Advertisement
Help Keep Boards Alive. Support us by going ad free today. See here: https://subscriptions.boards.ie/.
https://www.boards.ie/group/1878-subscribers-forum

Private Group for paid up members of Boards.ie. Join the club.
Hi all, please see this major site announcement: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058427594/boards-ie-2026

Evening Herald & My Home.ie Competition

13

Comments

  • Closed Accounts Posts: 5 Carlitos Way


    Needless to say I won’t be buying a pint in the Head Line Bar in Dublin.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 10,984 ✭✭✭✭Lump


    ANyone who's stupid enough to spend that much money on news papers deserves to feel like **** / not win / be a darwin awards entrant.

    John


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 17 Roz


    Moderator Lump, most of the ordinary people who entered this particular insidious competition were desperate more than stupid, and the blurb promoting this competition played/preyed on this.

    Just a couple of interesting website addresses:

    Gaming and Lotteries Act 1956 - http://www.irishstatutebook.ie/ZZA2Y1956.html

    and

    The Advertising Standards Authority For Ireland - http://www.asai.ie/ .

    Food for thought.

    Roz.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 10,984 ✭✭✭✭Lump


    Why would I read them. Anyone willing to spend €50,000 on newspapers, in the hope of winning a house is stupid.... nothing else, just stupid
    The competition was a complete fix. There is no way in the world that a group of people could possibly get there hands on 50000 papers (according to the Sunday Times) in the space of a week.

    Even if you spend €5,000, €500 or €50 on the Herald you are still stupid. I don't care about Gaming and lottery acts or the advertising standards authority.... stupid.

    John


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 17 Roz


    Sorry, Moderator Lump John, the second part of the above post was aimed at other people reading this post who may have an interest in this topic.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 10,984 ✭✭✭✭Lump


    Right.

    John


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,031 ✭✭✭MorningStar


    PPS- for those that are disheartened by the competition and feel that there’s no way there going to win the property, well you’re probably right, BUT you can justifiably look for a refund of the cash that you put into it. If you are pursuing this let people know, put it up here. There’s always strength in numbers.

    I doubt anybody here can honestly look for a refund. They were all talking about the different cheats thay could try. The pooling of tokens, joining sydicates etc...

    Read this thread and there were people warning about the problems but others just kepting going on about not being negative. I get the desperation of some people but desperation is no excuse for the level of sure stupidity of risking alot of money on this. The guy who won is obviously a gambler and business man. I would safely bet that he didn't put his house/future at risk. Anybody to think these type of people would not get involved in this were very niave at best and extremely stupid at worst.


  • Hosted Moderators Posts: 2,563 ✭✭✭Tazzle


    Lump's name is John, guys.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 17 Roz


    I get what you are saying MorningStar and John about people's foibles, but I would not exonerate and let the Evening Herald off the hook on this one. Apart from attempting to get refunds, Carlitos Way, and there is no harm in trying, there are other remedies and sanctions that can be pursued. Complaints about misleading advertising and promotion about the competition can be made to the Advertising Standards Authority For Ireland, and there are sanctions if such complaints are upheld, even if it is only a public slap on the wrist. Such bad publicity and bad feeling and other possible fallouts may hurt to some extent the benefits and financial gains earned by the Evening Herald from running from such a promotion/competition again in future.

    In addition, the Gaming and Lotteries Act is primarily there to protect people from their inbuilt weaknesses and gambling addictions, and the remedy I would like to see is that such competitions are not held in future by the Evening Herald or other newspapers.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2 emily


    While i don't think anyone has a hope in hell of getting a refund (i'm sure the evening herald/ my home have covered themselves)- i still cannot fathom how paddy managed to get 50,000 evening heralds or indeed how he had the confidence to hold off until so late in the competition. While it was pretty obvious the vouchers would increase towards the end- i can't undersatnd how he was in a position to secure so many copies. My heart goes out to anyone who did lose a lot of money- as above i reckon entering the competition reflected desperation and not stupidity! I know this is really sour grapes and possibly no consolation what's so ever. But i lived in a new holliokes house in lucan. Between a swamp in the backgarden, doors that wouldn't close properly, and plaster that fell off the walls (in the first three months) i can only say "nightmare". not the most pleasant company to deal with. (Bitter me- no no not at all!) ;)


