November Vanilla Werewolf - Game Thread

y0ssar1an22

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122898280#Comment_122898280

how do you know 2 wolves remain?

wrestlemaniac

Right. I'm putting in a vote now for Mac.

Just checked on there early engagement. Posted once on Day 0, it was the 'secrets' post. Both Neo and Necro picked up on it. Neo called it scummy. They were the first 2 munches, both flipped village.

Mac didn't post again until the following morning, quickly trying to look for FFA's or else people are wolf. They have kept that up throughout, giva an FFA or you are wolf.

Never voted on a wolf once.

Highlighted both by Oscar and LER when I pushed both of them to give me an alternate name.

GnR what are your thoughts? Why did you go there tonight?

wrestlemaniac

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122898662#Comment_122898662

Oscar, look into myself and Mac more please

OscarMIlde

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122898691#Comment_122898691

I think that meant me whittling down suspects to two when asking me to list suspicions.

wrestlemaniac

That was me pushing Oscar, as she had it narrowed down to me and Mac as most wolfy after LER

wrestlemaniac

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122898688#Comment_122898688

Is lynch form open?

y0ssar1an22

state of play and votes:

y0ssar1an22

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122898707#Comment_122898707

maybe, but it seems to me like he is talking about wolves remaining rather than suspected wolves.

OscarMIlde

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122898705#Comment_122898705

Will do. Also while Lorc pushed Lord could possibly have been a triangulation: there was some early Strawbs Lord shade, maybe they were all distancing themselves from one another if wolf.

My head is melted right now.

wrestlemaniac

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122898729#Comment_122898729

Just read back the posts between myself and Oscar properly

y0ssar1an22

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122898745#Comment_122898745

never! i'm basking in the utd victory and having a few drinks.

wrestlemaniac

🤣Same, minus the few drinks. They drive me to drink most times though

Trigger

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122898714#Comment_122898714

Yes it's open now until first Yeet.

OscarMIlde

Not as good as having a whiskey while watching this mad man.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zWdtGnZSbAA

wrestlemaniac

Perfect. My vote is in for Mac. I've given my reasons.

I will struggle to get online until afternoon tomorrow.

If I'm munched look at Mac everyone. I think we learn more lynching Mac instead of lynching Oscar.

wrestlemaniac

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122898810#Comment_122898810

1 hour of watching fireworks, you need to stop drinking whiskey, it's making you do mad things!

wrestlemaniac

Right off to bed. Looking at Triggers times, I won't be on until after munch 2,

y0ssar1an22

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122898813#Comment_122898813

do you think you'll be munched?

if i was a betting man, i'd say trit will be gone.

tritium

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122898813#Comment_122898813

why would you be munched?

lorcand1990

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122898008#Comment_122898008

If the wolfiest thing I've done is catch a wolf d1 and not move till they're lynched then I'm happy with that and I'll leave you to it

If I had switched off lord d3 would that make me more or less wolfy?

I'm somewhere between drunk and hungover and I don't like where it's going 😂

lorcand1990

Ya know what, if Oscar is the wolf I'll tip my hat and say amazing game, absolutely outstanding and take the loss. Gonna say it outright now I don't think they are a wolf

I think it's mac, all I have on their general play the first few days is read lists, synopsis of the game and asking for ffas. No info points, no wolf hunting, no asking questions, staying super low

wrestlemaniac

Quick check in.

Trit & yoss no idea if I'll be munched, I just won't be on until 3ish today which is after munch 1 and 2.

My lynch vote is in on Mac for all the reasons I posted last night and lorc highlighted too.

Hopefully my next check in is to see a village win.

lorcand1990

Vote gone in for Macdonalds euro saver menu

OscarMIlde

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122898813#Comment_122898813

Please change your vote to me.

There is one wolf left. A munch, lynch, munch, lynch, munch brings it to two players, one village and one wolf. Wolves have one.

After munch odds of picking the wolf are one in six. After second lynch, munch there is a one in four chance of picking a wolf so better odds.

There is too much evidence to suggest a wolf role for me. Lord, known wolf, moved in lynch wagon off between Liz and me, saving me.

Again, Lords vote could be interpreted as an attempt to save me and Strawbs. It's the most likely explanation in fact.

If I somehow survived first lynch, and the wolf isn't picked, the real wolf is home free as when push comes to shove even people who feel my posting is villagery will be forced to vote for me.

Not doing so is crazy like a fox.

I implore one and all, vote for me Oscar Milde this lynch morning.

*this has been a special election broadcast for do it the best interests of the village political party*

OscarMIlde

Lorc, please read my post above.

Odds in selecting wolf are helped by resolving my orientation first.

I'm voting for me and I mean it this time.

OscarMIlde

Also Wrestle and Mac, you were on a wolfteam with me before.

You know full well if I was wolf I would brazen it out.

lorcand1990

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122899429#Comment_122899429

I'm using all the info I have on you during the game, piecing it together and I'm determining that you are, in all likelihood, not a wolf

If you want to try convince me someone other than mac is a wolf, fine, but stop telling me to vote for you. If others want to tell me to vote for you I'll listen

OscarMIlde

Thoughts for what they are worth. My hit rate is terrible so not worth much.

Munches, while bad for the village at this point, are going to help in narrowing potential pool the wolf is paddling in.

For last lynch people NEED to keep their vote hidden. Do not share. In fact from this point on people need to be wary of giving to much/any voting info to wolf as will be easy to influence final lynch in four way vote.

Obvious instruction is obvious, but I urge people to go with their gut feeling on final lynch and not be swayed by thoughts of how others are voting. Hopefully wisdom of crowds will do it for us as it did in prior votes on Strawbs and Lord.

MacDanger

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122899429#Comment_122899429

Don't vote for yourself if you're genuinely village. This is the 2nd time you've tried this though so I feel like it's a strategy

MacDanger

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122898698#Comment_122898698

Just checked on there early engagement. Posted once on Day 0, it was the 'secrets' post. Both Neo and Necro picked up on it. Neo called it scummy. They were the first 2 munches, both flipped village.

You're right, a good few people mentioned that but I was literally quoting the OP, you can go back and check for yourself. Neo voted for you on night 1 so I'm not sure how one comment about me makes it likely that I munched him.

Mac didn't post again until the following morning, quickly trying to look for FFA's or else people are wolf. They have kept that up throughout, giva an FFA or you are wolf.

If pushing for FFAs is wolfy, then string me up!! I've said that not posting an FFA is wolfy but I've never actually used it as a reason for putting someone on my FFA or voting for someone. It's bizarre that I need to explain but the reason the village should push for FFAs is that it gives wolves less leeway for flip-flopping (e.g. in a vote, it's much harder to switch and say "I was alwys suspicious of X" if they didn't appear on your FFA) and crucially, when you're a wolf, you need to decide whether or not to put your fellow wolves on your FFA, do you leave them off, put 1 on or put both on? Villagers have no such qualms because while their reads may not be accurate, they're at least done in good faith. Tagging @lorcand1990 in this as he makes the same point

Never voted on a wolf once.

This is fair and there's no much I can say about it other than I voted people that I thought were wolves, I was open about my reasoning and never changed my vote even when known wolves were in trouble