Werewolf: Batman

Abigail WW wrote: »

Have you used this power yet?

No I have until 10am tomorrow to use it

Holly WW wrote: »

No I have until 10am tomorrow to use it

Would the best time to use it not be the three hours before vote?

I can't see a benefit for a random 3 hour window during any other time.

Doris WW wrote: »

Well I think we're fairly sure that we've caught one rogue anyway in Gertrude. Not sure whether she's Ivy or Penguin though. I'd put my bets on Penguin.

Can you point me to the post or page that confirms this?

Brendan WW wrote: »

Only catching up now. I thought I’d be pretty much free this week but a lot of stuff kinda just landed on me. Wish I hadn’t outed myself so early today since we now seem to have a good few options that would have jumped ahead of me on the lynch list.

Brendan. You are the Ultimate GENIE. GTFO!

Voted for Gertie.

Ok guys, I have been keeping tabs on things as best I can, but I have been genuinely busy and struggling a bit to keep up. I am Batman and I actually came out on thread at 10am. That’s why Conor knows the information that he correctly deciphered. Very well played Conor. A good bit of the information in this post was hidden in my post around 9.59 so goodies and baddies could of read it.

I didn't come out sooner as I thought I might of been able to hide, but with Poison Ivys delayed poison



So why the smokes and daggers and hidden info:



I was hoping if I didn’t die it would buy me a bit of time to get my 3rd read of villains and it worked! I got poison Ivys details which I have included in an updated list:

One of the following are:

Penguin – Doris , Gertrude , Holly , Isla (Dead), Desmond (Dead)

Joker – Henry, Jake, Wendy/Fiona/Teagan (Dead)

Poison Ivy – Abigail, Eva, Orla, Riona, Conor

These are facts, irrefutable and definite, the only question is who is the character.

Possible reason for Poison Ivy Delay:

I also have a “Detective Batman” power that gives me track if somebody bad tries a power on the person of my choice. I chose myself today so if a baddy takes an action on me that doesn’t kill me I can reveal on thread.


Conor, you spotted this information very quickly and I had been running it as if you were good all day but something just clicked. You are on Poison Ivy’s potential list. She will be worried that if she gives me poison I can reveal on thread who it is that gave it to me. That would actually explain the delay in her poisoning somebody. If She saw my post this morning and was planning on giving me the real poison very close to lynch, leaving Alfred little time to respond. This is why I have opted to come out. I felt I might of gotten lucky this morning, by hiding my information, but after Doris also spotted it I felt that its very unlikely that 5 baddies all missed it.

Conor Good or Bad ?

What I like about Conors post was that it was relatively quick and you would have to be a quick reader to read my post in 30 mins and come up with a plan. However, if you were on a team you would have a better chance of spotting it. In short , I am not sure where I stand on you Conor, a peak from the Seer might be worthwhile. I felt leaving things as wink wink between me and you could get you a lot of village credibility.

What is Orla smoking ? I want some!!!

I did not protect Orla, not sure what that was all about. Its either a wolf play to flush me out or a wolf play to put pressure on Orla. . I still cant work out why Orla came out on thread, getting protected doesn’t mean you need to come out like that, if you had of said nothing you prob wouldn’t be on anybodys radar. The timing of the "protection" announcement makes me think of a riddler power, but the question is whether Orla was using it for cover or was it used to confuse her.

Robin was not actually my apprentice (which I thought was odd), so there might be another who will gain access to my room and powers if I die.

My Abigail Theory (when working out Riddler)

I do feel that my Abigail theory is reasonably sound (look at it from last night if you aren’t familiar). In short Desmond went after Dent from Monday morning and all day. Would Dent toss a coin to “save” Desmond ? And I presume Dent would of known the outcome of both coin tosses. So if he didn’t know if Desmond had poison or not , why potentially save him ? Why not wait and see if the poison takes Dessie ? I think he knew it was fake poison which would mean Abigail got the real poison. Again , this is a theory and I know where Wendy is coming from, cant clear people on that, but for now I would sort of be feeling less about Abigail being a wolf. I am only putting this up here again in case people are Riddler hunting. Its not definitive, but its certainly a potential plus for me.

Joker - Jake or Henry?

In terms of Jake v Henry, my money is on Jake being the joker. Its not a definitive feel but there is good reason why I think it that I wont disclose yet. There is only one potential way that Henry is joker from my deductions, so its unfortunate for him if its this less likely outcome. Unless somebody else has a better read or suggestion my preference is to off Jake as the joker.

Holly, sexy Selena, or sneaky Penguin fishface mcf**k?

In terms of Hollys reveal, I am taking it at face for the moment but I do worry this could be a Penguin ruse of sorts. Others have highlighted concerns I share. If Gertie shows up good , Holly dies, its fairly straight forward to be fair.

So what now ?

Read through this post and help us come up with a plan. Unless I have misread everything, we kill Gertie tonight it confirms Hollys story or consigns Holly to death tomorrow. If a goody gets a prize kill Jake. We could chance killing Jake tonight, which may mean no SK kill tomorrow but if on the small chance its Henry it would be a wasted Kill. As i said, I have reliable information that suggests Henry is not Joker, but there is one way its possible he passed this test.

Also , Alfred please keep a sharp eye out for the poison, I will reveal immediately if I get it, but it might be too late. Maybe have the laptop ready to go. Maybe ask mods can you put in a placeholder for flower or rose as an automatic choice if you cant change in time.

Who done the numbers earlier? Can we have anymore NRVs after Doris?

I'm going with Jake. If Batman's info is reliable, then he IS the Joker! I think people should go here tonight. We don't know if the SK kill passes to Harley. But killing the Joker and potentially having one less kill tomorrow is optimal for the village surely?

Is there any liklihood that Batman has been silenced and Frank is talking bull?

Not likely i know, but throwing it out there.

I believe frank. He’s been pro village the entire game.

Need people talking.

Sorry all, today hasn’t been good for keeping up. I’m still not fully sure how we reconcile the Conor/ Orla/ holly trinity. My second part of orlas iso is still not complete but I’ve enough there to be confident she’s lying to us, so she’s my pick for a wolf. Based on today am I right we likely have Gertie too since he aligns in a few players reveals?

As for a plan

Kill Gertie, if correct

Kill Jake, if correct

Go after ivy

Abigail WW wrote: »

Sticking with Gertie.

Conor's batcomputer comments have you/Jake as Joker.
It stands to reason you want to start a wagon. Not planning on hopping on it just yet.

If I survive munch in morning, I'll look in that direction.

Why would I start a wagon in the only person who can prove me as the joker!?

If anything I'd be advocating leaving him alive. If he's killed and not the joker I'm the next Target....

There's absolutely no good reason for me to get Jake lynched if I'm the bloody joker. Good God

Henry WW wrote: »

Why would I start a wagon in the only person who can prove me as the joker!?

If anything I'd be advocating leaving him alive. If he's killed and not the joker I'm the next Target....

There's absolutely no good reason for me to get Jake lynched if I'm the bloody joker. Good God

Brain fart moment.