Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi all! We have been experiencing an issue on site where threads have been missing the latest postings. The platform host Vanilla are working on this issue. A workaround that has been used by some is to navigate back from 1 to 10+ pages to re-sync the thread and this will then show the latest posts. Thanks, Mike.
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

Ireland Team Talk XI: Team of nervoUS MOD warning Post 1

1910121415203

Comments

  • Hosted Moderators Posts: 8,140 ✭✭✭fitz


    awec wrote: »
    As a team we've stagnated. 2019 has shown that.

    Andy Farrell has a job on his hands rebuilding this side. It doesn't require major surgery in terms of personnel, but changes are needed. Obviously we need a replacement for Best. We need to address the back row, I am not sure we know what our most effective trio is.

    Sexton and Murray are still the men at 9 and 10 for now, but this business of them playing 70+ minutes every game and the backup getting a token jog out needs to end. Decide who the next cab off the rank is and give them some meaningful game time.

    In the centre we are fine. In the back three it is time for Kearney to be put out to pasture. Larmour seems the most likely candidate for that spot. I'd like to see Conway used more.

    We didn't progress this year, and Hansen clearly learned from the last defeat in Dublin. I think injuries to key players who then struggled with form during the year left us with no momentum, and you could see today the lack of confidence in the team. We weren't half the side of November 2018.

    I think we need to develop systems that allow in form young players to come in and get capped quickly, without being in a number of camps before being ready. Ironically, I think going back to Joe's early Leinster mission of being the best passing team is what's needed, and any players who can't handle and pass the ball to keep continuity without always taking contact shouldn't make the team.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 18,958 ✭✭✭✭Shefwedfan


    fitz wrote: »
    We didn't progress this year, and Hansen clearly learned from the last defeat in Dublin. I think injuries to key players who then struggled with form during the year left us with no momentum, and you could see today the lack of confidence in the team. We weren't half the side of November 2018.

    I think we need to develop systems that allow in form young players to come in and get capped quickly, without being in a number of camps before being ready. Ironically, I think going back to Joe's early Leinster mission of being the best passing team is what's needed, and any players who can't handle and pass the ball to keep continuity without always taking contact shouldn't make the team.


    The difference between Leinster and Ireland is huge

    With Leinster Joe had the players day in day out. He could teach them skills and get them playing to a specific way

    Ireland he has them at different times during the year and then they head back to province to play a completely different game.



    Joe has brought in young players, even when not in squad the likes of Larmour etc are in around the squad getting hints and tips so when they do get picked they are not overawed. This was a new process he brought in and it worked well.....



    Joe has, with Nucifora put a system in place that younger players are coming up with those skills.



    If you review everything over his reign a lot has worked well for Ireland. The last WC everything went right and then we lost half the team to injury and we got knocked out. He went to fixing that issue and build a huge squad. Which he done and build a team that could win....which he done but....when it came down to it he trusted his regualr players when he should have put in form players. POM, Stockdale, Kearney should not have been on pitch today. You could also question Henshaw and Healy.



    Conway was on fire, so was Kilcoyne. Ruddock was in cracking form and was was larmour.


    I am not saying we would have won starting those players, but we could have given a better account of ourselves.


  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 391 ✭✭Professor Genius


    Shefwedfan wrote: »
    The difference between Leinster and Ireland is huge

    With Leinster Joe had the players day in day out. He could teach them skills and get them playing to a specific way

    Ireland he has them at different times during the year and then they head back to province to play a completely different game.



    Joe has brought in young players, even when not in squad the likes of Larmour etc are in around the squad getting hints and tips so when they do get picked they are not overawed. This was a new process he brought in and it worked well.....



    Joe has, with Nucifora put a system in place that younger players are coming up with those skills.



    If you review everything over his reign a lot has worked well for Ireland. The last WC everything went right and then we lost half the team to injury and we got knocked out. He went to fixing that issue and build a huge squad. Which he done and build a team that could win....which he done but....when it came down to it he trusted his regualr players when he should have put in form players. POM, Stockdale, Kearney should not have been on pitch today. You could also question Henshaw and Healy.



    Conway was on fire, so was Kilcoyne. Ruddock was in cracking form and was was larmour.


    I am not saying we would have won starting those players, but we could have given a better account of ourselves.

