Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie

The Nurses.

2456718

Comments

  • Closed Accounts Posts: 6,395 ✭✭✭Marksie


    micmclo wrote:
    Whatever about pay and working hours, nurses get a fantastic pension.

    Won't bother my sister in laws best friend who was forced back to work after a debilitating viral illness. Initially part time then after two weeks put on full duties, she went into respiratory arrest and died two day later.

    Oh and a partner is the sole nurse in a day care centre for the elderly. OFFICIALLY she works 35 hours, but she is in there til 9 most nights organising everything from the food to doing the accounts.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,373 ✭✭✭Dr Galen


    i think there is some confusion here, i was talking specifically about the offer the employers made to unions, basically saying that for the nurses that they pay anomaly affected, THEY would get the increased allowance. NOT al the other nurses working in the system,

    this is what i mean when i say it basically institutionalises the idea that nurses should get paid less then the childcare worker

    as for your second point......i dunno if it does it not, i'll tell you in a few months ;)

    seriously though, when a job has increased stress levels, increased repsonsibility etc etc, normally what happens is that people get paid more. thats why, to use and example, CEO's et shedloads while data inputters get considerable less.
    over the past number of years the workload, responsibility and educational requirements to be a nurse, have shot up, but with NO pay increase, this leads to the situation we have now, where u have a lot of angry nurses, who feel undervalued etc workin the system.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 322 ✭✭boffin


    nurse_baz wrote:
    over the past number of years the workload, responsibility and educational requirements to be a nurse, have shot up, but with NO pay increase, this leads to the situation we have now, where u have a lot of angry nurses, who feel undervalued etc workin the system.

    I think that your battle is that many people feel like that in the private sector as well.

    I know from chatting to people that many feel that in compensation for your career choice you have job security for life, the ability is dramatically increase your pay through overtime and a pensionable job which are luxuries many don't in the private sector. These benefits many people believe out weight the perceived problems that are being quoted as reasons for increased pay.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,373 ✭✭✭Dr Galen


    but you see we don;t have a job for life, you only have to look across the water to the NHS where layoffs are common and from friends I have over there, it is increasingly difficult to get work as a nurse, even though they have a nursing shortage in real terms. also i'm not permanent staff, thats a misnomer. I might be wrong, but i think this is down to the employment ceilings introduced by the employers.

    the same goes for overtime, there isn't the overtime bonanza that people seem to think. if you were dedicated and did overtime (if it was even availible) every month or week, sure you could come out with a few grand extra, but i'm talking 4 or 5 more, not 15k. as well as that, after working the week, your that knackered, both physically and emotionally that going back in to do overtime is the last thing on your mind.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 11,005 ✭✭✭✭Flukey


    I'm not a nurse, but I can see a lot of what they are saying. There is a lot of "if they didn't like the job why did they go for it?" in this thread. The fact is that they do like their job, but they are not getting enough chance to do it as they are lumbered with other things that should not be part of their job. Does the surgeon have to come in and scrub the floors of the operating theatre before he does an operation? "Of course not, it is not his job" I hear you say. You are correct. Yet nurses are expected to do jobs that they should not be doing. Instead of looking after patients, which is the job they applied to do and want to do, they are off cleaning out toilets and doing other such work that others should be doing. Their patients are being neglected then. Nurses have been promised improvements as far back as 27 years ago. They are still waiting. Meanwhile, others around them have been getting promised improvements. Who amongst you, if promised some improvements in your working conditions 27 years ago and had not got them yet, would be happy with that? There are a lot of people that would be reading this thread that would not have been even born 27 years ago. So, it is a long time to wait.


