaningless football league games really doesn't help.

Mastermcgrath · 23-10-2020 12:23am

killbillvol2 wrote: »

Decent thing to do but the GAA should have made the decision for them and for all the games involving long trips. This is going to turn into a PR disaster for the GAA when an intercounty player brings Covid to home/workplave and their decision to proceed with meaningless football league games really doesn't help.

Methinks if the GAA started approaching northern counties to encourage them to concede home advantage to a southern venue the response might be slightly different. But great credit to Antrim nonetheless

PTH2009 · 23-10-2020 2:26pm

https://twitter.com/WaterfordGAA/status/1319532000458530816?s=19

At least its sorted now, its so sad looking at social media and some people ordering the GAA too cancel the rest of the season

spideyman92 · 23-10-2020 3:27pm

PTH2009 wrote: »

https://twitter.com/WaterfordGAA/status/1319532000458530816?s=19

At least its sorted now, its so sad looking at social media and some people ordering the GAA too cancel the rest of the season

I think there are legitimate concerns with having it go ahead. It can't be considered an elite sport and amateur at the same time considering the difference in lifestyles of the players outside of their team bubbles with players in actual elite sports. Fair amount of GAA players also work in essential jobs like teaching and stuff too.

PTH2009 · 23-10-2020 4:07pm

spideyman92 wrote: »

I think there are legitimate concerns with having it go ahead. It can't be considered an elite sport and amateur at the same time considering the difference in lifestyles of the players outside of their team bubbles with players in actual elite sports. Fair amount of GAA players also work in essential jobs like teaching and stuff too.

Strong personal responsibility needs to be taken by players/management

Billy Ocean · 23-10-2020 6:01pm

PTH2009 wrote: »

https://twitter.com/WaterfordGAA/status/1319532000458530816?s=19

At least its sorted now, its so sad looking at social media and some people ordering the GAA too cancel the rest of the season

a big portion of these people have a pre conceived anti GAA agenda and are looking for any excuse to stick to boot in.

Also the scenario of certain things been closed down for the moment and others not leads to resentment, e.g someone who regularly plays golf or tennis and is annoyed at the current situation could go down this path. Personally I think it's an awful mindset and doesn't do the person in question any good, I think golf courses been shut is ridiculous but I don't think intercounty GAA, or professional soccer and rugby should cease as a consequence. You'll easily find contradictions in the current restrictions and alot of the people I mentioned are going down this path. Each activity should be judged on its risk rather than the blunt instrument approach some of these people would prefer.

One thing 2020 has showed is how much whingers there is in this country and how alot of them aren't happy unless there doing that.

thesultan · 23-10-2020 6:39pm

There is a ton anti gaa jealousy on social media.

Billy Ocean · 23-10-2020 7:13pm

Very good video on the topic

https://youtu.be/xZuEr72I4-U

PTH2009 · 23-10-2020 7:16pm

Billy Ocean wrote: »

Very good video on the topic

https://youtu.be/xZuEr72I4-U

yeah thats a very good view on it

If you want a laugh go over and read the Gaelic Games thread in the Coronavirus section

Mastermcgrath · 23-10-2020 9:45pm

thesultan wrote: »

There is a ton anti gaa jealousy on social media.

Social media is full of jealousy and bitterness no matter what the topic. As the previous poster said, there are many legitimate concerns about GAA fixtures going ahead aswell.

I’m a GAA person myself so I’m delighted that there are games to look forward to, but I’m not convinced it’s the right thing to do.
It seems many intercounty panels are rife with spread of the disease already. I guess it’s up to the players themselves to understand and bear the risk.

upthedeise16 · 23-10-2020 9:49pm

Mastermcgrath wrote: »

Social media is full of jealousy and bitterness no matter what the topic. As the previous poster said, there are many legitimate concerns about GAA fixtures going ahead aswell.

I’m a GAA person myself so I’m delighted that there are games to look forward to, but I’m not convinced it’s the right thing to do.
It seems many intercounty panels are rife with spread of the disease already. I guess it’s up to the players themselves to understand and bear the risk.

As a GAA fan, I’m delighted but I can see the other side. After Offaly being told that they had 27 close contacts to a player who didn’t even train on the night in question and had to give a walkover to Kildare in the Christy Ring, it raises the possibility of it happening in a knockout game in the football/hurling championship where a team will have to just pull out. Realistically it could have in an All-Ireland 1/4 or 1/2 final

Gardner · 24-10-2020 11:03am

player gets in car, drives to Antrim, gets out of car, keeps social distance from everyone, gets ready in dressing room, plays match, gets in car and drives home.

player gets in car, drives to Louth, gets out of car, keeps social distance from everyone, gets ready in dressing room, plays match, gets in car and drives home.

what a farce from the Waterford Football team, there is **** all difference in both circumstances. absolute laughing stock we are.

tommylad1212 · 24-10-2020 11:12am

Gardner wrote: »

player gets in car, drives to Antrim, gets out of car, keeps social distance from everyone, gets ready in dressing room, plays match, gets in car and drives home.

player gets in car, drives to Louth, gets out of car, keeps social distance from everyone, gets ready in dressing room, plays match, gets in car and drives home.

what a farce from the Waterford Football team, there is **** all difference in both circumstances. absolute laughing stock we are.

