Is it just me or have SF vanished?

Truthvader · 14-07-2020 04:25PM

FrancieBrady wrote: »

So even if somebody puts the facts in front of you..(the timeline etc) you just ignore them and revert to the invented narrative.
Excellent.

You have no idea what has been reported to Gardai yet again prefer to invent.

And you haven't produced a scintilla of data to back up the claim of 'tribal empires' being anything other than localised problems.

Not hard to see who's 'argument' is in bother here.

Another question for yoy, if 'divisive partition' did not cause the conflict/war, what did?
Wete these people born as sociopaths and psychopaths?

People deciding to kill each other

dundalkfc10 · 14-07-2020 04:28PM

Have we nothing more to worry about, letting Americans in to roam the country, FFG not having a clue how to deal with it or have the balls to do with it.

I know what we will do have a go at SF

2020 Ireland

blanch152 · 14-07-2020 04:32PM

dundalkfc10 wrote: »

Have we nothing more to worry about, letting Americans in to roam the country, FFG not having a clue how to deal with it or have the balls to do with it.

I know what we will do have a go at SF

2020 Ireland

There are plenty of other threads for all of that.

dundalkfc10 · 14-07-2020 04:32PM

blanch152 wrote: »

There are plenty of other threads for all of that.

They all turn into have a go at SF threads, look at the Govt thread ffs

blanch152 · 14-07-2020 04:34PM

Truthvader wrote: »

People deciding to kill each other

Pretty much this was the reason for the conflict. Without the IRA killing people, we would have had peace a long time ago.

Adam9213 wrote: »

Well they all had some kind of support but the Provos were the only ones who had real support.

Also no one supported the Omagh bomb, no one in the real IRA supported it and no one in the general public supported it, it was an incompetent accident.

The dissident republican campaign at that stage had some low level support but after the Omagh bomb it only had support similar to the support of the New IRA today.

The Omagh bomb effectively ended the dissident republican campaign.

An incompetent accident? Is that all you can bring yourself to say about Omagh?

Truthvader · 14-07-2020 04:34PM

Adam9213 wrote: »

I've posted this numerous times and you've ignored it and still cite your claim that they "never" defended anyone.

The battle of St Matthews one of the most popular ones because it was when the PIRA had even started attacking tand before there was a guerilla war, it was their first major action.

As the situation worsened, Catholic residents feared that the gathering crowds of loyalists would attempt to invade the Short Strand and burn them from their homes. Local IRA members retrieved weapons from arms dumps. A young resident, Jim Gibney, recalled: "I saw neighbours, people I knew, coming down the street carrying rifles. I was just dumbstruck by this experience. I'd never seen such a thing before".

British soldiers eventually arrived in armoured vehicles and cordoned off the roads around the Short Strand, which denied the IRA "any hope of reinforcement".
A small group of IRA members and members of the Citizens' Defence Committee took up positions in the church grounds and in adjoining streets. The IRA members were armed with M1 carbines successfully preventing the incursion of loyalist mobs and militants.

This action brought a great deal of support for armed conflict on one hand you had the peaceful SDLP who after the shooting began, Stormont MP Paddy Kennedy went with Short Strand residents to the local RUC base cried and demanded protection for their homes which never came, and on the other hand you had the IRA who risked their lives some of whom were killed trying to protect the local people, ask the families who were shaking and scared in their homes do they think the IRA men who died were terrorists I doubt they'll say they were.

https://en.m.wikipedia...le_of_St_Matthew%27s

OK this seems like a bona fide defence of an are under attack. Still doesn't justify or explain 30 years of random murder.

And as to mandate. This is nonsense. Voting for something doesn't make it right. The streets were full of people glorying Bobby Storey a couple of weeks ago but he was still a thug and a thief

maninasia · 14-07-2020 04:36PM

aido79 wrote: »

I think Mary Lou finds it hard to criticise how FG are handling the situation. Everything she says they should do they are either doing or have plans to do. The empty can rattles the most but for now the can remains silent...

I don't think there are many people in the country who would want a party as inexperienced as SF handling the situation right now regardless of which side of the left right spectrum they stand on.

So they did a great job did they cratering the economy and allowing tens of thousands to come in without quarantine.
Even now from America and the UK.

Bad joke.

blanch152 · 14-07-2020 04:38PM

maninasia wrote: »

So they did a great job did they cratering the economy and allowing tens of thousands to come in without quarantine.
Even now from America and the UK.