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 322 ✭✭boffin


    That is the problem maybe - there is alot of misconceptions out there - I do feel that nurses do a great job but I am still to be convinced about the pay thing - but sure maybe Liam Doran will change my mind!!! ;)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,626 ✭✭✭timmywex


    i think they do great work but........

    the 10% increase is a non runner for me and the government are not going to give it either, if they get it,all state employees will want it,

    the 35 hour week tough i think would be ok and wouldnt mind them getting that, no problem there

    the HSE dont want them on strike either tough, there's another group threatning it at the moment aswell


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,373 ✭✭✭Dr Galen


    timmywex wrote:
    i think they do great work but........

    the 10% increase is a non runner for me and the government are not going to give it either, if they get it,all state employees will want it,

    the 35 hour week tough i think would be ok and wouldnt mind them getting that, no problem there

    the HSE dont want them on strike either tough, there's another group threatning it at the moment aswell

    could you explain why the 10% is non-runner for you?

    and just to say, i deffo don't want to be on strike or anything like it right now either. its a whole world of hassle


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,626 ✭✭✭timmywex


    10% is a huge amount to go with a shorter working week, all other employees wil start crying out for it and it will cost millions, i just dont agree with it, i think the shorter week would mean a pay rise because they are getting the same pay for less work so the amount per hour is going up,


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,384 ✭✭✭pred racer


    Nurse_Baz, you are not gonna get alot of sympathy here, the rest of us work in jobs where if we dont like the pay and conditions, we go look for a different job. I know alot of nurses and sure, they do a hell of a job, but when they start moaning at me I give them the same advice..."go do something else".


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,373 ✭✭✭Dr Galen


    timmywex wrote:
    10% is a huge amount to go with a shorter working week, all other employees wil start crying out for it and it will cost millions, i just dont agree with it, i think the shorter week would mean a pay rise because they are getting the same pay for less work so the amount per hour is going up,

    do you understand why nurses are looking for the 10% and why it is a separate issue to the shorter working week?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,828 ✭✭✭KerranJast


    IMO the nurses should be given their pay rise and the Govt. should try and encourage a few more people to become nurses in order to allow the workload on nurses to be lessened. Tired and stressed people make mistakes. In the private sector that = lost money. In the health service that = dead people. Forget about it encouraging the rest of the civil service to look for a pay rise. IMO there's no comparison between pen pushers in the various departments and the critical work done by nurses and junior doctors. There needs to be a financial incentive to attract good people to stressful and even dangerous jobs. Firefighters, Gardai directly involved in fighting drug gangs and nurses should be paid more than their fellow civil servants.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,626 ✭✭✭timmywex


    nurse_baz wrote:
    do you understand why nurses are looking for the 10% and why it is a separate issue to the shorter working week?

    yes, i do realise there is an issue with junior people reporting to other nurses getting paid more but think there are other ways of sorting this out


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,373 ✭✭✭Dr Galen


    pred racer wrote:
    Nurse_Baz, you are not gonna get alot of sympathy here, the rest of us work in jobs where if we dont like the pay and conditions, we go look for a different job. I know alot of nurses and sure, they do a hell of a job, but when they start moaning at me I give them the same advice..."go do something else".

    i can totally see your point here, i worked in the private sector for quite a while myself, and as previously noted, even ran a business.. but i was never one to go along with the put up or shut up mentality.

    i love my job, and throughly enjoy what i do, yeah its ****ty and stressful sometimes. emotionally its draining all the time. but there can be great moments. i really don't want to do anything else.......and why should i be forced to.

    again i ask, whats wrong with people looking to improve their conditions? to hear some people within the private sector talk, you'd think that it was all a big share and share alike, altruistic love in, but its not. it appears that a lot of you are in jobs that you really don't like very much, but are kinda stuck there (mortgages,rent, loans etc need to be paid) and i'm not knocking that, but please don't try and talk down to, or patronise those of us who actually enjoy our work, and want to do better out of it.

    for those (not you pred racer) that have called nurses greedy, u just think about the last time u were in hospital, or someone close to you was, and see if that holds any water. when i'm regularly out of work late because i took an extra 15 minutes with your dying granny, or held your dads hand for 2 hours while a doctor explained to him that he would be dead in 2 months, think again about some of the bull**** thats been posted here about nurses being greedy


