Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie

Mayo GAA Discussion Thread

1212213215217218335

Comments

  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,212 ✭✭✭lukin


    blueser wrote: »
    Didn't Donegal try the same trick against us (was it last year)? And they got their arses handed to them big style. Managers and selectors should try worrying about their own players' shortcomings, never mind having a pre-match dig at the opposition. It only fires your opponents up.

    Yeah McGuinness said some stuff before the game last year. I think managers do it to try to influence the referee more than upset the opposition.I would say most people in Cork think Ronan McCarthy (and Cuthbert) made asses of themselves by referring to Mayo before the game.
    Like you say it's better to keep the head down and concentrate on your own team.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 18,084 ✭✭✭✭BPKS


    blueser wrote: »
    Didn't Donegal try the same trick against us (was it last year)? And they got their arses handed to them big style. Managers and selectors should try worrying about their own players' shortcomings, never mind having a pre-match dig at the opposition. It only fires your opponents up.

    http://www.irishexaminer.com/sport/columnists/john-fogarty/john-fogarty-mayos-horan-no-stranger-to-mind-games-278162.html


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 16,373 ✭✭✭✭Fr Tod Umptious


    Just watched the match again on TV

    One thing that struck me, and it was mentioned on TV, was that this team were just going through the motions.
    They seemed to be never in doubt of their ability to win the game and expended as little energy as possible in doing so.

    They came out at half time and 'bang' went 7 pts up, hoping to finish off the game I presume.
    However they managed to loose that 7 pt lead I don't know but they did.
    But when Cork drew level, 'bang' they went 4 up, just like that.
    And again when Cork came back at them they added a few insurance scores and that was that.

    That is a good way to be playing a QF or SF, and Provincial games, they did the same v Roscommon, and v Galway, when Galway came out of the break with a few points in a row.

    Again I though Freemans efforts to win the ball to set up the goal were fantastic


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,039 ✭✭✭Call me Al


    My dad was at the match and he said the same thing as you Fr Tod, when I met him afterwards.
    They were never going to lose that game,and were always able to turn it up a gear when they had to.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,131 ✭✭✭NabyLadistheman


    Its easy to say that in hindsight. But they could very well have lost it if Colm O'Neill buried that last chance. Too close for comfort


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 16,373 ✭✭✭✭Fr Tod Umptious


    Its easy to say that in hindsight. But they could very well have lost it if Colm O'Neill buried that last chance. Too close for comfort

    Your right, but you could see them move up a gear when Cork drew level and again when they scored the second goal.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,291 ✭✭✭Padkir


    Didn't bother posting anything about it until I had watched it back again on telly and, to be honest, it just made me more confused as to what I thought about the game.

    Overall, have to be happy to get the win. Played reasonably well at times, but with plenty to work on for the semi final. Possibly lucky near the end but overall I think they were the better team and deserved the win.

    So onto a few specifics.

    The ref:
    Seemed absolutely atrocious watching it live, i.e. had no control over the game and made countless bad calls for both sides. Watching it on tv improved my opinion of him a little, although it was far from good. Thought Mayo got a raw deal in the 1st half (things like frees being given every time a few players surrounded a Cork man, despite no foul being committed). However, coming near the end, Cork were definitely screwed out of at least 1 or 2 points. Made the big calls right though, i.e. Aidan O'Shea was fouled when going down on the ball after Hennelly's save and the last foul was definitely outside the box. Overall, poor show and I hope it's his last for this year at least.

    The game itself:
    I don't know whether it's just that us Mayo fans are beginning to think confidently rather than optimistically, but I felt that we were tipping along without really getting going, yet looking like they could if the need arose. Similar to earlier games, they did enough and when they were under pressure, responded with good play and confident scores. Cork were better than I was expecting, but were very naive coming out from the back with the ball at times, especially given that everyone knows how hard the Mayo forwards work and how ferocious they are in the tackle. Think that the Cork fans give them a very hard time of it and they deserve more support than the few hundred that were in Croker on Sunday.

    Individual players:
    Thought Cafferkey and Barrett had a tough time of it today but seemed to get a bit tighter as the game progressed, with the exception maybe of the last 5 mins. Rest of the backs were solid again, with an honourable mention for Lee Keegan. He might not have been getting forward as much, but he kept a tight leash on Kerrigan, who effectively ran the show against Sligo, so big credit to him for that. Kerrigan is lightning quick, we all know that, but Keegan looked like he was at his ease keeping with him when he went off on long runs. Might not have taken the ball off him all that much, but forced him wide and made him recycle the ball, which is pretty much all you can ask of him.