    Carberry should have been starting 10. Sexton has been playing like a drain for the year


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 10,552 ✭✭✭✭AbusesToilets


    Shefwedfan wrote: »
    The difference between Leinster and Ireland is huge

    With Leinster Joe had the players day in day out. He could teach them skills and get them playing to a specific way

    Ireland he has them at different times during the year and then they head back to province to play a completely different game.



    Joe has brought in young players, even when not in squad the likes of Larmour etc are in around the squad getting hints and tips so when they do get picked they are not overawed. This was a new process he brought in and it worked well.....



    Joe has, with Nucifora put a system in place that younger players are coming up with those skills.



    If you review everything over his reign a lot has worked well for Ireland. The last WC everything went right and then we lost half the team to injury and we got knocked out. He went to fixing that issue and build a huge squad. Which he done and build a team that could win....which he done but....when it came down to it he trusted his regualr players when he should have put in form players. POM, Stockdale, Kearney should not have been on pitch today. You could also question Henshaw and Healy.



    Conway was on fire, so was Kilcoyne. Ruddock was in cracking form and was was larmour.


    I am not saying we would have won starting those players, but we could have given a better account of ourselves.

    My biggest criticism of Joe is how poor the players look for the national team. This guys are well capable of passing, attacking etc, and show it for their club.

    He's had them playing a style that doesn't take advantage of that at all. In addition, he's trying to play a power game that we don't have the players for, and picked guys who are lacking in rugby skills to accomplish that.

    He's regularly ignored players tearing it up for their clubs doing so. We're told we should ignore the evidence before us, and that they must be deficient in the training camps. Different levels and proven performers over flash in the pans. What message does that send to the players? That it doesn't matter how well they do in actual games, there are the starters and everyone else. It's the same issue again and again, from EOS to Kidney, and now to Joe.

    If the results posed by his tests in camp lead to results like today, then perhaps it's not the players that are deficient, but rather the test itself. The best coaches in sports are ruthless. Hansen, Belichick, they have a singular focus on winning. If a player isn't performing, he gets the boot.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,145 ✭✭✭DellyBelly


    Carberry should have been starting 10. Sexton has been playing like a drain for the year
    I said the exact same thing on both the Wales and Italy thread during the 6 nations and was shot down both times by a number of posters. Anybody who has a good judgement of rugby could see he was on the wane. I wonder will we see him again in an Irish jersey


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 45,433 ✭✭✭✭thomond2006


    Sexton is under contract for another two years and is on monster money. There's no question about him remaining in the Irish side. There is a glaring need for giving opportunities to someone to either replace Sexton when he retires or better still take the starting jersey from him.

    Kearney is a different story. He's on a one year deal and should really be done with the Ireland side. There are plenty options at fullback.

    Keith Earls is one of my favourite ever players but he's just turned 32 and like Kearney there are players ready to take his spot. His injury history would suggest he might have 2 seasons left at best. It's time to phase him out.


  • Registered Users Posts: 179 ✭✭Bigboldworld


    Sexton should pass the baton to Carbery, his form has been shockingly inconsistent, no faith in him anymore when he steps up to take the kicks, his conversion rate has been hit and miss for a good while now, new blood is needed


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 12,910 ✭✭✭✭whatawaster


    Sexton is under contract for another two years and is on monster money. There's no question about him remaining in the Irish side. There is a glaring need for giving opportunities to someone to either replace Sexton when he retires or better still take the starting jersey from him.

    Would be the perfect time for Sexton to have gone to France. Him hanging on for 2 more years obviously helps Leinster in the short term, but long term it’s good only for his Lions chances

    We need Byrne starting big games for Leinster


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 12,910 ✭✭✭✭whatawaster


    On Sexton, even if we are going to persist with him for 2 more years , it would be good for him, for Leinster and for Ireland for him to miss the 6N


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,223 ✭✭✭✭Clegg


    Sexton should pass the baton to Carbery, his form has been shockingly inconsistent, no faith in him anymore when he steps up to take the kicks, his conversion rate has been hit and miss for a good while now, new blood is needed

    New blood may be needed, but there's still the issue that Sexton is still the best 10 we have by an absolute mile. If he's fit and available to play for Ireland I don't think Farrell could leave him out.


  • Advertisement
  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 391 ✭✭Professor Genius


    Clegg wrote: »
    New blood may be needed, but there's still the issue that Sexton is still the best 10 we have by an absolute mile. If he's fit and available to play for Ireland I don't think Farrell could leave him out.

    That is no longer true. On current form Carberry is the better 10.


