Mod Note Post #1 - The 2022 All Ireland Senior Football Championship.

I'd liken that incident to what you sometimes see in hurling when a player loses his hurley and the opposition player has the ball and goes to strike it. Sometimes the defending player without the hurley will jump across the swing with hands, body, even head at times to execute a block on the player.

There is no onus on the player striking the ball to avoid hitting the lad defending it. Comerford was brave to be fair to him and it probably not getting the credit he should for a great double save that kept Dublin in the game.

Its telling that other than a few head bangers on here, no one is looking for it to have been a red card.

I'd imagine they will be very defensive too. They have nothing to match Clifford and O'Shea, but if they can park the bus around them, they have a greater depth of scorers than Kerry so have loads of options when they counter attack

e.g. Walsh, Comer, Finnerty, Tierney, McDaid, Conroy.

Finnerty looks good in spells all right. Comer can be a handful on his day given a little space. But walsh is their only top top class guy. Disagree about the depth of scorers v kerry. I guess we'll find out in a fortnight but they'll have to come up with something and have a few more tricks up their sleeve on the day because I see a big enough difference class between the 2 teams right now. As I've said before I didn't rate Derry and they were easily enough found out so not great preparation for a final for galway. But galway do have a nack of winning finals once there in um, if that counts for anything.

That's interesting. I was actually going to ask this question when I saw the other posters comments about duty of care. Its the third time that I heard the phrase being mentioned since the match yesterday. One of the commentators mentioned it during the match (McStay I think). And I've read it twice since. Why is being mentioned at all. I was wondering is there something in the rules about it. Try explaining duty of care to John Small after he put Eoghan MacLachlin from Mayo in hospital. I don't think duty of care is in any way relevant. Otherwise John Small would have had the book thrown at him. I could be wrong though.

The GAA rule book explicitly states that a category 3 infraction includes "Behaving in any way which is dangerous to an opponent".

If you want to make a complete fool of yourself you can pivot to try and claiming that doesn't mean a duty of care.

Seanie oshea has both feet off the ground when his left foot connects with Comerford - his left was sailing through the air after hitting the ball with his right and comerford is diving down at the same time. Comerford deserves more praise for the bravery he showed - SOS was coming in full pelt, ball was loose and comerford dived straight in. "Putting your head where others wouldn't put a shovel" as they say

Well said 👏

Perhaps it’s Galway bias, but I don’t think they are getting the respect they deserve.

Despite seven minutes of madness, Galway have been comfortably the best side in Connacht/Ulster this year, having been up by six points plus in every championship game.

Paul Conroy aside, they have a young team, the oldest defender is 27 and that defence is improving every day (notwithstanding crazy finish to Armagh game).

Kerry are favourites as they should be but they won’t get it soft.

You forgot about the other periods of madness in the Mayo and Roscommon x2 games this year. Armagh wasn't an isolated incident.

I think Galway will get an easy ride into the final by the media - lovely forwards - tradition - etc. - with very little real analysis of their strengths and weaknesses. In any case all the pressure is all on Kerry, Galway literally have nothing to lose.

Maybe if Kerry win this they will kick on and win a good few but right now there is nothing to suggest they are unbeatable.

Are Galway really that much worse than the Tyrone team that beat Kerry last year.

Sport would be awful boring if you can't go to a final thinking your team might actually win it.

I wouldn't say your biased or that they are not getting the credit they deserve,

It's just the way it is particularly with a young team, they haven't set the world on fire scoring wise or beaten any of the big teams, plus if they were already knocking on the door for a few years! You would say that experience would stand to them and they would be ready for the next step.

However nobody is doubting there talent or more importantly their ceiling if they can get there heads right in tight games against top quality opposition, they can't properly close games out and there full back line is all at sea under the high ball. A better team could make hay against that.

These are questions that they will have to answer like everyone else. They have made massive strides this year but are still green in allot of areas. If they can do all that you would think they certainly have an all ireland in um but maybe it's too soon for them this year