Bad joke.

Tens of thousands to come in without quarantine?

When? How?

And what sort of a police state do you want to create?

Personal responsibility is key. I don't need the government to tell me not to go on holidays to Spain.

Truthvader · 14-07-2020 04:39PM

FrancieBrady wrote: »

Out come the selective, emotive victims again.
You know as well as anybody that the intention was not to kill two boys.

Two boys died tragically though that didn't have to, like all the other victims, including 18 children killed by BA forces as the conflict ramped up.

No Francie they did not die "tragically". They died because a sociopathic person decided to plant a bomb in the town where they lived in the hope that whatever damage and death the bomb caused would extort something that they wanted or had decided they were entitled to or had a mandate for

Bishop of hope · 14-07-2020 04:53PM

dundalkfc10 wrote: »

Have we nothing more to worry about, letting Americans in to roam the country, FFG not having a clue how to deal with it or have the balls to do with it.

I know what we will do have a go at SF

2020 Ireland

Our biggest problem are the people coming in through northern Ireland.
No quarentine rules if you just cross the border.
You can hop across for funerals and all sorts.

Truthvader · 14-07-2020 04:53PM

FrancieBrady wrote: »

This isn't rocket science really Mark.
The goal was to force a British withdrawal because the British protection of the sectarian state was what was causing the problems for nationalists. A terror campaign in England was seen as the way to do that. Defence turned into attack...it isn't exactly unique in that regard.

You can think of that as right or wrong, who cares at this stage. The goal of those who REALLY signed up to the GFA is to make sure it never happens again. You can accept that without ever supporting any of the sides who turned to violence...and they all did.

I care as to many normal people. As you to accurately put it "the goal was to force a British withdrawal". The means was to murder and mutilate random innocent people until you got what you wanted. Only a sick sociopathic individual behaves like this

Not a defence of anything then

Truthvader · 14-07-2020 04:59PM

dundalkfc10 wrote: »

Have we nothing more to worry about, letting Americans in to roam the country, FFG not having a clue how to deal with it or have the balls to do with it.

I know what we will do have a go at SF

2020 Ireland

Are they out of Prozac again?

This is a Sinn Fein thread. Create an "FFG and Goldman Sachs are letting Americans kill us" thread if you want to generate some kind of hysterical debate on the topic

jm08 · 14-07-2020 05:00PM

Truthvader wrote: »

OK this seems like a bona fide defence of an are under attack. Still doesn't justify or explain 30 years of random murder.

And as to mandate. This is nonsense. Voting for something doesn't make it right. The streets were full of people glorying Bobby Storey a couple of weeks ago but he was still a thug and a thief

Most of it could have been avoided if unionists had agreed to power sharing with the SDLP in 1973. (Sunningdale). They violently resisted it and the British Government backed down which they always did to unionist threats.

Truthvader · 14-07-2020 05:12PM

Adam9213 wrote: »

You can bring up civilian deaths from any side in any conflict and say what you said "how did they defend their communities killing these people" and use that to discredit them, I can bring up the Ballymurphy massacre where 11 innocent men and women were killed one of them died of a heart attack from a mock execution by soldiers, or I could bring up the Springhill massacre where 5 people were killed including 13 year old Margaret Gargan.

The IRA were exploding hundreds of bombs on economic targets every year almost all of which were without casualties.

This one went horribly wrong and two innocent people were tragically killed.

A piece on BBC North West's Inside Out programme in September 2013 speculated that the bombing may have been the work of a "rogue" IRA unit, which was supported by the IRA but operated independently and who used operatives who were from England to avoid suspicion.The programme also examined a possible link between the attack and British leftist political group Red Action, though nothing was ever proven.

Ah the old rogue unit, the unauthorised action, the unsanctioned killing. Sure its hard to know what the lads were up to all the time. You can only fill them with explosives and hatred and hope for the best. And sure we can always just deny it. Sure one of the leaders wasn't even in the IRA. A confusing time God help us.

Truthvader · 14-07-2020 05:15PM

jm08 wrote: »

Most of it could have been avoided if unionists had agreed to power sharing with the SDLP in 1973. (Sunningdale). They violently resisted it and the British Government backed down which they always did to unionist threats.

This is undoubtedly true but it was not addressed or resolved or justified by bombing a pub in Birmingham full pf people on a night out

14-07-2020 05:21PM

FrancieBrady wrote: »

Out come the selective, emotive victims again.
You know as well as anybody that the intention was not to kill two boys.

