Brexit discussion thread XI (Please read OP before posting)

Rjd2 · 17-10-2019 01:41PM

8/13 on Betfair Boris loses on Saturday, and 8/15 or so with the high street bookies it loses if you want to bet in a betting shop.

That and Liverpool beating United on Sunday is my lock of the weekend.

J Mysterio · 17-10-2019 01:42PM

golfball37 wrote: »

I hope this gets passed in the HOC. Whilst Brexit is bad for Ireland it would be ridiculous and make a laugh of democracy if Britain didn't leave the EU after the result in 2016.

UK have already made a laugh of democracy. UK is in serious need of political reform (not to mind everything else).

Either way, Scotland will still want it's independence and will still want to rejoin. It seems this will be fast tracked once voted on.

Joe_ Public · 17-10-2019 01:43PM

If you were a remainer and wanted an election then short of voting Labour you're seriously reducing chances of a second vote. It's counterintuitive but that's the reality. Depending on numbers and whether Corbyn was still leader, it's likely the case that voting lib dems is actually merely boosting the Johnson position. That's why I think a lot of mps would prefer the second ref first path.

20silkcut · 17-10-2019 01:45PM

A lot of people on this thread predicted this outcome.
A lot of people in the UK did not.

It’s a tough one for remainers in the UK they are being shafted here. But the remain movement has been a massive failure over the last 3 years.
Considering 48% of the population are that way inclined that is unforgivable. Farage grabbed all the limelight at the euro elections while remainers sat on their hands divided.
But it’s also confirmation that the EU are happy to have the UK outside the EU.
You have to remember it was quite a hard fought achievement to get in back in the early 70’s .

J Mysterio · 17-10-2019 01:48PM

[Deleted User] wrote: »

He said earlier that he wouldn't. He said he prefers persuasion to threats.

In which case it makes the deal passing infinitely more likely.

Water John · 17-10-2019 01:48PM

Letwin gets the option for amendments on Sat. That's big.

ancapailldorcha · 17-10-2019 01:48PM

I've got this summary from BBC News:

What is in the deal?
Most of the deal is the same as the one agreed by Theresa May last year - the main change is the Northern Ireland proposals.

The UK will continue to abide by EU rules until the end of 2020, and possibly longer, to allow businesses to adjust
The UK will still pay an estimated £39bn "divorce bill"
The rights of EU citizens living in the UK, and UK citizens in the EU, will be guaranteed

What's changed?

Northern Ireland will be aligned to the EU single market
The controversial "backstop" - that critics feared could have kept the UK in a customs union with the EU indefinitely - has been removed
Northern Ireland will instead remain a part of the UK's customs territory, so it will be included in any future trade deals struck by the government after Brexit
But Northern Ireland will also remain an entry point into the EU's customs zone. The UK will apply tariffs to products entering Northern Ireland as long as they are not destined for onward transportation across the border
A joint EU/UK committee will decide which goods are at risk of entering the single market and the UK will collect EU tariffs on them on behalf of the EU
The Northern Ireland Assembly - which has been suspended since January 2017 - will get a vote every four years on whether to continue with the new trading arrangements
The decision would be based on a simple majority, rather than requiring a majority of both unionists and nationalists to support the rules in order for them to pass

I'm pessimistic. I don't see how the backstop can just be "removed". What happens if the Assembly, should it ever be restored decides to exercise its 4-year veto?

I'm personally unimpressed and a bit disappointed that the EU has yielded here but it's still early days.

Strazdas · 17-10-2019 01:49PM

20silkcut wrote: »

A lot of people on this thread predicted this outcome.
A lot of people in the UK did not.

It’s a tough one for remainers in the UK they are being shafted here. But the remain movement has been a massive failure over the last 3 years.
Considering 48% of the population are that way inclined that is unforgivable. Farage grabbed all the limelight at the euro elections while remainers sat on their hands divided.

Totally agree : coming out with "respecting the result of the referendum" nonsense and allowing the English far right and their media buddies to run riot and effectively take over the country.

devnull · 17-10-2019 01:49PM

lobbylad wrote: »

Rees Mogg in HoC has said about the debate on Saturday:

"The debate that follows will be a motion to either approve a deal or to approve a no-deal exit."

I though the HoC could only have a vote that had a Yes or No answer, not a choice?

And if his statement is true, that doesn't that avoid the Benn bill?

