Advertisement
Help Keep Boards Alive. Support us by going ad free today. See here: https://subscriptions.boards.ie/.
https://www.boards.ie/group/1878-subscribers-forum

Private Group for paid up members of Boards.ie. Join the club.
Hi all, please see this major site announcement: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058427594/boards-ie-2026

Manchester United Team Talk/Gossip/Rumours Thread - Read Mod Warning in OP 7/1/15

1275276278280281328

Comments

  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 12,219 ✭✭✭✭Pro. F


    kryogen wrote: »
    We have a fundamental disagreement there then, I don't see how you can call that football attractive either, it has been at least 6 years (imo) since we were playing consistently good, attractive football.

    If you are following the team 30+ years you must surely understand the process of building to something? Take into account how bad the football was in Fergies last season alone, in the season Moyes was in charge, it was not going to be solved by buying a few players, the entire squad needs an overhaul while also meeting the demands of keeping CL football.

    That is not an easy thing to do, if we get back into the CL this year it will have been a very good season, and one to build on next season, by hook or by crook. Van Gaal has developed teams before, we know this, he has had his teams play some outstanding football, consistently, we know this. Keep the faith and trust that even if you don't know what he is doing, he does.

    It seems like the bolded line is accepted by a lot of posters on here, but I have to say I disagree with it. I think people are misremembering the type of football we were playing in Ronaldo's last two seasons and disregarding all the good stuff we produced in the years after that until Fergie retired.

    In run-of-the-mill league games in the Ronaldo years there was a lot of interchanging of position to accommodate the star, but it was nothing amazing in terms of attractiveness or attacking compared to the standard Ferguson pattern - good games and bad, always well organised defensively, always finishing games strong with lots of pressing and always attacking for the win. In the big games in that period, especially the big CL games, we played more defensively than at any other time I can remember.

    After Ronaldo left, the mad interchanging stopped, but the team were still attacking, pressing and chasing the win in the normal league games. And in the big games there was a lot more high pressing than there had been. The general level of play was a bit poor (therefor less attractive) in Fergie's last season, but it was still more attacking with far higher pressing than the vast majority of PL teams you will see, and it was effective. It was miles better than what we have seen under Moyes and LVG.

    I had plenty to complain about in Fergie's time, but it was never anywhere near as bad as this.

    Edit: I should clarify that this is all just my memory of it. None of us can be certain either way.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,308 ✭✭✭Pyjamarama


    irishfeen wrote: »
    Arsenal certs for 3rd and Liverpool favourites for 4th now IMO .. If we get CL now I think it will be achievement.

    I'll call it - you heard it first!
    1. City
    2. Chelsea
    3. Arsenal
    4. Liverpool
    5. United
    6. Spurs

    With the talent at LVG's disposal?? 4th should be completely minimum and be viewed as a poor season. How many of liverpools players would actually get their game for United? Or Spurs? Or Southampton? I'm a liverpool fan and i can tell you not many.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 8,547 ✭✭✭Your Airbag


    To say its tight now is an understatement.

    o1MsAks.jpg

    Our next 8 EPL games before the final month of the season

    Man Utd v Sunderland
    Newcastle V Man Utd
    Man Utd V Tottenham
    Liverpool V Man Utd
    Man Utd V Aston Villa
    Man Utd V Man City
    Chelsea V Man Utd
    Everton V Man Utd

    Bar Villa at home they are all very tough fixtures. We could be in a bad way in two months time. Pool away will be huge.

    I predict WDWLWDLD giving us 12 points

    Arsenals next eight, not as tough as ours and all their big game clashes are at home

    Arsenal V Everton
    QPR V Arsenal
    Arsenal V West Ham
    Newcastle V Arsenal
    Arsenal V Liverpool
    Burnley V Arsenal
    Arsenal V Sunderland
    Arsenal V Chelsea

    I predict WWWDDWWD giving them 18 points

    The Saints next eight, some tough away games

    West Brom V Southampton
    Southampton V Crystal Palace
    Chelsea V Southampton
    Southampton V Burnley
    Everton V Southampton
    Southampton V Hull
    Stoke V Southampton
    Southampton V Tottenham

    DWLWLWDD I'm going with 12 points

    Pools next eight, four big team games, two at home and they are playing well now

    Liverpool V Man City
    Liverpool V Burnley
    Swansea V Liverpool
    Liverpool V Man Utd
    Arsenal V Liverpool
    Liverpool V Newcastle
    Hull V Liverpool
    West Brom V Liverpool