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 17 Roz


    Hi Emily. I hear what you are saying about Hollioake homes. A friend of mine lives in the Belfry in one of the Hollioake homes in a second floor duplex apartment, and the water heater timer in the hot press is one of those Grasslin QE7 Residential Water Heater timers which are currently being recalled (this warning was advertised in the Evening Herald and Irish Independent last Friday) because of a possible defect which can cause the timer to overheat possibly resulting in fire.

    People with these timers are being advised to stop using them and to turn the main switch to off. They are advised not to operate the main switch or boost function while sleeping or out of the house. If they need hot water, they are being advised to turn the main switch to on and push the boost button and to switch the main switch to off as soon as the water is heated.

    Anybody who has one of these timers is being advised to ring a freephone number 1800 946 360 to register for a replacement. People should check out what make and model of water heater timers they have and take the requisite action if necessary.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 436 ✭✭sleepwalker


    Why would I read them. Anyone willing to spend €50,000 on newspapers, in the hope of winning a house is stupid.... nothing else, just stupid

    they spent 50 grand because they knew they would get all their money back plus some more.

    that syndicate are not a group of idiots they only bet on sure things and they knew this would be one of them.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,951 ✭✭✭L5


    he said in the paper he was as confident of winning it as if he was taking a penalty kick, that he was almost certain he'd win it.
    Sounds pretty dodgy to me.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 11,909 ✭✭✭✭Wertz


    Well anyone that can organise a combined effort to buy 800,000 lotto tickets probably had very little problem getting their hands on 50,000 tabloids...

    I feel sorry for normal people that entered this thinking they had any chance of winning....there's always some smart c**t out there who has to turn it into a money making scheme. But did he break any rules? The fault lies with the people running the competiton IMO.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,958 ✭✭✭✭RuggieBear


    Wertz wrote:
    Well anyone that can organise a combined effort to buy 800,000 lotto tickets probably had very little problem getting their hands on 50,000 tabloids...
    .
    Bingo....nail on the head there. These guys would have figured out the logistics


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,652 ✭✭✭impr0v


    Couldn't it simply be the case that he pre-ordered a run of 50,000 copies on that day, knowing from the last competition that the highest value tokens are on the last day? The paper are hardly going to turn down an order of that magnitude out of some sort of moral obligation to all the deperate dreamers that already have a back garden full of unread newsprint. You all really should have seen it coming.

    And no, he probably wasn't sure of winning, but he was sure enough to warrant the gamble and would have been able to take the loss of the stake he was putting down.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2 emily


    Surely to have acquired so many papers on the final days he must have ahd to break the rules. Ordering a run of 50,000 from the evening herald cannot be a legitimate strategy. Especially as the number of copies joe soap could buy from independent newspapers was limited! In fact buying from you local newsagent was limited in a lot of cases. Also as Carlito mentioned the whole announcement was surprisingly low key. I read the paper (in the shop- never buying the rag again!!) today and there was no mention. has anyone seen anything other than yesterday's times? I suggest we all make a formal complaint and if anyone is up for it "talk to Joe"?


  • Moderators, Science, Health & Environment Moderators, Social & Fun Moderators, Society & Culture Moderators Posts: 60,119 Mod ✭✭✭✭Tar.Aldarion


    Tazzle wrote:
    Lump's name is John, guys.

    yes john marigold lump
    what of it.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2, Paid Member Posts: 25,004 ✭✭✭✭Sleepy