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 50 ✭✭seastar


    I'm not a nurse but I support the nurses strike. It's not an ideal situation but this government doesn't seem to listen to anything else. I feel that the arguements against the nurses being made on this thread are small-minded, made by the same type of people who give out about teachers holidays.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,373 ✭✭✭Dr Galen


    timmywex wrote:
    yes, i do realise there is an issue with junior people reporting to other nurses getting paid more but think there are other ways of sorting this out

    well.......... 6 years ago we tried to do that, then in benchmarking round 1, then again in benchmarking - towards 2016, then again throught the Health services own procedures for dealing with disputes. its not like this has just crept up on anyone......we've been talking about this for a long time now.

    the same goes for the 35 hour week, it was early 80's when the Labour Court said that nurses should be the first to get it. thats a long time coming, meanwhile, all other grades of health professional of our level, and below, have gotten it.........

    so when 20 odd years of talking gets you no where what do u do?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,410 ✭✭✭kizzyr


    pred racer wrote:
    Nurse_Baz, you are not gonna get alot of sympathy here, the rest of us work in jobs where if we dont like the pay and conditions, we go look for a different job. I know alot of nurses and sure, they do a hell of a job, but when they start moaning at me I give them the same advice..."go do something else".
    Well actually I fully support the nurses in what they are looking for and really hope they succeed.
    I am not a nurse but do work in the health service and have done for a good while now and am constantly amazed and disgusted at how badly treated this group of people, who do a huge amount of work, are.
    Yes they are looking for a shorter working week but that shorter working week only brings them in line with everyone else who works in the health service i.e 35 hours. Doctors are only on a 32 / 33 hour week so why should nurses who work in the same areas and with the exact same people be forced to work longer?
    Those who are in the admin/clerical grades not only get a 35 hour week up to and including the grade 7 positions (who at this grade get 30 days annual leave) also get flexi leave so effectively get 12 more days on top of this, a shopping day at Christmas, a privilage day at Christmas and Easter just for the heck of it and Good Friday too. Nurses get none of this.
    Effectively they are paid less and asked to work longer than others in the health service and so should be respected for the job they do, the qualifications and experience they bring to their roles and anyone who objects to this.....................well I suggest you get yourself into A&E on any given Saturday night and tell me those men and women do not deserve what they are asking for.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 838 ✭✭✭purple'n'gold


    “they are off cleaning out toilets and doing other such work that others should be doing.”

    Why on earth would a nurse clean a toilet? Don’t they have people to do that? And would it not be totally unhygienic for a nurse that is handling a patient to be mucking about in a toilet?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 838 ✭✭✭purple'n'gold


    Those who are in the admin/clerical grades not only get a 35 hour week up to and including the grade 7 positions (who at this grade get 30 days annual leave) also get flexi leave so effectively get 12 more days on top of this, a shopping day at Christmas, a privilege day at Christmas and Easter just for the heck of it and Good Friday too. Nurses get none of this.

    No one should get any of this, its part of why our public service bill is over the moon.
    Go work in the private sector and see how many privilege days you will get. You will have the privilege of seeing your employer get a hernia laughing at the mere mention of it.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,988 ✭✭✭constitutionus


    personally im fully in support of the nurses. i cant name any sector , public or private, that'd wait 27 years to get the same working hours as everyone else in their industry. and as to the wages its funny how everyone in the media is screaming about the increase but dont want to talk about the fact 46% of health expenditure is spent on administrators, who by the way should be the ones answering the phones and liasing with other labs and hospitals not nurses.