    DWWWLWWW 19 points

    Spurs next eight, they have the easiest of the fixtures imo, two big games and some poor teams to play

    Tottenham V Swansea
    QPR V Tottenham
    Man Utd V Tottenham
    Tottenham V Leicester
    Burnley V Tottenham
    Tottenham V Aston Villa
    Newcastle V Tottenham
    Southampton V Tottenham

    WWLWWWDL 16 points

    That would leave it like this with four games left

    3rd Arsenal 66 pts
    4th Liverpool 64 pts
    5th Spurs 60 pts
    6th Utd 59 pts
    7th Southampthon 58 pts

    Being 5 points behind Pool in fourth with four games remaining would be a nightmare, not out of it by then but a big ask and lots of luck needed to get fourth in that scenario. 3rd is gone I think with the fixtures everyone has coming up. A point ahead of the 7th place team, is it possible to finish 7th two years in a row? LVGs head must roll hard if we do given the cash spent.

    I hope I'm wrong but we have two very tough months coming up and I have a bad feeling.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,453 ✭✭✭Sheepy99


    If United don't get fourth, would ye be surprised to see Van Gaal leave if a manager of big enough reputation became available?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 19,199 ✭✭✭✭bucketybuck


    Sheepy99 wrote: »
    If United don't get fourth, would ye be surprised to see Van Gaal leave if a manager of big enough reputation became available?

    Considering the easy ride he's getting I suspect he will stay even if he doesn't get fourth.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,292 ✭✭✭Adamocovic


    Sheepy99 wrote: »
    If United don't get fourth, would ye be surprised to see Van Gaal leave if a manager of big enough reputation became available?

    I would be surprised to see him sacked in the summer even if we don't get fourth. I don't think they will want to put the club into disarray by bringing in a fourth manager in such a short time. I imagine the club would at the very minimum wait until October or November before deciding if they are to part ways. (I'm hoping it doesn't come to that)

    Now would LVG "leave" the club? I doubt it. He has his plan, he has his contract and has made a big deal about seeing it out. It would look poor on his part to pack up bags and leave.

    Still i am firmly in the group who think talks of a new manager are absurd. Yes we aren't playing spectacular but we are still 4th in the league, still in the FA cup and in with a great shout of CL football.

    If we are doing that well when everyone is complaining about how poor we have been then things aren't too bad. Surely a run of good form isn't too far away and if we do step it up a gear and make the possession count we could be a very dangerous side again.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,758 ✭✭✭Strongbow10


    To say its tight now is an understatement.

    o1MsAks.jpg

    Our next 8 EPL games before the final month of the season

    Man Utd v Sunderland
    Newcastle V Man Utd
    Man Utd V Tottenham
    Liverpool V Man Utd
    Man Utd V Aston Villa
    Man Utd V Man City
    Chelsea V Man Utd
    Everton V Man Utd

    Bar Villa at home they are all very tough fixtures. We could be in a bad way in two months time. Pool away will be huge.

    I predict WDWLWDLD giving us 12 points

    Arsenals next eight, not as tough as ours and all their big game clashes are at home

    Arsenal V Everton
    QPR V Arsenal
    Arsenal V West Ham
    Newcastle V Arsenal
    Arsenal V Liverpool
    Burnley V Arsenal
    Arsenal V Sunderland
    Arsenal V Chelsea

    I predict WWWDDWWD giving them 18 points

    The Saints next eight, some tough away games

    West Brom V Southampton
    Southampton V Crystal Palace
    Chelsea V Southampton
    Southampton V Burnley
    Everton V Southampton
    Southampton V Hull
    Stoke V Southampton
    Southampton V Tottenham

    DWLWLWDD I'm going with 12 points

    Pools next eight, four big team games, two at home and they are playing well now

    Liverpool V Man City
    Liverpool V Burnley
    Swansea V Liverpool
    Liverpool V Man Utd
    Arsenal V Liverpool
    Liverpool V Newcastle
    Hull V Liverpool
    West Brom V Liverpool

    DWWWLWWW 19 points

    Spurs next eight, they have the easiest of the fixtures imo, two big games and some poor teams to play

    Tottenham V Swansea
    QPR V Tottenham
    Man Utd V Tottenham
    Tottenham V Leicester
    Burnley V Tottenham
    Tottenham V Aston Villa
    Newcastle V Tottenham
    Southampton V Tottenham

    WWLWWWDL 16 points

    That would leave it like this with four games left

    3rd Arsenal 66 pts
    4th Liverpool 64 pts
    5th Spurs 60 pts
    6th Utd 59 pts
    7th Southampthon 58 pts

    Being 5 points behind Pool in fourth with four games remaining would be a nightmare, not out of it by then but a big ask and lots of luck needed to get fourth in that scenario. 3rd is gone I think with the fixtures everyone has coming up. A point ahead of the 7th place team, is it possible to finish 7th two years in a row? LVGs head must roll hard if we do given the cash spent.