  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 277 ✭✭Danthemanhere


    Clegg wrote: »
    New blood may be needed, but there's still the issue that Sexton is still the best 10 we have by an absolute mile. If he's fit and available to play for Ireland I don't think Farrell could leave him out.

    If he's that far ahead of the next 10, then we're in big trouble. He was awful today.


  • Registered Users Posts: 4,233 ✭✭✭ClanofLams


    You can still win but it's not the priority in this situation. The WC is bigger and with the issues Ireland have in them it'd be a bigger achievement to reach a semi than get a GS, to me anyway but I'm fairly confident that'd be a common view. Phasing out players who won't be there or are expected to be on the downslope in 2023 should be the focus ow with at least 2 players legitimately competing for each spot.


    Would be dreadful and damaging to rugby long term in this country. May also be utterly pointless if a single fixture in four years time goes wrong.

    There’s also the point that Ireland have a significantly better chance if they are in the top 4 when the rankings for the draw are made.


  • Site Banned Posts: 12,341 ✭✭✭✭Faugheen


    That is no longer true. On current form Carberry is the better 10.

    Bar one cameo against Italy, Carbery hasn’t shown the form to be selected ahead of Carty, never mind Sexton.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,814 ✭✭✭✭bilston


    Sexton still has a role to play.

    But let's see some new blood in February. For all the talk of us having the deepest squad ever I bet we could all have picked today's starting XV weeks ago.

    I'd like to see Rhys Ruddock brought into the starting pack, I'd like to maybe see Eric O'Sullivan fast tracked through and personally I think someone with the physicality of Stuart McCloskey should be given a proper chance as well.

    Oh and as an Ulster fan I have to say Jacob Stockdale needs to sort his s*** out. He was dreadful today. He can count himself lucky that Kearney and Earls are on their way out.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 18,958 ✭✭✭✭Shefwedfan


    My biggest criticism of Joe is how poor the players look for the national team. This guys are well capable of passing, attacking etc, and show it for their club.

    He's had them playing a style that doesn't take advantage of that at all. In addition, he's trying to play a power game that we don't have the players for, and picked guys who are lacking in rugby skills to accomplish that.

    He's regularly ignored players tearing it up for their clubs doing so. We're told we should ignore the evidence before us, and that they must be deficient in the training camps. Different levels and proven performers over flash in the pans. What message does that send to the players? That it doesn't matter how well they do in actual games, there are the starters and everyone else. It's the same issue again and again, from EOS to Kidney, and now to Joe.

    If the results posed by his tests in camp lead to results like today, then perhaps it's not the players that are deficient, but rather the test itself. The best coaches in sports are ruthless. Hansen, Belichick, they have a singular focus on winning. If a player isn't performing, he gets the boot.

    Who has ignored tearing it up for club?


  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 277 ✭✭Danthemanhere


    Were other teams building last year while we were going all out? It looks like it now. They were great achievements and we all celebrated but they don't look as good in retrospect.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,223 ✭✭✭✭Clegg


    That is no longer true. On current form Carberry is the better 10.

    What current form does Carbery have? His last appearance was an awful cameo against Samoa. Before that he was injured for months.

    Sexton was poor today. That's not in dispute. But don't assert that another player was in better form when that clearly isn't the case.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 10,552 ✭✭✭✭AbusesToilets


    Shefwedfan wrote: »
    Who has ignored tearing it up for club?

    He's pretty consistently ignored anyone from Connacht and Ulster. Continued to pick Munster backrow forwards over Leinster ones, who've outplayed them year after year.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users Posts: 11,790 ✭✭✭✭Burkie1203



    We need Byrne starting big games for Leinster


    Byrne started more "big" games then Sexton last season

    January
    V Toulouse & Wasps

    April
    V Ulster

    May
    V Munster


    Sexton had 3.
    Euro SF and Final
    Pro14 final


    Don't think Byrne is going to lack gametime in crunch matches


  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 277 ✭✭Danthemanhere


    Byrne is not up to it.


  • Site Banned Posts: 12,341 ✭✭✭✭Faugheen


    Byrne is not up to it.

    We’ve heard this numerous times and every time he shuts everyone up.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 14,381 ✭✭✭✭Professor Moriarty


    Sexton hasn't lost his skill, game management or courage. But his body isn't up to it anymore. Too many hits on board. Must be hugely frustrating for him.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,814 ✭✭✭✭bilston


    Shefwedfan wrote: »
    Who has ignored tearing it up for club?

