Boards.ie PW (Favourite) "Big Man" Tournament

ShagNastii · 24-09-2014 06:58PM

Andre beats Bam Bam in a great bout. Bam Bam very much like Vader, almost cut from the same cloth, find it hard to suppress utter icons of wrestling in both Andre and Taker. Two brilliant Semis with WM12 rematch and a dream match for two guys that were one stage billed as kayfabe father and son.

So we have our two semi finals. It is Andre VS Big Show and The Undertaker VS Diesel.

We kick off with the Giants. No limited I will give this a few hours and we'll call it a day maybe late tonight or in the morn.

Semi Final 1

Andre The Giant
“The Original Big Man”
6a00d8341c630a53ef0147e4422722970b-800wi

VS

Big Show/The Giant
“Andre’s Son”

CSF · 24-09-2014 07:04PM

Andre. I really don't like Big Show at all

Alfred Borden · 24-09-2014 07:08PM

Andre for me too. One of the best big men and never have had any love for the Big Show.

Necro · 24-09-2014 07:09PM

Hmmm.... Gonna go with Big Show here, more my era and loved his early work as I said before. Andre, while great could barely move around the ring.

WinnyThePoo · 24-09-2014 07:10PM

Andre again for me. He defines BIG for me in every way.

Bounty Hunter · 24-09-2014 07:51PM

Andre.

Okay so Show was like a younger faster, more agile Andre but Andre was the larger than life big man that broke the mold and was a true global star, he made you go wow when it wasnt all shock tactics like in the attitude era and when Show was at his most prominent.

Andre simply deserves to lose in the final :pac:

gerrybbadd · 24-09-2014 08:19PM

Giving it to Big Show. Much more capable in the ring than Andre. Many better matches as well, against several different opponents. A former WCW, WWE and ECW champion.

Moneymaker · 24-09-2014 08:19PM

Andre, more charasmatic and more iconic then Show. And if you go way back before his WWE runs he was pretty agile for his size too.

Sin Eater · 24-09-2014 09:21PM

Andre over the Big Show. I do think that Big Show is probably the more skilled wrestler, and if he had been around back in the day, he would have been the bigger name, but he wasn't, Andre was, and he defined what it is to be a giant in wrestling.

24-09-2014 09:42PM

Can't believe Yoko went out so early, agreed Andre wa the ultimate big man, but poor Yoko was a sight to behold in his own way. As I said Andre is the ultimate big man. Obviously I grew up watching show but Andre had an aura about him and still does to this day which Big Show lost yearly when he built up some cred.

OBEY!

CIARAN_BOYLE · 24-09-2014 10:16PM

Big Show he just has more to him than being the big guy

24-09-2014 10:38PM

gerrybbadd wrote: »

Giving it to Big Show. Much more capable in the ring than Andre. Many better matches as well, against several different opponents. A former WCW, WWE and ECW champion.

Exactly this. Andre was absolute cack. Matches were just stupid looking, especially the tying himself up in the ropes bit. Big Show, or rather Giant, could move well and could throw drop kicks and do a nip up. Plus he had personality.

Griever931 · 24-09-2014 10:53PM

Big Show for me. I seen a lot more of his matches and preferred them too.

ShagNastii · 25-09-2014 09:07AM

So the 8th wonder of the world knocks out his protégé. The Big Slow has a very impressive showing for somebody that has been viewed as stale and boring in recent times. In our second semi-final we have two guys that led the new generation. One went on to sail the WWE ship through the Monday night wars and the other guy has driving the pirate that was firing the cannons at time. Dark lord of the Ministry and cool dude of the NWO. Diesel VS The Undertaker.

Semi Final 2

Undertaker+vs.+Diesel+%28Wrestlemania+XII%29.jpg

Diesel/Kevin Nash
"Big Daddy Cool"

VS

Undertaker
“The Phenom”

As with Andre/Show we’ll give this a few hours and most votes will take it.

CSF · 25-09-2014 09:30AM

Diesel. I'll never like Undertaker knowing the Kanyon story

Sin Eater · 25-09-2014 09:56AM

The Undertaker. Quite frankly he's the greatest big man of all time. He has been towards the top of the wrestling world for 24 odd years, is a household name, and has been stealing the spotlight at wrestlemania for years.

beakerjoe · 25-09-2014 10:00AM

Ah It has to be Taker. Best big man in the business and the main attraction at WM for the last 6-7 years. No body does it better. He made teh undertakler gimmick work and gave it more legs than it should have ever had. Also Nash sucks. Over rated to bits, only got where he is based on his friends.

