Advertisement
Help Keep Boards Alive. Support us by going ad free today. See here: https://subscriptions.boards.ie/.
https://www.boards.ie/group/1878-subscribers-forum

Private Group for paid up members of Boards.ie. Join the club.
Hi all, please see this major site announcement: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058427594/boards-ie-2026

Munster Team Talk/Gossip/Rumours Thread.

1145146148150151321

Comments

  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 45,433 ✭✭✭✭thomond2006


    du Preez, Varley, Botha, Nagle, POC, Leamy, O'Mahony, Coughlan;
    Murray, ROG, Hurley, Keatley, Chambers, Howlett, Murphy

    Bench: Fogarty, Horan, Hayes, DOC, O'Donnell, O'Leary, Barnes, Mafi

    Hayes there simply for a last run out at Thomond (please let that be his last!). [clutching at straws] Keatley at 12 because a lot of Munster's good back play at the start of the season came from his creative ability. He hasn't played 12 much, but **** it he's probably better than the options. [/clutching at straws]

    Some might want Zebo or Barnes to replace Earls, but again against the Saints lightning back three we need to be defensively solid. Hurley offers that. Plus all we do in attack is go from side to side anyway and Hurley is the best man for our limited style of play.

    Donners, Ryan and Ronan dropped for being brainless penalty machines, I do feel sorry for Ryan who is clearly out of position at 6.

    All in all I wish the Munster management would grow a pair of balls and throw in the youngsters. Throw in Nagle alongside POC!

    Northampton: Foden; Ashton, Clarke, May, Artemyev; Lamb, Dickson; Tonga'uiha, Hartley (capt), Mujati; Lawes, Sorenson, Clark, Dowson, Wilson.
    Replacements: Haywood, Waller, Doran-Jones, Manoa, Wood, Roberts, Myler, Pisi.

    This is Northampton's lineup for their trip to Wasps tommorrow. This is pretty close to the side that will face us. I don't know if Downey is injured/dropped.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 8,048 ✭✭✭Amazotheamazing


    Word is Earls is out for the November HEC games, fairly much a disaster for us.


  • Moderators, Science, Health & Environment Moderators Posts: 18,464 Mod ✭✭✭✭CatFromHue


    Donnacha O Callaghan has written a book. Excerpts were in todays Sunday Times. The excerpts were a bit bland and not particularly interesting to be honest.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,456 ✭✭✭Cpt_Blackbeard


    Word is Earls is out for the November HEC games, fairly much a disaster for us.

    I like to think that Zebo will get a chance to step up but, he is very raw and throwing him in against Northhampton is a big ask. We are really missing individual attacking threat with Jones and Earls out.

    I'll have to see the Leinster match before I can say what team I'd like to see against Northhampton.

    Is Keatley a realistic option at fullback with Murphy slotting in at 11?

    Should Barnes be ahead of Mafi/Chambers?

    Is this our chance (next month, not necessarily the next match) to try TOL on the wing?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 5,592 ✭✭✭GerM


    Think Downey is dropped this week. With Lamb coming in, I think Northampton want to get the ball out to utilise their flyers more. Tom May is much more of a footballing option and can integrate into that game. With that said, Northampton are crying out for a quality flanker and scrum half to make them a really quality team. Tom Wood is a very good player but he's a little off the boil currently. Lee Dickson is a weak point. They signed the former Scarlet, Martin Roberts but he's of a similar standard really.

    Earls being out is a blow but it's not the end of the world at all for this game. He would have been facing Chris Ashton and I have no doubt that Northampton would have looked to get Ashton one on one with Earls. As it stands, I wouldn't be surprised to see someone like Denis Hurley drafted in for the purpose of minding Ashton and putting in a big defensive shift. Munster aren't going to win this match on the wings but they could lose it there so being prudent and going with their strongest back three defensively might not be a bad idea.


