South Park WW ROLE MADNESS - Game Thread

Winifred WW wrote: »

up to potentially seven people with a backroom collaborating with the rest of us in the dark, and you think they couldn't manipulate a vote?

I agree, that there's info to be gained in that perspective, I'm just saying wolves have a lot more power to drive conversation or voting a certain way when they can communicate behind closed doors and all we see is what they want us to see.

Conor WW wrote: »

The theory is that the wishmaster could only grant wishes to people who post a wish in bold on thread (one wish a day).



So Im above would isla get one or multiple bullets? Since the amount is not defined it’s hard to say.



Well it wasn’t an evil seeking bullet as Gertie was good but wouid a villager be evil to baddies? Meh, not convinced.



Again, this didn’t happen but sure I would imagine wishes prob had to be more for tools to catch wolves as opposed to just a wolf dieing.



Somebody was shot yesterday but it looks like the bullet didn’t kill until
This morning, I think it was Gerties kill



So that would hint that Isla got a gun with bullet(s) and shot Gertie.

Henry WW wrote: »

I just don't agree - I think having a vote is better than just giving it to someone who could potentially be a wolf.

Des has said that he doesn't want to choose himself.

In fact, I think we should choose one of the poisoned players to do the peek. If they're potentially going to die this evening anyway, we could get their alignment and know whether or not they're telling the truth.

Henry WW wrote: »

I just don't agree - I think having a vote is better than just giving it to someone who could potentially be a wolf.

Des has said that he doesn't want to choose himself.

In fact, I think we should choose one of the poisoned players to do the peek. If they're potentially going to die this evening anyway, we could get their alignment and know whether or not they're telling the truth.

Henry WW wrote: »

I just don't agree - I think having a vote is better than just giving it to someone who could potentially be a wolf.

Des has said that he doesn't want to choose himself.

In fact, I think we should choose one of the poisoned players to do the peek. If they're potentially going to die this evening anyway, we could get their alignment and know whether or not they're telling the truth.

Winifred WW wrote: »

Fair enough. The more village input, and the more discussion and information we get out on the thread the better.

I can see a reason to target a poisonee, but one of them is going to die anyway it seems, so not sure what we really get out of it, ahead of any other person?

Isla WW wrote: »

If I got a gun ironically Steve would have been the one I'd have shot. I thought him Jester which was the only reason I didn't vote for him. Shoot him yes, lynch him no. Plus going by your quotes above I would either have more bullets or have killed a baddie as my wish specified.





I was wrong though and he could grant wishes. I also encouraged your theory so I can't blame you here but someone (not me) did shoot him. My guess though given everyone has a role is just someone could shoot someone as part of their role. Would be surprised with so many roles if nobody got such a power

Henry WW wrote: »

I'm saying we choose a poisoned person to do the peeking. We get a 50% chance of knowing their alignment tonight, so knowing if the peek was true.

Isla WW wrote: »

Lean good for them makes sense. 100% do not clear them on that though but I've no reason to suspect them atm


After reading back on the thread, which seemed to kick it up a notch post after a slower weekend...


Steve and Gertie shot. an hour to be saved?
Derry/Liam poisoned

Henry quick to positively explain the poison targets... did he do it?


Eva then explains the wolves choice of Steve - focus on the steve wagon. Except I think they were going for Steve hoping to hit the Jester / thinking he would not be ressurected so the village could see who he was. Wolfy Gut feeling on Eva here

FFS ultimate power granter... And Satan & Scott Tenorman being good! ha

Don't think the Cartman hunter is neccesarily leading to Cartman (not me) being bad though as roles / characters don't = good/bad. The Devil was good too. Character wise

In my first post I questioned if the recent Hudra test would indicate the mods were going to do such a role in this game so I can see where the Orla/Lucy stuff originated but unless they both have access to both their accounts that is surely out the window as we have the same number of players sign up as accounts. Actually makes me slightly lean village on them as wolf team mates would probably tell them not to act the maggot like that behind closed doors.


I'm confused by Clodagh's

After the Catman Hunter has already been killed

Derry WW wrote: »

I've no problem carrying out the peek. If I had to chose who to peek it would be Orla / Lucy to see if there was anything in yesterdays spat.

Derry WW wrote: »

This is wrong, Steve was munched, Gertie was shot.

Having read back I wouldn't have put Steve as the Jester - I actually think it could be Orla / Lucy and they are rowing with the other person in order for the other person to form a bandwagon for lynch.