    Midfield was unreal and most of the starting forwards played well.Thought Vaughan didn't have a great game when watching live, but seemed a lot better on telly somehow... Not sure why that is to be honest, must be just my perception. Dillon had a great game and Doherty is really beginning to shine. He looks very confident and he's a dangerous man when he looks like that.

    Subs were only ok... Varley was terrible and hard to see how he's ahead of Freeman or even Conroy. I think this could be one poor showing too much though so could spell the end of him for this year. Freeman worked like a dog but snatched at the one real decent chance he got. Think he needs to start to get a bit of confidence going.

    Looking to the Kerry match:
    Think that Tom Cunniffe and Freeman should start, leave Andy on the bench to settle things later in the game. Barrett could be one to miss out at the back if he wants to let Vaughan back to half back and bring in Gibbons or Moran, but it's a tough one to call.

    Not thinking too much about it yet, will look forward to the other two quarter finals next weekend first and see how that side is going.

    Conclusion:
    Happy with the win, relatively happy with the performance and seems to be no shortage of desire or belief in the team. Will have a good chance against Kerry but will be a very nervous trip to Croker at the same time. Looking forward to it already!


    A quick mention of the minors is deserved too, they were unbelievable at times in their game and it's great that we get to see them again as part of our semi final double header!

    Hon Mayo! :D


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,530 ✭✭✭davegrohl48


    What would be cool would be a player rating system with a bit of measurement to it similar to the way the football ranking table works.
    Relatively easy to set that up for forwards/midfielders. Takes a bit of thinking for defenders. Then those who post on here who watch the game back afterwards could fill in the blanks for:
    - turnovers won/lost
    - posessions per player
    - successful/unsuccessful passes
    - blocks made
    - successful tackles
    - Scoreable frees won
    - Frees given away

    Apply a weighting to various categories of performance. With the way substitutions happen in Gaelic Football (taking off corner forward first) I don't think this is operating at inter county level where player performance is rated based on measurement. Possibly Dublin/Donegal might be doing it. Clearly Mayo are not.
    The overarching player performance is how that players performance on average impacts the scoreboard for his team and opposition.
    So in a tight defensive game against Donegal you might rate even higher scoring and frees won. Which makes me think you could use the final scoreline to setup the weightings.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,938 ✭✭✭Coillte_Bhoy


    Read in Mayo News that there was a row at a county board meeting last week over Horan telling players not to play in club c'ship games despite what had been agreed. if there is an agreement in place then he was way out of order imo though only McLoughlin didnt play afaik


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,814 ✭✭✭✭keane2097


    What would be cool would be a player rating system with a bit of measurement to it similar to the way the football ranking table works.
    Relatively easy to set that up for forwards/midfielders. Takes a bit of thinking for defenders. Then those who post on here who watch the game back afterwards could fill in the blanks for:
    - turnovers won/lost
    - posessions per player
    - successful/unsuccessful passes
    - blocks made
    - successful tackles
    - Scoreable frees won
    - Frees given away

    Apply a weighting to various categories of performance. With the way substitutions happen in Gaelic Football (taking off corner forward first) I don't think this is operating at inter county level where player performance is rated based on measurement. Possibly Dublin/Donegal might be doing it. Clearly Mayo are not.
    The overarching player performance is how that players performance on average impacts the scoreboard for his team and opposition.
    So in a tight defensive game against Donegal you might rate even higher scoring and frees won. Which makes me think you could use the final scoreline to setup the weightings.

    Take a look at http://www.afl.com.au/match-centre/2014/19/syd-v-ess to see what your dream looks like realised.

    Scroll down and click Full-time stats -> Advanced stats


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,621 ✭✭✭ultrapercy


    Just watched the match again on TV

    One thing that struck me, and it was mentioned on TV, was that this team were just going through the motions.
    They seemed to be never in doubt of their ability to win the game and expended as little energy as possible in doing so.

    They came out at half time and 'bang' went 7 pts up, hoping to finish off the game I presume.
    However they managed to loose that 7 pt lead I don't know but they did.
    But when Cork drew level, 'bang' they went 4 up, just like that.
    And again when Cork came back at them they added a few insurance scores and that was that.

    That is a good way to be playing a QF or SF, and Provincial games, they did the same v Roscommon, and v Galway, when Galway came out of the break with a few points in a row.