Two boys died tragically though that didn't have to, like all the other victims, including 18 children killed by BA forces as the conflict ramped up.

Why didn't those 2 kids have to be killed?
My answer would be that terrorists planted bombs in a shopping area where people where out shopping.

Have you a different answer to that Francie?

Adam9213 · 14-07-2020 05:22PM

Truthvader wrote: »

I care as to many normal people. As you to accurately put it "the goal was to force a British withdrawal". The means was to murder and mutilate random innocent people until you got what you wanted. Only a sick sociopathic individual behaves like this

Not a defence of anything then

Not really as only 29% of IRA victims were civilians and that figure also includes informers, politicians etc.

You seem to ignore logic in all your posts and just throw out idiotic insults, also the IRA in the 80s and 90s apparently had to abort 80% of their operations because of the risk to civilians.

blanch152 · 14-07-2020 05:24PM

jm08 wrote: »

Most of it could have been avoided if unionists had agreed to power sharing with the SDLP in 1973. (Sunningdale). They violently resisted it and the British Government backed down which they always did to unionist threats.

The British Government didn't back down. Sunningdale allowed for power-sharing, if the parties in Northern Ireland wouldn't power-share, there was nothing the British Government could do.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northern_Ireland_Constitutional_Convention

"On the face of it, the NICC was a total failure as it did not achieve its aims of agreement between the two sides or of introducing 'rolling devolution' (gradual introduction of devolution as and when the parties involved saw fit to accept it). Nevertheless, coming as it did not long after the Conservative-sponsored Sunningdale Agreement, the NICC indicated that no British government would be prepared to re-introduce majority rule in Northern Ireland."

Peace was getting closer.....the public mood however, was changed by incidents such as Kingsmill.

14-07-2020 05:26PM

Adam9213 wrote: »

Well they all had some kind of support but the Provos were the only ones who had real support.

Also no one supported the Omagh bomb, no one in the real IRA supported it and no one in the general public supported it, it was an incompetent accident.

The dissident republican campaign at that stage had some low level support but after the Omagh bomb it only had support similar to the support of the New IRA today.

The Omagh bomb effectively ended the dissident republican campaign.

How was planting 2 bombs are either end of a town with a delay on one an accident?

I look forward to seeing your answer!!

Adam9213 · 14-07-2020 05:27PM

Truthvader wrote: »

Ah the old rogue unit, the unauthorised action, the unsanctioned killing. Sure its hard to know what the lads were up to all the time. You can only fill them with explosives and hatred and hope for the best. And sure we can always just deny it. Sure one of the leaders wasn't even in the IRA. A confusing time God help us.

The IRA was one of the most sophisticated well organized guerrilla armies in the world at the time the leadership had tight control over the organisation but of course you can't control everyone 100% of the time that's inevitable

Adam9213 · 14-07-2020 05:34PM

SouthWesterly wrote: »

How was planting 2 bombs are either end of a town with a delay on one an accident?

I look forward to seeing your answer!!

The PIRA were exploding hundreds of bombs on economic targets every year, in 1972 they exploded 1300 bombs on economic targets almost every single one of these bombings no one was killed from they would phone in a warning that the bomb will explode in 30 minutes enough time to clear the area but not enough time to disarm the bomb.

The RIRA tried to do this and obviously messed up, even a dog in northern Ireland would have nothing but negative effects for them.

jm08 · 14-07-2020 05:36PM

blanch152 wrote: »

The British Government didn't back down. Sunningdale allowed for power-sharing, if the parties in Northern Ireland wouldn't power-share, there was nothing the British Government could do.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northern_Ireland_Constitutional_Convention

"On the face of it, the NICC was a total failure as it did not achieve its aims of agreement between the two sides or of introducing 'rolling devolution' (gradual introduction of devolution as and when the parties involved saw fit to accept it). Nevertheless, coming as it did not long after the Conservative-sponsored Sunningdale Agreement, the NICC indicated that no British government would be prepared to re-introduce majority rule in Northern Ireland."

Peace was getting closer.....the public mood however, was changed by incidents such as Kingsmill.

The SDLP were not bombing anyone. Why did unionists refuse to go into Government with them? Are you trying to insinuate that the SDLP were behind Kingsmills now?

14-07-2020 05:37PM

blanch152 wrote: »

Pretty much this was the reason for the conflict. Without the IRA killing people, we would have had peace a long time ago.

