Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie

Do you have to be ethnically Irish to be considered Irish?

Options
13567…10

Comments

  • Options
    #62
    Rodin
    Registered Users Posts: 3,130 ✭✭✭Rodin


    begbysback wrote: »
    I’ve no idea if you are then considered Irish or English, but I am very impressed by your independence at two years of age having left your parents in England.

    That'll be the Irish side...


  • Options
    #63
    ExMachina1000
    Closed Accounts Posts: 3,748 ✭✭✭ExMachina1000


    Rodin wrote: »
    Im always very suspicious of anybody shouting from the rooftops about their new nationality wnen they get a passport after 5 years.
    No real football fan even changes their club never mind their nationality.

    The country is 95% empty over there. They rely on large scale immigration to constantly grow the economy. Apparently the after effects of covid lockdowns which put immigration to a halt is going to affect the Australian economy and society hugely in the long term.

    But anyway , I'm not shouting about anything The passport is in the bottom of a drawer somewhere.


  • Options
    #64
    Hamachi
    Registered Users Posts: 2,467 ✭✭✭Hamachi


    ExMachina1000 wrote: »
    A piece of paper doesn't change the fact just because I lived there for a while

    Tend to agree with this. I lived in another country for a decade. Now I never took out citizenship but was well embedded there.

    Not for one second did I ever consider myself a native of that country. If I ever described myself as such, the locals would have looked at me as if I had ten heads.

    And rightly so.


  • Options
    #65
    Rodin
    Registered Users Posts: 3,130 ✭✭✭Rodin


    ExMachina1000 wrote: »
    The country is 95% empty over there. They rely on large scale immigration to constantly grow the economy. Apparently the after effects of covid lockdowns which put immigration to a halt is going to affect the Australian economy and society hugely in the long term.

    But anyway , I'm not shouting about anything The passport is in the bottom of a drawer somewhere.

    Im talking about people who come here eulogising being Irish after 5 years.

    I agree with you that an Aussie passport doesn't make you Australian... then again what it means to to be Australian is a different debate altogether...


  • Options
    #66
    Rodin
    Registered Users Posts: 3,130 ✭✭✭Rodin


    Hamachi wrote: »
    Tend to agree with this. I lived in another country for a decade. Now I never took out citizenship but was well embedded there.

    Not for one second did I ever consider myself a native of that country. If I ever described myself as such, the locals would have looked at me as if I had ten heads.

    And rightly so.

    People think themselves Irish having spent half that time here.


  • Advertisement
  • Options
    #67
    Hamachi
    Registered Users Posts: 2,467 ✭✭✭Hamachi


    Rodin wrote: »
    People think themselves Irish having spent half that time here.

    Like who?

    I know several people here for 20 years who wouldn’t even vaguely consider themselves Irish.


  • Options
    #68
    ExMachina1000
    Closed Accounts Posts: 3,748 ✭✭✭ExMachina1000


    Rodin wrote: »
    Im talking about people who come here eulogising being Irish after 5 years.

    I agree with you that an Aussie passport doesn't make you Australian... then again what it means to to be Australian is a different debate altogether...

    Apologies I picked you up wrong.


  • Options
    #69
    joe40
    Registered Users Posts: 3,811 ✭✭✭joe40


    Rodin wrote: »
    Im talking about people who come here eulogising being Irish after 5 years.

    I agree with you that an Aussie passport doesn't make you Australian... then again what it means to to be Australian is a different debate altogether...

    This thread isn't about that. It was started because of the story about David Lanny an English MP (born in England) who was told he was not ethnically English.
    I agree with you if I move to another country, say England, I would still be Irish. However kids born and reared there would be English.


  • Options
    #70
    SimonTemplar
    Registered Users Posts: 2,815 ✭✭✭SimonTemplar


    Lammy was born and raised in London. Of course he is English. The caller to that show is just a bigot.