    TBH the thing thats bothering me the most is the media reaction to it. its the most biased demonizing bile ive ever heard, particularly claire byrne on newstalk. the thick bitch actually compared opening the door or answering the phone once or twice in newstalk to the extracontractual work the nurses are made do on a daily basis. im sure newstalk's receptionist is delighted to know dennis obrien can sack her at anytime cause clair's willing to do her work for free:rolleyes:
    there's something really sinister going on here with what looks like corporate ireland looking to crush union representation by an orchestrated campaign against the nurses when anyone whos actually been in a hospital knows the only people your likely to see are nurses and junior doctors. i mean has anyone actually seen an administrator?:confused: what do these ****ers do to deserve 7 billion a year??
    and the patronising manner in which the debate is conducted. theyre either "saints" and " angels " or money grabbing bitches. well im sorry but I Thought they were professionals and as such as entitlled to sue for redress like everyone else. just because half the posters that post here are celtic tiger morons who dont know what a recession is and think the working condidtions they have just appeared out of thin air doesnt mean there are sectors out there, public and private, which are based on continual abuse and exploitation. and people in those professions have every right to do everything in their power to address the situation.

    i think the nurses shouldve gone on actual strike from day one! but then again we wouldnt have seen the scaremongering from the HSE about how the work to rule (which by the way just means you do what your PAID to do) was causing such "dificulty". maybe the HSE would be better off explaining why day to day running of a health service involves depending on people doing work that ISNT their responsibility whilst simultaneously keeping on detrius like the entire 11 ex health boards at a cost to the tax payer of over 1 million a year on just the heads alone till they retire and the jobs cease to exist. HELLO! ever heard of redundancy? justs give the ****ers two weeks pay for every year they were there and thats the end of it, but no, harney has to give em jobs for life with bench marking :(.

    christ im sorry but im just so angry by the ignorant comments by posters and the media on this issue. like anyone could pay you enough to be puked on by a heroin addict or end up on a six months course of drugs cause some scumbag with HIV attacked you in A & E with a syringe he dragged out of his own arm:mad:

    its not a "vocation" its a profession and these people have got the short end of the stick for over two decades. FFS WW1 and WW2 together were resolved shorter than this dispute. theyre only asking for what they deserve and if the money's hard to come by sack a few administrators. at 70k ago it shouldnt take that many to make up the difference. christ knows nobody'd miss them !

    and dont start me on the "go elswher if your not happy" crap. nurses are the ONLY profession that are still emmigrating. practically 90% are gone in two years!


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,819 ✭✭✭Vorsprung


    kizzyr wrote:
    Yes they are looking for a shorter working week but that shorter working week only brings them in line with everyone else who works in the health service i.e 35 hours. Doctors are only on a 32 / 33 hour week so why should nurses who work in the same areas and with the exact same people be forced to work longer?.

    You don't know many doctors do you? :rolleyes: :rolleyes: I know interns still working 90+ hours in a major Dublin teaching hospital, and consultants are often in from 7 till 6.

    Nurses put up with a lot of **** everyday of the week and fully deserve a pay increase (which hopefully junior doctors will soon be getting!). There needs to be a big shakeup though, there's nurses in outpatient dept making the same as nurses on the wards which I personally don't agree with, and there's nurses in ICUs who are making the same as them too, and they should be getting more (not least because there's a big shortage)


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,623 ✭✭✭dame


    I have a nurse friend who has gone into the management side and works a 35 hour week with nice regular sociable hours. She's recently had her first child and her friends who are still nurses have been telling her she should go back to the regular nursing cos she can cut her hours right down and work days/hours that suit her. She can't do that in the job she's currently in because it's full time, end of story. Obviously working part-time isn't an option for some people but it's also obvious that nurses do have a great deal of flexibility and can choose to cut down their hours if they wish to.

    I do think that they should be paid more than the lower-skilled folks working with them though.

    On the emigration side of the argument; I have a cousin who's a nurse and when she graduated she worked in Ireland for almost a year then she and a group of other nurses chose to travel for a year or two. It's great that they have a qualification that allows them to travel and work in other parts of the world when they feel like it. Most of her class went away for a few months at least, but most have since returned home to work when the travel bug has left them.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,410 ✭✭✭kizzyr


    Those who are in the admin/clerical grades not only get a 35 hour week up to and including the grade 7 positions (who at this grade get 30 days annual leave) also get flexi leave so effectively get 12 more days on top of this, a shopping day at Christmas, a privilege day at Christmas and Easter just for the heck of it and Good Friday too. Nurses get none of this.