    Can't say I'm surprised to be honest. I'd be interested in hearing the logistics of how they got the 50,000 copies 'without' breaking the rules of the competition. Wondering if a lot of it was from the guys who sell them at the traffic lights? Most of them look like the sort of guys that'd be desperate enough to help out someone like that for a couple of quid.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 11,909 ✭✭✭✭Wertz


    emily wrote:
    Surely to have acquired so many papers on the final days he must have ahd to break the rules. Ordering a run of 50,000 from the evening herald cannot be a legitimate strategy. Especially as the number of copies joe soap could buy from independent newspapers was limited! In fact buying from you local newsagent was limited in a lot of cases. Also as Carlito mentioned the whole announcement was surprisingly low key. I read the paper (in the shop- never buying the rag again!!) today and there was no mention. has anyone seen anything other than yesterday's times? I suggest we all make a formal complaint and if anyone is up for it "talk to Joe"?

    Excuse my ignorance on the mechanics of the competition, but if I wanted to do this I'd get 40 friends/employees to drive to 40 provinical towns/cities, each buying 50 copies of the paper for 25 days. Not exactly an Olympic opening ceremony fireworks display in terms of organisation...
    50 grand plus the same again in wages/petrol or whatever other overheads, for what the guy reckons was moreorless a sure thing.
    Even if he lost he's still rolling in it anyways from his lottery hits and other ventures.

    The conspiracy theorist in me is dieing to say that there's staff of the paper in cahoots with the guy or his affiliates somewhere down the line, but that would be silly...I


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 10,984 ✭✭✭✭Lump


    What's the facination with my name?

    John


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,315 ✭✭✭Chalk


    Wertz wrote:
    Excuse my ignorance on the mechanics of the competition, but if I wanted to do this I'd get 40 friends/employees to drive to 40 provinical towns/cities, each buying 50 copies of the paper for 25 days. Not exactly an Olympic opening ceremony fireworks display in terms of organisation...
    50 grand plus the same again in wages/petrol or whatever other overheads, for what the guy reckons was moreorless a sure thing.
    Even if he lost he's still rolling in it anyways from his lottery hits and other ventures.

    The conspiracy theorist in me is dieing to say that there's staff of the paper in cahoots with the guy or his affiliates somewhere down the line, but that would be silly...I
    the problem with that is the ever increasing value of the tokens,
    from 100euro or so for the first few weeks to 50000eu in the last week.

    i doubt there was a conspiracy,
    just a well thought out plan to buy lots of heralds at the last minute.
    those auctions in the herald are always done the same way,
    the high value at the end encourages every one caught up to buy more,
    most of them dont consider that someone has outsmarted them.
    and since theyve probably invested a few thousand euros at this stage theyll gladly throw a few more at it.

    if you can buy that many lotto tickets in a few days,
    you can surely buy a few heralds.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 5 Carlitos Way


    Some of you have focused on the fact that if the same guy can organise 800,000 lotto tickets then its safe to say he could organise 50,000 Evening Heralds. Does anybody actually remember back to that particular lotto stunt? He had an ‘insider’ of sorts back then as he must have had this time around also. He had pre-arranged with a shop to run off the boxes and boxes of lotto tickets that he had prepared with all the different combinations. The shop was his ‘insider’ then; who was it this time. I don’t care about his luck with the lotto stunt that he pulled, good luck to him. There’s no limit that one person can buy of lotto tickets as far as I’m aware. But there was in this competition. I can vouch for the fact that the idea that this guy was driving around picking up 15 Evening Heralds per shop and at the end of all his hard work, had 50,000, is total horse****. Physically and logistically this would be impossible. Traffic alone makes it unthinkable. And lets not forget, almost all shops have two Evening Herald drops, afternoon (2pm) and late afternoon (4pm). The papers sell out at around 8pm. That’s a daily window off opportunity of about 6 hours. Not forgetting that were talking about sometimes as little as only three papers in a shop at that time of night, if even. Further, I personally didn’t notice all that much of a drain on the papers ‘public’ circulation (as oppose to 'private’, for those at the back). I was actually surprised how many Evening Heralds were actually available for that last week!!! Some of you have mentioned the fact that those that got involved in this competition are just stupid. Well most gambling sort of is, in a way. But one SAFE bet is that not one of that guy’s papers ever saw the inside of a newsagency or petrol station.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 5 Carlitos Way