  • Options
    #71
    joe40
    Registered Users Posts: 3,811 ✭✭✭joe40


    Hamachi wrote: »
    Why? Because you say so? Who are you to make that determination?

    For the record, I agree that poster is Irish. However, for you to dismiss concepts like heritage and ethnicity, reveals astounding levels of ignorance, particularly from someone who claims to be an educator.
    On reflection saying heritage and ethnicity was nonsense was ott.
    I'm proud of my Irish heritage.
    I do think though the whole notion can be overstated though.
    Someone born here, who identifies as Irish is as Irish as I am.


  • Advertisement
  • Options
    #72
    ExMachina1000
    Closed Accounts Posts: 3,748 ✭✭✭ExMachina1000


    joe40 wrote: »
    This thread isn't about that. It was started because of the story about David Lanny an English MP (born in England) who was told he was not ethnically English.
    I agree with you if I move to another country, say England, I would still be Irish. However kids born and reared there would be English.

    Well he isnt ethnically English. If I think what do ethnically English people look like my mind thinks historically. A white protestant.

    Just like if I was asked about the ethnicity of someone from Saudi Arabia my mind pictures an Arab muslim.

    Or an ethnically Chinese person my mind gives an image of someone with Asian features.

    I dont see a white person as an ethnicity of Saudi Arabia or a black person as ethnicity Chinese

    It doesn't really add up. Maybe in ten generations time but not now.
    He is definitely English but not ethnically English

    Seems to be only in the west that these changes are taking place


  • Options
    #73
    SharpshooterTom
    Registered Users Posts: 3,017 ✭✭✭SharpshooterTom


    joe40 wrote: »
    There are plenty of English people who have Irish parents.
    Plenty see themselves as English first.

    I have cousins from Scotland whose parents were both Irish. They visit here often but would consider themselves scottish first and foremost.

    There are plenty of Scottish people (certainly Scottish unionists/loyalists, Rangers fans and the like) who certainly wouldn't though. Go to any Rangers online forum and lot of them wont consider people of Irish catholic origin to be properly Scottish, that problem appears to be much worse than in England so I'm actually glad I wasn't born and raised there.


  • Options
    #74
    SharpshooterTom
    Registered Users Posts: 3,017 ✭✭✭SharpshooterTom


    Hamachi wrote: »
    Tend to agree with this. I lived in another country for a decade. Now I never took out citizenship but was well embedded there.

    Not for one second did I ever consider myself a native of that country. If I ever described myself as such, the locals would have looked at me as if I had ten heads.

    And rightly so.

    I actually disagree with this. I think because countries like America/Canada/Australia/New Zealand are countries with a strong immigrant culture and aren't tied by ethnicity like the way "old world" European/Asian countries are.

    I know lots of naturalised Americans who identify as American even if they moved there as adults. And Americans are proud of that. Naturalization is celebrated there and I've always admired that about them. Ronald Reagan in a speech on immigration spoke of a letter he received from a recent naturalised immigrant on what it means to be an American:

    "You can go to live in France, but you cannot become a Frenchman. You can go to live in Germany, or Turkey or Japan, but you cannot become a German, a Turk or Japanese. But anyone, from any corner of the Earth, can come to live in America and become an American."


  • Options
    #75
    Rodin
    Registered Users Posts: 3,130 ✭✭✭Rodin


    joe40 wrote: »
    On reflection saying heritage and ethnicity was nonsense was ott.
    I'm proud of my Irish heritage.
    I do think though the whole notion can be overstated though.
    Someone born here, who identifies as Irish is as Irish as I am.

    And others disagree...
    I don't think people not from here identify with the history. People who are here for generations identify with the history... indeed their ancestors starved, rebelled, recovered then rebuilt in the country. Don't tell me that someone with no Irish heritage identifies with that...


  • Options
    #76
    Rodin
    Registered Users Posts: 3,130 ✭✭✭Rodin


    SharpshooterTom wrote: »
    I actually disagree with this. I think because countries like America/Canada/Australia/New Zealand are countries with a strong immigrant culture and aren't tied by ethnicity like the way "old world" European/Asian countries are.