    No one should get any of this, its part of why our public service bill is over the moon.
    Go work in the private sector and see how many privilege days you will get. You will have the privilege of seeing your employer get a hernia laughing at the mere mention of it.
    I'm not saying that its right that people in the admin grades get that kind of leave don't get me wrong but when its offered to you you're not going to say no to it are you? However when it is offered to certain sections of the service then it should be offered to all. I've worked in the private sector so I know what its like there in terms of leave and pay rises etc so I'm not totally naive that I think that the public sector gets away with too much and that if the pay and conditions are going to stay as they are then a system of checks should be put in place and only those that deserve the increases get them.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 27,644 ✭✭✭✭nesf


    Steyr wrote:
    They knew they type of **** they were going to have to deal with so **** em, Money grabbing bitches.

    Keep it civil please.


  • Hosted Moderators Posts: 7,486 ✭✭✭Red Alert


    I have to defend the nurses claim for more pay here. My gran had many encounters with nurses in the few months before she died, especially during her stay in the hospice. Most of them really did a stellar job - caring for the elderly is very stressful, and all of them were so caring and interested in gran and everyone else there. They made an effort to get to know the family, and were always there if there was anything you needed.

    I don't like the way they are dealing with their pay claim, but I feel that they are so discriminated against that it is the only course of action open to them. Going into a hospital is one of the most stressful jobs i can imagine - they are all heros to do that day after day.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 27,644 ✭✭✭✭nesf


    Honestly, while I sympathise to an extent on the pay issue and the work-time issue, I actually think that they should cop on and realise that they are one small part of a much larger civil service and that they should work within the same necessary structures as the rest of said service.

    Really, you'd swear they existed in a vacuum apart from the rest of the economy.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,638 ✭✭✭PeakOutput


    Won't bother my sister in laws best friend who was forced back to work after a debilitating viral illness. Initially part time then after two weeks put on full duties, she went into respiratory arrest and died two day later.

    wat has that got to do with anything?????

    i skipped threw a few of the replies on this page so if its been said i apologise

    you cannot say the 10% raise and the shorter week are seperate issues.........they are problems caused by different factors but you are looking for them at the same time


    affectively as it stands now, when you factor in the shorter week nurses are effectively looking for a 20% increase on their hourly wage(by my calculations but its been a long time since i did maths) that is an outlandish amount to look for imo especially as we will have to hire another nurse for every 7/8 at the moment to do the same amount of work(again by my calculation and assuming no nurse will do overtime as clearly they wont because thats too stressfull)


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 6,395 ✭✭✭Marksie


    nurse_baz wrote:
    that have called nurses greedy, u just think about the last time u were in hospital, or someone close to you was, and see if that holds any water. when i'm regularly out of work late because i took an extra 15 minutes with your dying granny, or held your dads hand for 2 hours while a doctor explained to him that he would be dead in 2 months, think again about some of the bull**** thats been posted here about nurses being greedy

    Tell me nurse_baz. Do you get an annual bonus for meeting or exceeding performance target? Many of my friends in the private sector do.

    But then again how can one measure in real terms what you have just posted.

    What you have said is totally true. I cannot imagine some of the more vitriolic posters here holding their bosses hand because he has missed his targets, But you can be damn sure they will be the first ones to whine and moan about not getting the service they need if they are sick.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,638 ✭✭✭PeakOutput


    What you have said is totally true. I cannot imagine some of the more vitriolic posters here holding their bosses hand because he has missed his targets, But you can be damn sure they will be the first ones to whine and moan about not getting the service they need if they are sick.

    bit of a stupid analogy but whatever

    paying the nurses more and reducing the working week is not going to improve the service the patients recieve

    in fact imo shortening the working week for them will dramatically decrease the level of service as there will be an even greater shortage of staff then there is now


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 884 ✭✭✭NutJob


    No problem with them having a normal working week which there entitled to and deserve but another pay rise two is a bit much.


Advertisement