Mcanns telling the truth or not?

badabing106 · 17-02-2010 02:05AM #1

I am very interested in this politics and public opinion of this scenario , I believe the mcanns are vigorously trying to block the publication of a book by the former lead detective in the case who alleges that the mcanns were invovled with the "accidental death of their daughter" .

Are the Mcanns telling the truth or not? They believe that their daughter was kidnapped .

I'd like to post another poll if the book that the mcanns are trying to block , is allowed to be published in the near future as well to see if the opinion is any different .

Senna · 17-02-2010 02:08AM

badabing106 wrote: »

book by the former lead detective

($) ($)

jimmycrackcorm · 17-02-2010 02:08AM

Hang on - let me put my psychic glasses on....

Midnight_EG · 17-02-2010 02:12AM

No, Snyper did it....we knew that....a long damn time!

badabing106 · 17-02-2010 02:12AM

Senna wrote: »

($) ($)

There is alot of that on the mcann side as well .

Bodhisopha · 17-02-2010 02:14AM

I believe they are telling the truth, but more importantly, does anyone else think Jerry and Kate look a lot alike eachother?

Red_Marauder · 17-02-2010 02:14AM

badabing106 wrote: »

I am very interested in this politics and public opinion of this scenario

I think you are giving too much intellectual weight to this issue by referring to its "politics".

It's tabloid trash, not politics.

darragh16 · 17-02-2010 02:16AM

Random interjection;

Maddie is an anagram for "Im dead"...

epgc3fyqirnbsx · 17-02-2010 02:17AM

I genuinely couldn't see them 'hiding' a dead kid which is the only way they could not be telling the truth

Horrible **** happens, I'm sure they haven't slept right for leaving their kids unsupervised since

Bad parenting?? Parenting is at a very high standard these days, I remember driving from mayo to wexford many times with 5 kids in the back of the car with no babychairs or seatbelts. Which was common...

Biggins · 17-02-2010 02:20AM

1. Where is the "I have no idea" option?
2. This thread won't end well.

Where ever the girl rests, if she rests, I hope she does so in peace. RIP.
End of story.

DazMarz · 17-02-2010 02:22AM

It's debatable... If they had anything to do with it or whatever, they are thoroughly despicable.

m@cc@ · 17-02-2010 02:22AM

badabing106 wrote: »

I am very interested in this politics and public opinion of this scenario , I believe the mcanns are vigorously trying to block the publication of a book by the former lead detective in the case who alleges that the mcanns were invovled with the "accidental death of their daughter" .

Are the Mcanns telling the truth or not? They believe that their daughter was kidnapped .

I'd like to post another poll if the book that the mcanns are trying to block , is allowed to be published in the near future as well to see if the opinion is any different .

He shouldn't be discussing an ongoing case in public. If he has adequate evidence, prosecute them. If he doesn't, **** up!

What is fact, is that the Portugese police have been shown to be an incompetent force. There is little fact known about this case, just conjecture and circumstance.

badabing106 · 17-02-2010 02:25AM

Red_Marauder wrote: »

I think you are giving too much intellectual weight to this issue by referring to its "politics".

It's tabloid trash, not politics.

You are right , it has become tabloid trash but there were alot of politics involved beforehand...

Sharpshooter · 17-02-2010 02:27AM

badabing106 wrote: »

I am very interested in this politics and public opinion of this scenario , I believe the mcanns are vigorously trying to block the publication of a book by the former lead detective in the case who alleges that the mcanns were invovled with the "accidental death of their daughter" .

And wouldn't you if you knew you were innocent?

/btw there is no body so to say accidental death is jumping the gun, so to speak, no?

Are the Mcanns telling the truth or not?

How would we know the answer to that, other than what we have seen and heard from them on TV and interviews?

They believe that their daughter was kidnapped .

Of course they do, so do the Police.

badabing106 wrote: »

I'd like to post another poll if the book that the mcanns are trying to block , is allowed to be published in the near future as well to see if the opinion is any different .

You are welcome to do that, but wait and see how this one goes first.;)

Dudess · 17-02-2010 02:27AM

badabing106 wrote: »

I believe the mcanns are vigorously trying to block the publication of a book by the former lead detective in the case who alleges that the mcanns were invovled with the "accidental death of their daughter"

Rather than the blocking being an admission of guilt, I'd be more inclined to believe it's down to simply not wanting such a macabre book being published. I'm sure the skewed "If they've nothing to hide, they'd leave it go ahead" logic will be used, which is... illogical.

Are the Mcanns telling the truth or not?

A lot of people sure as hell hope they're not - nothing like a witch hunt...

dlofnep · 17-02-2010 02:28AM

Unlike obviously everyone else on the internet, I actually don't know enough about what happened to pass judgement.

OutlawPete · 17-02-2010 02:28AM

Wish the Poll was public.

Can't understand anyone thinking they are lying.

Both of them always looked distraught and trustworthy to me.

Shekamu · 17-02-2010 02:29AM

It's horrific. I was upset when I lost my camera in a taxi while on holidays in France.. can't imagine what it would be like to lose my daughter!

