Advertisement
Please note that it is not permitted to have referral links posted in your signature. Keep these links contained in the appropriate forum. Thank you.

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2055940817/signature-rules
Help Keep Boards Alive. Support us by going ad free today. See here: https://subscriptions.boards.ie/.
https://www.boards.ie/group/1878-subscribers-forum

Private Group for paid up members of Boards.ie. Join the club.
Hi all, please see this major site announcement: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058427594/boards-ie-2026

How reliable is your car? (Everything before 2005)

  • 11-05-2010 02:08PM
    #1
    Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,306 ✭✭✭


    Discrimination says I. This is for every car/van/jeep manufactured before 2005, and how reliable it is for you. Might be useful for second hand buyers on what are the reliable cars. So how reliable is your older car??

    Lets get the ball rolling :

    1993 Land Rover Defender 2.5tdi.

    Problems: Steering Knuckle joint loose. Rear hardy spicer joint. All cheap fixes. Thats all thats gone wrong in the last 3 years.

    Ever fail to start: The extreme winter killed the battery. Wouldnt turn over the big diesel.

    Rattles: heheheheeehehe...... No mechanical rattles but its a noisy aul thing.



    1985 Golf 1.3. 120k miles

    Problems: Frost broke the right hand window winder and the rear right door release. Snapped hand brake cable. No major mechanical or electrical problems.

    Ever fail to start: With a good battery, no. Very quick to turn over and start.

    Rattles: 2. the banjaxed window winder rattles a bit on rough roads.


«13

Comments

  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 38,227 ✭✭✭✭Guy:Incognito


    Copied over from the other thread:


    2000 Clio bought new as my fist car. Never missed a beat despite being horribly misstreated in it's early years and survived long enough to be usedas a scrappage car last month.

    94 accord 2.0 died
    94 rover 620 ( accord) 2.0 died

    93 Renault safrane 2.0 never missed a beat , sold because it wasunderpowered for the size of it and my next car came available.

    97 Renault safrane 2.5 auto again never missed a beat sold because I needed a van for work.

    Never should have sold either of the safranes

    97 Peugeot partner. Perfectly reliable .

    2000 xantia 1.8 low mileage and perfectly reliable ( must sell that seeing as I can't afford to run a car and van)

    currently driving a peugeot expert that's never missed a beat.

    The missus has had a 99 micra from new an 01 a140 from new thathad a couple of issues that were escalated to very dangerous by dodgy repairs done in a now closedtallaght merc dealer . After that it was a 00 scenic and now an 05 grand scenic that have needed nothing up untill I had to change the coils in last week ( it still started and ran, just lumpy). €120 outside of regular maintenance over 5 years is grand IMO.

    That's everything I've had and/or used on a daily basis


  • Posts: 23,497 ✭✭✭✭ [Deleted User]


    Stekelly wrote: »

    94 accord 2.0 died
    94 rover 620 ( accord) 2.0 died

    Any more detail ? Died isn't too informative. It's funny how a 00 Clio lasting 10 years is somehow meant to impress, shouldn't they survive this long ? I have a 1993 520i and a 1997 rover Coupe that I wouldn't dream of scrapping.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,306 ✭✭✭Mycroft H


    Stekelly wrote: »
    2000 xantia 1.8 low mileage and perfectly reliable ( must sell that seeing as I can't afford to run a car and van)

    I have to say that the xantia is a very under-rated car.

    MY da has a 20Hdi 110 and its as reliable as they come, not a problem with it.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,128 ✭✭✭cynder


    99 toyota yaris the clutch is starting to go.
    05 toyota verso still like day 1.


    01 renault Megan
    the pulley belt went got it replaced and 2 days later it snapped got it replaced again next day car conks out going round a corner and the pulley belt snapped again and went into the timing belt and had damaged the pistons..... nice car but wouldn't get one again after that.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 73,328 ✭✭✭✭colm_mcm


    Off the top of my head:

    00 Punto Sporting
    Problems: headlights condensating, side repeaters condensating, syncromesh went after small mileage, all done under warranty.
    Ever fail to start: Yes, loose battery terminal
    Rattles: none

    99 Mazda 323 1.5 GLX
    Problems: None, over 3 years
    Ever fail to start: No
    Rattles: none

    01 Mazda 323 1.6 GLX
    Problems: Coil pack, needed gearbox seal after driving through flood, broke alternator belt
    Ever fail to start: Yes, needed new battery
    Rattles: none