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 134 ✭✭jasper11


    whats peoples take on Nagle? donners needs competition big time


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 8,048 ✭✭✭Amazotheamazing


    I like to think that Zebo will get a chance to step up but, he is very raw and throwing him in against Northhampton is a big ask. We are really missing individual attacking threat with Jones and Earls out.

    I'll have to see the Leinster match before I can say what team I'd like to see against Northhampton.

    Is Keatley a realistic option at fullback with Murphy slotting in at 11?

    Should Barnes be ahead of Mafi/Chambers?

    Is this our chance (next month, not necessarily the next match) to try TOL on the wing?

    Zebo is far, far too raw defensively to play HEC rugby. I expect we'll see Hurley, which is fine defensively but not much else.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 8,048 ✭✭✭Amazotheamazing


    GerM wrote: »
    Think Downey is dropped this week. With Lamb coming in, I think Northampton want to get the ball out to utilise their flyers more. Tom May is much more of a footballing option and can integrate into that game. With that said, Northampton are crying out for a quality flanker and scrum half to make them a really quality team. Tom Wood is a very good player but he's a little off the boil currently. Lee Dickson is a weak point. They signed the former Scarlet, Martin Roberts but he's of a similar standard really.

    Earls being out is a blow but it's not the end of the world at all for this game. He would have been facing Chris Ashton and I have no doubt that Northampton would have looked to get Ashton one on one with Earls. As it stands, I wouldn't be surprised to see someone like Denis Hurley drafted in for the purpose of minding Ashton and putting in a big defensive shift. Munster aren't going to win this match on the wings but they could lose it there so being prudent and going with their strongest back three defensively might not be a bad idea.

    Think like last Friday it'll come down to our backrow, had we started POM and Coughlan we'd have done better, imo and both should start this weekend.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,881 ✭✭✭PhatPiggins


    CatFromHue wrote: »
    Donnacha O Callaghan has written a book. Excerpts were in todays Sunday Times. The excerpts were a bit bland and not particularly interesting to be honest.

    Rugby player rights a boring autobiography!! Surely this has never happened before.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,881 ✭✭✭PhatPiggins


    Think like last Friday it'll come down to our backrow, had we started POM and Coughlan we'd have done better, imo and both should start this weekend.

    Northamptons backrow isn't a patch on Leinsters, I'd be happy with any backrow combination we put out as long as it contains O'Mahony at 7.


  • Advertisement
  • Posts: 24,798 ✭✭✭✭ Clementine Helpless Scalpel


    Northamptons backrow isn't a patch on Leinsters, I'd be happy with any backrow combination we put out as long as it contains O'Mahony at 7.

    has to be
    6 Leamy
    7 POM
    8 Coughlan

    or else

    6 Ryan
    7 Leamy
    8 Coughlan

    with DOC/POC gone at 55/60 for POM, and Ryan moving to the second row and Leamy to 6?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 13,264 ✭✭✭✭Fireball07


    Word is Earls is out for the November HEC games, fairly much a disaster for us.

    It really is...people like to criticise him but he's our main attacking threat and once again, the replacements aren't as dangerous.
    I like to think that Zebo will get a chance to step up but, he is very raw and throwing him in against Northhampton is a big ask. We are really missing individual attacking threat with Jones and Earls out.

    I'll have to see the Leinster match before I can say what team I'd like to see against Northhampton.

    Is Keatley a realistic option at fullback with Murphy slotting in at 11?

    Should Barnes be ahead of Mafi/Chambers?

    Is this our chance (next month, not necessarily the next match) to try TOL on the wing?

    I'd like to see Zebo involved more, but not to start this week. Not that he will anyway. If McGahan didn't include him against Aironi and Leinster, he won't against Northampton.

    Keatley could be an option at full-back but again, this isn't the time to try it out. Same with TOL on the wing (which could work, I really think it could).