I think the parents could only sleep with exhaustion and the thoughts of what's happening to their child at the moment and who she is with or how she has been tortured or killed.

Whoever is responsible for child kidnapping anywhere in the world needs capital punishment.

It's up to the investigators to deal with the McCann case. I don't think the public should jump in and criticize the parents if there is nothing proven against them.

m@cc@ · 17-02-2010 02:31AM

I love the annoyance of people that they say "Are they still going on about their daugther?". If it was me, I'd annoy the hell out of every c*** on earth until I found/ found out what happened to my daughter.

Shekamu wrote: »

It's horrific. I was upset when I lost my camera in a taxi while on holidays in France.. can't imagine what it would be like to lose my daughter!

F*** me, I'm glad you were able to empathise.

_LilyRose_ · 17-02-2010 02:37AM

I think that the Portuguese police guy who wrote that book had no right to say those things. I doubt the McCanns [accidentally] killed their daughter while on holidays, and then made up a kidnapping. It doesnt make sense given the fact that they were enjoying dinner with their friends. Madeleine was abducted, full stop. It's awful enough without some amateur cop writing malicious conspiratory theories that can only blacken the McCanns names and take the focus away from actually trying to find Maddie. I really feel sorry for them and hope the poor child isn't suffering, where ever she is...:(

badabing106 · 17-02-2010 02:44AM

m@cc@ wrote: »

I love the annoyance of people that they say "Are they still going on about their daugther?". If it was me, I'd annoy the hell out of every c*** on earth until I found/ found out what happened to my daughter.

F*** me, I'm glad you were able to empathise.

Does it not worry you that the Mcanns would refuse to answer 20 questions that would help investigators with the dispaearence of their daughter , and that they would refuse to participate in the re-inaction of the disapearance of their daughter ???

fkt · 17-02-2010 02:44AM

_LilyRose_ wrote: »

I think that the Portuguese police guy who wrote that book had no right to say those things. I doubt the McCanns [accidentally] killed their daughter while on holidays, and then made up a kidnapping. It doesnt make sense given the fact that they were enjoying dinner with their friends. Madeleine was abducted, full stop. It's awful enough without some amateur cop writing malicious conspiratory theories that can only blacken the McCanns names and take the focus away from actually trying to find Maddie. I really feel sorry for them and hope the poor child isn't suffering, where ever she is...:(

Well, that's great, case closed then.

/thread

_LilyRose_ · 17-02-2010 02:47AM

fkt wrote: »

Well, that's great, case closed then.

/thread

Way to take it out of context...whats your point?

Hater......:P

OutlawPete · 17-02-2010 02:47AM

Jaycee Dugard's case would have given them hope as she was kidnapped when she was 11 in 1991 and was only found last year, 19 years later.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aIPGjHRM-Pg

K-9 · 17-02-2010 02:47AM

_LilyRose_ wrote: »

I think that the Portuguese police guy who wrote that book had no right to say those things. I doubt the McCanns [accidentally] killed their daughter while on holidays, and then made up a kidnapping. It doesnt make sense given the fact that they were enjoying dinner with their friends. Madeleine was abducted, full stop. It's awful enough without some amateur cop writing malicious conspiratory theories that can only blacken the McCanns names and take the focus away from actually trying to find Maddie. I really feel sorry for them and hope the poor child isn't suffering, where ever she is...:(

The fact that they where enjoying dinner while their children where unwatched, that far away, made it strange and let the Conspiracy theories go unchecked.

Still, I don't think they did it. Where they irresponsible on the day? Yes. If they had behaved more responsibly on that day would she still be here? Yes!

They have to bear that guilt and responsibility and I empathise with that.

MeerKat17 · 17-02-2010 02:53AM

Bodhisopha wrote: »

I believe they are telling the truth, but more importantly, does anyone else think Jerry and Kate look a lot alike eachother?

Hahaha! Ya they do! But I find oddly enough that a lot of married couples look alike....

badabing106 · 17-02-2010 02:53AM

K-9 wrote: »

The fact that they where enjoying dinner while their children where unwatched, that far away, made it strange and let the Conspiracy theories go unchecked.

What are you basing that on ?

K-9 · 17-02-2010 02:56AM

badabing106 wrote: »

What are you basing that on ?

That they had dinner with friends and the children where not there?

Sharpshooter · 17-02-2010 03:00AM

badabing106 wrote: »

What are you basing that on ?

What are you basing your thread on?

Because as far as I can see it's all conjecture.

kmart6 · 17-02-2010 03:01AM

Did he not get fired?! And hasn't he accussed them already?!

_LilyRose_ · 17-02-2010 03:03AM

I was watching a programme about this a while back- the McCanns and the friends that they went on holidays with went back to the hotel and re-enacted the hour or so around the time she was taken. I can't remember who found her missing first, Kate I think, but anyway, it was one of the fathers (not Jerrys) turn to check on all the kids before Kates and he actually didn't go right into the room to physically see the children, he only listened at the door. If he'd looked in, it might have given Madeleine an extra half hour:(

Mcanns telling the truth or not?

? 114 votes

Comments