Two adult brothers in a relationship

Scanlas The 2nd · 16-08-2012 5:33pm #1

Do you think it's wrong?

If so why?

I can't think of a legitimate reason why it shouldn't be allowed. So long as they aren't harming anyone good luck to them. Now the thought of it somewhat turns my stomach, but that is hardly justification to forbid two brothers from being together.

who what when · 16-08-2012 5:34pm

Have you something to tell us?
About you and your brother maybe?

WhimSock · 16-08-2012 5:34pm

I feel sorry for their kids.

BluesBerry · 16-08-2012 5:34pm

Its incest

TheQueen · 16-08-2012 5:35pm

Where, who why???

Or did this thought just pop into your head?

Did you tell your brother?

B.A._Baracus · 16-08-2012 5:35pm

Scanlas The 2nd wrote: »

Do you think it's wrong?

If so why?

I can't think of a legitimate reason why it shouldn't be allowed. So long as they aren't harming anyone good luck to them. Now the thought of it somewhat turns my stomach, but that is hardly justification to forbid two brothers from being together.

wtf?

why would you even post such a thread as this

rednik · 16-08-2012 5:36pm

Keep it in the family.

My name is URL · 16-08-2012 5:36pm

Each to their own

quite literally in this case

Mr.Crinklewood · 16-08-2012 5:36pm

BluesBerry wrote: »

Its incest

Is that hat the "I fecking hate spiders!!!" thread is about ?

Dave0301 · 16-08-2012 5:37pm

I hope this is inspired by a news report and not something you are thinking of indulging in

Scanlas The 2nd · 16-08-2012 5:37pm

B.A._Baracus wrote: »

Scanlas The 2nd wrote: »

Do you think it's wrong?

If so why?

I can't think of a legitimate reason why it shouldn't be allowed. So long as they aren't harming anyone good luck to them. Now the thought of it somewhat turns my stomach, but that is hardly justification to forbid two brothers from being together.

wtf?
why would you even post such a thread as this

To see if anyone can justify why it's wrong. I can't.

Lyaiera · 16-08-2012 5:37pm

If they were long lost brothers who found each other in their twenties and got in a relationship I wouldn't have a problem with it. If they were brothers who grew up together then I would. There's far too much of a likelihood that their relationship is predicated on some form of abuse or emotional neglect.

This has been pointed out to you repeatedly in another thread, and you've ignored it so I presume you'll ignore it again here. I'm just waiting for you to "bow out of this thread" here too.

1ZRed · 16-08-2012 5:37pm

And this is what you get out of the "Father doesn't accept gay son" thread?

mauzo · 16-08-2012 5:38pm

I can't even watch porn with female twins in it, just creeps me out big time.

16-08-2012 5:38pm

incest is way hot , as long as the people in question is over 18

Mr.Crinklewood · 16-08-2012 5:39pm

syndeyfife wrote: »

I can't even watch porn with female twins in it, just creeps me out big time.

Weirdo.

Cassidy28 · 16-08-2012 5:40pm

"Running in the family" Level 42

al28283 · 16-08-2012 5:40pm

syndeyfife wrote: »

I can't even watch porn with female twins in it, just creeps me out big time.

you're weird

FANTAPANTS · 16-08-2012 5:40pm

syndeyfife wrote: »

I can't even watch porn with female twins in it, just creeps me out big time.

send them dvds over to me and i will surely watch them for ya

:D

Lyaiera · 16-08-2012 5:40pm

1ZRed wrote: »

And this is what you get out of the "Father doesn't accept gay son" thread?

Yeah, that's pretty much it in a nutshell. Scanlas just wants to paint homosexuality in the same light as incest.

All in all it's really encouraging how deranged some parts of society are about people of the same sex having sex. /sarcasm.

I'm just glad those deranged people are kept in their own particular nuthouse organisations like Coir.

16-08-2012 5:40pm

syndeyfife wrote: »

I can't even watch porn with female twins in it, just creeps me out big time.

watch gay male twins even hotter

Scanlas The 2nd · 16-08-2012 5:40pm

1ZRed wrote: »

And this is what you get out of the "Father doesn't accept gay son" thread?