    I was very impressed with Barnes against Leinster, but it's hard to know how good Chambers is really. Didn't get much chance to shine so far. Mafi is unpredictable...


    If POM and Coughlan are both playing and ROG is on form, we've got a decent chance at home.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,456 ✭✭✭Cpt_Blackbeard


    Zebo is far, far too raw defensively to play HEC rugby. I expect we'll see Hurley, which is fine defensively but not much else.

    Thats my worry but, our backline looks very, very dull without him or Keatley being thrown in. We will probably go with the following backline for Northhampton:
    09. Murray
    10. ROG
    11. Hurley
    12. Mafi
    13. Chambers
    14. Howlett
    15. Murphy
    That won't cause anyone any troubles. Its such a pity because, we ended last season with an excellent attacking back 3 and now we have no real obvious threat.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 8,048 ✭✭✭Amazotheamazing


    Is it worth risking Barnes at 13 and pushing Chamber out to the wing, think he's played there in super15?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 8,048 ✭✭✭Amazotheamazing


    Fireball07 wrote: »
    It really is...people like to criticise him but he's our main attacking threat and once again, the replacements aren't as dangerous.



    I'd like to see Zebo involved more, but not to start this week. Not that he will anyway. If McGahan didn't include him against Aironi and Leinster, he won't against Northampton.

    Keatley could be an option at full-back but again, this isn't the time to try it out. Same with TOL on the wing (which could work, I really think it could).


    I was very impressed with Barnes against Leinster, but it's hard to know how good Chambers is really. Didn't get much chance to shine so far. Mafi is unpredictable...


    If POM and Coughlan are both playing and ROG is on form, we've got a decent chance at home.

    TOL as a back three player is something we should investigate. He's still a great athlete if all else fails.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,456 ✭✭✭Cpt_Blackbeard


    Is it worth risking Barnes at 13 and pushing Chamber out to the wing, think he's played there in super15?

    It might have to be done but, I'd rather if Chambers was left at 13 with the same player at 12 beside to see if he comes good. We should learn from our mistakes with JdV.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 45,433 ✭✭✭✭thomond2006


    Who is our attack coach at the moment? McGahan/Holland? He's the problem.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 8,048 ✭✭✭Amazotheamazing


    It might have to be done but, I'd rather if Chambers was left at 13 with the same player at 12 beside to see if he comes good. We should learn from our mistakes with JdV.

    How many players look good at 13 outside Mafi though? Tbf, Barnes is the only guys who's managed it since Tipoki (they used to alternate).


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2, Paid Member Posts: 26,591 ✭✭✭✭phog


    du Preez, Varley, Botha, Nagle, POC, Leamy, O'Mahony, Coughlan;
    Murray, ROG, Hurley, Keatley, Chambers, Howlett, Murphy

    Bench: Fogarty, Horan, Hayes, DOC, O'Donnell, O'Leary, Barnes, Mafi

    Hayes there simply for a last run out at Thomond (please let that be his last!). [clutching at straws] Keatley at 12 because a lot of Munster's good back play at the start of the season came from his creative ability. He hasn't played 12 much, but **** it he's probably better than the options. [/clutching at straws]

    Some might want Zebo or Barnes to replace Earls, but again against the Saints lightning back three we need to be defensively solid. Hurley offers that. Plus all we do in attack is go from side to side anyway and Hurley is the best man for our limited style of play.

    Donners, Ryan and Ronan dropped for being brainless penalty machines, I do feel sorry for Ryan who is clearly out of position at 6.

    All in all I wish the Munster management would grow a pair of balls and throw in the youngsters. Throw in Nagle alongside POC!

    Northampton: Foden; Ashton, Clarke, May, Artemyev; Lamb, Dickson; Tonga'uiha, Hartley (capt), Mujati; Lawes, Sorenson, Clark, Dowson, Wilson.
    Replacements: Haywood, Waller, Doran-Jones, Manoa, Wood, Roberts, Myler, Pisi.