    I'd argue Stuart McCloskey at Ulster but like a few other players like Gilroy, O'Halloran and even Zebo to an extent there was something that Joe didn't like. Maybe Farrell will have different ideas.

    We did a move today straight off the top from a lineout and Murray hit Ringrose on a crash ball, and I just thought if you're going to do that have a big man in the midfield like McCloskey or Farrell. But don't use Ringrose.


  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 277 ✭✭Danthemanhere


    Faugheen wrote: »
    We’ve heard this numerous times and every time he shuts everyone up.

    Not really, he was picked to play against England in the warm ups. He didn't really shut anybody up. In fact, he was so bad he was instantly ruled out for the world cup.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,814 ✭✭✭✭bilston


    That is no longer true. On current form Carberry is the better 10.

    I don't know about that. Carbery has been injured for most of the WC so who knows what his form is. Sexton was poor today but then he was very good against Samoa.


  • Registered Users Posts: 11,790 ✭✭✭✭Burkie1203


    Not really, he was picked to play against England in the warm ups. He didn't really shut anybody up. In fact, he was so bad he was instantly ruled out for the world cup.

    Jean Kleyn was on the pitch that day and travelled.

    If that game is how you judge players then none of them should have gone East


  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 277 ✭✭Danthemanhere


    Burkie1203 wrote: »
    Jean Kleyn was on the pitch that day and travelled.

    If that game is how you judge players then none of them should have gone East

    The poster claimed that Byrne always shuts up the doubters, I was pointing out that his post was incorrect. He had a very bad game against England and ruled himself out of the world cup.


  • Registered Users Posts: 1,564 ✭✭✭RugbyLover123


    Neither Carberry or Byrne are the answer. Carberry is a lovely player but not a 10. He belongs at 15 imo. I’m one for giving new guys a chance and phasing sexton out, but as another poster here said, Byrne is not an international standard 10 unfortunately. Byrne is more Ian Keatley then Sexton.

    Best Ireland can hope for is Harry Byrne to come through as I think he has a more attack minded game then his older brother.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 7,440 ✭✭✭The Rape of Lucretia


    That is the biggest take from today - that Sexto is done. Great servant to Irish rugby. Terrific at his best. But time waits for no man. It would be a good moment to retire from the international scene for him. Still have a role to play with Leinster for a couple of years, bring on the talent there, and still pick up a couple of medals.
    Good night sweet prince.


  • Advertisement
  • Site Banned Posts: 12,341 ✭✭✭✭Faugheen


    Not really, he was picked to play against England in the warm ups. He didn't really shut anybody up. In fact, he was so bad he was instantly ruled out for the world cup.

    He had no chance against England. When the pack were bullied and defence non-existent.

    Again, another player who consistently out-performs his counterparts at the provinces and in Europe.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 12,910 ✭✭✭✭whatawaster


    That is the biggest take from today - that Sexto is done. Great servant to Irish rugby. Terrific at his best. But time waits for no man. It would be a good moment to retire from the international scene for him. Still have a role to play with Leinster for a couple of years, bring on the talent there, and still pick up a couple of medals.
    Good night sweet prince.

    100%


  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 1,287 ✭✭✭Niallof9


    https://twitter.com/VodafoneIreland/status/1185529434905960448

    Jaysis

    i wish they would stop. You'd swear some of the lads on here are in the Vodafone marketing department


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 69,984 ✭✭✭✭FrancieBrady


    Niallof9 wrote: »
    https://twitter.com/VodafoneIreland/status/1185529434905960448

    Jaysis

    i wish they would stop. You'd swear some of the lads on here are in the Vodafone marketing department

    I wish some here would 'stop'. There isn't a team of anybody at this level in any sport that doesn't engage in that kind of motivational stuff.

    Just ignore it, it isn't done to offend.


  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 277 ✭✭Danthemanhere


    Faugheen wrote: »
    He had no chance against England. When the pack were bullied and defence non-existent.

    Again, another player who consistently out-performs his counterparts at the provinces and in Europe.

    He had chances and he was awful. Did nothing to stem the tide. Club rugby is not the same as international level rugby.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 18,958 ✭✭✭✭Shefwedfan


    He's pretty consistently ignored anyone from Connacht and Ulster. Continued to pick Munster backrow forwards over Leinster ones, who've outplayed them year after year.

