Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Werewolf: Batman
Options
Comments
-
-
-
-
-
See above and the link in it from last night. Nobody seemed to be wondering (on thread anyways) why the joker didn’t get a kill yesterday. I know the SK is just one person but they get one kill and now they have 2 on their team.
So your line of thinking is that the SK got to chose to either convert/kill? I like that your trying to work it out but I would say it's more along the lines of having something to do with the lynch as the announcement was after the results. Surely if the SK chose to convert or kill the announcement for conversion would have been at 10:00am yesterday?
It still doesn't explain the lack of SK kill though, maybe they missed the deadline for sending in the kill order or something? I know in my first game as a wolf I missed the deadline for my power, it wasn't my finest hour
0 -
Advertisement
-
-
-
-
-
So your line of thinking is that the SK got to chose to either convert/kill? I like that your trying to work it out but I would say it's more along the lines of having something to do with the lynch as the announcement was after the results. Surely if the SK chose to convert or kill the announcement for conversion would have been at 10:00am yesterday?
It still doesn't explain the lack of SK kill though, maybe they missed the deadline for sending in the kill order or something? I know in my first game as a wolf I missed the deadline for my power, it wasn't my finest hour
The timing of the conversion after the lynch is the odd part alright so I can see why the focus is on the votes to be fair. I have seen a wolf team miss the deadline so that’s not completely impossible but is unlikely.
Look at robins convert this morning. Very odd time, seems almost random. Maybe joker had a choice of convert or kill but had to wait until after lynch? Maybe at a set time in the game there was always going to be converts (goody and baddy?)0 -
Advertisement
-
-
-
-
-
Liam P2My guess is that it's advanced warning that there's going to be a competition at 1pm tomorrow.It will. Today is Day 0. Tomorrow is Day 1.
Wut?Okay, see it now.Yeah, pretty much. It's advance warning today (Day 0), that there's going to be a competition tomorrow (Day 1) at 1pm.My clip is better as it actually cuts to show he's looking at Kim Bassinger.
This is all fine, just conversation around competition. Helpful for all reallyHow do you know this?
Games often have tasks in Day 0. Less likely to have competitions then, but tasks, yeah.Other way around usually.
Mechanical stuffBarbara, I think you might be on to something. What do you make of the mod's second post, of the 32deg?
Clarifications mehShe's not listed, but she's right there in the OP. You really think she'd not make an appearance, or even think she might and that mentioning her wouldn't be a good idea.
Helpful mechanicsOnce only that I can see:
Only other mention was Fiona's who picked up on Gabriel's post:Ah okay. I was just looking for "Harvey Quinn" combos. Nice find.If we're bringing up odd posts, I'd noted this as odd also.
Also here only post.*her
Though, just realised, it was way after the newspaper article was published, so probably not related. Still worth nothing though IMO.
Helpful, looking for tasks. Working as a team her. Good lookGenie!
If I understood correctly after the 13-seer game, a full reveal was recommended simply because the seer was the only role. While I think the intentions are good (though I'm not thrilled about who made the suggestion), I don't think we should go down the road of saying who we peeked.
Push back against Spartacus. I like the Spartacus idea so I maybe biased on this one. Doesn’t really explain what their issue with it is though, just hangs there.If you say it often enough we might just believe you.Not just that. But also her OP saying "she wished she'd randed Harley" and the newspaper article coming right after.Can you expand on this? You posted it in relation to the newspaper post from the mods.
Getting into some finger pointing. I’d high hopes here but....It is worth discussing, but this time of night, when most are heading to bed, and having not a massive amount of time before munch in the morning, probably wasn't the time to suggest it, and certainly not the time to act on it.
That's assuming you're the genuine article.
....bedtime kills it (it was late tbf)Seems like a decent enough paraphrase to me, tbh:Yeah, was surprised you'd take part. I put it down to the drink.Not helping Orla, not helping.You’re obsessed by Chandler, mate.
Bit banter, backing other players views, mehIt's really not the same deal. Player dies, auto-priest says they're Batman. What does the fact that they were one of the ones who claimed Batman actually tell us? That helps us.
OtOH, a seer actually has useful information to leave behind.
And as mentioned previously, that is a "seer game". Everyone is NRV, wolf or seer. As vanilla as you can get. This is an entirely different game.
I've slept on it. I've read the arguments. I'm still against it.
Ok better explanation of their view if spartacus. Seems a bit counter intuitive to me tbh but at least they’re giving somethingI already answered this in 496 to Barbara.Why claim him at all?Tasks for first kill?
Though that usually happens between two wolf teams. Less often between wolf team and SK. But could explain some odd posting over the weekend?
I guess we'll see when bodies start appearing.Barbara's theory was Joker found Harley and former was Gabriel and latter was Eva.