Is this their long awaited trick to bypass the Benn act?

Surely the motion will just be amended anyway?

LuckyLloyd · 17-10-2019 01:50PM

20silkcut wrote: »

A lot of people on this thread predicted this outcome.
A lot of people in the UK did not.

It’s a tough one for remainers in the UK they are being shafted here. But the remain movement has been a massive failure over the last 3 years.
Considering 48% of the population are that way inclined that is unforgivable. Farage grabbed all the limelight at the euro elections while remainers sat on their hands divided.

Yep, the Remain movement has only itself to blame. No effective protest; no strikes; no civil disobedience; complete failure to control media; little or no extraordinary parliamentary politics to try and force the issue. This deal and the consequences of it are what they deserve. To the victors go the “spoils”.

Zubeneschamali · 17-10-2019 01:51PM

Bambi wrote: »

the Irish Government just ran straight over its main red line to get this deal done, that it would not agree to anything that could create a hard border on this Island.

I was in favour of the Irish Government saying that all along, you can check my history. But I also was aware, and pointed out, that No Deal meant an instant hard border in Ireland, which we would be required by our Single Market membership to police as an EU external border.

The only reason to go for No Deal was the hope that in trade talks, the UK could be bullied into reversing course and accepting the backstop later to re-open the border. I thought (and still think) that this could happen quite quickly since No Deal will be a disaster.

But the same trade pressure can still be applied in the proposed set up - the EU can negotiate a trade deal which depends on the border staying open (through whatever means). So we get 7 years of open border, and then, if MLAs take leave of their senses and vote for a hard border, we can apply the same trade pressure to the whole UK that we could in a No Deal situation.

I don't see a downside.

MrMusician18 · 17-10-2019 01:52PM

20silkcut wrote: »

A lot of people on this thread predicted this outcome.
A lot of people in the UK did not.

It’s a tough one for remainers in the UK they are being shafted here. But the remain movement has been a massive failure over the last 3 years.
Considering 48% of the population are that way inclined that is unforgivable. Farage grabbed all the limelight at the euro elections while remainers sat on their hands divided.

In fairness, with the leave media it was always going to be hard for remain to get traction.

That said, the inability for the lib Dems and labour to coalesce around a common position (or indeed labour itself to coalesce around a common position) has led to remain neutering itself.

A great shame imo.

20silkcut · 17-10-2019 01:53PM

LuckyLloyd wrote: »

Yep, the Remain movement has only itself to blame. No effective protest; no strikes; no civil disobedience; complete failure to control media; little or no extraordinary parliamentary politics to try and force the issue. This deal and the consequences of it are what they deserve. To the victors go the “spoils”.

This is all happening under the likelihood that a majority of the population now support remain.
It is a desperate failure for them.

Headshot · 17-10-2019 01:53PM

BJ 6 defeats in a row in the UK Parliament.

This might be a chance for a confirmation referendum

Zubeneschamali · 17-10-2019 01:54PM

Penn wrote: »

Wouldn't they need for the EU to grant an extension to hold the referendum?

The need an extension anyway - there isn't time to get this all into law before the 31st.

Joe_ Public · 17-10-2019 01:55PM

Remain lost the referendum and UK should have left. What more do people think opposition could have done beyond opposing the bad deals gov was coming back with? I mean, practical things, not protests - we've had plenty of those in case folk have forgotten.

Strazdas · 17-10-2019 01:55PM

LuckyLloyd wrote: »

Yep, the Remain movement has only itself to blame. No effective protest; no strikes; no civil disobedience; complete failure to control media; little or no extraordinary parliamentary politics to try and force the issue. This deal and the consequences of it are what they deserve. To the victors go the “spoils”.

They're absolutely pathetic : terrified of the right wing press and of Leave voters

Their cowardice took their country to the brink of No Deal (and perhaps still will).

MrMusician18 · 17-10-2019 01:56PM

In a confirmatory referendum, what way would the DUP swing, presumably with remain as the other option on the ballot.

Strazdas · 17-10-2019 01:58PM

MrMusician18 wrote: »

In a confirmatory referendum, what way would the DUP swing, presumably with remain as the other option on the ballot.

Go with whatever the Tories are saying I would imagine

Varadkar looks in very good form in his live interview

MrMusician18 · 17-10-2019 02:00PM

Joe_ Public wrote: »

Remain lost the referendum and UK should have left. What more do people think opposition could have done beyond opposing the bad deals gov was coming back with? I mean, practical things, not protests - we've had plenty of those in case folk have forgotten.