    93 Corolla 1.6 SE
    Problems: None, over 6 years
    Ever fail to start: Yes, needed battery
    Rattles: one from around the radio, sorted

    99 Fiat Brava HSX 16v (ex hire)
    Problems: Rear wiper, front wiper linkage, front washer jets, central locking broke on passenger door, contacts on boot door rusted for rear wiper, rear washer pipe detached, syncromesh on 2nd gear, head gasket X2, needed new cam followers, oil consumption, exhaust centre section very prone to getting torn on speedbumps, starter motor. sunroof motor needed replacement
    Ever fail to start: yes, battery, alarm and sterter problems


    00 Alfa 146 1.4 Sportivo (ex hire)
    Problems: Remote locking never worked, CD player overheating, windows closing outside of frames
    Ever fail to start: No
    Rattles: 5, dash creaky, window regs rattled, seats noisy

    95 Mitsubishi FTO GPX Tiptronic
    Problems: none over 18 months
    Ever fail to start: Needed new battery

    95 Mitsubishi FTO GPX manual
    Problems: none over 18 months
    Ever fail to start: No

    00 Citroen Xsara 1.4 VSX
    Problems: Fog lights didn't work, CD player faulty, lock button on remote key not working
    Ever fail to start: No


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,631 ✭✭✭Einstein


    from memory

    00 Peugot 206 (first car!) no problems!

    01 Peugot 306 - no problems

    99 Citroen Xzara - fan/heater inside stopped working just before I traded it in.

    01 Alfa 147 - Bulbs went regularly. Never failed to start

    04 Audi A4TDI - no problems.

    I've been uber lucky!


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,816 ✭✭✭Stevie Dakota


    95 BMW 520i
    Owned from 2000-2008
    Lots of money spent on preventive maintenance plus

    AC condensor (warranty)
    Rust on front wings (warranty)
    Rear electric window switches (warranty)
    Rusted brake lines (warranty)
    Wiper linkages (warranty)
    Viscous fan coupling
    Central locking erratic
    Battery
    Window motor

    Failed to start - twice - battery and imobiliser problem
    Issue with flooded engine if car moved short distance, had to run it to warm to avoid.

    Rattles - 2

    Best car I've ever owned.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 38,227 ✭✭✭✭Guy:Incognito


    RoverJames wrote: »
    Any more detail ? Died isn't too informative. It's funny how a 00 Clio lasting 10 years is somehow meant to impress, shouldn't they survive this long ? I have a 1993 520i and a 1997 rover Coupe that I wouldn't dream of scrapping.

    They blew up in clouds of steam and smoke. Cant actually remeber exactly it's few years ago now. The Accord blew the rad and the cooling system went with it elsewhere. The Rover engine died altogether.

    The Clio saw nothing but petrol for it's first 3 years and 40,000 odd miles. It also suffered body damage in it's first couple of months as a result of allowing the missus to drive it (think it was about 6 weeks old when it was run up a gate).

    01 renault Megan
    the pulley belt went got it replaced and 2 days later it snapped got it replaced again next day car conks out going round a corner and the pulley belt snapped again and went into the timing belt and had damaged the pistons..... nice car but wouldn't get one again after that.

    If he same hing kept hapening within days I'd be looking at whoever fxed it tbh. Was it he same person each time?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 134 ✭✭Damomayo


    1997 VW Polo 1.9SDI saloon
    Bomb proof car ~ only non standard service item were
    1. headlight after stone made a hole (bad stone)
    2. window winder on drivers door

    had to spray WD40 in door lock to keep it free in winter
    Never touched brake pads or clutch, always started first turn

    nothing else on the car from 60,000 to 170,000 miles


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 134 ✭✭Damomayo


    2001 VW Bora 1.9 (130Bhp)

    Very realible
    Had to replace turbo after it blew but limped home
    Gets through a set of front bushes every 40,000 miles or so
    Door lock on passangers door jammed and had to be sorted out
    no rattles apart from when front bushes are going or wheels r worn


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 10,179 ✭✭✭✭Max Power1


    96 Fiesta 1.3 - no problems. Still have it

    00 Rover 75 1.8 Only bought recently. A few niggly electrics (E/W switch on driver side) but sound mechanically so far it seems.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 38,227 ✭✭✭✭Guy:Incognito


    landyman wrote: »
    I have to say that the xantia is a very under-rated car.

    MY da has a 20Hdi 110 and its as reliable as they come, not a problem with it.

    Yeah I love it tbh. But he problem is it'd be destroyed in weeks if I sas using it to carry tools and got in to it dirty after work (Plumber).