    This is Northampton's lineup for their trip to Wasps tommorrow. This is pretty close to the side that will face us. I don't know if Downey is injured/dropped.

    I'm not big into predicting team selections but for the life of me I cant see how anyone would want to drop two W/C players in place of a guy just out of the academy. I've huge regard and even bigger hope for Nagle but to drop one of Ryan and DOC to the bench and the other off the squad for our 1st H/C of the season is plain mad and replace them with Nagle who missed most of the early season through injury. Also, I wouldn't be jumping into trying to squeeze Keatley into 12 without trying him first in a RPD12 game first.

    We've 11 games in as many weeks, 2 of which are only 4 days apart, that alone will see squad rotation so Nagle will get gametime and Keatley might be tried at 12.


  • Moderators, Science, Health & Environment Moderators Posts: 18,464 Mod ✭✭✭✭CatFromHue


    Who is our attack coach at the moment? McGahan/Holland? He's the problem.

    McGahan is the head coach and Holland is the backs coach. I think it's too easy to just lay the blame at the coaches though. It's a mixture of both the players and coaching.

    ROG caught a ball and ran it from deep late in the game on Friday, I think Heaslip was in the bin and there was a lot of space to run into. He didn't know what to do and Chambers offered himself as a runner. Chambers then ran into a Leinster player and gave a penalty away for crossing. This isn't fully the coaches fault the players have to take responsibility here. ROG for his indecisiveness and Chambers for not stopping before he ran into a Leinster player.

    In the first half Munster ran it from deep and the ball got to Murphy with Barnes outside him. He was faced with one Leinster defender and possibly another defender who was 20 or more meters away. Instead of drawing one defender and leaving Barnes with a one on one on a guy 20m away Murphy booted the ball away. The players have to take some responsibility for this.


  • Advertisement
  • Moderators, Sports Moderators, Paid Member Posts: 31,765 Mod ✭✭✭✭Podge_irl


    Rugby player rights a boring autobiography!! Surely this has never happened before.

    current rugby player writes boring autobiography is more the problem. I know what they do it while still in the limelight, but it's so utterly pointless as they can't say much of any interest without potentially damaging their career.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,456 ✭✭✭Cpt_Blackbeard


    Podge_irl wrote: »
    current rugby player writes boring autobiography is more the problem. I know what they do it while still in the limelight, but it's so utterly pointless as they can't say much of any interest without potentially damaging their career.

    Its a shame as, you'd expect DOC's autobiography to be incredibly entertaining.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 8,048 ✭✭✭Amazotheamazing


    CatFromHue wrote: »

    In the first half Munster ran it from deep and the ball got to Murphy with Barnes outside him. He was faced with one Leinster defender and possibly another defender who was 20 or more meters away. Instead of drawing one defender and leaving Barnes with a one on one on a guy 20m away Murphy booted the ball away. The players have to take some responsibility for this.

    Murphy can be like that though, he's not a great creator in the sense that he doesn't really bring other players in to games. He's a decent finisher and decent enough player, but he's not what we need unless we play him on the wing.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 8,048 ✭✭✭Amazotheamazing