Easy to have a peace process when all.the nationlists killed/driven out....only for ira standing up and defending their communities there would be no nationlists there today

Why were the british throwing fireworks and attacking homes in short strand at the weekend btw,they still wont accept nationlists about??

An incompetent accident? Is that all you can bring yourself to say about Omagh?

The brits drove people deliverately towards that bomb imo....why have they still not released the call giving bomb warning??

14-07-2020 05:38PM

jm08 wrote: »

The SDLP were not bombing anyone. Why did unionists refuse to go into Government with them? Are you trying to insinuate that the SDLP were behind Kingsmills now?

The sdlp.were just as likely to be targets of unionist paramilitaries too.....anyone remember words of the pan-nationlist front pedeled by ian paisley

Truthvader · 14-07-2020 06:04PM

Adam9213 wrote: »

Not really as only 29% of IRA victims were civilians and that figure also includes informers, politicians etc.

You seem to ignore logic in all your posts and just throw out idiotic insults, also the IRA in the 80s and 90s apparently had to abort 80% of their operations because of the risk to civilians.

The subtext of course being that it is OK to murder informers or politicians. Any wonder Francie wont go near the Guards

And to be clear the murder of British Soldiers is equally murder in my view.

Truthvader · 14-07-2020 06:21PM

Deleted User wrote: »

And what of likes of seamus mcillwee....arrested on active service with the ira,interrogated and executed on side of the road??

Had to Google that. I assume you are referring to "Seamus McElwaine".Maybe get O'Broin to check the spelling in future.

What I discovered is that McElwaine murdered 10 people in his miserable useless life before being caught preparing a bomb to murder more (I assume this is the craven reference to "active service") He was wounded, questioned and murdered by the SAS. Yep a war crime no doubt- though hard to feel much sympathy. The soldiers should have been prosecuted. Not really the same as murdering kids out buying mothers day cards is it?

Spanish Eyes · 14-07-2020 06:29PM

SF did try to engage the so called middle classes.

They saw through it though, OK, we will pay for everything along with the baggage and the cost to many. But you go ahead and choose high calibre candidates. LOL.

Sorry now.

And before anyone gets the chance, FF not a week in office were up to their old tricks again. Quelle Surprise. But they don't represent me either. They are hankering after a tent in Galway and always will, read into that what you like.

jm08 · 14-07-2020 06:34PM

Truthvader wrote: »

Had to Google that. I assume you are referring to "Seamus McElwaine".Maybe get O'Broin to check the spelling in future.

What I discovered is that McElwaine murdered 10 people in his miserable useless life before being caught preparing a bomb to murder more (I assume this is the craven reference to "active service") He was wounded, questioned and murdered by the SAS. Yep a war crime no doubt- though hard to feel much sympathy. The soldiers should have been prosecuted. Not really the same as murdering kids out buying mothers day cards is it?

In January 1993 an inquest jury returned a verdict that McElwaine had been unlawfully killed. The jury ruled the soldiers had opened fire without giving him a chance to surrender, and that he was shot dead five minutes after being wounded. The Director of Public Prosecutions requested a full report on the inquest from the RUC, but no one has been prosecuted for McElwaine's death.

He was serving 30 years for the killing of two British Security people when he escaped, not 10 as you are trying to claim here. It seems you think the British Army / SAS can be judge, jury and executioner.

Truthvader · 14-07-2020 06:44PM

[Deleted User] wrote: »

Murder is murder imo,but its clear your willing to turn blind eye and downplay some cases??

And what about soldiers raping ira members,who have been arrested??
Eamonn collins,who also went onto be killed,being among most well known.......how is this keeping the peace?

Its clear you need a lot more help from OBroin and the intellectuals if you managed to extract the message that I am willing to turn a blind eye to anything. Unaware of the Collins rape claim. Have his book here but dont recall that. Anyway rapists should be prosecuted. Pity we cant ask Eamonn for details but he was murdered by Uncle Gerry and the lads.

FrancieBrady · 14-07-2020 07:20PM

Truthvader wrote: »

People deciding to kill each other

Well QED.

Simplify when you are caught out for an answer

None of us with Irish ancestry are above what happened in the north.
Nobody anywhere in fact, is above it, when pushed or ignored or threatened enough.

Another fact of history the high moral grounders ignore

Is it just me or have SF vanished?

Comments