    I know lots of naturalised Americans who identify as American even if they moved there as adults. And Americans are proud of that. Naturalization is celebrated there and I've always admired that about them. Ronald Reagan in a speech on immigration spoke of a letter he received from a recent naturalised immigrant on what it means to be an American:

    "You can go to live in France, but you cannot become a Frenchman. You can go to live in Germany, or Turkey or Japan, but you cannot become a German, a Turk or Japanese. But anyone, from any corner of the Earth, can come to live in America and become an American."

    Because America has eff all history of any length.
    Even Americans identify with being from elsewhere... African-American, Irish American, Italian American.....etc


  • Options
    #77
    DerekC16
    Registered Users Posts: 183 ✭✭DerekC16


    You don't become Irish by obtaining citizenship, you become a citizen of Ireland. Nationality and citizenship are two different things.


  • Options
    #78
    Rodin
    Registered Users Posts: 3,130 ✭✭✭Rodin


    ExMachina1000 wrote: »
    Well he isnt ethnically English. If I think what do ethnically English people look like my mind thinks historically. A white protestant.

    Just like if I was asked about the ethnicity of someone from Saudi Arabia my mind pictures an Arab muslim.

    Or an ethnically Chinese person my mind gives an image of someone with Asian features.

    I dont see a white person as an ethnicity of Saudi Arabia or a black person as ethnicity Chinese

    It doesn't really add up. Maybe in ten generations time but not now.
    He is definitely English but not ethnically English

    Seems to be only in the west that these changes are taking place

    Only in the west are we expected to adapt and assimilate.
    The greatest misogynists, racists, and least progressive types are not in the west. Just try getting a hot dog in Riyadh during Ramadan because you're not of the local faith...


  • Options
    #79
    bfa1509
    Registered Users Posts: 1,022 ✭✭✭bfa1509


    99nsr125 wrote: »
    No

    No Irish heritage not Irish

    Would you consider someone Chinese just because they lived a while in China.

    Holding a passport is not the same as being

    I call myself Chinese... after 10 pints


  • Options
    #80
    85603
    Registered Users Posts: 1,184 ✭✭✭85603


    You may have no other gods before me.

    To be Irish you must be willing to put Ireland before any and all other countries.

    So, in a theoretical war with Brazil, or Poland or Nigeria those countries become your enemy.


  • Options
    #81
    T.V Eye
    Registered Users Posts: 120 ✭✭T.V Eye


    85603 wrote: »
    You may have no other gods before me.

    To be Irish you must be willing to put Ireland before any and all other countries.

    So, in a theoretical war with Brazil, or Poland or Nigeria those countries become your enemy.

    I was born in Ireland but I’m switching sides if we go to war with any of those nations.


  • Advertisement
  • Options
    #82
    jacksonsarm
    Registered Users Posts: 19 ✭jacksonsarm


    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2T1D9-94xOU


  • Options
    #83
    Hamachi
    Registered Users Posts: 2,467 ✭✭✭Hamachi


    SharpshooterTom wrote: »
    I actually disagree with this. I think because countries like America/Canada/Australia/New Zealand are countries with a strong immigrant culture and aren't tied by ethnicity like the way "old world" European/Asian countries are.

    I agree with you on this. It’s possible to become ‘X’ in the ‘new world societies founded on immigration.

    The scenario I was describing was in Europe. I don’t believe there is a single society in Europe that would you accept you as a native after a mere decade. This holds true for the most inclusive and multicultural societies on the continent.

    That’s what makes the ignorance of denying an Irish heritage and ethnicity so galling. It’s usually done by Irish people who have never spent substantial time outside the country and have no idea how seriously other nations treat these concepts.


