If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Moderators, Computer Games Moderators, Technology & Internet Moderators, Help & Feedback Category ModeratorsPosts: 26,237
CMod ✭✭✭✭
Join
Date:
Posts: 23746
Enjoyable and easy going bit of fun. Like the previous episode, they took time to continue all the previous small threads. But it seems like they also torpedoed the Spock/Chapel thing, which is a little surprising.
That was absolutely brilliant ! What a ballsy call to do that start to the episode, and then the opening credits, and indeed the end scene.
Just pure fun, pure Trek and Boimler and Mariner in the flesh were amazing. So good to see both actors in real life playing off each other, great chemistry, as they do as voiceovers in Lower Decks.
That goes down as one of the best cross over episodes ever!
Even my wife who is not a Star Trek fan, enjoyed it ! Actually turned to me and said is it supposed to be this funny !!!
Star Trek Strange New Worlds, long may it continue, has brought back everything that I loved about Trek.
Fantastic episode. Easily the best of the season without any doubt. They also managed to blend the humour incredibly well. Loved Pikes line about the communicator "but the flipping is the best part". Also brought in the self awareness in a way that wasn't too hamfisted, from Boimler commenting on the size of the bridge, to him and Mariner mentioning how quietly and slowly everyone spoke compare to LD. Fantastic stuff.
Also must add again to how much I've been impressed with Ethan Peck. Jesus his smile is disconcerting in this in a way it probably would seem to Boimler.
I had no real hopes for this episode but it turned out really well. Boimler kind of works in live action but Mariner seemed weird, then I could have been distracted by my loathing of nose piercings. One thing they could have added was a little visit from Dulmer and Lucsly at the end.
The "new ship has a piece of the old ship" thing is kind of interesting but then how does it work in cases Like C to D?
I had no real hopes for this episode but it turned out really well. Boimler kind of works in live action but Mariner seemed weird, then I could have been distracted by my loathing of nose piercings. One thing they could have added was a little visit from Dulmer and Lucsly at the end.
The "new ship has a piece of the old ship" thing is kind of interesting but then how does it work in cases Like C to D?
Yeah it doesn't really work when you overthink it. The Enterprise-Nothing was destroyed, the Enterprise-A was a redesignation of a different ship. Similarly, Ent-C was destroyed and the Enterprise-G was the Titan redesignated. Guess it's a "best effort" kind of tradition.
I think it would be funny if Boimler was freaked out seeing Una because of the pre-TOS accident that resulted in Nurse Chapel's consciousness permanently trapped in Number One's body.
Nurse Chapel's consciousness was never permanently trapped in Number One's body in any Star Trek canon. This was a fan theory that was popularized by the novel "The Return" by Diane Duane, but it was never actually confirmed in any of the shows or movies.
In the novel, Chapel's consciousness is accidentally transferred into Number One's body after a transporter accident. Chapel is able to live in Number One's body for a while, but eventually she decides to transfer her consciousness back to her own body. The novel ends with Chapel and Number One both alive and well in their own bodies.
Pretty sure Boimler wasn't the only one with a poster of her, which I guess is the joke.
Ortegas and Uhura reaiising they were sounding like Mariner and Boimler.
Una commenting on the oddly specific scenarios.
Thought might have gotten some comment about Pelia, either saying how never heard of her or how she's known by everyone, as a wee joke about how her and her species are new (aren't they?).
No comment about La'an either. Surely they must've had some thoughts about Khan.
Anyone else think the lead Orion looked like Rene Auberjonois? At least I think that's who he reminded me of.
I was joking about them both being played by Majel Barrett. (And all mentions of number One pretty much disappearing entirely from canon until SNW came along). Didn't actually realise that someone took that too far and wrote a fanfiction novel around it.
That was very good and weirdly more of a straight episode than some of the other "comedy" episodes.
The intro and finale were great calls. I also didn't realise just how much I loved Lower Decks. I mean seeing them gave me the same kind of buzz you get from seeing legacy characters on Lower Decks.
Only downside was that from very early on I thought we are going to see NX-01
I was actually more impressed with Mariner, thought she was perfect in live action. I've seen Jack Quaid in enough TV and film that I expected he'd be good (and he was!) but I've never seen Tawny Newsome in anything. Instantly recognisable as the character, both looks and mannerisms, and really funny.
Also -- don't think it's been noted here yet -- this was a Frakes episode, too. I'd say that was a lot of fun on set.
This is an embed external element. It can be deleted using the delete key or the backspace key. To view the full element, press the preview button below.