    Connacht player bar Aki have really failed to make the step up, without playing regular HC they have an huge jump to make....just look at some of those player who have moved up to Leinster and failed at taking that step up

    TOH etc are just not good enough, I would put Carty in same bracket after this WC....

    Stander I would have in my team but at 6, POM I just have never seen why he gets the praise....it’s a huge loss with Heaslip sitting in stand today...

    Ulster I don’t know, they have been a mess and again those players have failed to step up, Stockdale was brought in ASAP and Addison, Balacoune was too young

    McCloskey was a favourite of mine but really who would you drop if current centres fro him? He is a significant step down from the 4 that flew over

    Connacht need to play in HC every year, I don’t care how IRFU do it but it has to happen, their manager mentioned before about taking young Leinster players on 1-2 year contract to get experience and then move back to Leinster, maybe that is the route to take....they seemingly done it in Oz before.....


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 18,958 ✭✭✭✭Shefwedfan


    That is the biggest take from today - that Sexto is done. Great servant to Irish rugby. Terrific at his best. But time waits for no man. It would be a good moment to retire from the international scene for him. Still have a role to play with Leinster for a couple of years, bring on the talent there, and still pick up a couple of medals.
    Good night sweet prince.

    Who will replace him? Harry Byrne is 2 years away from been a regular

    Carbery is a 15
    Ross Byrne seems to be out of contention
    Carty is not good enough...

    I don’t see anyone else knocking around In the next 2 years


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,814 ✭✭✭✭bilston


    Shefwedfan wrote: »
    Connacht player bar Aki have really failed to make the step up, without playing regular HC they have an huge jump to make....just look at some of those player who have moved up to Leinster and failed at taking that step up

    TOH etc are just not good enough, I would put Carty in same bracket after this WC....

    Stander I would have in my team but at 6, POM I just have never seen why he gets the praise....it’s a huge loss with Heaslip sitting in stand today...

    Ulster I don’t know, they have been a mess and again those players have failed to step up, Stockdale was brought in ASAP and Addison, Balacoune was too young

    McCloskey was a favourite of mine but really who would you drop if current centres fro him? He is a significant step down from the 4 that flew over

    Connacht need to play in HC every year, I don’t care how IRFU do it but it has to happen, their manager mentioned before about taking young Leinster players on 1-2 year contract to get experience and then move back to Leinster, maybe that is the route to take....they seemingly done it in Oz before.....

    Your absolute arse McCloskey is a significant step down from the four centres who travelled.

    He needs to get a shot. We need to see what he can do. He has a physicality that the others don't have, even Aki and Farrell.

    Also Ulster were a mess 18 months ago, but they aren't now. Not that there is a queue of players demanding selection. But McCloskey and eventually Eric O'Sulluvan should be under consideration.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 7,440 ✭✭✭The Rape of Lucretia


    Shefwedfan wrote: »

    Connacht need to play in HC every year, I don’t care how IRFU do it but it has to happen, their manager mentioned before about taking young Leinster players on 1-2 year contract to get experience and then move back to Leinster, maybe that is the route to take....they seemingly done it in Oz before.....

    I couldnt agree. We are better served by them playing in the second tier. We dont have enough players to usefully field 4 teams at that level. 3 is sufficient, and will do better for a concentration of resources rather than further dilution into Connacht. Connacht's role is as a back up, holding pattern, for players where there is a logjam at Leinster and better than possible prospects get useful regular game time at their level rather than being lost to foreign contracts.


  • Registered Users Posts: 1,564 ✭✭✭RugbyLover123


    Shefwedfan wrote: »
    Connacht need to play in HC every year, I don’t care how IRFU do it but it has to happen, their manager mentioned before about taking young Leinster players on 1-2 year contract to get experience and then move back to Leinster, maybe that is the route to take....they seemingly done it in Oz before.....

    You’d have to imagine the interest from the Connacht neutral will deteriorate if the province essentially comes a nursing ground for young Leinster academy players to learn their trade before being brought back to Leinster.


  • Advertisement
  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 1,287 ✭✭✭Niallof9


    bilston wrote: »
    Your absolute arse McCloskey is a significant step down from the four centres who travelled.

    He needs to get a shot. We need to see what he can do. He has a physicality that the others don't have, even Aki and Farrell.

    Also Ulster were a mess 18 months ago, but they aren't now. Not that there is a queue of players demanding selection. But McCloskey and eventually Eric O'Sulluvan should be under consideration.