    Again I though Freemans efforts to win the ball to set up the goal were fantastic

    I dont think it is a good thing. To win an all ireland Mayo need to win just 6 games. Its not a big ask to stay switched on for 6 70 minute intervals spread across 5 months. Habits are hard to break and they may find it hard to maintain the intensity level when they really need to. 4 semi finals on the trot is a good body of work tho and they do seem to have mastered the path to the final but as we saw last year drifting out of games wont seal the deal at the top level.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,530 ✭✭✭davegrohl48


    keane2097 wrote: »
    Take a look at http://www.afl.com.au/match-centre/2014/19/syd-v-ess to see what your dream looks like realised.

    Scroll down and click Full-time stats -> Advanced stats
    That is impressive and is the way Gaelic Games will go is going.
    If you look at something like turnovers it wasn't even a phrase used in discussing Gaelic Football even ten years ago. Now you have people attending games 50 years using the phrase. I think it's more enjoyable for the type of really interested fan to appreciate the valuable aspects outside of just scores.
    For example I'm a huge fan of blocks. I think it's a very difficult skill. If we had sideline stats at that AFL type advanced level Freeman would not have been subbed last year. He would have been down as winning difficult posessions. You'd probably rank differently pressured posessions i.e. winning the ball while under defensive coverage.
    The way I see it is that players will be assigned substitution ratings. So a proven game winner like Cillian OConnor has to totally not perform before you hit his substitution level as your factoring in his ability to setup/score goals/convert frees.
    During the course of the game the scoreline will change players substitution ratings e.g. a full back on a yellow card with ten minutes left while leading by 5 points and you've only one sub left has a low substitution rating as the square is going to be attacked heavily in the final ten minutes. You are at a real risk of finishing the game with 14 players and yer full back missing.
    A midfielder doing poor on catching kickouts will have a low rating with time almost up if all you need to do is win at least one kickout and use up some time.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 413 ✭✭neiphin


    Read in Mayo News that there was a row at a county board meeting last week over Horan telling players not to play in club c'ship games despite what had been agreed. if there is an agreement in place then he was way out of order imo though only McLoughlin didnt play afaik
    [FONT=Calibri,Arial,Helvetica,sans-serif][FONT=Times New Roman,serif]

    Quarter finals of this years intermediate football championship were due to take place this weekend.

    We have had a request from James Horan to delay this weekends fixtures based on the following reasons;
    1. James Horan feels that players will require maximum recovery time following last weekends quarter final against Cork.
    2. There are now only two weeks remaining before the Mayo/Kerry semi final and this is a very important game in Mayo Senior teams plans to
    progress into the All Ireland Final.

    Members of the CCC have discussed the matter at length with James Horan and have explained the pressures relating to County and Provincial fixtures.

    A proposal from the Senior Team manager had been considered and agreed and is as follows.

    The Intermediate Quarter Finals will now take place on Saturday the 30th of August and the eight participating teams will have their players released to them in the week leading up to the games.

    We regret the position regarding the coming weekend but taking all matters into account we have agreed to the proposal to try our best to be fair to all involved,[/FONT]
    [/FONT]


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,100 ✭✭✭Barlett


    That Horan story isn't entirely accurate, he had requested managers not to pick intercounty players in games where nothing was at stake.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 388 ✭✭Gary Neville


    Mayo were not impressive against Cork, IMO but I think that will suit them going into the Kerry Game.

    I would have been happy if we were within 5 points of Mayo on Sunday. We have a very inexperienced management team that were found our badly against the expertly prepared Kerry. Cork then completely changes tactics and employed 2 sweepers v Sligo (in preparation for the Mayo game)

    Cork had 8 players that made their c/ship debut in the last 14 months - there was a lot on injury concerns coming into the game - 2 players Kelly & Cahalane were not long back from serious hip ops and hadn't played much football. Cadogan had missed 2 months with a bad hamstring injury and again had very few games played. AW played very little league time and like Cadogan and Cahalane - he had been mostly involved with the Hurlers who had a lot of big games. Cork have had huge problems with their kick-outs and were always likely to struggle for possession. There was little or no preparation for the blanket defence system compared to the work put in by the likes of Donegal, Armagh and Monaghan - even though Cork were warned about taking the ball into contact - their lack of preparaion was always going to lead to mistakes.

    After Cork's terrible Munster Final and poor enoough form v Sligo, it was to be expected that Mayo went in very confident and were not expecting a big challenge.

    Kerry will set up in a pretty similar way to Cork and will plan to get the ball to their 2 scoring forwards. Mayo have learned a huge amount from the Cork Game and will be far better the next day. However it'll be a tactical arm wrestle with both sides haveing gtear insight to the strength and weaknesses of each other through Cian O Neill and Donie Buckley - I'm really looking forard to this one and I'd give a hesitant vote to mayo.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,736 ✭✭✭Fowler87


    neiphin wrote: »
    [FONT=Calibri,Arial,Helvetica,sans-serif][FONT=Times New Roman,serif]

    Quarter finals of this years intermediate football championship were due to take place this weekend.

