Werewolf: Batman

Phil WW · 22-07-2019 10:31am

Not quite a claim but they mention their character name here. NRV plus suggests NRV who might become more than that later on.

Conor WW wrote: »

What does NRV+ mean? I hadn't spotted the claim from Gabriel

Is it not strange theres been no SK kill?

Looking at Barbaras theory, she has it split into two sections when I think it can be split into three sections.
The Joker could have found Harley and that might not be related to Eva's post

However from my quick scan it would seem likely that if he has found her then its likely to be from someone leaving breadcrumbs, and that points to Eva and Ewan?

Gabriel WW wrote: »

A few things.

I'm so excited. I'm on a mobile and can't post GIFs which upsets me cause I don't think a batman claim is relevant without them.

I've just spent hours rereading the Batman story and I'm a little sad for his poor folks. Poor Thomas Wayne.

I'm torn now between reading more comics and backstory or actually reading the thread.

Angus WW · 22-07-2019 10:32am

Having the game start on Saturday has really messed with the way I do my top, middle or bottom method of wolf hunting. When do we usually start, around 1 on a Sunday?

Angus WW · 22-07-2019 10:39am

@liam

Based on my previous extensive research into the matter

I would say that it’s the joker who would have to find Harley. Meaning the joker doesn’t have to say anything but Harley has to leave breadcrumbs.

Brendan WW · 22-07-2019 10:47am

Good morning all. Just checking in quickly to make sure I’m not dead

I shall return shortly, for I am Batman!

Bounty Hunter · 22-07-2019 11:00am

Someone has been poisoned

Poison Ivy has been a busy girl! It would seem two Citizens of Gotham have been hospitalized showing symptoms of a very specific type of poison. They were also recipients of flower deliveries this morning.

Desmond WW received a Rose

Abigail WW received an Orchid

Both Gotham residents' symptoms started to show almost immediately. One's will subside by lynch time, the other will not be so lucky.

Conor WW · 22-07-2019 11:03am

Angus WW wrote: »

@liam

Based on my previous extensive research into the matter I would say that it’s the joker who would have to find Harley. Meaning the joker doesn’t have to say anything but Harley has to leave breadcrumbs.

I’d agree

Also @Liam I mentioned above that Barbara had broken her analysis out into two parts, neither of which were reliant on the other being true. Likewise I think he could have found Harley and Eva not be her but it certainly looks like she was breadcrumbing

This bring us to the question of why Gabs was munched. Here’s a theory

The wolves believe Barbara’s theory on Gabs and Eva, decide to get rid of another team, or part thereof. If this is true IMO it would lead me to believe in a less experienced wolf team, they would surely want the SK alive for a bit longer to keep the kill rate up.
If that is the case I’d be leaning village on Barbara as she seems to experienced to do that. If she suspected Gabs I think she’d hold out for a night of two.

The real hole in my theory comes with why they would lynch Gabs over Eva, the evidence against her was a lot stronger IMO

Desmond WW · 22-07-2019 11:03am

I knew this was coming! I feel honoured

Wendy WW · 22-07-2019 11:04am

Desmond WW wrote: »

I knew this was coming! I feel honoured

Only way you could 'know' is if you were a wolf

Desmond WW · 22-07-2019 11:04am

They think I'm the seer

Happy days, Abigail isn't the seer either but may be important, I dont know, could be a double bluff

Desmond WW · 22-07-2019 11:05am

Wendy WW wrote: »

Only way you could 'know' is if you were a wolf

Or if I tagged a wolf a 9.59am and put the ****s up you

Frank WW · 22-07-2019 11:05am

Phil WW wrote: »

Good evening fellow citizens. Not enough dancing for my liking.

Phil WW wrote: »

Hate to ruin all your moments folks, but you're all lying.

Phil WW wrote: »

Well at least we know that there is autopriest now, which can now filter into the seer argument.

Phil WW wrote: »

Not quite a claim but they mention their character name here. NRV plus suggests NRV who might become more than that later on.

Noticed you posting and was like “has Phil actually posted yet?” So decided to do a quick ISO. Not an awful lot in that Phil.

I’d love to get to know the real Phil, what are your aspirations? what music do you like? Who does he want to kill? Those kind of things..... So many questions.