Either engage in the discussion or find another thread to moan in.

Do you think it's wrong?

B.A._Baracus · 16-08-2012 5:40pm

Scanlas The 2nd wrote: »

To see if anyone can justify why it's wrong. I can't.

Like, if there was a news story about it and you quoted that. Fair enough. But to go onto boards and say to yourself "would two adult gay brothers in a relationship with each other be wrong? lets find out" is nuts :P

jessiejam · 16-08-2012 5:42pm

I pressume you mean blood brothers, not "yo bro" brothers?
If so, Its wrong on every single level.

mattjack · 16-08-2012 5:42pm

Is there a Scanlas The 1st involved ?

Zebra3 · 16-08-2012 5:42pm

Deleted User wrote: »

incest is way hot , as long as the people in question is over 18

And they're fit sisters....

Scanlas The 2nd · 16-08-2012 5:43pm

Lyaiera wrote: »

1ZRed wrote: »

And this is what you get out of the "Father doesn't accept gay son" thread?

Yeah, that's pretty much it in a nutshell. Scanlas just wants to paint homosexuality in the same light as incest.

All in all it's really encouraging how deranged some parts of society are about people of the same sex having sex. /sarcasm.

I'm just glad those deranged people are kept in their own particular nuthouse organisations like Coir.

I'm have nothing against homosexuality, if you want to enlighten me why two brothers in a relationship is wrong work away?

Gee Bag · 16-08-2012 5:43pm

BluesBerry wrote: »

Its incest

Legally, incest can only occur between a male and a female. Strange but true.

FANTAPANTS · 16-08-2012 5:43pm

http://youtu.be/Uzae_SqbmDE

Jimoslimos · 16-08-2012 5:44pm

syndeyfife wrote: »

I can't even watch porn with female twins in it, just creeps me out big time.

:eek: Out of interest, where did you find this porn? Just so I can decide whether to inform the authorities like......:p

Anyway 99.99% of those vids are just girls who look identical but are of no relation

Dave0301 · 16-08-2012 5:45pm

Scanlas The 2nd wrote: »

To see if anyone can justify why it's wrong. I can't.

So if you end up with say two sons and at the age of 17 they are quite happily going at it like a pair of rabbits, you'd be ok with that?

Would you be happy for them to conduct a romantic relationship around your house as most teenage relationships are?

ejmaztec · 16-08-2012 5:45pm

Gee Bag wrote: »

Legally, incest can only occur between a male and a female. Strange but true.

This is arsecest we're talking about.

Knex* · 16-08-2012 5:47pm

syndeyfife wrote: »

I can't even watch porn with female twins in it, just creeps me out big time.

Lesbian porn is overrated anyways.

There, I said it.

/runs

jessiejam · 16-08-2012 5:48pm

Scanlas The 2nd wrote: »

I'm have nothing against homosexuality, if you want to enlighten me why two brothers in a relationship is wrong work away?

Eh.. because they are brothers????????????????????????????
Isn't that reason enough?

Could you imagine what it would do to the parents?

Scanlas The 2nd · 16-08-2012 5:49pm

Dave0301 wrote: »

Scanlas The 2nd wrote: »

To see if anyone can justify why it's wrong. I can't.

So if you end up with say two sons and at the age of 17 they are quite happily going at it like a pair of rabbits, you'd be ok with that?

Would you be happy for them to conduct a romantic relationship around your house as most teenage relationships are?

No I wouldn't be happy about it, but me being disgusted about it is hardly justification. There are plenty of parents disgusted by their homosexual children but that doesn't make it wrong to be homosexual.

ScumLord · 16-08-2012 5:50pm

BluesBerry wrote: »

Its incest

Incest is biologically repulsive because of the possibility of having children with genetic abnormalities. Two men can't produce children so it's only disgusting but not harmful.

Hilly Bill · 16-08-2012 5:51pm

Scanlas The 2nd wrote: »

Do you think it's wrong?

If so why?

I can't think of a legitimate reason why it shouldn't be allowed. So long as they aren't harming anyone good luck to them. Now the thought of it somewhat turns my stomach, but that is hardly justification to forbid two brothers from being together.