    http://www.independent.ie/sport/rugb...s-2927134.html

    Fighting his corner after rapid ascent to top ranks

    By way of research we asked a young rugby fan what he would most like to know about Conor Murray. Expecting a question perhaps about how long he spends practising his pass, or what it was like to sprint from the back of the bunch to become the top scrumhalf in Ireland, the response was left of centre.
    "Ask him if he uses hair straighteners."
    This reminded us of life in a previous existence, receiving an order from an unhinged newspaper editor, after Ireland had lost dismally to Scotland in Murrayfield in 1993, to ring up each and every member of the team and ask them why they were such 'w**kers.'
    Naturally enough we did as bid but altered the wording slightly. And this time, figuring that the interview could be lost if we opened on a note about personal grooming, we parked it until the main business was done.
    And with young Mr Murray there is plenty of business on the agenda.
    Some will find it hard to fathom for example that next weekend's tie with Northampton Saints in Thomond Park will be his first in the Heineken Cup. Coming after six caps for Ireland, four of them in the World Cup, this sequence of country before province is O'Driscollesque.
    Of course it was Munster that launched him towards the World Cup. In the short career of Conor Murray, the key week was in March this year when Peter Stringer and Tomás O'Leary came back from the Six Nations squad and coach Tony McGahan stuck with the man who had been minding the shop while they were away.
    "Playing with Munster towards the end of the season really stood to me because they were really high-standard games and I ended up coming through them -- I thought -- pretty well," he says. "I suppose Tony did as well because he kept me in for the run-in to the (Magners) final. The faith he showed . . . I owe him a lot for that because that's what allowed me to push on into the Irish squad. We mightn't be having this conversation if he'd put the two lads back in. I don't know if I would have accepted it, but I couldn't have argued with it. He could have just said the lads were more experienced and they were coming back from Irish duty."
    The perception of Murray is either that he arrived late and then made up for lost time, or that he's a kid who was just discovered this year and has made unreal progress. He's actually 22, so hardly sprog material. And if you call Ireland under 19s late then sure enough he was a bit behind. It wasn't that he was idle, just that in the current climate of tracking kids from 16, with a view to having them in academies by the time they leave school, Murray doesn't fit that bill.
    A combination of circumstances meant he wasn't a frontline rugby player from the start. Oddly enough this has nothing to do with coming from Patrickswell where he hurled -- it would have been unnatural not to -- but not with anything like the passion he had for soccer and Gaelic football.
    Then, when he went to St Munchin's, he was overage for his peer group so hadn't much enthusiasm for playing ahead of himself. In time he would get involved in schools cup rugby, but it wasn't until his final year there that the pressure came on to abandon other pursuits.
    He did so, reluctantly, for he associates soccer especially with endless games with his pals when parents would stop play long after light made it hazardous. The reward for focusing on rugby was to make the outer reaches of the Munster Schools squad. "I was 23rd man. The fella who doesn't even tog out," he remembers. "The lads have a good laugh at me for that."
    Thereafter he made the squads for Munster and Ireland at under 19 level whereupon he got the call from Munster to join their Academy. "That's when I got tuned into the whole idea of being a professional," he says. "At that stage everyone was talking about whether they had Academy places or what's your story."
    Once on board three years ago, Murray made a name for himself, first as a player who was happy to work as hard as it took to get ahead, and then for what he could do on the field. We came across him first in the AIL for Garryowen two years ago and he looked like a man who wouldn't be at that level too long. Fast forward to him being named as part of the cast of thousands assembled initially to prepare for the World Cup and the odds started to shorten on him making the trip. You suspect also that the players who knew best how quickly he would take the next step were the other scrumhalves in the squad: Eoin Reddan and Isaac Boss. Sure enough, Murray made the most of his time in New Zealand.
    "It was a brilliant experience," he says. "I thought we'd struggle to pass the time during the day because we only did three sessions a week on the pitch and we had our weights as well but in between that and games there's a lot of free time and I thought going over there it'd be hard enough. I brought a book with me and I ended up only reading four pages of it. We were just always doing stuff and everyone, all the provinces, got on really well, it wasn't forced or anything like that. It was a really happy squad. I thought I'd get homesick but not at all. I wanted to stay out there as long as we could.
    "Obviously when you think about the Wales game that's the one point you'd like to have back and see how we could go about it again. But when you look at the tournament as a whole it was brilliant and I suppose it will stand to me in years to come. I learned a lot from it and took a lot of positives from it, bar that one negative game."
    Seemingly those positives included being dropped from a great height not once, but three times, as be bungied his way around the country. "I got a bit addicted to that thrill," he admits. In his day, Murray's dad had some scary moments as a marshal on the pro cycling circuit, this is the hairy gig on the motorbikes, not standing on the side of the road with a flag, and he says his mam was also considering following her son's lead over the edge at the Nevis River in Queenstown, which at 134 metres is the second highest bungy in the world. So there seems to be some adrenalin-seeking in the Murray blood.
    Now for thrills their son will have to content himself with fighting off Tomás O'Leary in Munster, and then getting to the Six Nations in February with his star still shining brightly. The challenge will be to do it with a Munster team whose Heineken Cup reputation has been dismantled. Murray is one of the young men the fans will look to to reassemble it, for already the bolter status of last summer seems years back.
    "The Heineken Cup is going to be pretty new to me but hopefully the bit of experience I gained over the last while will help me to perform in those games. There's a good buzz abut the Munster squad at the
    moment. I'm only back a week but there's still a lot of young fellas here who have to come through and haven't got much game time over the last few years but they're still around and they can fill in for the older guys. And those older guys, or whatever term you want to call them, are still on their game. People are really excited about our group and everybody is clued in at the minute. Danny Barnes is one fella -- he played in the final last year and in the run-up and he's been scoring tries -- and Peter O'Mahony would be another."
    Murray's confidence aside, Munster are short on new blood, and his new status as a scrumhalf with game-changing capacity will load a lot of responsibility on him. He sounds perfectly happy with all of this, having come home from the World Cup three kilos heavier -- good weight, which can be hard to find -- and both physically and mentally raring to go.
    And so to the critical issue: if we were to set the sniffer dogs on his kitbag would they come up with grooming products that included a set of hair straighteners?
    "No, absolutely not!" he says. "I get a fairly bad doin' down here over the Justin Bieber look, but definitely nothing like that."