Conor WW · 22-07-2019 11:05am

Good and bad news for Des and Abby, likely to not be suspected as a wolves just yet. Bad news is there’s a 25% chance they’ll be dead by lynch

Wendy WW · 22-07-2019 11:06am

Desmond WW wrote: »

Or if I tagged a wolf a 9.59am and put the ****s up you

Up who? Me? I've yet to see your reasoning on your hilariously wrong call :pac:

Phil WW · 22-07-2019 11:08am

Frank WW wrote: »

Noticed you posting and was like “has Phil actually posted yet?” So decided to do a quick ISO. Not an awful lot in that Phil.

I’d love to get to know the real Phil, what are your aspirations? what music do you like? Who does he want to kill? Those kind of things..... So many questions.

What do you expect Frank? I've only posted four times. Of course there won't be an awful lot in it :rolleyes::rolleyes:

Aspirations - help win the game for the village
Music - like a bit of pop, country and traditional
Who do I want to kill? - no one .... yet

Any other questions?

Frank WW · 22-07-2019 11:09am

So poison Ivy can send two roses, one good and one bad. She can also use this power to sort of semi clear one of her teammates as she knows which one is which. Just saying....

Liam WW · 22-07-2019 11:09am

Angus WW wrote: »

@liam

Based on my previous extensive research into the matter I would say that it’s the joker who would have to find Harley. Meaning the joker doesn’t have to say anything but Harley has to leave breadcrumbs.

Is that not what I said? It's certainly what I meant to say. It was Eva (the potential Harley) was was breadcrumbing.

Desmond WW · 22-07-2019 11:09am

Wendy WW wrote: »

Up who? Me? I've yet to see your reasoning on your hilariously wrong call :pac:

Poor wolf play targeting me, when I die your locked dead anyway so I'll spend the rest of my time hunting the rest of your buddies!

I'll do an ISO later for you to respond to but like, sometimes you just know.

Wendy WW · 22-07-2019 11:10am

Frank WW wrote: »

So poison Ivy can send two roses, one good and one bad. She can also use this power to sort of semi clear one of her teammates as she knows which one is which. Just saying....

Exactly. The fake poisoned person is not in any way clear.

Holly WW · 22-07-2019 11:10am

I am here after a busy weekend. Was expecting to see two deaths but looking back over the OP it seems like the SK kill isn't a night time action

Joker - His origins may be disputed but a psychopath with a warped, sadistic sense of humor is not someone you will want to have a dispute with in this game. Every day the Joker will bring his own form of unbridled chaos to Gotham city as he kills one citizen with his own unique flair - AKA this SK can write their own flavor for the Joker kill!

To the guys who received the flowers - do you get told by PM or did you just find out on thread? Have you received any other information? I assume Alfred can chose to save the person if he wants but means there will be no vig shot today if he does.

Desmond WW · 22-07-2019 11:11am

Pretty sure I got the poison but we can wait for Abigail to give us some thoughts to her importance in the game before discussing possible outcomes

Wendy WW · 22-07-2019 11:11am

Desmond WW wrote: »

Poor wolf play targeting me, when I die your locked dead anyway so I'll spend the rest of my time hunting the rest of your buddies!

I'll do an ISO later for you to respond to but like, sometimes you just know.

Oh really, do post it, I'm looking forward to another agenda driven post by you

I'm good and I can debunk your theory in a simple post if I wanted to

Conor WW · 22-07-2019 11:12am

I would save, there’s too little info yet to be killing off people

Angus WW · 22-07-2019 11:12am

Frank WW wrote: »

So poison Ivy can send two roses, one good and one bad. She can also use this power to sort of semi clear one of her teammates as she knows which one is which. Just saying....

Alfred can heal poison but it’s pot luck who he picks.

Desmond WW · 22-07-2019 11:12am

Wendy WW wrote: »

Oh really, do post it, I'm looking forward to another agenda driven post by you

I'm good and I can debunk your theory in a simple post if I wanted to

Cool, teeing up the fake claim! I look forward to it

Phil WW · 22-07-2019 11:12am

Wendy WW wrote: »

Oh really, do post it, I'm looking forward to another agenda driven post by you

I'm good and I can debunk your theory in a simple post if I wanted to

Let them stew a bit first Wendy.