    I hope I'm wrong but we have two very tough months coming up and I have a bad feeling.

    You have Arsenal v Liverpool predicted as a draw (when predicting Arsenals fixture outcomes) and a loss for Liverpool (in Liverpool section). 2 different outcomes for the Southampton v Spurs fixture too

    And they say the table doesn't lie :cool:


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 14,134 ✭✭✭✭Rayne Wooney


    I think we'll be on 61 after the Everton game and Liverpool ahead on 64/65 with Arsenal ahead of them


  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 1,861 ✭✭✭fuzzydunlop85


    If we don't get fourth this year the squad is gonna need a serious overhaul(and even If we do), the whole defence / attack could be ditched for all I care. Realistically though I can see Evans, Falcao, Rafael, Mc Nair going for sure, would love to get rid of Jones, smalling and RVP also. We should also cut out losses with Di Maria if PSG make us a decent offer. Worried about the quality of player we are gonna be able to attract though if we miss out on CL, we might have to take a punt on some young players(which might not be a bad thing).


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 8,073 ✭✭✭irishfeen


    Pyjamarama wrote: »
    With the talent at LVG's disposal?? 4th should be completely minimum and be viewed as a poor season. How many of liverpools players would actually get their game for United? Or Spurs? Or Southampton? I'm a liverpool fan and i can tell you not many.
    I think sometimes people overrate United players because they are playing for United .. Valencia. Jones, Evans, Smalling, McNair are all very average PL players who will be moved from 1st team duties over the next few windows.

    RVP also coming to the end of his fantastic career. United have problems all over the place but LVG will fix them - of that I have no doubt.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2, Paid Member Posts: 19,300 ✭✭✭✭Mantis Toboggan


    irishfeen wrote: »
    I think sometimes people overrate United players because they are playing for United .. Valencia. Jones, Evans, Smalling, McNair are all very average PL players who will be moved from 1st team duties over the next few windows.

    LVG just gave McNair a new contract and is playing him right back ahead of Valencia and Rafael even though he's a central defender. So I cannot take the rest of the post seriously.

    Free Palestine 🇵🇸



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 14,134 ✭✭✭✭Rayne Wooney




  • Closed Accounts Posts: 17,638 ✭✭✭✭bangkok



    cant take him back until summer, he should be brought back, we can give them valencia on loan for the year instead


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 8,073 ✭✭✭irishfeen


    LVG just gave McNair a new contract and is playing him right back ahead of Valencia and Rafael even though he's a central defender. So I cannot take the rest of the post seriously.
    You can do what you want with my post because I couldn't give a shíte but McNair will not be playing as a main member of the next United PL winning team - squad player, absolutely, but not first choice unless he improves drastically. Might happen but I doubt it.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 25,953 ✭✭✭✭kryogen


    irishfeen wrote: »
    No point in panicking, just being realistic.. Current form means we don't deserve top 4... Of course that could change but we've been saying that for a while now.

    Last 6 league games we have won 4 drawn 1 and lost 1

    Its not shambolic form in fairness, the football isn't actually that bad you know until it gets to the final third, the lack of movement and cutting edge is absolutely murdering us, its slow, its laboured a hell of a lot and of course it can be much better. To call it terrible is off the mark though I feel, the final ball is terrible, the execution of the attackers is terrible, but the performances have been pretty dominant for the most part.

    The final third is where it counts of course so I understand the frustration and he sure as **** needs to get it sorted sooner rather then later , the toothless attack is dragging us into a fight that we really should be above tbh. The team spirit is good which is a big positive and if it was not I would probably be more concerned.

    Why I have faith in Van Gaal? His career demands I have faith in him, his self confidence and ability to remain calm and not get carried away gives me plenty of faith in him. I don't understand certain choices he makes, of course I disagree with decisions he takes but I do understand that he has a better insight into the goings on at the club, he obviously has a plan for how he wants to play and it has not come off yet.