  • Options
    #84
    ...Ghost...
    Registered Users Posts: 3,355 ✭✭✭...Ghost...


    odyssey06 wrote: »
    Who you cheer for in sports is also a good indication... ultimate test is if they are playing your ancestral homeland.

    I usually hear people cheering for Man United or Liverpool in the pub. Not many Irish in the local.

    Stay Free



  • Options
    #85
    snotboogie
    Registered Users Posts: 3,568 ✭✭✭snotboogie


    Hamachi wrote: »
    I agree with you on this. It’s possible to become ‘X’ in the ‘new world societies founded on immigration.

    The scenario I was describing was in Europe. I don’t believe there is a single society in Europe that would you accept you as a native after a mere decade. This holds true for the most inclusive and multicultural societies on the continent.

    That’s what makes the ignorance of denying an Irish heritage and ethnicity so galling. It’s usually done by Irish people who have never spent substantial time outside the country and have no idea how seriously other nations treat these concepts.

    You are conflating moving to a country as an adult with someone of a different ethnicity being born and raised in the country, which is the topic of the OP. Are you saying that Zlatan isn't considered Swedish in Sweden? Or that the French don't consider Zidane one of their own?


  • Options
    #86
    Rodin
    Registered Users Posts: 3,130 ✭✭✭Rodin


    snotboogie wrote: »
    You are conflating moving to a country as an adult with someone of a different ethnicity being born and raised in the country, which is the topic of the OP. Are you saying that Zlatan isn't considered Swedish in Sweden? Or that the French don't consider Zidane one of their own?

    Id say that if instead of a world class footballer, Zidane was a terrorist shooting Charlie Hebdo comics then his Algerian heritage would soon come to the fore...


  • Options
    #87
    Hamachi
    Registered Users Posts: 2,467 ✭✭✭Hamachi


    snotboogie wrote: »
    You are conflating moving to a country as an adult with someone of a different ethnicity being born and raised in the country, which is the topic of the OP. Are you saying that Zlatan isn't considered Swedish in Sweden? Or that the French don't consider Zidane one of their own?

    I’m not conflating anything. I was responding to a point another poster made, not the OP.

    That’s permitted I believe.


  • Options
    #88
    Black Swan
    Moderators, Category Moderators, Science, Health & Environment Moderators, Society & Culture Moderators Posts: 47,226 CMod ✭✭✭✭Black Swan


    Does shrimp have to be on the barbie?


  • Options
    #89
    snotboogie
    Registered Users Posts: 3,568 ✭✭✭snotboogie


    Hamachi wrote: »
    I’m not conflating anything. I was responding to a point another poster made, not the OP.

    That’s permitted I believe.

    You are though. You are conflating an adult living in a different European country for 10 years not being accepted as a national of that country with us "denying an Irish heritage and ethnicity" presumably because we accept non ethnically Irish people born and raised here as one of our own. In reality all Western European countries do the same.


  • Options
    #90
    gozunda
    Registered Users Posts: 18,996 ✭✭✭✭gozunda


    joe40 wrote: »
    You're Irish, simple as that.

    You may choose to identify with your Parents Country also that is up to you.

    This notion of heritage or ethnicity is nonsense.

    So would you say ethnic descriptors such as Afro Caribbean Or Indian are incorrect?

    Ethnicity is simply a grouping of people who identify with each other on the basis of shared attributes which distinguishes them from other groups such as shared or common folklore, culture, ancestry, history, society, religion etc.

    And by that definition - a significant majority of the population in this country would be defined as ethically Irish ie belonging to an ethnic group 
    who trace their full or partial ancestry to Ireland and who share a common identity and culture.

    That said there's plenty of wriggle room in such descriptors tbh.


  • Advertisement
  • Options
    #91
    TheValeyard
    Registered Users Posts: 12,234 ✭✭✭✭TheValeyard


    Hmmmm this seems trickier the more I read the thread.

    Can definitely see both sides of the argument.

    Fcuk Putin. Glory to Ukraine!



Advertisement