If in Antrim they were getting bus,staying over night, more food stops etc

upthedeise16 · 24-10-2020 11:45am

Gardner wrote: »

player gets in car, drives to Antrim, gets out of car, keeps social distance from everyone, gets ready in dressing room, plays match, gets in car and drives home.

player gets in car, drives to Louth, gets out of car, keeps social distance from everyone, gets ready in dressing room, plays match, gets in car and drives home.

what a farce from the Waterford Football team, there is **** all difference in both circumstances. absolute laughing stock we are.

Ah yeah, leave at 8:30, don’t bother eating at all, shur why would the Waterford footballers need food?? Sit in a car for 4 and half hours but don’t stop, arrive on at 1, play the match and get hammered a dead rubber match cos they are stiff after after the trip, pick up a few injuries and head away home. I genuinely believe that’s what some of our own county thinks would be suitable for our footballers, laughable.

PTH2009 · 24-10-2020 2:12pm

And its a great start for us. Waterford twitter not even bothering keeping the score updated. Get this bloody game over and done with

https://twitter.com/AontroimGAA/status/1319989696328568833?s=19

upthedeise16 · 24-10-2020 2:37pm

PTH2009 wrote: »

And its a great start for us. Waterford twitter not even bothering keeping the score updated. Get this bloody game over and done with

https://twitter.com/AontroimGAA/status/1319989696328568833?s=19

Waterford twitter have every score and scorer up

PTH2009 · 24-10-2020 2:38pm

upthedeise16 wrote: »

Waterford twitter have every score and scorer up

Must be an issue with my app

https://twitter.com/AontroimGAA/status/1319996455948636160?s=19

PTH2009 · 24-10-2020 3:35pm

https://twitter.com/WaterfordGAA/status/1320010255993081856?s=20

good effort after a bad start, No fear of Limerick at home in the Munster Championship next Saturday

Gardner · 24-10-2020 8:08pm

tommylad1212 wrote: »

If in Antrim they were getting bus,staying over night, more food stops etc

go away out of it, so they drive to Louth now but if they had to drive an extra hour they had to get a bus and stay over night. You are talking complete and utter nonsense.

im delighted they got the ****e bate out of them tonight. they deserved it for their antics!

Gardner · 24-10-2020 8:11pm

upthedeise16 wrote: »

Ah yeah, leave at 8:30, don’t bother eating at all, shur why would the Waterford footballers need food?? Sit in a car for 4 and half hours but don’t stop, arrive on at 1, play the match and get hammered a dead rubber match cos they are stiff after after the trip, pick up a few injuries and head away home. I genuinely believe that’s what some of our own county thinks would be suitable for our footballers, laughable.

to drive an extra hour up the road made no blind bit of difference. you swear they were going to be another 4 hours the way you are carrying on. they didn't want to play the game and got rotten. they should be ****ed out of the championship.

Both Gleeson and Montgomery are out next week due to playing Football. it's about time we banned it in Waterford

tommylad1212 · 24-10-2020 10:32pm

Gardner wrote: »

go away out of it, so they drive to Louth now but if they had to drive an extra hour they had to get a bus and stay over night. You are talking complete and utter nonsense.

im delighted they got the ****e bate out of them tonight. they deserved it for their antics!

Your a clown , ud swear I was making them get the bus, would you go if your job told you ud have to self isolate after returning

JeffKenna · 24-10-2020 10:58pm

Gardner wrote: »

go away out of it, so they drive to Louth now but if they had to drive an extra hour they had to get a bus and stay over night. You are talking complete and utter nonsense.

im delighted they got the ****e bate out of them tonight. they deserved it for their antics!

Jez, that kind of comment says a lot about you as a person.

killbillvol2 · 25-10-2020 12:24am

JeffKenna wrote: »

Jez, that kind of comment says a lot about you as a person.

Nothing he hasn't proven before. At least this exchange makes it clear he never set foot in a dressing room, contrary to earlier claims.

seligehgit · 25-10-2020 9:27am

Gardner wrote: »

go away out of it, so they drive to Louth now but if they had to drive an extra hour they had to get a bus and stay over night. You are talking complete and utter nonsense.

im delighted they got the ****e bate out of them tonight. they deserved it for their antics!

Gardner wrote: »

to drive an extra hour up the road made no blind bit of difference. you swear they were going to be another 4 hours the way you are carrying on. they didn't want to play the game and got rotten. they should be ****ed out of the championship.

Both Gleeson and Montgomery are out next week due to playing Football. it's about time we banned it in Waterford

Mod warning

Gardner going forward argue your points in a constructive non inflammatory manner.

In addition you must rein your less than complimentary posting re your home county.

Waterford GAA Thread - Mod note post #1

Comments