    We have had a request from James Horan to delay this weekends fixtures based on the following reasons;
    1. James Horan feels that players will require maximum recovery time following last weekends quarter final against Cork.
    2. There are now only two weeks remaining before the Mayo/Kerry semi final and this is a very important game in Mayo Senior teams plans to
    progress into the All Ireland Final.

    Members of the CCC have discussed the matter at length with James Horan and have explained the pressures relating to County and Provincial fixtures.

    A proposal from the Senior Team manager had been considered and agreed and is as follows.

    The Intermediate Quarter Finals will now take place on Saturday the 30th of August and the eight participating teams will have their players released to them in the week leading up to the games.

    We regret the position regarding the coming weekend but taking all matters into account we have agreed to the proposal to try our best to be fair to all involved,[/FONT]
    [/FONT]
    Wonder is there any truth in Horan threatening to walk if they were played this weekend? Anyhow they'll hardly be played that weekend either if Mayo beat Kerry.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 349 ✭✭jibber5000


    Barlett wrote: »
    That Horan story isn't entirely accurate, he had requested managers not to pick intercounty players in games where nothing was at stake.

    Well he requested Knockmore not to play McLoughlin in a game which did matter against Garrymore which they did...To my knowledge they were the only club to do so..

    For example Breaffy could have lost the last group match by 40 points to Ballina and theu would have still topped the group but all the county men still played..

    In the end Garrymore beat Knockmore, top the group and got Charlestown in the quarters whilst knockmore ended up with Castlebar..I know there is serious issues over this within the Knockmore club..

    As to the intermediate cancellations this weekend...all club players understand that county comes first and know that the club scene in mayo is way ahead every other serious county when it comes to club games being played..What rankles however is the late notice of these cancellations..Unbelievably disruptive..Like whats the point in setting them for the 30th? not a hope will they be played if Mayo win.

    I also think if it was just Barrett involved they would go ahead as he prob wont start vs Kerry and needs competitive games badly..However Higgins involvement was the killer and made a postponement inevitable


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 90 ✭✭patrickn


    It is not just the Senior players the clubs would be missing in Intermediate Championships many of the clubs have Minors who would not be available.


  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 7,466 ✭✭✭blinding


    I just watched Mayo v Cork again.

    Just one or two observations.

    Andy Moran had fierce trouble keeping on his feet. Is it his footwear or just lacking physicality.

    Jason Doherty has really developed as an asset for scoring points and contesting for his ball and challenging defenders.

    I think that we really needed Aiden O'Shea in the forwards to make our forwards as a whole more of a threat.

    We are a really good team with some outstanding players.

    Hopefully we can get past Kerry.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 6,299 ✭✭✭djPSB


    blinding wrote: »
    I just watched Mayo v Cork again.

    Just one or two observations.

    Andy Moran had fierce trouble keeping on his feet. Is it his footwear or just lacking physicality.

    Jason Doherty has really developed as an asset for scoring points and contesting for his ball and challenging defenders.

    I think that we really needed Aiden O'Shea in the forwards to make our forwards as a whole more of a threat.

    We are a really good team with some outstanding players.

    Hopefully we can get past Kerry.

    Fancy Mayo to beat Kerry but a few issues that may prevent an All Ireland win;

    - T Cunnniffe isn't good enough to start
    - Barrett got cleaned against Cork and could be found wanting against a team like the Dubs.
    - Vaughan is a bit headless
    - Andy Moran is not good enough to start.
    - Dillon will most likely freeze on All Ireland final day again.
    - A good team will man mark O'Connor and limit his input.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,413 ✭✭✭naughto


    Can't see Donegal beating the dubs they are just to strong.the first semi pro team in Ireland


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,621 ✭✭✭ultrapercy


    naughto wrote: »
    Can't see Donegal beating the dubs they are just to strong.the first semi pro team in Ireland

    Dublin are not semi pro if the players are not getting paid. I dont think the Dublin set up is too far ahead of any County in AI contention. They probably have more resources but if they are considered semi pro then so could 8 or 10 other county set ups.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,839 ✭✭✭Always_Running


    naughto wrote: »
    Can't see Donegal beating the dubs they are just to strong.the first semi pro team in Ireland
    Yes very hard to see it. Donegal not at the level of 2012 while Dublin have improved from last year. Hard to know will Mayo have enough to even beat Kerry as the defence seems a bit ropey this summer.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,151 ✭✭✭kupus


    Yes very hard to see it. Donegal not at the level of 2012 while Dublin have improved from last year. Hard to know will Mayo have enough to even beat Kerry as the defence seems a bit ropey this summer.