    Yeah but can we forgive him for that dropped offload v England? Joe obviously never did!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 11,906 ✭✭✭✭PhlegmyMoses


    Do we think that there will be any surprise retirements from international? Would say a few of the older heads, beyond Best, will be considering their future. Have a sneaking suspicion that Healy might bow out earlier than most.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 7,440 ✭✭✭The Rape of Lucretia


    Do we think that there will be any surprise retirements from international? Would say a few of the older heads, beyond Best, will be considering their future. Have a sneaking suspicion that Healy might bow out earlier than most.

    Sexto needs a word in his ear from the men in the smoke filled rooms.


  • Registered Users Posts: 589 ✭✭✭baas baa


    McCloskey ticks all the boxes of what you would want from a 12 but I've always felt there was some intangible missing from him for test rugby and I think Schmidt must've thought the same. I think we need a change of tack from the approach we have now though. Someone like Henshaw ticks all the boxes in terms of character you could want but I think the Lions tour showed him to be an ultimately limited rugby player. Maybe we need to back the players with the physical and technical tools to succeed and hope they grow into test rugby. There are a lot of players in this Irish side with limited skill levels for test rugby and though they've had fine careers when it comes to the pinnacle of the game like today they come up disastrously short.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 11,906 ✭✭✭✭PhlegmyMoses


    Sexto needs a word in his ear from the men in the smoke filled rooms.

    I would agree. His age and injury profile means he has to be wrapped in cotton wool unfortunately.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,814 ✭✭✭✭bilston


    Do we think that there will be any surprise retirements from international? Would say a few of the older heads, beyond Best, will be considering their future. Have a sneaking suspicion that Healy might bow out earlier than most.

    Healy has been about a long time, he's still our best LH. But it's a position where I can see the logic in nurturing a younger option.

    We'll see what happens. Ultimately the players will get a week or two off, then they'll go back and play European rugby and ultimately that's where we can start speculating on form players etc.

    Who has started the season well at the four provinces? To be honest I haven't watched anyone other than Ulster so far, bar the last 20 mins of the Cheetahs v Munster game.

    For Ulster, Billy Burns and Luke Marshall have started the season very well. What about the other provinces?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 7,440 ✭✭✭The Rape of Lucretia


    I would agree. His age and injury profile means he has to be wrapped in cotton wool unfortunately.

    The almost unspeakable truth is that he just isnt really that good any more. Out limited player pool means we do tend to flog players to the bitter end, and are dazzled by the previous level, as if once great, always great. Stronger teams would have ditched him at this stage.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,814 ✭✭✭✭bilston


    baas baa wrote: »
    McCloskey ticks all the boxes of what you would want from a 12 but I've always felt there was some intangible missing from him for test rugby and I think Schmidt must've thought the same.

    You might be right about McCloskey, but my point is, give him a run in the side. He hasn't really had a shot. Where do we tour next June? In my head I'm thinking Argentina. Wherever it is give someone like McCloskey three tests, give Ruddock a run of tests, maybe Tadgh Beirne, but that is the time to do it.

    Sure we can stick with the tried and trusted while everyone else is experimenting and we might win a title and get a few big scalps, but come 2023 we will be in the same position we are now.

    Joe tried his best to develop a squad, but again we all knew our starting XV weeks ago, bar maybe one centre position. If you look at England and NZ and you'd probably have some doubt about some positions on both teams week to week.

    We have a deeper squad than we used to, but we've still some way to go.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,814 ✭✭✭✭bilston


    It will be interesting to see who takes over as Captain.

    O'Mahony will probably be favourite, but personally I'd have Ruddock in the side at the minute. Sexton has enough to worry about without being skipper. It might well be Ryan, unless there is a surprise option.

    Of course if Ruddock plays he could be an option, but given he would always be looking over his shoulder it would be a risky call.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 11,906 ✭✭✭✭PhlegmyMoses


    The almost unspeakable truth is that he just isnt really that good any more. Out limited player pool means we do tend to flog players to the bitter end, and are dazzled by the previous level, as if once great, always great. Stronger teams would have ditched him at this stage.

    I don't blame Schmidt for not ditching him and Murrat at this WC. The whole build up was contingent on them having their form from last year, where they were top of the world in their positions. But 18 months between the GS and the WC is a long time for a man of Sexton's age and injury profile. The mind is willing but the body not so much


This discussion has been closed.
Advertisement