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 45,433 ✭✭✭✭thomond2006


    http://www.rte.ie/sport/rugby/2011/1107/munster_earlsk.html

    Earls out for "four to six weeks".

    That's good news considering, I thought it could have been one of those season ending injuries at the time.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2, Paid Member Posts: 26,591 ✭✭✭✭phog


    From the Irish Times
    Failing to make the knockout stages last year hurt Munster but Gerry Thornley finds Paul O’Connell in a positive frame of mind for this year’s campaign.

    IN THE build-up to last Friday’s latest rendezvous with Leinster, Paul O’Connell had said the fixture would tell Munster everything they needed to know about themselves before they returned to European matters next weekend. Amid the disappointment of defeat, O’Connell believes there were plenty of positives for Munster to take from the game.

    Beginning with the game’s finale, as it were, the most encouraging aspect was their surge in the final quarter which yielded the game’s only try, albeit a penalty try. “I was very happy with the way we finished the game and our levels of finish. Our set scrum was good too.”

    Leinster had looked marginally the more likely to score a try throughout the penalty-riddled arm wrestle, but O’Connell was not especially concerned about that. “You are looking at a very good Leinster team who are very good defensively, and they’re hard to break down, so I don’t see that as a big issue.”

    O’Connell’s biggest concern was Munster’s ill-discipline, which afforded Jonathan Sexton seven successful penalties at goal. “In the end, it was down to us, and certainly if we play like we did in the first half against Northampton, we will be in trouble.”

    And therein lies the rub, for O’Connell and Munster would have gladly exchanged a defeat last Friday for two wins over the next couple of Saturdays, daunting as that task is against last year’s beaten finalists Northampton, and high-flying Castres in Toulouse.

    Munster have had fully 10 months to digest their first exit at the pool stages since the 1997-98 season, and not that they would have needed it, but all the launches, interviews, media days and previews of this season’s tournament have helped to jog the memory.

    “Yeah, it probably was a timely reminder and the disappointment of it and I suppose, whatever about going (out), some of the performances and the way we performed some times was just disappointing.”

