November Vanilla Werewolf - Game Thread

i'm leaning towards mac danger

Looking at the day 2 lynch votes again:

Why was Lordy forced to change his vote rather than the 3rd wolf changing theirs:

Wolf Lorcan: Was already on a wolf so couldn't switch

Wolf Oscar: Was already on a wolf so couldn't switch

Wolf Trit: Was already on Oscar; him, Strawbs & Lordy were the other wagons so had nowhere to switch to

Wolf WM: Was already on a wolf so couldn't switch

Wolf MacDanger: I could have switched although it would have conflicted with my FFA (Trit, Leggy & WM)

Wolf Yoss: Ended up on Lordy so this is a great look

Wolf G&R: Moves from a non-wolf to a wolf; this wouldn't make any sense

Yoss is top villager by a mile, I can't see any scenario where he's a wolf

Based on the above, it's either Trit or WM for me - WM seems to be anxious to railroad the voting so that has him top of my list ahead of Trit (although I did vote for Trit at that lynch so that's bugging me too!). At the moment, I'll be voting WM

I'd say you are comfortable with your vote alright! Handy way to avoid answering questions - are you denying that your strategy was to bring Oscar (who had previously been your most wolfy) to the final lynch so that it'd be a landslide?

You've posted about the dead villagers a couple of times now but no response whatsoever to my quoted posts from Neo? Doesn't suit your narrative I guess

In yesterday's list, I'd say the main reason people had me ahead of others was because I haven't (other than the Lordy vote who as it happens, you didn't vote for) voted for a known wolf. You'd have to ask them to be sure though

@MacDanger

Wasn't too hard to find. He is meh on me.

Funny you didn't post it as he is scummy on you.

Like I said didn't suit your narrative.

Nice try though

going to spend some time on read back. On reflection leaving Oscar around was possibly a better strategy last lynch, and play in the grey area instead-meh whatever

of the remaining

if Yoss is wolf he deserves to win, I won’t be voting there

Mac vs Wm is where it’s at at this point.

if I was wolf I certainly wouldn't have munched him first, as it would have drawn too much attention on me.

So you wouldn't have munched someone who voted for you? But after munch earlier, you said:

I think Mac munches Green to remove a vote of of them for lynch later.

That's a pretty convenient way of looking at the exact same thing in completely different ways.

I may have arsed about on Day 0, thought that was the whole point of having a non lynch/munch day but once the game has started I've had a pretty consistent level of engagement across the game

Helpful? You're having a laugh, right? The crytpic FFA that you did was on Day 1, not Day 0 so is this more lies? Another mistake in your timeline?

I've asked plenty of questions and I've been pushing FFAs because as I've said, not doing FFAs suits the wolves and allows them wiggle room. I questioned both Trit (about what looked like a fake interaction with Neo before Neo got munched, it's why I voted for him) & Yoss (I've been at him several time about the fake vote).

For me, it all comes back to the votes on the 2nd lynch and why Lordy voted the way he did - if you look that logically, it's 100% not Yoss and IMO, it's down to you or Trit and looking at that in combination with you wanting to keep Oscar for the final lynch makes you the last wolf

Never said my cryptic was on Day 0, that's a discussion creator which I've said before. Whether people agree or not is up to them.

My hello fellow wolves was Day 0 and was arsing about.

Don't remember you voting for Green before they were munched, so not the same at all actually.

I disagree about you asking questions. Now when your back is up against the wall you ask questions. Pity you couldn't be this helpful and active from the start.

You can spin the it all comes back to votes on 2nd lynch but look at your own voting.

I'll say it again and you can answer when youre on again.

LER, lorc, GnR and Oscar. The last four villagers all lynched or munched had suspicions about you.

Why do you think that is?

It's been a busy day in work, so forgive me if I've missed something obvious you're are talking about, but I don't get your question, I think Mac is wolf!

As in, Mac claims to be a villager, but I just don't see how he has been a helpful villager as I don't see him contributing to village

Mac things you first read list

“Here's where I am with everyone at this early stage:

Necro: Has > 40 posts and was in for Liz on his 4th post which is fair enough as a cage rattle; I'm not sure if he's using her later posts to fit that narrative or if he actually thinks that she's a wolf (as below, I'm not convinced). If Liz were to flip wolf, I'd have him a practically lock villager. First one to post a list of reads which is a good look.
OscarMIlde: ~ 20 posts and I'm finding her hard to judge, some good posts though
jayo44: < 10 posts so hard to judge, appears to be a newbie
Leg End Reject: ~10 posts, first post was straight to Strawbs' list which I didn't like as it feels like they're setting themselves up to follow whatever Strawbs says
lorcand1990: ~30 posts, lots to like here IMO, rattling plenty of cages
JP Liz V1: ~25 posts, more villager than not for me; while her play isn't fully chaotic Liz, it's not as measured as the last game IMO.
Neowise: ~ 25 posts, overall, I think their posting is villager but on second reading of their list, I really dislike that they put themselves in it. Still a village lean though
y0ssar1an22: Unknown, 2 posts
Lord TSC: ~ 10 posts, not saying a whole pile yet, seems reluctant to accuse anyone which I get to an extent but would like to see something more during the day
wrestlemaniac: ~15 posts, probably my most wolfy read - the opening comment "hello wolves" and esp for the comment "how you reading myself?", both felt a bit needy to me and trying too hard to be TWTBAW.
tritium: ~10 posts, another poster I like, rattling a few cages without going mad, village lean
StrawbsM: ~10 posts, making a big deal of the list thing sort of annoys me but at least it's something, will wait and see if she delivers reads based on the list
Green&Red: Yet to post”

lots of opinions there but I’d really like to know why you managed to be bupkiss neutral on two wolves in there- plenty of villagers rated, wolves not so much. Explain please

who you thinking is the final wolf trit?

just looking at the votes to date:

trit has not voted for any wolves.

macdanger has not voted for any wolves.

wrestlemaniac has voted for strawberry.

feck, this is tough

*excepting night 3, where there was the lord bandwagon.

that should be WMs

yeah, thats why i voted him night 1. thought it was such a backroom slip, but people said thats just his way.

that then leaves macdanger.