    Ive been saying this since the league that mayos defense is bad at leaking goals. I hope JOD picks up a cold or a flu just before the game cos thats the only way I can see him not scoring.:pac:


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 6,299 ✭✭✭djPSB


    kupus wrote: »
    Ive been saying this since the league that mayos defense is bad at leaking goals. I hope JOD picks up a cold or a flu just before the game cos thats the only way I can see him not scoring.:pac:

    Put Keith Higgins on him.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,391 ✭✭✭letowski


    I think the main reason Mayo are conceding so many soft goals is down to Horans philosophy on how he want's his half back line to play. They play in a very offensively and leave the full back line exposed on the counter attack. It's why I feel ye give away so many 'soft' goals, when in a good position. It's worrying for ye guys because in Kerry (the Dubs aside) no other county moves the ball as quick.

    Brolly says Mayo should just double mark JOD which might work, but in the spaces of Croke Park a player of his calibre can still do alot of damage. Horan is better off getting a strategy in place to limit the supply into the full back line and have adequate cover in place when the ball does come in.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 6,047 ✭✭✭Da Shins Kelly


    Really looking forward to the Kerry/Mayo match. Has the potential to be the match of the tournament. Honestly, I'm wondering what Kerry are capable of pulling out of the bag. I always feel like they're a team for the big occasion. I'd give Mayo a slight edge, but only slight, simply because of their experience. Really wouldn't be surprised at all if Kerry pull off something amazing though.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,530 ✭✭✭davegrohl48


    letowski wrote: »
    I think the main reason Mayo are conceding so many soft goals is down to Horans philosophy on how he want's his half back line to play. They play in a very offensively and leave the full back line exposed on the counter attack. It's why I feel ye give away so many 'soft' goals, when in a good position. It's worrying for ye guys because in Kerry (the Dubs aside) no other county moves the ball as quick.

    Brolly says Mayo should just double mark JOD which might work, but in the spaces of Croke Park a player of his calibre can still do alot of damage. Horan is better off getting a strategy in place to limit the supply into the full back line and have adequate cover in place when the ball does come in.
    My thoughts on the leaking goals problem.
    In the league the full backline was inexperienced. Colm Boyle was back corner back n for example against Kildare he rushed in as an extra unnecessary tackler n left a clear route behind him for a goal.
    Cafferkey has some responsibility with not dominating his square or 1 on 1s.
    Harrison a bit light yet. Cunniffe/Barret were out n now returning from injury. We also didn't take any black cards to prevent goals, I only recall Barry Moran doing so.
    How to solve it?
    I'd have Lee Keegan freed up to attack due to his high scoring percentage from shots. He's also a goal threat n can shoot left n right.
    Boyle n Vaughan I'd have man mark. I'd prefer Keith Higgins as the other half back with Paul Flynn coming down the line or Declan OSullivan in semi final.
    In full backline Id bring Cunniffe back from midfield n have direct double coverage on main goal threat of opposition. Kerry JOD n Dublin might actually be OGara as I see OGara on his form this year beating our backs in a 1 on 1.
    A tactic like limiting the supply only has a certain percentage improvement. For example Cork had 38 posessions inside our 45 in a game we were winning at midfield. They managed to goal twice. Alot of goals have been in second half so maybe is idea to bring in fresh legs like McHale for Caff for last 15 minutes. On view that a fresh Mchale is significantly better than Cafferkey with 55 mins played.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,413 ✭✭✭naughto


    How did we go from having one of the best back lines last yr to what we have now?
    Is it all to do with the f1ucking about with Higgins in the forward line that has unsettled the backs


  • Advertisement
  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 7,466 ✭✭✭blinding


    naughto wrote: »
    How did we go from having one of the best back lines last yr to what we have now?
    Is it all to do with the f1ucking about with Higgins in the forward line that has unsettled the backs
    If they are that easily thrown off their stride then they must be a delicate bunch.

    Intermitent injuries to Cunniffe and Barret hav'nt helped and the attacking ethos (necessary to supplement our sometimes under performing attack) of our halfback line leave the full back line somewhat vulnerable.

    Robbing Peter to pay Paul.

    Hopefully we can get it together for 1 and hopefully 2 more games.

    Our forwards have to pull their own fair share.


This discussion has been closed.
Advertisement