We know at least one part of that is now wrong (Gabriel wasn't the Joker)
Questions remaining:
- Did Joker actually find Harley? Is she even in the game? My guess is Yes to both.
- Is Eva Harley with an unknown Joker? I thought for sure she was when Barbara proposed it. I've wavering since, based on Eva's posts, and more now that Gabriel turned out not to be the Joker.
Some opinion, some mechanical stuff. Not much here tbh, not impressed seeing mechanics this far in thoughIs that not what I said? It's certainly what I meant to say. It was Eva (the potential Harley) was was breadcrumbing.
Tags EvaTBH, I think Desmond could be a wolf, being "poisoned" to garner villager points.
I'd already had the tingles about this, and his quick response "expecting it" ups my suspicious mind.
Tags desIf Alfred is listening, I think Abigail should be saved.
Very definite but it is consistent to previous postYeah. I noticed that (you asking her). Didn't understand the significance of the question at the time. Would I be right in saying that she's not actually replied? This could be a really good find actually. I'd be interested in her answer. Though I'd a village lean on Fiona up to now.That's fine. That's asked a lot. It's the specific use of 11 and 4 that seem odd.
I mean, if you've 20 posts per page, on page 11, you'll be on maximum 220. That'd be page 6 on 40 posts per page.
It could well be nothing. But that she brought up those two numbers twice is interesting, and it'd be good to have an explanation.
Again engaging on other players (me) theories. Not clear why you wouldn’t ask about the first part before now if you were wondering. Want to like it but not sure I doCompetition entered. I WANT A PRIZE!I went 11.We all know how that went down!!!I know. I’m on board. I was only teasing.Someone will win, whoever is closest.
But yeah, it doesn't maximise the Village's chance of getting the prize.
I wonder how the mods split it if the number is chosen by more than one person, or more than one person distant from the number. Probably a toss of a coin.
Getting into the competition. Not liking the only teasing bit here, it feels like a player who’s hedged their bet and then went the way the wind is blowing.Of course she knew.So did I actually. I'll probably change though. When I'm home.
Tags Eva again#FFA1
Clodagh - still not liking her OP, and she's not done anything since to earn village points
Steve - still worried he may have been doing a task. No Shakespeare since munch
Orla - think she was doing a task.
Honourable mention to Eva. I really, really like her posts. I think she's coming across villagery and I kind of want her to be village. But I still can't get away from her potential call to the Joker followed by the mod's newspaper announcement. I'm parking it for now, but I remain suspicious.
Also, (further) proof that Harley is likely to be in the game is Gabriel's character not being in the OP either. Mods even said they had secrets, and now we know that part of those secrets include secret roles.
Further honourable mentions to a significant handful of players that I have zero read on and need to get involved more: Brendan, Gertrude, Holly, Isla, Jake. Jake has more post count than others like Clodagh, Phil and Riona, yet I've no memory of a single significant post they've made this game.
I hate this ffa tbh. I can’t link it clearly to anything that went before. Eva was his vote but is now honorable mention. It’s like she just slips out of view.I'm not on the Eva bandwagon.
But you were!!Just as a matter of interest, because I'm leaning village on Fiona too ... in what scenario would wolf-Fiona badger Gabriel so much, knowing that he was going to be chow this morning? A double-bluff?
Maybe she wasn't converted. Maybe she was always team SK but they had to find each other to strategies together.
Fair enough point hereExplain? What lies?Mods have secrets. Gabriel's character wasn't listed.Go for it.They did. So?They're there as flavour, not as players.
Harley could also be seen as flavour, as she's in a photo.
Were the Wayne's added in later? Mods only clarification was the anon accounts that were removed.
Don’t like this at all, not now Harley is in the gameNever even noticed the "other" option. I didn't scroll down that far.
Or this, it’s not viableI don't know why you'd presume that?
There were just two too many anon accounts listed. I can't see what that has to do with Gabriel and another person.
Anyway, it's irrelevant.
I still think there's a good chance Harley is in this game.
YepAh. I see the confusion.
I meant Gabriel's character (Thomas Wayne), not listed as a role.
Yeah, the Gabriel WW account was there all along.@Wendy, I'd still like an answer to this please. I don't like being called a liar when I've not been.
This is just silly given what went before.I said I had voted for her, but was going to change when I got home. Which I did. She didn't even make my FFA.Reasons?I didn't hop off it. I was never on it. She was a placeholder this morning long before a bandwagon had formed.Sigh.
I voted this morning. Even if I stayed on Eva, how is that a bandwagon, when I voted within 30 minutes of the form opening?
FWIW, I'm leaning Villager on Fiona, so don't think you should vote there either. Of those, Ewan is probably you're best bet, though he didn't make my FFA.