    I'd rather give it up than wreck it.


    I bought it in early 2008 with 60,000 miles on it with fsh. I replaced the suspention spheres and put a new set of discs and pads on it last year. It's still only got 65k on it.


  • Posts: 24,773 ✭✭✭✭ [Deleted User]


    Bmw 318ci 2001 currently 126k miles

    Front wishbones (wear and tear goes in all 3ers) approx 400 euro incl fitting.

    Thermostat (stuck open so could drive the car just with no heat) 70 euro and fitted it myself

    Camshaft sensor, about 100 euro

    Lock on passenger door sometimes gets stuck closed but not annoying enough to warrant fixing.

    A/C needs re-gassing.

    Passed the NCT in November first time with no preparation except 2 new tyres and cleaning the MAF myself.

    Ever fail to start: once with a dead batt started first time with jump leads.
    once when the starter got wet, started easily on the clutch with just two of us pushing (and its a heavy car). Started its self again the next morning no work required.

    So I can say around 700 euro (of non-standard maintenance) just to allow for anything I might have forgotten, not bad in almost 3 years of owning it.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 21,283 ✭✭✭✭Eoin


    1989 Mini City (6 months): All I can say is :(

    2001 Peugeot 206 (2 years): Brake light stayed on, but was a quick fix.

    1999 Golf 1.4 (1 year): Constant sticky throttle cable (I think), plus many assorted annoyances.

    2000 Alfa Romeo 156 1.6 (2 years): Headlights were prone to blowing on occasion. Apart from that, it was just regular servicing. Honestly.

    2000 BMW e46 320d (2 years) Needed new clutch & DMF, coolant system needed a good few replacement parts. Various other things needed replacing, but it was at the 100K miles mark where these things tend to happen. I'm sure there was more as well; on reflection it was an expensive car to keep on the road, and I've little doubt a 320i would have been cheaper in the long run.

    2000 BMW 525 (2 years and counting): Cooling system needed a few parts replacing. New stereo head unit. New air blower / "hedgehog". Rocker cover a tiny bit leaky, so replaced recently. Other than that, it's been rock solid and still feels really tight.


  • Posts: 23,497 ✭✭✭✭ [Deleted User]


    All from memory so it's a struggle

    1990 Rover 414si bought in June 1999 as first car, put 20,000 miles on her over the following 20 months. Needed back box, alternator, battery and CV joint in that time and a clutch, thats18 year olds in their first car for you.

    1995 Rover 214SEi bought in March 2001, kept her for 5 years and put 100K miles on her. Fuel pump and gearbox went on her so stranded both those times, blocked fuel filter also had me stranded once. One or both CV joints and a wishbone needed doing, along with the catalytic converter.

    2005 Mondeo 2.0Tddi, company car for a year, flywheel and intercooler hose both needed fixing under warranty, not stranded by either but intercooler issue resulted in driving 40miles at less than 30 miles / hour.

    1999 Rover 600, bought in Sep 2006 and sold in April 2007. Never an issue really, think I needed a CV boot done on her for the NCT.

    1995 Toyota Celica bought in April 2007 and sold the following Christmas, nothing at all (except tyres and oil change but that doesn't count presumably, most of the other cars had pads and whatnot along with oil changes and plugs etc done too obviously)

    1997 Rover 400 diesel bought in late 2007 and driven until March 2009, had to replace the battery, one CV joint, other CV boot and a wishbone on her, nothing else. Actually had to have the starter looked at, new brushes or something in that.

    1993 Prelude 2.2 auto non VTEC, bought in March 2009 and sold 3 or 4 month later. Nothing here either, CV boot actually now that I think of it, don't do them myself, potentially messy and pain in arse :)

    1992 Merc E250 diesel bought in Summer 2009 and driven for 3 months until September 2009, nothing really, needed a relay for the ABS. Only a tidy up and a service otherwise, was 230 000 miles on her.

    1997 Rover 216 Coupe, bought in late Summer 2009 and driven for 6 months until April 2010, had to put a battery into her, nothing else. She's currently at home off the road, needs a wiper motor for the NCT as it doesn't work on intermittent setting.

    1993 BMW 520i touring, bought in March 2010 and currently my daily driver, have spent nothing on it except a tonneau cover off ebay which doesn't count really. Was serviced before I got her and she is in great condition, still need to have a look at drivers door though, won't open from the inside, she'll be for sale shortly as I only need an estate for the next couple of months.