    Wertz wrote:
    Excuse my ignorance on the mechanics of the competition, but if I wanted to do this I'd get 40 friends/employees to drive to 40 provinical towns/cities, each buying 50 copies of the paper for 25 days. Not exactly an Olympic opening ceremony fireworks display in terms of organisation...
    50 grand plus the same again in wages/petrol or whatever other overheads, for what the guy reckons was moreorless a sure thing.
    Even if he lost he's still rolling in it anyways from his lottery hits and other ventures.

    The conspiracy theorist in me is dieing to say that there's staff of the paper in cahoots with the guy or his affiliates somewhere down the line, but that would be silly...I

    Wertz you sound like a really interesting guy. For starters you have no less than 40 mates. Plus they’re all unemployed and available to help you. They all have a car. They love you so much that they are willing to drive to County Meath or where ever, and back to buy you a couple of papers. And to top it all off, they like you so much, you don’t have to worry about them stealing your idea!!!!

    PS- Wertz, I’m not being an asshole but that’s hardly realistic now is it. It’s a lot easier to get in contact with someone who works for the Evening Herald. Throw a couple of grand his way (as he can’t enter the competition anyway) and you get an apartment. Publicans have a lot of contacts in a lot of places. Contacts would be essential for this to be pulled off, not a drive to Meath!!


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 17 Roz


    Here is a current link to an online version of the article in the Sunday Times last Sunday - http://www.timesonline.co.uk/newspaper/0,,2765-1602790,00.html for those who want to read it. My gripe is not with the winner/winners and his/their tactics - had there been some syndicate out there willing to gamble €60,000, they would have been beaten, and there were probably syndicates out there who spent €20,000 to €30,000 thinking they were on to a sure thing. My gripe is with the Evening Herald for effectively running a gambling racket that Las Vegas would be proud of.

    The aftermath of the National Lottery fiasco in 1992 was that the rules of the Lottery were changed so that a similar coup could not be pulled off again. It was a statistical certainty at the time (the only caveat being the existance of another jackpot winner/winners) that if you covered all combinations, you would win all prizes between match three and the jackpot, which would equal more than you spent.


  • Hosted Moderators Posts: 2,563 ✭✭✭Tazzle


    And the poor children in Africa...


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 5 Carlitos Way


    Tazzle wrote:
    And the poor children in Africa...

    How profound!

    In the name of love, one man, in the name of love... uh oh uh oh, uh oh uh oh...


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,031 ✭✭✭MorningStar


    emily wrote:
    as above i reckon entering the competition reflected desperation and not stupidity! /QUOTE]

    Desperate people do stupid things, desperation does not mean you are exempt from stupidity. After a brief investigation it would have been apparent that a serious bank roll would be needed or some other form of "cheating".
    What is the desperation for? To own a house? You can always rent there is no need to own a house it's desire not need. Try paying for a house yourself if you can't afford it get over it you have to rent!


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,031 ✭✭✭MorningStar


    The shop was his ‘insider’ then; who was it this time. I don’t care about his luck with the lotto stunt that he pulled, good luck to him.

    Actually that time he had a lot more than one "insider" as you put it. No corner shop was going to enforce a 15 paper rule. I 'm not sure of the rules for the competition but there was no legal way that the 15 paper rule could be enforced. The best the paper could have threatened was not to supply the shops with papers which they wouldn't do if the store normally sold a lot or if it would have covered a whole region.
    There is also the company that deals with returned papers for shops. If I was doing this I would have gone to them first. THey cut of the headers for the shops and credit the shops.


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,031 ✭✭✭MorningStar


    The guy who won was just on the radio. He only spent €25k and an additional €10k to somebody if he won. He got the other person on-line because he heard there were syndicates on line and got somebody from one of them to join him. THere was also a lot of mention of other people spending more money than he did.


Advertisement
Advertisement