Remain let the leavers control the narrative and were simply unable to get their message heard.

A simple example of this was the leavers tactic of saying something demonstrably untrue as a televised panel discussion was being wound up. Never challenged, either on the spot by refusing to let the piece be wound up or complaining afterwards. Newsnight in particular was terrible for this.

Water John · 17-10-2019 02:01PM

There is a long way to go IWT in the UK side of this yet. Johnson possibly will not get the Deal though unscathed. The optics are, he lost the first vote after concluding this historic Deal, so HOC not overly impressed.
A confimatory vote V remain may be the only option left as he may again look for a GE and not get it.
That's whn it's up to Lb, Lib Dems and others get their sh1t together and force that Referendum.

MrMusician18 · 17-10-2019 02:01PM

Strazdas wrote: »

Go with whatever the Tories are saying I would imagine

Surely the DUP couldn't back a deal in a referendum that they refused to vote for in parliament?

robinph · 17-10-2019 02:04PM

devnull wrote: »

Is this their long awaited trick to bypass the Benn act?

Surely the motion will just be amended anyway?

That has to be Mogg trying to reframe what the vote means without any actual basis in fact. If it was possible to have parliament vote in any way other than yes/no to each individual policy we wouldn't be here right now as they would have done that when the previous series of indicative votes happened.

Strazdas · 17-10-2019 02:04PM

MrMusician18 wrote: »

Surely the DUP couldn't back a deal in a referendum that they refused to vote for in parliament?

I suppose it would depend on what has happened in the meantime. A referendum would be at least two or three months away, maybe more.

Varta · 17-10-2019 02:04PM

MrMusician18 wrote: »

Remain let the leavers control the narrative and were simply unable to get their message heard.

A simple example of this was the leavers tactic of saying something demonstrably untrue as a televised panel discussion was being wound up. Never challenged, either on the spot by refusing to let the piece be wound up or complaining afterwards. Newsnight in particular was terrible for this.

That's very true, however, that was all aimed at the public, it is the remain politicians who should have done more. Brexit happened at a time when the Labour party was and still is in disarray. Even now they are having issues such as antisemitism distract them.

listermint · 17-10-2019 02:04PM

devnull wrote: »

Is this their long awaited trick to bypass the Benn act?

Surely the motion will just be amended anyway?

Have to agree with this.

The DUP are not going half as mental and they usually do. Wheres their heads exploding.

And the erg who are normally as vocal.... Saying nothing.

This is all a big trick and a poor one. No idea how the EU are falling for it.... Or are they.

I see none of this as a real deal. Tbh

Varta · 17-10-2019 02:07PM

MrMusician18 wrote: »

Surely the DUP couldn't back a deal in a referendum that they refused to vote for in parliament?

The DUP's position, whatever it might be, will be ignored by the majority of the NI electorate. They have sh*t the bed in that regard.

Strazdas · 17-10-2019 02:07PM

listermint wrote: »

Have to agree with this.

The DUP are not going half as mental and they usually do. Wheres their heads exploding.

And the erg who are normally as vocal.... Saying nothing.

This is all a big trick and a poor one. No idea how the EU are falling for it.... Or are they.

I see none of this as a real deal. Tbh

The EU and the Taoiseach are well aware of what Johnson is really like.....they wouldn't trust him

Nate--IRL-- · 17-10-2019 02:07PM

Optics are satisfied for the EU side. It this fails it will be squarely on the UK. The EU have no control over that.

NAte

jmayo · 17-10-2019 02:08PM

MrMusician18 wrote: »

Remain let the leavers control the narrative and were simply unable to get their message heard.

A simple example of this was the leavers tactic of saying something demonstrably untrue as a televised panel discussion was being wound up. Never challenged, either on the spot by refusing to let the piece be wound up or complaining afterwards. Newsnight in particular was terrible for this.

Newsnight was a disgrace.
One of the few people on there that really stood up was Gina Miller who took no shyte from the eejits in the audience who had to have been plants.

Corbyn's leadership is responsible for Labour's failure to either capitalise on a severely dysfunctional Tory party or prevent UK's exit based on a dodgy referendum where a lot of people probably regret their voting decision.

Brexit discussion thread XI (Please read OP before posting)

Comments