    All the above had routine servicing done, oil, filters etc when needed along with tires and that sort of stuff :)


  • Moderators, Business & Finance Moderators, Society & Culture Moderators Posts: 9,760 Mod ✭✭✭✭ToxicPaddy


    First car - 1986 Fiesta Mk II 996cc (36k miles in 18 months)
    Surprising reliable car for the rust bucket that it was, apart from a few electrical switch blowing, no real problems.

    Second Car - 1996 Polo 1ltr
    Very reliable, put 96k miles on in 3 years, never as issue..

    Third Car - 1997 Modeo 1.6LX Saloon (had for 8 years and 182k miles)
    Back bushes and wishbones replaced twice in 8 years,
    Front brake disks
    1 light switch
    Blocked valve in engine (a common thing apparently with this model)
    Cause emissions to rise and failed NCT emmissions test by .5% as a result :rolleyes:

    Current Car - 2001 Audi A6 1.8T (had for 3 years and 30k miles now)
    Issue with remote central locking, still going (Nothing serious)
    MAF had to be replaced
    Still only 75k miles on it, so still a relative young one.. :D

    Thats it really, I am lucky enough not to have had too many problems yet with many of my cars..


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 7,684 ✭✭✭JHMEG


    Damomayo wrote: »
    2001 VW Bora 1.9 (130Bhp)

    Very realible
    Had to replace turbo after it blew but limped home
    What did that set you back?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,843 ✭✭✭CountingCrows


    1999 Pug 306 1.4 (2 years)

    New Exhaust
    Fan control unit
    Great car

    2000 Celica (1 year)

    Nothing, another great car.

    2001 BMW 320CI (1 year)

    Brake discs
    Battery
    Fuel hose
    Coils

    2002 Audi A4 TDI (1 year)

    Nothing


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 8,574 ✭✭✭Matt Simis


    1993 BMW 850CSi
    About 5k spent in parts (not all failed, some preventative) since owning, 7mths. Its also my daily driver.

    Some big ones:
    Clutch burnt out on day2.
    MAF sensor (1 of 2)
    Rear Shocks
    Rear and Front suspension arms/bushings (ie everything but the front shocks and all springs)
    Rear exhaust backboxes


    Im sure it will be perfectly reliable when its all fixed though. :D


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,226 ✭✭✭angelfire9


    From memory 1993 Nissan Micra which I bought in 2001 was perfect never had a problem with it
    Changed car to a 2000 Nissan Micra in 2004 kept til 2006 perfect never had a problem with it
    Currently driving 2004 Fiesta Zetec Steel no problems as such did have a dead battery twice in the 4 years i've had it both occassions due to me leaving internal light on AND sat nav charging overnight in in-car charger


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,717 ✭✭✭ARGINITE


    1999 Rover 200
    Leaky rocker cover gasket, caused it to burn oil for the first few months I had it.
    New exhaust.
    One rear wheel bearing.

    Other than the above it has not missed a beat in the 3 years I have had it.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 7,684 ✭✭✭JHMEG


    Most of my cars have been non-stories.

    1991 Integra XSI (dohc vtec)
    Blew a bearing in the distributor at 234,000km. €180 for a new dizzy from Canada.
    Trailing arm bushes went at some stage, failing the NCT. €38.
    ABS never worked, thanks to faulty Sumitomo pump.

    2004 Civic IMA
    Thanks to someone leaving a rubber seal off, water got in where it shouldn't have and blew an injector. €102 for a new one. Injector in turn damaged the ECU, £120 for a replacement off ebay (€1100 from a main dealer:eek:)


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 7,132 ✭✭✭x in the city


    88 colt

    nothing wrong apart from wrapping it around a barrier on a slippery bend back in them heydays, somehow managed to fix it up, (practically a whole new car...:rolleyes:)

    sold it, traded it in for a 95 i think colt. japanese one

    bomb proof

    sold that for a 98 civic coupe sr vtec

    bomb proof and fairly nippy :eek:

    sold that for 2 bmws

    first was a 95 316i...

    trouble, everything that could go wrong, did

    sold that for a 93 bmw 316i. less trouble.

    (notice the downgrading...!)

    current car is a mondeo 01 zetec. bomb proof.

    apart from rear suspension.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2, Paid Member Posts: 29,801 ✭✭✭✭_Kaiser_


    99 Mitsubishi Mirage Hatchback(Colt Import) - perfect till a woman pulled out in front of it on a national route one morning :(

    98 Mitsubishi Mirage Coupe (Import) - again perfect till traded in because I needed a diesel for my increased mileage

    02 VW Passat TDI - bought from what I too late discovered was a cowboy :(
    - Problems with door locks
    - Oil consumption started going mad
    - Dash lit up like a christmas tree towards the end
    - Later found out that despite being sold as a 130 BHP version, Cartell lists it as a 100 BHP model :(
    Ironically despite all that, it still drove very well and was very comfortable
    Eventually traded in as it was approaching NCT time and wasn't worth the money to fix it.