Desmond WW · 22-07-2019 11:13am

Wendy WW wrote: »

Oh really, do post it, I'm looking forward to another agenda driven post by you

I'm good and I can debunk your theory in a simple post if I wanted to

What's the agenda by the way? Finding wolves?!

Gertrude WW · 22-07-2019 11:14am

Good morning everyone

Wendy WW · 22-07-2019 11:14am

Ah Des you picked on the wrong person.

I look forward to you being fake poisoned and shot tomorrow.

Nice play, but too fancy.

Henry WW · 22-07-2019 11:14am

Sorry for the low post count and pretty much useless input village. Finding it very difficult to follow along with this game for some reason.

Could be just the Anonitis settling in early game. I hope I can be more useful going forward.

Wendy WW · 22-07-2019 11:16am

Phil WW wrote: »

Let them stew a bit first Wendy.

*Cue the scrabbling in the backroom to find what I'm talking about*

Desmond WW · 22-07-2019 11:17am

Wendy WW wrote: »

Ah Des you picked on the wrong person.

I look forward to you being fake poisoned and shot tomorrow.

Nice play, but too fancy.

Why the hell would I go hell for leather for you if I was a wolf, let's be honest, your a high poster and if I was worried by you or what you could do then you'd be munched realistically.

Also the only way you'll know I was fake poisoned is if you were involved in which case your pushing for me not to be cured. If I'm cured and no death tonight then I've not been fake poisoned.

Frank WW · 22-07-2019 11:18am

So is nighttime 9pm to 10 am in game terms “night action” , “day action” (10am to 9pm)?

This isn’t my first rodeo but I still sometimes get this confused.

Desmond WW · 22-07-2019 11:18am

Wendy WW wrote: »

*Cue the scrabbling in the backroom to find what I'm talking about*

There's no scrambling, if you've a gun then shoot, I've no issue there! I'm gonna die tonight or in the morning

Angus WW · 22-07-2019 11:19am

Off topic a bit

I know there’s new players in this game so don’t feel overwhelmed. Lots of post will go over your head (I’ve been playing years and still get confused) but just go with the flow and ask questions and enjoy. It will all make sense as you go along.

Frank WW · 22-07-2019 11:20am

Angus WW wrote: »

It will all make even less sense as you go along.

Corrected that for you... :pac:

Wendy WW · 22-07-2019 11:20am

Desmond WW wrote: »

Why the hell would I go hell for leather for you if I was a wolf, let's be honest, your a high poster and if I was worried by you or what you could do then you'd be munched realistically.

Also the only way you'll know I was fake poisoned is if you were involved in which case your pushing for me not to be cured. If I'm cured and no death tonight then I've not been fake poisoned.

Ah so you don't know if I'm a wolf, you're only pushing a bullspit agenda (that you posted at 9.59am for effect).

Gotcha.

Angus WW · 22-07-2019 11:20am

Frank WW wrote: »

So is nighttime 9pm to 10 am in game terms “night action” , “day action” (10am to 9pm)?

This isn’t my first rodeo but I still sometimes get this confused.

Yep that’s exactly it. We at now in day 1 and tonight (after 9) will be night 1.

Angus WW · 22-07-2019 11:23am

Desmond WW wrote: »

There's no scrambling, if you've a gun then shoot, I've no issue there! I'm gonna die tonight or in the morning

Eh? When did wolves get guns?

Gertrude WW · 22-07-2019 11:23am

Henry WW wrote: »

Sorry for the low post count and pretty much useless input village. Finding it very difficult to follow along with this game for some reason.

Could be just the Anonitis settling in early game. I hope I can be more useful going forward.

Its day1. Everyone is more or less blind at this point

Wendy WW · 22-07-2019 11:27am

I'm happy to leave Des's fate in the hands of Alfred today fwiw.

It goes without saying that we probably shouldn't lynch either of them.

So lettuce move on from this at least until Abi starts posting I suppose.

I think Orla did a task on day 0. Discuss

Phil WW · 22-07-2019 11:28am

Gertrude WW wrote: »

Its day1. Everyone is more or less blind at this point

Abigail WW · 22-07-2019 11:28am

Steve WW wrote: »

Gab dead! Jus sayin!