CSF wrote: »

Diesel. I'll never like Undertaker knowing the Kanyon story

Go on..... Im unaware of the Kanyon story

Necro · 25-09-2014 10:06AM

Undertaker. Stated my reasons already in the last round. Countless match of the year candidates, multi world title reigns, and the Streak.

gerrybbadd · 25-09-2014 11:09AM

Taker all the way, so many memories. Sure, the Kanyon thing is a blip on an otherwise impeccable chart.

I like big Kev, but he's no Undertaker when it comes to match quality, legacy, presence, and many other clichéd attributes!

Bounty Hunter · 25-09-2014 03:49PM

Kanyon stuff aside...

Taker.

He is the greatest big man of all time imo His matches vs HBK at mania alone are better than anything any of these other big man could do match quality wize. Best Gimmick of all time. WWEs stalwart who had some great times like The Ministry, his HIAC bouts obviously highlighted by KOTR 98 and.... wait I should save some for why he should win the final

Griever931 · 25-09-2014 08:17PM

Undertaker for me. One of my favourite wrestlers growing up and found his matches more entertaining than Diesel's and his character too.

Moneymaker · 25-09-2014 08:41PM

Diesel has no chance here. Taker is superior in every way.

The Kanyon stuff obviously doesn't look great, but it doesn't take away from the sheer length oh his career and countless great matches.

CSF · 25-09-2014 09:41PM

Moneymaker wrote: »

Diesel has no chance here. Taker is superior in every way.

The Kanyon stuff obviously doesn't look great, but it doesn't take away from the sheer length oh his career and countless great matches.

For me it makes him a horrible person and that shapes my entire view of him

ShagNastii · 26-09-2014 09:45AM

So there we have it. With must debate Takers goes through. Our Final Andre VS Undertaker. Will let it ride for the rest of the day, most votes win.

THE FINAL

Andre The Giant
“The Original Big Man”
6a00d8341c630a53ef0147e4422722970b-800wi

VS

Undertaker
“The Phenom”

Bounty Hunter · 26-09-2014 10:05AM

Andre has that special aura about him but so does taker tbh

When you move past that with Andre unless you go back to before most posters here were born Andre wasn't exactly the best in the ring and didn't have too many classics but taker vs HBK, Foley, HHH, Angle etc were all brilliant

He had the best gimmick ever IMO and with it lead a top stable in the form of the Ministry.

He had a truly great entrance and reinvented himself brilliantly with the American badass, big evil etc.

He was for WWF what Sting was for WCW the man who never left and the man who they could rely on.

I could go on but I think its obvious I'm voting for taker. The best big man ever IMO and tbh I personally would have Vader number 2 not Andre although the big fellah was a legend

Necro · 26-09-2014 10:10AM

Undertaker for me too. I grew up watching the man, and the gimmick would never have survived a year in anyone else's hands. Taker found ways to breathe life back into his character to stop himself from going stale, and will surely go down as one of the best ever.

The Streak in its later years dominated Wrestlemanias and the breaking of it produced one of the greatest (for better or worse) and shocking moments in wrestling history.

gerrybbadd · 26-09-2014 10:44AM

Undertaker. He has everything, size, speed, agility, prescence, charisma. Many many classic matches down through the years. Deadly feuds with many of the top stars down through the ages.

Andre, well, every time i think of him, it's winning the Battle Royal at Wrestlemania, or being slammed by Hogan. And thats about it.

Undertaker for me, every day of the week

Kankan14 · 26-09-2014 12:08PM

Taker for me.

Longevity of character,charisma and countless superb matches.

Most important of all he was so agile/skilful for a big man in the ring.

Moneymaker · 26-09-2014 12:50PM

Undertaker. BH pretty much outlined my explanation :pac:

Taker had more memorable moments and matches for me.

Sin Eater · 26-09-2014 01:59PM

The Undertaker. Quite simply the best big man that has been in he business (that I am aware of). Since the days of Hulk Hogan the Undertaker has been a draw, he has seen Ultimate Warrior, Shawn Michaels, Sid, Bret Hart, Diesel, Steve Austin, The Rock, Edge, Batista, and dozens of others come to the WWE and go from the WWE, and he has always been towards the top!

Boards.ie PW (Favourite) "Big Man" Tournament

Comments