    06 VW Passat TDI DSG
    - Problems with the boot lid. Needed to be regassed
    - Very sore on dipped bulbs (but I do have them on all the time I guess)
    - Power has started to "surge" intermittently when the engine is cold resulting in jerky movements.
    - Intermittent rattling/scraping sound from what I'm told is the dual-mass flywheel which is going to cost me a grand to get sorted :(


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 5,372 ✭✭✭Saab Ed


    The Best:

    1996 Laguna Mirage 1.8. Bought it to sell on and make a profit but the missus grabed it and kept it for 2 and a half years in which time nothing went wrong, and I meen nothing. I didn't spend a penny on that car bar a service....oh and I sold it for 200 quid profit after all that :D

    The Worst:

    1990 Citroen AX van. In my ownership for 6 months. In that time it stopped on the road twice, refused to start 14 times , various bits fell off it and in the end I crashed it. Enough said :o


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 11,222 ✭✭✭✭Marty McFly


    Opel Astra 99 1.4: Had it for four years it served me well. Water pump went on 2nd year, replaced that along with the belts.
    Then head gasket went with only 65,000 miles on the clock at that point traded it in for my new car.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,689 ✭✭✭JimmyCrackCorn


    Honda accourd 1996 2.0i 96,000 miles and probably clocked:D

    Only problem i had was an attempted theft and the previous owner killed the clutch(reflected in price).


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,400 ✭✭✭Skuxx


    Citroen Berlingo ...... '03 1.9 non turbo

    This bitch has been nothing but trouble in the 6 months I have it!!
    • New clutch
    • New wishbone
    • New thermostat
    • Broken back door handle, have to climb through van and open from inside
    • Non-turbo means its as slow as a wet week
    • Eats through break and indicator lights for some reason (think I've put 6 new bulbs in it)
    • Drivers door is slightly offline which means it doesn't always close properly without an incredible bang!!
    It has never failed to start though, even with the harsh winter!!:D


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 38,227 ✭✭✭✭Guy:Incognito


    alan1990 wrote: »
    Citroen Berlingo ...... '03 1.9 non turbo

    This bitch has been nothing but trouble in the 6 months I have it!!
    • New clutch
    • New wishbone
    • New thermostat
    • Broken back door handle, have to climb through van and open from inside
    • Non-turbo means its as slow as a wet week
    • Eats through break and indicator lights for some reason (think I've put 6 new bulbs in it)
    • Drivers door is slightly offline which means it doesn't always close properly without an incredible bang!!
    It has never failed to start though, even with the harsh winter!!:D

    TBH that sounds like the previous owner knew there was maintenance coming up and offloaded it.

    Clutch is a wear and tear item. Thermostat can go and only cost about €10 anyway. Wishbone could be damaged from hittign a big pothole/kerb.

    Handle would be an easy fix from a scrap yard.

    The door could be as a result of one of my pet hates, people standing leaning on the open door.

    The engine is slow alright, Ihave the same one in my expert, the upside is, it'll never break. Toyota used them in the corolla (van i think) for a bit in the 90's,

    Honda accourd 1996 2.0i 96,000 miles and probably clocked:D

    Only problem i had was an attempted theft and the previous owner killed the clutch(reflected in price).

    Every 90's Jap car should have had a recall over here and been fitted with a big chan to go around the steerign wheel.:)


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,502 ✭✭✭chris85


    my current 2004 honda civic 1.4s is no trouble at all. Starts east every time and drives smoothly and great for mileage. Have it about 9 months now. It has a small ding on the body which i need to get fixed (its tiny to be honest)

    Previously had a 2001 punto. head gasket, gearbox, power steering all had to get fixed while i had it as well as front shocks and a few other things. Absolute nightmare.

    Also previously had a 1995 Toyota Cynos. Probably my favourite car i had as was fun to drive. Always started good and never a mechanical issue. Clutch went but it was due to. Also got timing belt done but again it was due it so not bad at all. Would think about getting a 98-99 model and i always consider it if i see it on adverts or somewhere. Was great until someone rear ended it and wrote it off.


Advertisement
Advertisement