    I choose to believe it will, the possession play is fine, it is something we have wanted for years at the club, to go out and to dominate the opposition, it is something they have improved upon greatly, but have all to often ended up in the possession without doing anything zone. It seems obvious to me how to help this possession turn in to more clear cut chances and goals but so far he has not really done that, he obviously has other ideas about how he wants them to progress.

    Playing with two strikers can work well even in this system as long as the strikers have the pace or movement to drag defenders out of position and to give them something to worry about in behind, they are always very comfortable with the ball in front of them. Midfielders getting forward and making the unselfish runs would be helpful too obviously to isolate defenders, to create space. The build up play needs to be a lot faster and sharper when it gets to the final third, everytime the ball goes to Valencia he slows it down and looks to go laterally or back, when he does go to cross he has taken so much time there is no chance for a ball played in behind the defenders since they are already in good positions to defend and it makes his crossing look even worse then it is as the ball is cut out so easily 9 times out of 10

    On the other side Shaw looks capable of delivering the early ball, as does Di Maria but the delivery has been poor too often, Young plays more quickly and gets the ball in to the box with his crosses a lot faster then the others right now so they can pose more problems, defenders don't like to be turned around facing their own goal and running back with strikers making runs in front or behind them and too often our attacks are so slow they have everything in front of them and see out the danger.

    The mess we are at the back is a lot down to the instability of a settled back line and if you don't have that it puts a doubt right through the team and I believe hampers the midfielders from commiting themselves forward enough as they don't want to get caught out at the back.

    The next month will tell us a lot about where we will finish this season and like I said, I am confident we will make the top 4, the dream of course would be that the attack clicks and we start getting the goals and destroying teams, I will be very happy to scrape through it this year and continue to work on using possession better and not just possession for the sake of possession. You have to allow a certain human factor also, the players will have been reeling from missing out on the CL last season and now that it looks to be so close this season the pressure will be taking some toll on them and again, allows a certain fear to creep in which hampers creative performance. I look forward to getting Carrick back to provide the calming influence again from midfield.

    One last thing as I am getting pressed for time, start Hererra, start him in every game please.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,022 ✭✭✭✭Iused2likebusts


    Pyjamarama wrote: »
    With the talent at LVG's disposal?? 4th should be completely minimum and be viewed as a poor season. How many of liverpools players would actually get their game for United? Or Spurs? Or Southampton? I'm a liverpool fan and i can tell you not many.

    Look at it from the other side how many utd players would get in the liverpool team.De gea di maria and possibly rooney are the only 3 i think would be an obvious upgrade.There is little or no difference between both squads. De Gea di maria sterling Sturridge rooney and you could argue the toss for the other 6 positions.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 29,346 ✭✭✭✭homerjay2005



    It pains me to think or best right sided attacking player Is banging in goals for another club, while we pay his wages.

    At least the man tries things and while they don't always come off, I'd rather see players do things apart from passing the ball side ways and back to Dr gea.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 8,547 ✭✭✭Your Airbag


    You have Arsenal v Liverpool predicted as a draw (when predicting Arsenals fixture outcomes) and a loss for Liverpool (in Liverpool section). 2 different outcomes for the Southampton v Spurs fixture too

    And they say the table doesn't lie :cool:


    My bad although it doesn't change the predicted final table :(


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2, Paid Member Posts: 17,234 ✭✭✭✭Nalz


    It pains me to think or best right sided attacking player Is banging in goals for another club, while we pay his wages.

    At least the man tries things and while they don't always come off, I'd rather see players do things apart from passing the ball side ways and back to Dr gea.

    100% on the money


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2, Paid Member Posts: 35,307 ✭✭✭✭The_Kew_Tour


    Not sure what was worse yesterday. Me being in Swansea end and having to get up off my seat when Swansea scored or just watching the pure desperation of that last 15 minutes yesterday.

    Once Swansea got in front even their fans were confident. We don't have that fear factor anymore.

    And from few players reactions from time to time its clear the "team spirit" is not as good as I expect.

    I could not help notice the amount of times De Gea kept shaking his head and arms at some of the play yesterday.

    EVENFLOW



  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,917 ✭✭✭Whatsisname


    Not sure what was worse yesterday. Me being in Swansea end and having to get up off my seat when Swansea scored or just watching the pure desperation of that last 15 minutes yesterday.

    Once Swansea got in front even their fans were confident. We don't have that fear factor anymore.

    And from few players reactions from time to time its clear the "team spirit" is not as good as I expect.