Its 100% out of order.

Cassidy28 · 16-08-2012 5:51pm

I'm not sure about two brothers in a relationship, but two sisters yeah.

holystungun9 · 16-08-2012 5:51pm

bros before hoes personified.

Owryan · 16-08-2012 5:51pm

are you the jealous 3rd brother ?

1ZRed · 16-08-2012 5:53pm

Scanlas The 2nd wrote: »

Either engage in the discussion or find another thread to moan in.

Do you think it's wrong?

You had your argument over in that thread and you ignored what posters were pointing out to you and saying that there was NO need to bring incest into a debate about gay rights and homophobia because there's no connection between them.

All you seemed to do was bring up gay brotherly incest any chance you could for no reason. I think you should be explaining why you were so obsessed about it.

Edit, and incest is disgusting gay or straight

Halloween Jack · 16-08-2012 5:53pm

It hasn't done jedward any harm......

16-08-2012 5:54pm

sure ive played with brother for a years aka we shared a room just a phase

TeddyTedson · 16-08-2012 5:54pm

Another Jedward thread ffs :rolleyes:. Isn't everyone sick of these two by now

TeddyTedson · 16-08-2012 5:55pm

Halloween Jack wrote: »

It hasn't done jedward any harm......

I think you just mind ****ed me:eek:

Dave0301 · 16-08-2012 5:55pm

Scanlas The 2nd wrote: »

No I wouldn't be happy about it, but me being disgusted about it is hardly justification. There are plenty of parents disgusted by their homosexual children but that doesn't make it wrong to be homosexual.

Parents disgusted by their children's homosexual relations are bigoted and living in the stone age.

As for the part in bold, in this context it is correct but you can't apply that logic to all aspects and walks of life. Say for example "There are plenty of parents disgusted by their racist children but that doesn't make it wrong to be racist." Using the same logic that you applied to homosexuality doesn't apply to racism.

Or another "There are plenty of parents disgusted by their rapist children but that doesn't make it wrong to be a rapist." Again there is a failure using this logic with regards to this context. The same can be said for incest.

kneemos · 16-08-2012 5:58pm

Weird question.I think it would get in the way of a normal brotherly relationship,it is socially unacceptable so they may not be accepted by thier peers and local community and it's just off really is'nt it?

Scanlas The 2nd · 16-08-2012 5:58pm

1ZRed wrote: »

Scanlas The 2nd wrote: »

Either engage in the discussion or find another thread to moan in.

Do you think it's wrong?

You had your argument over in that thread and you ignored what posters were pointing out to you and saying that there was NO need to bring incest into a debate about gay rights and homophobia because there's no connection between them.

All you seemed to do was bring up gay brotherly incest any chance you could for no reason. I think you should be explaining why you were so obsessed about it.

Edit, and incest is disgusting gay or straight

Thinking its disgusting is one thing, but do you think it's wrong?

strobe · 16-08-2012 5:58pm

You raise an interesting question and point Scanlas, and it will be interesting if anyone can actually address it properly.

RedRightHand · 16-08-2012 5:58pm

Incest between close family members(male/female) is prohibited is due to fear of children being born with abnormalities. I'm not aware of another reason, maybe historically a biblical interpretation was used for it's prohibition but today few argue that laws should be based purely on religious texts. So the question remains, it was a valid question to ask. Most people would answer that's it's just too yucky but would not be able to articulate any further. Personally I think yucky is a good enough answer, even if they're consenting adults.

16-08-2012 6:00pm

RedRightHand wrote: »

Incest between close family members(male/female) is prohibited is due to fear of children being born with abnormalities. I'm not aware of another reason, maybe historically a biblical interpretation was used for it's prohibition but today few argue that laws should be based purely on religious texts. So the question remains, it was a valid question to ask. Most people would answer that's it's just too yucky but would not be able to articulate any further. Personally I think yucky is a good enough answer, even if they're consenting adults.

but my brother and i both males messed around for years still do harmless fun we see it were hurting no-one

Two adult brothers in a relationship

Comments