    The hurt hasn’t gone away. To qualify for the knockout stages for 12 successive seasons is quite possibly a sequence that will never be equalled, but it left them victims of their own high standards and all that.

    “Definitely. Every team will go through a transition or whatever but you’ve got to make sure no matter who’s on the field that you’re emptying the tank and being dogged for everything we can get, and maybe at times last year we didn’t do that.”

    As captain, O’Connell carries the demands established by that legacy, the pain of last season’s “failure” and the desire for atonement, so in that sense reviving a few old wounds from last season may be no harm, although he says he’s not sure yet whether he needs to revisit this theme with his team-mates.


    “I don’t really know. I think a lot of guys will be conscious of it,” he says, citing the many changes from last season, and adds: “This will be the second of back-to-back games against last season’s two Heineken Cup finalists, and then we have Castres away who were unbeaten at home until the week before last and are flying high in the Top 14, and they look to have a massive pack from the little bit I saw of them at the weekend.”

    Munster have always drawn heavily from their umbilical link with their supporters, who have spent fortunes travelling around Europe supporting them. Admittedly, they’ve had plenty of parties and highs along the way, and by rights Munster owe them or the rest of us nothing. To a degree, O’Connell suggests, now is when Munster need their supporters more than ever.

    “Last year was disappointing but I think it’s important that the supporters stick with us as well though, you know? There’s no doubt that we have to dig deep in the next few weeks and I think it’s important that they dig deep for us as well in terms of being there with an atmosphere. We really need that. But absolutely, we probably owe them one from last year.”

    Invariably, on foot of Munster’s Heineken Cup exit and Ireland’s departure from the World Cup, there’s been much talk of eras or cycles ending. Raise this question and O’Connell reveals both some of his hopes and doubts for the future.

    He points to Seán O’Brien’s emergence after Jamie Heaslip and Stephen Ferris, along with Conor Murray and latterly Mike Sherry and Peter O’Mahony at Munster to support his real belief that there are “phenomenal players coming through and are already there for Ireland”.

    “So while it is the end of an era a little bit in that certain players are moving on, but for me, the only thing about losing those guys, the like of the Foleys, the Hayes, the Quinnys, is that you lose their mentality more than anything. That’s just the only thing I look to see.

    “I think that most of the guys coming through from being in the academies all have skill levels and all that, and they’re all big men. The big thing you wonder is: are they going to have the mentality of those guys? The Hayes, the Quinnys and the Foleys; the doggedness, the belligerence, this mentality that they’d fight with you over a toothpick on Monday, y’know, this kind of attitude. That’s the only thing I wonder sometimes.”

    Analyse this a tad more, and the concern might grow, for the Foleys, Quinlans, Hayes and co cut their teeth, in large part, in the hard school of the All-Ireland League – O’Connell with Young Munster included.

    “Yeah, maybe that did come from there,” he concedes. “I was at Young Munster-Shannon the other day and there was 2,000 at it. Munsters had a man sent off wrongly after half an hour,” he says, and spoken like a true “Munsters” man, “but they won the game. Now, it was a typical Limerick derby, in that if they were still playing, there probably still wouldn’t have been a try but it was dogged and as physical as anything you’ll see.

    “That’s still there, but I think it’s all about the attitude. Young guys coming in are, as I said, they’re big, they’re strong, they’re able to play ball. But what set those guys apart and what set Munster on the run to success was those guys’ mental attitude and their mental strength. If they came across a guy that was better than them, they’d figure a way to beat them. That remains to be seen in the young guys coming through.”

    Should these young players be exposed to more AIL rugby than they are. “I don’t know would it give them as it gave us back then. But it’s all mental. Rugby is an emotional game and it’s about mental strength, and the young guys who come through with that will be successful, and the guys who don’t have it won’t be.”