Covered this already. Consistent on Fiona, pushes ewanLOL! Okay, I'll give you that. But I didn't notice the "other" when I did that.Should we all declare at 8.59pm who we voted for? Just in case there's any messing around of votes?You don't believe her Martha claim?I'm not sure what's happening.I voted Desmond.Mine was cast ages ago (around the time I did the FFA). I declared because:
Which everyone else seemed to ignore.
Grand consistent with ffaHow will we know if nobody actually says who they voted for?So only discrepancy I can see is that Ewan said he voted for Fiona, but results show Wendy.
Anyone else appear in the results where they didn't expect to?
Helpful here.Actually, scratch that because I don't see where he said it any more. I might have got it mixed up with Fiona saying she was voting for Ewan.You voted Steve, but it says Desmond?Reordered in time order. Hadn't noticed Fiona voting so late as there were three names after hers, so this might be easier.
Ewan WW Angus WW 7/22/2019 18:16:49 1
Wendy WW 7/22/2019 19:14:14 1
Henry WW 7/22/2019 19:51:59 1
Abigail WW 7/22/2019 20:24:47 1
Desmond WW 7/22/2019 20:34:15 1
eva ww 7/22/2019 20:52:49 1
Phil WW 7/22/2019 20:58:24 1
Fiona ww 7/22/2019 20:59:35 1
Ewan WW Total 8
Orla WW steve ww 7/22/2019 10:11:46 1
Holly WW 7/22/2019 18:22:48 1
Gertrude WW 7/22/2019 19:41:47 1
Frank WW 7/22/2019 20:22:52 1
Jake WW 7/22/2019 20:32:30 1
Orla WW Total 5
Desmond WW Liam WW 7/22/2019 18:48:08 1
Clodagh WW 7/22/2019 19:04:17 1
Brendan WW 7/22/2019 20:55:43 1
Desmond WW Total 3
Eva WW Doris WW 7/22/2019 10:15:09 1
Conor WW 7/22/2019 20:36:59 1
Eva WW Total 2
Frank WW Orla WW 7/22/2019 17:55:40 1
Frank WW Total 1
Fiona WW Tegan WW 7/22/2019 18:50:54 1
Fiona WW Total 1
Liam WW Riona ww 7/22/2019 19:11:30 1
Liam WW Total 1
Conor WW Barbara WW 7/22/2019 19:41:03 1
Conor WW Total 1
Wendy WW Ewan WW 7/22/2019 20:32:47 1
Wendy WW Total 1Well one. Angus.
Again helpful. Not advancing things much but helpful.I agree. Still leaves the question of the meaning of the newspaper open.Yesterday, yeah, I was the first to point out your weird OP. And you stayed in my FFA today because of it. But I didn't even vote for you so not sure how I could have started your bandwagon.Yeah, very possible.And Steve too then? As your first?Ohhhhh, I get it now.Why is Orla's vote off wagon villagery but Tegan's is wolfy?
I'm not insinuating anything by the question, btw, just trying to understand.Oooh, congrats on the promotion, Robin!Ah, thanks, I get you.
Now sleeeep!
Lots of short bits then (tbh I’m beginning to lose the will at this stage)
Will be back with conclusion in a bit0 -
Someone has been poisonedPoison Ivy has been a busy girl! It would seem another two Citizens of Gotham have been hospitalized showing symptoms of a very specific type of poison. They were once again recipients of flower deliveries this morning. (Sorry taffic caused the delay).
Phil WW recieved a Rose
Jake WW received an Orchid
Both Gotham residents' symptoms started to show almost immediately. One's will subside at the end of the day phase, the other will not be so luck.0 -
-
Bounty Hunter wrote: »Someone has been poisonedPoison Ivy has been a busy girl! It would seem another two Citizens of Gotham have been hospitalized showing symptoms of a very specific type of poison. They were once again recipients of flower deliveries this morning. (Sorry taffic caused the delay).
Phil WW recieved a Rose
Jake WW received an Orchid
Both Gotham residents' symptoms started to show almost immediately. One's will subside at the end of the day phase, the other will not be so luck.
I see mischief is afoot.0 -
-
-
Advertisement
-
-
That's interesting now. If Phil is NRV, is he better sacrificing himself for Alfred to take a pot shot at hitting a baddie?
I'm not sure. Can someone do the numbers? I just have to run for a bit.
Phil -if you're village then sorry you got the flower. Story of my life - no one ever gives me flowers.
Here you go
0 -
-
-
-
-
Bounty Hunter wrote: »Someone has been poisonedPoison Ivy has been a busy girl! It would seem another two Citizens of Gotham have been hospitalized showing symptoms of a very specific type of poison. They were once again recipients of flower deliveries this morning. (Sorry taffic caused the delay).
Phil WW recieved a Rose
Jake WW received an Orchid
Both Gotham residents' symptoms started to show almost immediately. One's will subside at the end of the day phase, the other will not be so luck.
Ahh Jaysus.0 -
-
-
Advertisement
-
Advertisement