Wendy WW wrote: »

Gabs death does shine a light on Fiona admittedly. Though I wonder if that was (even partially) the intention?

True indeed, I wonder because this was put out there led to the below.

Bounty Hunter wrote: »

Someone has been poisoned

Poison Ivy has been a busy girl! It would seem two Citizens of Gotham have been hospitalized showing symptoms of a very specific type of poison. They were also recipients of flower deliveries this morning.

Desmond WW received a Rose

Abigail WW received an Orchid

Both Gotham residents' symptoms started to show almost immediately. One's will subside by lynch time, the other will not be so lucky.

I was wondering why I had "I feel it in my fingers, I feel it in my toes" in my head.

Can't see anything to highlight me as being a threat to the wolf side in my limited posting to date

Desmond WW wrote: »

They think I'm the seer Happy days, Abigail isn't the seer either but may be important, I dont know, could be a double bluff

I am not seer either, there has been a lot of "I am seer posts", when I added that I must be the only non-seer post this was being true.

Desmond WW wrote: »

Pretty sure I got the poison but we can wait for Abigail to give us some thoughts to her importance in the game before discussing possible outcomes

I am at a loss as to why I am being targeted. Only been on phone for most part, so not that active. Pain in the proverbial to try and multi-quote. Didn't see anything to flag you either Des.

Tegan WW · 22-07-2019 11:28am

Henry WW wrote: »

Sorry for the low post count and pretty much useless input village. Finding it very difficult to follow along with this game for some reason.

Could be just the Anonitis settling in early game. I hope I can be more useful going forward.

Me too. I'm distracted and I'm not following along with who is saying what. I might try and do a couple of ISOs today to try and get my head straight with who is saying what.

Wendy WW · 22-07-2019 11:30am

Tegan WW wrote: »

Me too. I'm distracted and I'm not following along with who is saying what. I might try and do a couple of ISOs today to try and get my head straight with who is saying what.

ISOs are a good way of getting your feelings straight. I look forward to them

Tegan WW · 22-07-2019 11:31am

On the seer/spartacus theory, I like this but I need to have a think about some of the arguments against and look at the numbers.

I see what people are saying - if there are wrong guesses, that eliminates that person as seer, but with the numbers as they are, instinctively I feel like we'd have greater clarity over seer choices if the seer does die. And with the number of deaths each day, that could happen sooner rather than later. It also eliminates the guessing over who the seer peeked.

Wendy WW · 22-07-2019 11:32am

Actually Abi that's a very good call. The poisoning happened at a time that there was some discussion around Fiona.

Worth bearing in mind.

Also I think Alfred healing is much more important than shooting right now btw, we have a chance of clearing a player a day from being a wolf (but not the SK) if he guesses correctly.

Angus WW · 22-07-2019 11:32am

Wendy WW wrote: »

I'm happy to leave Des's fate in the hands of Alfred today fwiw.

It goes without saying that we probably shouldn't lynch either of them.

So lettuce move on from this at least until Abi starts posting I suppose.

I think Orla did a task on day 0. Discuss

Elaborate ?

Tegan WW · 22-07-2019 11:33am

Wendy WW wrote: »

ISOs are a good way of getting your feelings straight. I look forward to them

At the moment I'd be happy just to have an idea of what has been said and by who. I've scanned the thread but none of it seems to have lodged in my fuzzy monday-morning head.

Will come back (hopefully with something more useful) shortly.

Wendy, I'm going to do you first before your postcount gets totally out of my reach.

Wendy WW · 22-07-2019 11:37am

Angus WW wrote: »

Elaborate ?

Click into this below post for a series of posts by Orla. I feel they are quite tasky.

Wendy WW wrote: »

By the way, if anyone is doing a task on day 0 it's likely Orla.

Just look at the above posts.

Wendy WW · 22-07-2019 11:38am

Tegan WW wrote: »

At the moment I'd be happy just to have an idea of what has been said and by who. I've scanned the thread but none of it seems to have lodged in my fuzzy monday-morning head.

Will come back (hopefully with something more useful) shortly.

Wendy, I'm going to do you first before your postcount gets totally out of my reach.

Jokes aside I do like being ISOed

Werewolf: Batman

Comments