RTE Brewing Up A Storm - opinions

Skid wrote: »

Seriously, have you really ever watched anything on RTE?

It's a bit of fun, it is done well and it is not intended to be dissected frame by frame.

Fair play to all involved, it was a great effort.

Also, I would say most of the personalities done this for free.

humberklog wrote: »

It was one take.

that for starters is ****, there are parts of it that could be edited, it was made to look like one take and a really bad "one take"

RTE Really don't to editing very well, it was edited, your eye just dosen't see it.

The whole song goes out of synch to fit a visual image, after that good looking girl walks down the corridor, we arrived before the camera, your brain says it's unedited but it actually is different angle.

And don't forget a good editor can make something look seemless, I can make walking backwards, turn into walking forwards very quicklily and have everyone in synch

That is where they failed, no one was in synch, they where out of time, The Stunning should ask for it to be remade, cause it's just a half arsed attempt of being slightly clever.


It was never a one take either.

Skid wrote: »

Seriously, have you really ever watched anything on RTE?

It's a bit of fun, it is done well and it is not intended to be dissected frame by frame.

Fair play to all involved, it was a great effort.

Listen to what I said earlier in my posts, I like RTE, I just thought that "Brew up a storm " was a poo (****e) idea, it actually failed messirably in explaining what the whole thing is about.

I now know they where advertising a music week, I am that confused with the add I don't even know when.

And the track synch was horrible, give me two weeks with it and RTE and the stunning would have being happy,

But no they allow a director, producer, and an editor (already employed) to come up with this crap.

And apologies if I offending anyone in this thread, but as anyone of these jobs Director, Producer or Editor.

I would never stand by that job, it's basically crap, and please don't talk down to me, I'm actually good at doing does jobs

If your happy with a sh!t storm far enough, I would prefer to brewing up a storm as the song suggested.

My Opinion;)

Dicky Pride wrote: »

In order to successfully talk down to people who are more than capable at their jobs and in order for us to take you a little bit more seriously, you're going to need to learn how to spell.

Hence the reason I'm not a writer (mind you some great writers can't spell )

I think what gets me is that it looks like it was rendered in a NTSC format (29 frame per sec), while it was edited or produced as the PAL Format (25 frames per sec), this can lead to a time lag in the video the longer it goes on.

Hence the out of sync I mentioned before, and again my apologies this shouldn't have got by the editor, producer or director, as they should have known better. Particularly for a music week.

The concept is brilliant don't get me wrong, filmed brilliantly, but fell down in post production, can happen to the best of them Editors, Directors or Producers. And has happened to me (not that I'm the best of any of the above) but most after watching the video, would try to fix it, not release it for National TV.

Again this is just my opinion (people can take it or leave it)

GoldenLight wrote: »

Hence the reason I'm not a writer (mind you some great writers can't spell )

I think what gets me is that it looks like it was rendered in a NTSC format (29 frame per sec), while it was edited or produced as the PAL Format (25 frames per sec), this can lead to a time lag in the video the longer it goes on.

Hence the out of sync I mentioned before, and again my apologies this shouldn't have got by the editor, producer or director, as they should have known better. Particularly for a music week.

The concept is brilliant don't get me wrong, filmed brilliantly, but fell down in post production, can happen to the best of them Editors, Directors or Producers. And has happened to me (not that I'm the best of any of the above) but most after watching the video, would try to fix it, not release it for National TV.

Again this is just my opinion (people can take it or leave it)

When were you fired by RTE?

Scioch wrote: »

Only because you think what you are doing is giving an opinion and whatever everyone else does is complaining. When they are really just the same.

No...there really is a difference. I never claimed that everyone who dislikes the video is bitching and moaning, but I think it's pretty evident that claiming to be sick to the stomach or the like fits into that category.