    I could not help notice the amount of times De Gea kept shaking his head and arms at some of the play yesterday.

    He genuinely seems shocked at some of the mistakes the players are making infront of him whenever he concedes.

    Also, as you were there, did the players seem a bit subdued when Herrera scored? on TV it looked like they were a bit, not sure if anyone elses noticed, someone on reddit said it too.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 25,953 ✭✭✭✭kryogen


    It pains me to think or best right sided attacking player Is banging in goals for another club, while we pay his wages.

    At least the man tries things and while they don't always come off, I'd rather see players do things apart from passing the ball side ways and back to Dr gea.

    Nani is doing exactly what he gets **** for from United fans on here, Di Maria is also doing exactly what Nani gets **** for from United fans on here.

    I would love them both at the club.


  • Posts: 17,925 ✭✭✭✭ [Deleted User]


    Rob Thomas wrote: »
    .......

    Seriously though, for all the gloom about the performances and the lack of a cutting edge, it is all about top 4 this season. Given the way the season has panned out with Spurs and Liverpool it should have been much easier and we should be odds on by now, but it's still the minimum requirement and it's how LVG will be measured at the end of the season.........

    Utd are currently odds on to finish in the Top4

    http://www.oddschecker.com/football/english/premier-league/top-4-finish

    and prior to this weekend's games were much shorter, also Man Utd have been odds on for Top4 for months.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2, Paid Member Posts: 35,307 ✭✭✭✭The_Kew_Tour


    He genuinely seems shocked at some of the mistakes the players are making infront of him whenever he concedes.

    Also, as you were there, did the players seem a bit subdued when Herrera scored? on TV it looked like they were a bit, not sure if anyone elses noticed, someone on reddit said it too.

    Did not take notice myself of that. Will have look at goals again in while.

    It was the lack of ideas once last 15 minutes came that surprised me. Never once did we look like we might create something.

    The Swansea players movement was very good and ours was anything but good. Cork had fine game. Nice player.

    EVENFLOW



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2, Paid Member Posts: 35,307 ✭✭✭✭The_Kew_Tour


    Augeo wrote: »
    Utd are currently odds on to finish in the Top4

    http://www.oddschecker.com/football/english/premier-league/top-4-finish

    and prior to this weekend's games were much shorter, also Man Utd have been odds on for Top4 for months.

    Think its worth a lay on the exchanges if you can get the right price.

    I think its 50\50 now if we get Top 4 or not

    EVENFLOW



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,292 ✭✭✭Adamocovic


    Hey at least we have loads of possession.....

    tumblr_ne771rY7kB1tk500go1_400.gif


  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 1,861 ✭✭✭fuzzydunlop85


    Pains me to say it but you have to admire the way Liverpool have turned their season around, they were a complete shambles and a laughing stock earlier in the season. Their signings have improved drastically over the season while ours have remained distinctly average(to put it mildly). Time for our lads to show some similar fight and spirit.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 29,346 ✭✭✭✭homerjay2005


    Think its worth a lay on the exchanges if you can get the right price.

    I think its 50\50 now if we get Top 4 or not

    the longer Liverpool arsenal and spurs remain in europe, the better it is for us.

    However, if they get knocked out in this round, I believe they are all ahead of us on current form so that makes us 6th . No matter what way people want to spin it, we are not playing well enough to deserve top 4.

    Our entire attacking unit is off form and the longer this goes on, the bigger the mess gets.


  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 1,861 ✭✭✭fuzzydunlop85


    Think its worth a lay on the exchanges if you can get the right price.

    I think its 50\50 now if we get Top 4 or not

    I would be lumping on the pool if I weren't a united fan, they have all the momentum while we just seem to be stagnating,


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,579 ✭✭✭MythicalMadMan


    I would be lumping on the pool if I weren't a united fan, they have all the momentum while we just seem to be stagnating,

    All the teams that played in the uefa cup had poor games today, Liverpool included, and in past seasons teams have performed badly after it. Its a big variable in terms of who finishes where in the race for the top 4.

    The longer spurs and liverpool stay in the better for us and Liverpool have an easier draw in the FA cup there fixture list could get quite packed up very soon.

    It'll be tight and I think southamton will be there or there abouts once they get their shooting boots back on.

    They have beat arsenal at home, drew with chelsea and where unlucky to lose to us and the pool. Ive no idea why poeple are writing them off bar the fact what their name is


This discussion has been closed.
Advertisement