    O’Connell has always been a deep thinker about the game, and 32 later this month, he is perhaps more thoughtful than ever. He says he returned from the World Cup feeling as drained and defeated as he did after the Lions’ tour. “I think World Cups and Lions tours are probably the ‘forever moments’ if you can be successful in them, and we left the Lions’ tour in 2009 behind and probably now we’ve left a World Cup behind.”

    Thankfully though, there are some key differences. For starters, after a brief holiday, he had the added distraction and incentive of leading Munster into the Heineken Cup campaign. O’Connell will be 35 at the next World Cup, and while the odds are against him making it to England, he’s not ruling it out. “I’m enjoying training; I’m enjoying everything about rugby at the moment, probably more than ever,” he reveals, which is good to hear. “I dunno. I don’t know where I’ll be in four years but at the moment I’m enjoying it and I’m keeping going.

    “Maybe it’s because it’s coming towards the end and what’s after the end is going to be nothing like as enjoyable as hanging around with 30 lads who are your closest mates, and training hard, and trying to achieve something and having a major involvement in every decision and everything we do it’s good as it gets really. And to be living at home as well, to be a professional sports person living 10 minutes from home, and still be able to hang around with your friends, not a lot of Irish people get to do it.”

    Of his three World Cups, the 2011 version will always be the one that got away, though he maintains that the defeat to Wales was in no way due to the Irish squad getting ahead of themselves. Yet despite the anti-climactic nature of that World Cup, O’Connell will still have fond memories of it and, on reflection, feels that, in being able to view it as a missed opportunity, maybe a barrier was overcome. To begin with, in the immediate aftermath of the laboured opening win over the USA, he privately worried as to whether Ireland were doomed to having a permanent hang-up about the World Cup.

    “Nearly the opposite to Argentina, who go to World Cups and grow, I thought ‘are we going to go to World Cups and shrink?’ I was a bit worried about that, but I think now whatever Irish team goes to the next World Cup they’ll go there with a lot of belief knowing that the team of 2011 had a great chance to win it, and probably could have won it. It’ll help give Irish teams belief.”

    Furthermore, he’s feeling fit and healthier than he has done in a couple of years following on from his well-documented groin problems which ruined much of the last two seasons.

    “I’ve just come off the back of a horrible year and a half injury wise. I mean I played some games toward the end of last season when I didn’t feel physically right. There were times during some games when I wanted the ground to swallow me up I felt so bad. I’m enjoying now feeling close to the shape I need to be in to play games, whereas last year there were times, with no pre-season, and I’d just come off the back of an infection, it’s not that I wasn’t enjoying the rugby, I just wasn’t in the shape I needed to be in to make the kind of impact I like to be able to make.

    “It’s a tough thing in a rugby career that you end up playing a lot of the time not in the shape you want to be in. There’s very few of us playing 100 per cent fit, I’d say there’s no one playing 100 per cent at the moment, and that’s the challenge of it. You need to be able to get out there and perform when you’re not 100 per cent right. All those little bits are what make it hard and make it good as well.

    “There’s plenty left in the tank for a lot of the players,” he maintains, and that evidently includes himself.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 5,592 ✭✭✭GerM


    POC's birthday was a few weeks ago. Thornley is getting as bad as the rest.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,207 ✭✭✭durkadurka


    Soooooo..... Con Murray convicted of killing Michael Jackson. That's just taking "physicality" too far


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 8,048 ✭✭✭Amazotheamazing


    Unusually candid interview with POC, he's fairly much questioning whether the young players in Munster can step up. It's either a brave call to arms or a desperately worrying sign that he genuinely doubts them.

    At least now he's back fit he can show them what it means to play for Munster. A guy like POM can't have played much with POC over the past few seasons?


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2, Paid Member Posts: 26,591 ✭✭✭✭phog


    durkadurka wrote: »
    Soooooo..... Con Murray convicted of killing Michael Jackson. That's just taking "physicality" too far

    someone has been reading twitterland :D


This discussion has been closed.
Advertisement